Selective Control and Characteristics of Water Oxidation and Dioxygen Reduction in Environmental Photo(electro)catalytic Systems.

ConspectusEmploying semiconductor materials is a popular engineering method to harvest solar energy, which is widely investigated for photocatalysis (PC) and photoelectrocatalysis (PEC) that convert solar light to chemical energy. In particular, environmental photo(electro)catalysis has been extensively studied as a sustainable method for water treatment, air purification, and resource recovery. Environmental PC/PEC processes working in ambient conditions are initiated mainly through hole transfer to water (water oxidation) and electron transfer to dioxygen (O2 reduction) and the subsequent photoredox transformation of water and dioxygen serves as a base of various PC/PEC systems. Through the redox transformations, different products can be generated depending on the number of transferred electrons and holes. The single electron/hole transfer generates radical species and reactive oxygen species (ROS) which initiate the degradation/transformation of various pollutants in water and air, while the multicharge transfer can generate energy-rich chemicals (e.g., H2, H2O2). Therefore, understanding the characteristics of the photoredox reactions of water and dioxygen on the semiconductor surface is critically important in controlling the selectivity and efficiency of photoconversion processes.In this Account, we describe various environmental PC/PEC conversions with a particular focus on how the phototransformation of dioxygen and water is related to the overall processes occurring on diverse semiconductor materials. The activation of water or dioxygen can be controlled by modifying the properties of semiconductors, changing the kind of counterpart half-reaction and the experimental conditions. If water can be used as a ubiquitous reductant under solar irradiation, many kinds of reductive transformations can be carried out under ambient environmental conditions. For example, various toxic oxyanions (or metal ions) can be reductively transformed to harmless or less harmful species or useful chemicals/fuels can be synthesized under ambient conditions if water can provide electrons and protons via solar water oxidation. On the other hand, dioxygen can turn into reactive oxygen species (ROS) as a versatile oxidant or to a chemical like H2O2. There should be many more possibilities of utilizing the photoconversion of water and dioxygen for environmentally significant purposes, which are yet to be further developed and demonstrated. In this Account, we highlight the recent strategies and the novel functional materials for effective activation of water and dioxygen in environmental PC/PEC systems. Design of environmentally functional PC/PEC systems should be based on better understanding of water and dioxygen activation.

Freezing-Enhanced Photoreduction of Iodate by Fulvic Acid.

Iodate is a stable form of iodine species in the natural environment. This work found that the abiotic photosensitized reduction of iodate by fulvic acid (FA) is highly enhanced in frozen solution compared to that in aqueous solution. The freezing-induced removal of iodate by FA at an initial pH of 3.0 in 24 h was lower than 10% in the dark but enhanced under UV (77.7%) or visible light (31.6%) irradiation. This process was accompanied by the production of iodide, reactive iodine (RI), and organoiodine compounds (OICs). The photoreduction of iodate in ice increased with lowering pH (pH 3-7 range) or increasing FA concentration (1-10 mg/L range). It was also observed that coexisting iodide or chloride ions enhanced the photoreduction of iodate in ice. Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometric analysis showed that 129 and 403 species of OICs (mainly highly unsaturated and phenolic compounds) were newly produced in frozen UV/iodate/FA and UV/iodate/FA/Cl- solution, respectively. In the frozen UV/iodate/FA/Cl- solution, approximately 97% of generated organochlorine compounds (98 species) were identified as typical chlorinated disinfection byproducts. These results call for further studies of the fate of iodate, especially in the presence of chloride, which may be overlooked in frozen environments.

MnO2-Induced Oxidation of Iodide in Frozen Solution.

Metal oxides play a critical role in the abiotic transformation of iodine species in natural environments. In this study, we investigated iodide oxidation by manganese dioxides (ß-MnO2, γ-MnO2, and δ-MnO2) in frozen and aqueous solutions. The heterogeneous reaction produced reactive iodine (RI) in the frozen phase, and the subsequent thawing of the frozen sample induced the gradual transformation of in situ-formed RI to iodate or iodide, depending on the types of manganese dioxides. The freezing-enhanced production of RI was observed over the pH range of 5.0-9.0, but it decreased with increasing pH. Fulvic acid (FA) can be iodinated by I-/MnO2 in aqueous and frozen solutions. About 0.8-8.4% of iodide was transformed to organoiodine compounds (OICs) at pH 6.0-7.8 in aqueous solution, while higher yields (10.4-17.8%) of OICs were obtained in frozen solution. Most OICs generated in the frozen phase contained one iodine atom and were lignin-like compounds according to Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance/mass spectrometry analysis. This study uncovers a previously unrecognized production pathway of OICs under neutral conditions in frozen environments.

Sculpting In-plane Fractal Porous Patterns in Two-Dimensional MOF Nanocrystals for Photoelectrocatalytic CO2 Reduction.

Herein, by choosing few-nm-thin two-dimensional (2D) nanocrystals of MOF-5 containing in-planner square lattices as a modular platform, a crystal lattice-guided wet-chemical etching has been rationally accomplished. As a result, two attractive pore patterns carrying Euclidean curvatures; precisely, plus(+)-shaped and fractal-patterned pores via ⟨100⟩ and ⟨110⟩ directional etching, respectively, are regulated in contrast to habitually formed spherical-shaped random etches on MOF surface. In agreement with the theoretical calculations, a diffusion-limited etching process has been optimized to devise high-yield of size-tunable fractal-pores on the MOF surface that tenders for a compatibly high payload of catalytic ReI -complexes using the existing large edge area once modified into a free amine-group-exposed inner pore surface. Finally, on benefiting from the long-range fractal opening in 2D MOF support structure, while loaded on an electrode surface, a facilitated cross-interface charge-transportation and well-exposure of immobilized ReI -catalysts are anticipated, thus realizing enhanced activity and stability of the supported catalyst in photoelectrochemical CO2 -to-CO reduction.

Freeze-Thaw Cycle-Enhanced Transformation of Iodide to Organoiodine Compounds in the Presence of Natural Organic Matter and Fe(III).

The formation of organoiodine compounds (OICs) is of great interest in the natural iodine cycle as well as water treatment processes. Herein, we report a pathway of OIC formation that reactive iodine (RI) and OICs are produced from iodide oxidation in the presence of Fe(III) and natural organic matter (NOM) in frozen solution, whereas their production is insignificant in aqueous solution. Moreover, thawing the frozen solution induces the further production of OICs. A total of 352 OICs are detected by Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry in the freeze-thaw cycled reactions of Fe(III)/I-/humic acid solution, which are five times as many as OICs in aqueous reactions. Using model organic compounds instead of NOM, aromatic compounds (e.g., phenol, aniline, o-cresol, and guaiacol) induce higher OIC formation yields (10.4-18.6%) in the freeze-thaw Fe(III)/I- system than those in aqueous (1.1-2.1%) or frozen (2.7-7.6%) solutions. In the frozen solution, the formation of RI is enhanced, but its further reaction with NOM is hindered. Therefore, the freeze-thaw cycle in which RI is formed in the frozen media and the resulting RI is consumed by reaction with NOM in the subsequently thawed solution is more efficient in producing OICs than the continuous reaction in frozen solution.

Production of Reactive Oxygen Species by the Reaction of Periodate and Hydroxylamine for Rapid Removal of Organic Pollutants and Waterborne Bacteria.

Periodate (PI, IO4-) can be activated by hydroxylamine (HA), resulting in the rapid removal of organic pollutants within seconds. While the previous studies on PI-based advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) have proposed iodate radical (•IO3) as the major reactive species, no evidence of •IO3 production was found in the present PI/HA system. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) including •OH, HO2•, and 1O2 are proposed to be the main oxidants of the PI/HA system, which is supported by various tests employing the scavengers, chemical probes, and spin-trapping electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) technique. To minimize the risk of toxic iodinated byproduct formation caused by reactive iodine species such as HOI and I2, the molar ratio of HA/PI was optimized at 0.6 to achieve the stoichiometric conversion of IO4- to iodate (IO3-), a preferred nontoxic sink of iodine species. The PI/HA system also efficiently inactivated both Gram-positive and -negative bacteria with producing 1O2 as the dominant disinfectant. The mechanism of ROS production was also investigated and is discussed in detail. This work offers a simple and highly efficient option for PI activation and ROS production which might find useful applications where urgent and rapid removal of toxic pollutants is needed.

Cr(VI) Formation via Oxyhalide-Induced Oxidative Dissolution of Chromium Oxide/Hydroxide in Aqueous and Frozen Solution.

The oxidative dissolution of Cr(III) species (Cr2O3 and Cr(OH)3) by oxyhalide species, which produces hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)), was studied in aqueous and frozen solution. The oxyhalide-induced oxidation of Cr(III) in frozen solution showed a different trend from that in aqueous solution. Cr(VI) production was higher in frozen than aqueous solution with hypochlorous acid (HOCl) and bromate (BrO3-) but suppressed in frozen solution with hypobromous acid (HOBr) and periodate (IO4-). In particular, bromate markedly enhanced Cr(VI) production in frozen solution, whereas it had a negligible activity in aqueous solution. On the contrary, periodate produced Cr(VI) significantly in aqueous solution but greatly suppressed it in frozen solution. Bromate was found to be much more concentrated in the ice grain boundary than periodate according to both chemical and Raman spectral analyses. The oxidative transformation of Cr(III) to Cr(VI) was accompanied by the concurrent and stoichiometric reduction of oxyhalide species. Dissolved O2 had little effect on the oxidative dissolution, but dissolved organic matter retarded the oxidation of Cr2O3 in both aqueous and frozen conditions. This study proposes that the oxyhalide-induced oxidation of Cr(III) (particularly by bromate) in frozen conditions might have a significant effect on the generation of Cr(VI) in the frozen environment.

How g-C3N4 Works and Is Different from TiO2 as an Environmental Photocatalyst: Mechanistic View.

Graphitic carbon nitride (CN) as a popular visible light photocatalyst needs to be better understood for environmental applications. The behaviors of CN as an environmental photocatalyst were systematically studied in comparison with a well-known TiO2 photocatalyst. The two photocatalysts exhibit different photocatalytic oxidation (PCO) behaviors and dependences on the experimental conditions (e.g., pH, Pt loading, and the kind of organic substrate and scavenger). The PCO of organic substrates was significantly enhanced by loading Pt on TiO2 under UV light (λ > 320 nm), whereas Pt-CN exhibited a lower PCO activity than bare CN under visible light (λ > 420 nm). While the presence of Pt enhances the charge separation in both TiO2/UV and CN/visible light systems (confirmed by transient IR absorption spectroscopic analysis), the opposite effects of Pt are ascribed to the different mechanisms of •OH generation in the two photocatalytic systems. The negative effect of Pt on CN is ascribed to the fact that Pt catalytically decomposes in situ-generated H2O2 (a main precursor of OH radical), which hinders •OH production. The production of OH radicals on CN is favored only at acidic pH but 1O2 generation is dominant in alkaline pH. The pH-dependent behaviors of reactive oxygen species generation on CN were confirmed by electron paramagnetic resonance spin trap measurements.

Entangled iodine and hydrogen peroxide formation in ice.

Ice-core records show that anthropogenic pollution has increased the global atmospheric concentrations of hydrogen peroxide and iodine since the mid-20th century. Here, for the first time, we demonstrate a highly efficient mechanism that synergistically produces them in icy water conditions. This reaction is aided by a key intermediate IO2H, formed by an I- ion with a dissolved O2 in acidic icy water, which produces both I as well as O2H radicals. I recombines with I- to produce I2- at a diffusion-limited rate, followed by formation of I3- through disproportionation, while O2H yields H2O2 with I- and a proton dissolved in icy water.

Heteroatom Dopants Promote Two-Electron O2 Reduction for Photocatalytic Production of H2 O2 on Polymeric Carbon Nitride.

Polymeric carbon nitride modified with selected heteroatom dopants was prepared and used as a model photocatalyst to identify and understand the key mechanisms required for efficient photoproduction of H2 O2 via selective oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). The photochemical production of H2 O2 was achieved at a millimolar level per hour under visible-light irradiation along with 100 % apparent quantum yield (in 360-450 nm region) and 96 % selectivity in an electrochemical system (0.1 V vs. RHE). Spectroscopic analysis in spatiotemporal resolution and theoretical calculations revealed that the synergistic association of alkali and sulfur dopants in the polymeric matrix promoted the interlayer charge separation and polarization of trapped electrons for preferable oxygen capture and reduction in ORR kinetics. This work highlights the key features that are responsible for controlling the photocatalytic activity and selectivity toward the two-electron ORR, which should be the basis of further development of solar H2 O2 production.

Organometallic Iridium(III) Complex Sensitized Ternary Hybrid Photocatalyst for CO2 to CO Conversion.

A series of heteroleptic iridium(III) complexes functionalized with two phosphonic acid (-PO3 H2 ) groups (dfppy IrP, ppy IrP, btp IrP, and piq IrP) were prepared and anchored onto rhenium(I) catalyst (ReP)-loaded TiO2 particles (TiO2 /ReP) to build up a new IrP-sensitized TiO2 photocatalyst system (IrP/TiO2 /ReP). The photosensitizing behavior of the IrP series was examined within the IrP/TiO2 /ReP platform for the photocatalytic conversion of CO2 into CO. The four IrP-based ternary hybrids showed increased conversion activity and durability than that of the corresponding homo- (IrP+ReP) and heterogeneous (IrP+TiO2 /ReP) mixed systems. Among the four IrP/TiO2 /ReP photocatalysts, the low-energy-light (>500 nm) activated piq IrP immobilized ternary system (piq IrP/TiO2 /ReP) exhibited the most durable conversion activity, giving a turnover number of ≥730 for 170 h. A similar kinetic feature observed through time-resolved photoluminescence measurements of both btp IrP/TiO2 and TiO2 -free btp IrP films suggests that the net electron flow in the ternary hybrid proceeds dominantly through a reductive quenching mechanism, unlike the oxidative quenching route of typical dye/TiO2 -based photolysis.

In Situ Photoelectrochemical Chloride Activation Using a WO3 Electrode for Oxidative Treatment with Simultaneous H2 Evolution under Visible Light.

Reactive chlorine species (RCS) such as HOCl and chlorine radical species is a strong oxidant and has been widely used for water disinfection. This study investigated a photoelectrochemical (PEC) method of RCS production from ubiquitous chloride ions using a WO3 film electrode and visible light. The degradation of organic substrates coupled with H2 evolution using a WO3 electrode was compared among electrochemical (EC), photocatalytic (PC), and PEC conditions (potential bias: +0.5 V vs Ag/AgCl; λ > 420 nm). The degradation of 4-chlorophenol, bisphenol A, acetaminophen, carbamazepine, humic acid, and fulvic acid and the inactivation of E. coli were remarkably enhanced by in situ RCS generated in PEC conditions, whereas the activities of the PC and EC processes were negligible. The activities of the WO3 film were limited by rapid charge recombination in the PC condition, and the potential bias of +0.5 V did not induce any significant reactions in the EC condition. The PEC activities of WO3 were limited in the absence of Cl- but significantly enhanced in the presence of Cl-, which confirmed the essential role of RCS in this PEC system. The PEC mineralization of organic compounds was also markedly enhanced in the presence of Cl- where dark chemical chlorination by NaOCl addition induced a negligible mineralization. The H2 generation was observed only at the PEC condition and was negligible at PC and EC conditions. On the other hand, the oxidation of chloride on a WO3 photoanode produced chlorate (ClO3-) as a toxic byproduct under UV irradiation, but the visible light-irradiated PEC system generated no chlorate.

Spontaneous Generation of H2O2 and Hydroxyl Radical through O2 Reduction on Copper Phosphide under Ambient Aqueous Condition.

Copper phosphide (Cu xP) was synthesized and tested for its reactivity for generating H2O2 through spontaneous reduction of dioxygen under ambient aqueous condition. The in situ generated H2O2 was subsequently decomposed to generate OH radicals, which enabled the degradation of organic compounds in water. The oxygen reduction reaction proceeded along with the concurrent oxidation of phosphide to phosphate, then copper ions and phosphate ions were dissolved out during the reaction. The reactivity of Cu xP was gradually reduced during 10 cycles with consuming 8.7 mg of Cu xP for the successive removal of 17 µmol 4-chlorophenol. CoP which was compared as a control sample under the same experimental condition also produced H2O2 through activating dioxygen but did not degrade organic compounds at all. The electrochemical analysis for the electron transfers on Cu xP and CoP showed that the number of electrons transferred to O2 is 3 and 2, respectively, which explains why OH radical is generated on Cu xP, not on CoP. The Cu+ species generated on the Cu xP surface can participate in Fenton-like reaction with in situ generated H2O2. Cu xP is proposed as a solid reagent that can activate dioxygen to generate reactive oxygen species in ambient aqueous condition, which is more facile to handle and store than liquid/gas reagents (e.g., H2O2, Cl2, O3).

Nitrite-Induced Activation of Iodate into Molecular Iodine in Frozen Solution.

A new mechanism for the abiotic production of molecular iodine (I2) from iodate (IO3-), which is the most abundant iodine species, in dark conditions was identified and investigated. The production of I2 in aqueous solution containing IO3- and nitrite (NO2-) at 25 °C was negligible. However, the redox chemical reaction between IO3- and NO2- rapidly proceeded in frozen solution at -20 °C, which resulted in the production of I2, I-, and NO3-. The rapid redox chemical reaction between IO3- and NO2- in frozen solution is ascribed to the accumulation of IO3-, NO2-, and protons in the liquid regions between ice crystals during freezing (freeze concentration effect). This freeze concentration effect was verified by confocal Raman microscopy for the solute concentration and UV-visible absorption spectroscopy with cresol red (acid-base indicator) for the proton concentration. The freezing-induced production of I2 in the presence of IO3- and NO2- was observed under various conditions, which suggests this abiotic process for I2 production is not restricted to a specific region and occurs in many cold regions. NO2--induced activation of IO3- to I2 in frozen solution may help explain why the measured values of iodine are larger than the modeled values in some polar areas.

Abiotic Formation of Humic-Like Substances through Freezing-Accelerated Reaction of Phenolic Compounds and Nitrite.

A previously unknown abiotic humification pathway which is highly accelerated in frozen solution containing phenolic compounds and nitrite was investigated and proposed. The production of humic-like acids (HLA) and fulvic-like acids (FLA) was observed in the frozen solution (-20 °C) whereas it was negligible in aqueous solution (20 °C). Inorganic nitrogen was transformed into organic nitrogen during the humification process. Mass spectrometry (MS) and elemental analyses, including pyrolysis-GC/MS and FT-ion cyclotron resonance/MS, showed that humification products (HLA and FLA) have chemical structures and compositions similar to nature humic substances. The enhanced humification reaction could be attributed to the freeze-concentration effect, whereby nitrite ions in the unfrozen grain boundary region are transformed into nitrosonium ions which oxidize phenols to phenolic radicals. Confocal Raman microscopy confirmed that catechol and nitrite ions are preferentially concentrated at the ice grain boundary and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopic analysis of catechol/nitrite solution detected the phenolic radicals only in frozen solution, not in aqueous solution. The freezing-induced generation of phenolic radicals should lead to the formation of humic-like substances through polymerization. This study identifies and proposes a new humic formation pathway that might work as a model abiotic "bottom-up" mechanism in frozen environmental conditions.

Simultaneous and Synergic Production of Bioavailable Iron and Reactive Iodine Species in Ice.

The bioavailable iron is essential for all living organisms, and the dissolution of iron oxide contained in dust and soil is one of the major sources of bioavailable iron in nature. Iodine in the polar atmosphere is related to ozone depletion, mercury oxidation, and cloud condensation nuclei formation. Here we show that the chemical reaction between iron oxides and iodide (I-) is markedly accelerated to produce bioavailable iron (Fe(II)aq) and tri-iodide (I3-: evaporable in the form of I2) in frozen solution (both with and without light irradiation), while it is negligible in aqueous phase. The freeze-enhanced production of Fe(II)aq and tri-iodide is ascribed to the freeze concentration of iron oxides, iodides, and protons in the ice grain boundaries. The outdoor experiments carried out in midlatitude during a winter day (Pohang, Korea: 36°0' N, 129°19' E) and in an Antarctic environment (King George Island: 62°13' S 58°47' W) also showed the enhanced generation of Fe(II)aq and tri-iodide in ice. This study proposes a previously unknown abiotic mechanism and source of bioavailable iron and active iodine species in the polar environment. The pulse input of bioavailable iron and reactive iodine when ice melts may influence the oceanic primary production and CCN formation.

The Technology Horizon for Photocatalytic Water Treatment: Sunrise or Sunset?

Advanced oxidation processes via semiconductor photocatalysis for water treatment have been the subject of extensive research over the past three decades, producing many scientific reports focused on elucidating mechanisms and enhancing kinetics for the treatment of contaminants in water. Many of these reports imply that the ultimate goal of the research is to apply photocatalysis in municipal water treatment operations. However, this ignores immense technology transfer problems, perpetuating a widening gap between academic advocation and industrial application. In this Feature, we undertake a critical examination of the trajectory of photocatalytic water treatment research, assessing the viability of proposed applications and identifying those with the most promising future. Several strategies are proposed for scientists and engineers who aim to support research efforts to bring industrially relevant photocatalytic water treatment processes to fruition. Although the reassessed potential may not live up to initial academic hype, an unfavorable assessment in some areas does not preclude the transfer of photocatalysis for water treatment to other niche applications as the technology retains substantive and unique benefits.

Ligand-Specific Dissolution of Iron Oxides in Frozen Solutions.

The freezing-enhanced dissolution of iron oxides by various ligands has been recently proposed as a new mechanism that may influence the supply of bioavailable iron in frozen environments. The ligand-induced dissolution of iron oxides is sensitively affected by the kind and concentration of ligands, pH, and kind of iron oxides. While most ligands are thought to be freeze-concentrated in the ice grain boundary region along with iron oxides to enhance the iron dissolution, this study found that some ligands, such as ascorbic acid, suppress the iron dissolution in frozen solution relative to that in aqueous solution. Such ligands are proposed to be preferentially incorporated in the ice lattice bulk and not freeze-concentrated in the liquid-like grain boundary. The experimental analysis estimated that the ionized forms of ligands (e.g., iodide ions) are hardly present in the ice bulk region (<3%) and enhance the iron dissolution in frozen solution (relative to that in aqueous solution), whereas some neutral ligands (e.g., undissociated ascorbic acid) are significantly trapped in the ice bulk (>50%) and suppress the iron dissolution compared to the aqueous counterpart. The present results reveal that the ligand-induced dissolution of iron oxide in frozen solution is not always enhanced relative to aqueous solution but depends upon the kind of ligand and experimental conditions.

Active {001} Facet Exposed TiO2 Nanotubes Photocatalyst Filter for Volatile Organic Compounds Removal: From Material Development to Commercial Indoor Air Cleaner Application.

TiO2 nanotubes (TNT) have a highly ordered open structure that promotes the diffusion of dioxygen and substrates onto active sites and exhibit high durability against deactivation during the photocatalytic air purification. Herein, we synthesized {001} facet-exposed TiO2 nanotubes (001-TNT) using a new and simple method that can be easily scaled up, and tested them for the photocatalytic removal of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in both a laboratory reactor and a commercial air cleaner. While the surface of TNT is mainly composed of {101} facet anatase, 001-TNT's outer surface was preferentially aligned with {001} facet anatase. The photocatalytic degradation activity of toluene on 001-TNT was at least twice as high as that of TNT. While the TNT experienced a gradual deactivation during successive cycles of photocatalytic degradation of toluene, the 001-TNT did not exhibit any sign of catalyst deactivation under the same test conditions. Under visible light irradiation, the 001-TNT showed degradation activity for acetaldehyde and formaldehyde, while the TNT did not exhibit any degradation activity for them. The 001-TNT filter was successfully scaled up and installed on a commercial air cleaner. The air cleaner equipped with the 001-TNT filters achieved an average VOCs removal efficiency of 72% (in 30 min of operation) in a 8-m3 test chamber, which satisfied the air cleaner standards protocol (Korea) to be the first photocatalytic air cleaner that passed this protocol.