Clinical experience with recombinant molecules for allergy vaccination.

Numerous allergens have been cloned and produced by the use of recombinant DNA technology. In several cases recombinant variants with reduced IgE-reactivity have also been developed as candidates for allergen specific immunotherapy. Only very few of these proteins have as yet been tested in the clinic, and the major focus has been on birch and grass pollen, two of the most common causes of IgE-mediated allergic disease. This article serves to justify the rational for using recombinant products and reviews the progress that has been made to date with their clinical assessment.

Hypoallergenic mutants of the Timothy grass pollen allergen Phl p 5 generated by proline mutations.

BACKGROUND: Phl p 5 is a major allergen of Timothy grass (Phleum pratense). A recombinant native Phl p 5 has already been used in clinical trials of allergen-specific immunotherapy as a component of a cocktail of allergens. Recombinant hypoallergenic allergens should further improve the treatment by reducing the risk of anaphylactic reactions at an increased therapeutic dosage. Native Phl p 5 is formed by α-helical regions separated by regions containing prolines. In order to generate hypoallergenic mutants, we studied the effect of proline mutations in single and multiple regions. METHODS: All mutants were analyzed by IgE inhibition assays and size exclusion chromatography with on-line mass determination. Selected mutants were additionally analyzed by field-flow fractionation, dynamic light scattering, circular dichroism spectroscopy, basophil activation and T-cell proliferation assays. RESULTS: Variants lacking prolines in a single region were obtained as soluble monomers. Six of eight molecules showed a slightly reduced IgE-binding capacity. Mutants carrying proline deletions in multiple regions formed monomers, dimers or insoluble aggregates. The mutant MPV.7 with five proline deletions and a substitution of proline 211 to leucine is monomeric, shows a strongly diminished IgE binding and maintains T-cell reactivity. The hydrodynamic radius and the content of the α-helical structure of MPV.7 are well comparable with the wild-type allergen. CONCLUSIONS: The hypoallergenic Phl p 5 variant MPV.7 combines multiple proline deletions with a substitution of proline 211 to leucine and meets basic demands for a pharmaceutical application. MPV.7 is a promising candidate for grass pollen immunotherapy with a cocktail of recombinant hypoallergens.

Recombinant allergens for specific immunotherapy.

Recombinant DNA technology provides the means for producing allergens that are equivalent to their natural counterparts and also genetically engineered variants with reduced IgE-binding activity. The proteins are produced as chemically defined molecules with consistent structural and immunologic properties. Several hundred allergens have been cloned and expressed as recombinant proteins, and these provide the means for making a very detailed diagnosis of a patient's sensitization profile. Clinical development programs are now in progress to assess the suitability of recombinant allergens for both subcutaneous and sublingual immunotherapy. Recombinant hypoallergenic variants, which are developed with the aim of increasing the doses that can be administered while at the same time reducing the risks for therapy-associated side effects, are also in clinical trials for subcutaneous immunotherapy. Grass and birch pollen preparations have been shown to be clinically effective, and studies with various other allergens are in progress. Personalized or patient-tailored immunotherapy is still a very distant prospect, but the first recombinant products based on single allergens or defined mixtures could reach the market within the next 5 years.

The European Union CREATE project: a model for international standardization of allergy diagnostics and vaccines.

Allergen measurements are used extensively in the formulation of allergy diagnostics and vaccines, yet no purified international allergen standards are available for calibration purposes. The aims of the European Union CREATE project were to develop international standards with verifiable allergen content. Purified natural and recombinant allergens were analyzed by means of SDS-PAGE, mass spectrometry, circular dichroism spectra, and small-angle x-ray scattering. IgE reactivity was assessed by means of direct RAST, RAST inhibition, immunoblotting, and basophil histamine release with sera from 961 allergic patients. Three recombinant allergens, rBet v 1, rPhl p 5a, and rDer p 2, were structurally indistinguishable from their natural counterparts and showed excellent IgE reactivity suitable for use as certified reference materials. A second tier of allergens (rPhl p 5b, rOle e1, rDer p 1, rDer f 1, and rDer f 2) was identified that could provide suitable candidates for certified reference materials with minor improvements to the recombinant proteins. Only rPhl p 1 was considered unsuitable as a reference material. Quantitative ELISAs were identified that accurately measured each allergen, except for rPhl p 1. The CREATE project has provided a major step forward in allergen standardization and provides a model for the development of a comprehensive panel of international reference preparations that will harmonize allergen measurements worldwide.

Monoclonal antibodies.

Monoclonal antibodies (mabs) are powerful tools for the quantification, detection, and targeting of specific molecules. Allergen-specific mabs are important for the quantification of major allergens in allergen preparations used for allergen-specific immunotherapy and allergy diagnosis. Indeed, progress in the understanding of the mechanisms of the immunological responses underlying allergic disease would not have been possible without the use of mabs. Quantification assays are also important in the assessment of environmental allergen exposure and monitoring of avoidance procedures.Mabs against human IgE provide the basis for various test systems for the detection of specific and nonspecific IgE. Mabs raised against IgE or defined cytokines or cytokine receptors have potential as neutralizing reagents in vivo for the treatment of allergic diseases.Allergen-specific mabs are also valuable tools for the localization of allergens within their source material and the characterization of allergens derived from natural sources and by recombinant technologies. Furthermore they are often used for the isolation of allergens from complex extracts by affinity chromatography. The procedure described in this chapter has been used successfully to produce mabs against numerous allergens from house dust mites, insect venoms, cat, hens egg white, tree-, grass-, and herb pollens, and fungi, with the ultimate aim of obtaining matched antibody pairs to establish two-site binding assays for the quantification of major allergens. The method has also been used successfully to generate mabs against human IgE.

Bacterially expressed and optimized recombinant Phl p 1 is immunobiochemically equivalent to natural Phl p 1.

Recombinant production in bacteria of soluble and monomeric Phl p 1, a major allergen of Timothy grass pollen, has proved to be very problematic. In order to facilitate expression and purification of this allergen, a recombinant variant was designed with a single amino acid substitution. Several comparative analyses with natural counterparts using electrophoretic and HPLC separations, together with immunological assays, demonstrated high equivalence. This is the first description of an approach aiming at an improvement of a natural like recombinant allergen.

Strategies for recombinant allergen vaccines and fruitful results from first clinical studies.

Recombinant DNA technology has delivered the prospect of a new generation of preparations for allergen-specific immunotherapy. The first clinical studies with recombinant allergens have yielded encouraging results, suggesting that there is a good chance that such preparations will become available for use in the routine management of allergic disease.

Purification strategy for recombinant Phl p 6 is applicable to the natural allergen and yields biochemically and immunologically comparable preparations.

The recombinant major grass pollen allergen Phl p 6 has been expressed with a N-terminal 6 x His-tag sequence and subsequently purified using nickel-chelating Sepharose. After cleavage of the tag-sequence, a second pass over the affinity chromatography revealed that even untagged rPhl p 6 bound tightly. In order to determine if that property is typical for Phl p 6, the natural allergen was purified in the same way starting with a grass pollen extract. Indeed, nPhl p 6 could be highly enriched in one step using nickel-chelating Sepharose. In addition to this new powerful purification method, the results provide further information in that the recombinant and natural allergens share a lot of properties, since biochemical characteristics are reflected in the purification strategies. The preparations of natural and recombinant Phl p 6 were used for comparative electrophoretic, chromatographic and immunological analysis which demonstrated high similarity.

Sensitization to different mite species in German farmers: in vitro analyses.

Allergic airway diseases are often caused by house dust mites (HDM) and storage mites (SM), respectively, and we were recently able to demonstrate that symptomatic German farmers are frequently sensitized to different mite species. The present study aimed to obtain information on the protein and immunobiochemical characteristics of the extracts of the following mites: Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus, Dermatophagoides farinae, Acarus siro, Acarus farris, Lepidoglyphus destructor, Tyrophagus putrescentiae, Blomia tjibodas, Blomia topicalis, Blomia kulagini, Glycyphagus domesticus, Thyreophagus entomophagus, and Cheyletus eruditus. Specific IgE determinations were performed with EAST. The protein patterns of the mite extracts were studied by SDS-PAGE estimating the weighted-average molecular weights of the proteins. Using the Western blot technique, we determined the allergen pattern in several mite extracts. The allergens in each extract were classified in terms of the frequency of sensitization as major, intermediate, and minor allergens using allergograms. As already reported, a positive EAST to at least one mite was measured in 31/86 patients, and most sera were positive with several mite species. The majority of the mite extracts exhibited a very complex protein pattern according to SDS-PAGE. An allergen was found in Western blots of nearly all species equivalent to a molecular weight of 14 to 15 kD. This was, in our opinion, the first time that this particular allergen was detected in Blomia tjibodas and Glycyphagus domesticus. In conclusion, using EAST we were able to show that 36% of the German farmers tested were sensitized to SM. All mite extracts showed a complex protein pattern in the molecular weight range -95 kD to -10 kD. A common allergen band in the region of -14 to -15 kD was found in the majority of the mites studied, and it can be assumed that this corresponds with the group 2 allergen.

Analysis of epitope-specific immune responses induced by vaccination with structurally folded and unfolded recombinant Bet v 1 allergen derivatives in man.

Previously, we have constructed recombinant derivatives of the major birch pollen allergen, Bet v 1, with a more than 100-fold reduced ability to induce IgE-mediated allergic reactions. These derivatives differed from each other because the two recombinant Bet v 1 fragments represented unfolded molecules whereas the recombinant trimer resembled most of the structural fold of the Bet v 1 allergen. In this study, we analyzed the Ab (IgE, IgG subclass, IgA, IgM) response to Bet v 1, recombinant and synthetic Bet v 1-derived peptides in birch pollen allergic patients who had been vaccinated with the derivatives or adjuvant alone. Furthermore, we studied the induction of IgE-mediated skin responses in these patients using Bet v 1 and Bet v 1 fragments. Both types of vaccines induced a comparable IgG1 and IgG4 response against new sequential epitopes which overlap with the conformational IgE epitopes of Bet v 1. This response was 4- to 5-fold higher than that induced by immunotherapy with birch pollen extract. Trimer more than fragments induced also IgE responses against new epitopes and a transient increase in skin sensitivity to the fragments at the beginning of therapy. However, skin reactions to Bet v 1 tended to decrease one year after treatment in both actively treated groups. We demonstrate that vaccination with folded and unfolded recombinant allergen derivatives induces IgG Abs against new epitopes. These data may be important for the development of therapeutic as well as prophylactic vaccines based on recombinant allergens.

Bacterial fermentation of recombinant major wasp allergen Antigen 5 using oxygen limiting growth conditions improves yield and quality of inclusion bodies.

A process for bacterial expression and purification of the recombinant major wasp allergen Antigen 5 (Ves v 5) was developed to produce protein for diagnostic and therapeutic applications for type 1 allergic diseases. Special attention was focused on medium selection, fermentation conditions, and efficient refolding procedures. A soy based medium was used for fermentation to avoid peptone from animal origin. Animal-derived peptone required the use of isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG) for the induction of expression. In the case of soy peptone, a constitutive expression was observed, suggesting the presence of a component that mimics IPTG. Batch cultivation at reduced stirrer speed caused a reduced biomass due to oxygen limitation. However, subsequent purification and processing of inclusion bodies yielded significantly higher amount of product. Furthermore, the protein composition of the inclusion bodies differed. Inclusion bodies were denatured and subjected to diafiltration. Detailed monitoring of diafiltration enabled the determination of the transition point. Final purification was conducted using cation-exchange and size-exclusion chromatography. Purified recombinant Ves v 5 was analyzed by RP-HPLC, CD-spectroscopy, SDS-PAGE, and quantification ELISA. Up to 15 mg highly purified Ves v 5 per litre bioreactor volume were obtained, with endotoxin concentrations less than 20 EU mg(-1) protein and high comparability to the natural counterpart. Analytical results confirm the suitability of the recombinant protein for diagnostic and clinical applications. The results clearly demonstrate that not only biomass, but especially growth conditions play a key role in the production of recombinant Ves v 5. This has an influence on inclusion body formation, which in turn influences the renaturation rate and absolute product yield. This might also be true for other recombinant proteins that accumulate as inclusion bodies in Escherichia coli.

Phl p 3: structural and immunological characterization of a major allergen of timothy grass pollen.

BACKGROUND: The relevant importance of individual allergens for allergic sensitization is only partially understood. More detailed information on allergen structure and how it influences immunological responses can lead to better diagnosis of disease and improved preparations for allergen-specific immunotherapy. Grass pollen contains several different allergens, and although the group 3 allergens have been classified long ago, their structure and allergenicity have been poorly investigated. OBJECTIVE: To characterize Phl p 3 from timothy grass pollen and compare it with Phl p 2 with respect to biochemical structure and allergenicity. METHODS: Natural Phl p 2 and Phl p 3 were separated from a pollen extract by chromatography and characterized by 2D electrophoresis and protein sequencing. The complete sequences were determined by DNA cloning and detected in natural pollen extracts by mass spectrometry. Further comparisons of the allergens were made for IgE-binding and cross-reactivity, allergenicity was determined by basophil CD203c activation and skin prick test and 3D structures were compared by molecular modelling. RESULTS: Phl p 3 reveals molecular masses of 10.958 and 10.973 kDa and pIs of 8.9 and 9.3, respectively, Phl p 2 a molecular mass of 10.816 kDa and a pI of 4.6. The sequence identity is 58%. In spite of these differences in the primary structures, both allergens reveal similar conformational structures, resulting in similar immunological and allergological moieties. CONCLUSIONS: The group 3 and group 2 allergens are major allergens with similar 3D structures. Although they differ considerably in their protein sequences and their pIs, they show only a slightly higher immunological reactivity for Phl p 3 on the B-cell level (conformational epitopes). But distinct differences between the sequences may influence reactivity at the T cell level.

Giant ragweed specific immunotherapy is not effective in a proportion of patients sensitized to short ragweed: analysis of the allergenic differences between short and giant ragweed.

BACKGROUND: Short ragweed and giant ragweed pollen allergens are considered largely cross-reactive, and it is generally believed that 1 species is sufficient for skin testing and immunotherapy. However, in the area north of Milan (a zone widely invaded only by short ragweed), about 50% of patients submitted to injection specific immunotherapy with giant ragweed showed little or no clinical response, but showed an excellent outcome if they were shifted to short ragweed specific immunotherapy. OBJECTIVE: To investigate allergenic differences between short and giant ragweed. METHODS: IgE reactivity to short ragweed of sera from 16 patients allergic to ragweed was assessed by immunoblot before and after absorption with short and giant ragweed. Moreover, 41 ragweed-monosensitive patients underwent skin prick test with both ragweed species. RESULTS: In several cases, preabsorption of sera with giant ragweed extract was unable to inhibit IgE reactivity fully against both a 43-kd allergen and other allergens at different molecular weights in short ragweed. On skin prick test, short ragweed induced larger wheals than giant ragweed in the majority of patients, and 6 of 41 (15%) patients were strongly short ragweed-positive but giant ragweed-negative. The immunoblot with the serum from 1 of these subjects showed a strong IgE reactivity to short ragweed at about 43 kd in the absence of any reactivity to giant ragweed. CONCLUSION: Short and giant ragweed are not allergenically equivalent. Allergenic differences involve both the major allergens Amb a 1-2/Amb t 1-2 and some minor allergens. In patients allergic to ragweed, both diagnosis in vivo and immunotherapy should always be performed by using the ragweed species present in that specific geographic area.

Allergen-specific immunotherapy with recombinant grass pollen allergens.

BACKGROUND: Allergen-specific immunotherapy uses aqueous extracts of natural source materials as a basis for preparations to down regulate the allergic response. Recombinant DNA technology has enabled the cloning of many allergens, thus facilitating investigations aimed at improving efficacy and safety of immunotherapy. OBJECTIVE: To determine the effectiveness of a mixture of 5 recombinant grass pollen allergens in reducing symptoms and need for symptomatic medication in patients allergic to grass pollen. METHODS: A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of subcutaneous injection immunotherapy was performed in subjects with allergic rhinoconjunctivitis, with or without asthma. Primary endpoint was a symptom medication score compiled from separate symptom and medication scores. Secondary endpoints included a rhinitis quality of life questionnaire, conjunctival provocation, and specific antibody responses. RESULTS: The symptom medication score showed significant improvements in subjects receiving recombinant allergens as opposed to placebo, with reductions in both symptoms and medication usage. The rhinitis quality of life questionnaire revealed clinically relevant significant improvements in overall assessment and in 5 of 7 separate domains, and conjunctival provocation showed a clear trend in favor of active treatment. All treated subjects developed strong allergen-specific IgG(1) and IgG(4) antibody responses. Some patients were not sensitized to Ph l p 5 but nevertheless developed strong IgG antibody responses to that allergen. CONCLUSION: A recombinant allergen vaccine can be a effective and safe treatment to ameliorate symptoms of allergic rhinitis. The clinical benefit is associated with modification of the specific immune response with promotion of IgG(4) and reduction of IgE antibodies consistent with the induction of IL-10-producing regulatory T cells.

Primary structure, recombinant expression, and molecular characterization of Phl p 4, a major allergen of timothy grass (Phleum pratense).

Grass pollen allergy is one of the most important allergic diseases world-wide. Several meadow grasses, like timothy grass and rye grass, contribute to allergic sensitizations, but also allergens from extensively cultivated cereals, especially rye, make a profound contribution. The group 4 allergens are well known as important major allergens of grasses. We have cloned for the first time group 4 sequences from Phleum pratense, Lolium perenne, Secale cereale, Triticum aestivum, and Hordeum vulgare, and investigated the IgE-reactivity of recombinant Phl p 4 as a candidate for allergy diagnostic and therapeutic applications.

Allergen-specific nasal IgG antibodies induced by vaccination with genetically modified allergens are associated with reduced nasal allergen sensitivity.

BACKGROUND: We have performed a double-blind, placebo-controlled injection immunotherapy study with genetically modified derivatives of the major birch pollen allergen, Bet v 1 (Bet v 1-trimer, Bet v 1-fragments). OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether vaccination with genetically modified allergens induces allergen-specific antibodies in nasal secretions and to study whether these antibodies affect nasal allergen sensitivity. METHODS: A randomly picked subgroup of patients (n = 23; placebo, n = 10; trimer, n = 10; fragments, n = 3) was subjected to an extensive analysis of serum samples and nasal lavage fluids and to nasal provocation testing. Bet v 1-specific IgG(1-4) and IgA antibodies were determined in serum samples obtained before and after vaccination, after the birch pollen season, and 1 year after start of vaccination as well as in nasal lavage fluids obtained after the birch pollen season and 1 year after start of vaccination by ELISA. Nasal sensitivity to natural, birch pollen-derived Bet v 1 was determined by active anterior rhinomanometry after the birch pollen season and 1 year after start of vaccination. RESULTS: Vaccination with genetically modified Bet v 1 derivatives, but not with placebo, induced Bet v 1-specific IgG1, IgG2, and IgG4, and low IgA antibodies in serum, which also appeared in nasal secretions, but no IgG3 antibodies. The levels of therapy-induced Bet v 1-specific IgG4 antibodies in nasal secretions were significantly (P < .05) associated with reduced nasal sensitivity to natural, birch pollen-derived Bet v 1 as objectively determined by controlled nasal provocation experiments. CONCLUSION: Our data demonstrate that vaccination with genetically modified allergens induces IgG antibody responses against the corresponding natural allergen not only in serum but also in mucosal fluids, where they may protect against allergen-induced inflammation.

Cytokine and antibody responses in birch-pollen-allergic patients treated with genetically modified derivatives of the major birch pollen allergen Bet v 1.

BACKGROUND: Recently, recombinant hypoallergenic derivatives of the major birch pollen allergen, Bet v 1, were used to treat birch-pollen-allergic patients in a double-blind, placebo-controlled, multi-centre immunotherapy study. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of vaccination with aluminium-hydroxide-adsorbed recombinant Bet v 1 derivatives versus placebo on T-cell, cytokine and antibody responses in a subgroup of patients. METHODS: Blood was drawn from patients of the Swedish centre (n = 27; rBet v 1 fragments: n = 10; rBet v 1 trimer: n = 8, and placebo-aluminium hydroxide: n = 9) before the start and after completion of the treatment. PBMC were stimulated with rBet v 1 and analysed for cytokine (IL-4, IL-5, IL-10, IL-12, IL-13 and IFN-gamma)-secreting cells by ELISpot. Bet v 1-specific antibody levels in serum (IgG(1-4), IgE and IgA) were measured by ELISA. Skin prick tests with defined Bet v 1 concentrations were performed before and 10-11 months after the beginning of the study. RESULTS: Bet v 1-specific IgG levels, consisting of IgG(1), IgG(2) and IgG(4), were significantly increased after treatment with recombinant allergen derivatives. Treatment with rBet v 1 trimer led to a significant (p < 0.05) reduction of Bet v 1-reactive IL-5- and IL-13-producing cells, reflecting a reduced Th2 response. In addition, a decreased number of Bet v 1-reactive IL-4 producing (p = 0.07) and an increase of IL-12-producing (p = 0.06) cells was noted in the trimer-treated patients. In contrast to placebo, active treatment resulted in significantly reduced immediate-type skin reactions to Bet v 1 even 10-11 months after treatment. CONCLUSION: Vaccination with recombinant hypoallergenic Bet v 1 derivatives induces a Bet v 1-specific IgG response and leads to reduced skin reactivity in allergic patients. A reduction of Bet v 1-specific Th2 responses was observed in trimer-treated patients, which may reflect the intrinsic property of this allergen derivative.

Analytical and preparative native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis: Investigation of the recombinant and natural major grass pollen allergen Phl p 2.

Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and Western blot are amongst the most popular methods for allergen characterization, such as comparison of recombinant allergens with their natural counterparts. Native PAGE was evaluated as a possible robust and simple method offering high-resolution capacity for characterization of the major grass pollen allergen Phl p 2. Analytical separation of recombinant Phl p 2 provided a superior quality control in terms of homogeneity and, after Western blotting, immunoglobulin E (IgE) reactivity. Separation of natural Phl p 2 identified two major isoforms which were shown to have different N-terminal sequences and IgE-binding properties. After isolation using preparative native PAGE in combination with electrodialysis, both isoforms were investigated by specific proteolysis and reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC). The results demonstrate differences in the primary structures and that the recombinant counterpart corresponds exactly to one isoform. Analytical and preparative native PAGE thus proved to be powerful tools for the investigation of allergen isoforms and quality control of recombinant counterparts.

Transition of recombinant allergens from bench to clinical application.

The cloning and production of an increasing number of allergens through the use of DNA technology has provided the opportunity to use these proteins instead of natural allergen extracts for the diagnosis and therapy of IgE-mediated allergic disease. For diagnostic purposes, it is essential that the molecules exhibit IgE-reactivity comparable with that of the natural wild-type molecules, whereas T cell reactivity and immunogenic activity may be more important for allergen-specific immunotherapy. In relation to the latter, the development of hypoallergenic recombinant allergen variants is an approach which shows great promise. Clinical application of the proteins requires that they must be produced under conditions of Good Manufacturing Practice and meet the specifications set down in the appropriate Regulatory Guidelines, principally the ICH-Guidelines. Special consideration has to be given to the choice of expression system, the design of the expression vectors, and the purification strategy to obtain a pure product free from toxins and contamination. The availability of the pure recombinant molecules provides the opportunity to formulate preparations that are free from the non-allergenic ballast proteins present in natural allergen extracts and which contain relative concentrations of the allergens in clinically appropriate proportions.