Intracellular trafficking of perforin: to thwart a killer.

How do killer cells restrain perforin, the most potent toxin known to biologists, at its point of synthesis in the endoplasmic reticulum, where conditions are ideal for its activation? In this issue of Immunity, Brennan et al. (2011) study its trafficking, offering insights into protective mechanisms.

Membrane pore formation at protein-lipid interfaces.

Pore-forming proteins (PFPs) interact with lipid bilayers to compromise membrane integrity. Many PFPs function by inserting a ring of oligomerized subunits into the bilayer to form a protein-lined hydrophilic channel. However, mounting evidence suggests that PFPs can also generate 'proteolipidic' pores by contributing to the fusion of inner and outer bilayer leaflets to form a toroidal structure. We discuss here toroidal pore formation by peptides including melittin, protegrin, and Alzheimer's Aß1-41, as well as by PFPs from several evolutionarily unrelated families: the colicin/Bcl-2 grouping including the pro-apoptotic protein Bax, actinoporins derived from sea anemones, and the membrane attack complex-perforin/cholesterol dependent cytolysin (MACPF/CDC) set of proteins. We also explore how the structure and biological role of toroidal pores might be investigated further.

Human and mouse granzyme A induce a proinflammatory cytokine response.

Granzyme A (GzmA) is considered a major proapoptotic protease. We have discovered that GzmA-induced cell death involves rapid membrane damage that depends on the synergy between micromolar concentrations of GzmA and sublytic perforin (PFN). Ironically, GzmA and GzmB, independent of their catalytic activity, both mediated this swift necrosis. Even without PFN, lower concentrations of human GzmA stimulated monocytic cells to secrete proinflammatory cytokines (interleukin-1beta [IL-1beta], TNFalpha, and IL-6) that were blocked by a caspase-1 inhibitor. Moreover, murine GzmA and GzmA(+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) induce IL-1beta from primary mouse macrophages, and GzmA(-/-) mice resist lipopolysaccharide-induced toxicity. Thus, the granule secretory pathway plays an unexpected role in inflammation, with GzmA acting as an endogenous modulator.

Mouse cytotoxic T cell-derived granzyme B activates the mitochondrial cell death pathway in a Bim-dependent fashion.

Cytotoxic T cells (Tc) use perforin and granzyme B (gzmB) to kill virus-infected cells and cancer cells. Recent evidence suggests that human gzmB primarily induces apoptosis via the intrinsic mitochondrial pathway by either cleaving Bid or activating Bim leading to the activation of Bak/Bax and subsequent generation of active caspase-3. In contrast, mouse gzmB is thought to predominantly induce apoptosis by directly processing pro-caspase-3. However, in certain mouse cell types gzmB-mediated apoptosis mainly occurs via the mitochondrial pathway. To investigate whether Bim is involved under the latter conditions, we have now employed ex vivo virus-immune mouse Tc that selectively kill by using perforin and gzmB (gzmB(+)Tc) as effector cells and wild type as well as Bim- or Bak/Bax-deficient spontaneously (3T9) or virus-(SV40) transformed mouse embryonic fibroblast cells as targets. We show that gzmB(+)Tc-mediated apoptosis (phosphatidylserine translocation, mitochondrial depolarization, cytochrome c release, and caspase-3 activation) was severely reduced in 3T9 cells lacking either Bim or both Bak and Bax. This outcome was related to the ability of Tc cells to induce the degradation of Mcl-1 and Bcl-XL, the anti-apoptotic counterparts of Bim. In contrast, gzmB(+)Tc-mediated apoptosis was not affected in SV40-transformed mouse embryonic fibroblast cells lacking Bak/Bax. The data provide evidence that Bim participates in mouse gzmB(+)Tc-mediated apoptosis of certain targets by activating the mitochondrial pathway and suggest that the mode of cell death depends on the target cell. Our results suggest that the various molecular events leading to transformation and/or immortalization of cells have an impact on their relative resistance to the multiple gzmB(+)Tc-induced death pathways.

Granzyme A produced by γ(9)δ(2) T cells induces human macrophages to inhibit growth of an intracellular pathogen.

Human γ(9)δ(2) T cells potently inhibit pathogenic microbes, including intracellular mycobacteria, but the key inhibitory mechanism(s) involved have not been identified. We report a novel mechanism involving the inhibition of intracellular mycobacteria by soluble granzyme A. γ(9)δ(2) T cells produced soluble factors that could pass through 0.45 µm membranes and inhibit intracellular mycobacteria in human monocytes cultured below transwell inserts. Neutralization of TNF-α in co-cultures of infected monocytes and γ(9)δ(2) T cells prevented inhibition, suggesting that TNF-α was the critical inhibitory factor produced by γ(9)δ(2) T cells. However, only siRNA- mediated knockdown of TNF-α in infected monocytes, but not in γ(9)δ(2) T cells, prevented mycobacterial growth inhibition. Investigations of other soluble factors produced by γ(9)δ(2) T cells identified a highly significant correlation between the levels of granzyme A produced and intracellular mycobacterial growth inhibition. Furthermore, purified granzyme A alone induced inhibition of intracellular mycobacteria, while knockdown of granzyme A in γ(9)δ(2) T cell clones blocked their inhibitory effects. The inhibitory mechanism was independent of autophagy, apoptosis, nitric oxide production, type I interferons, Fas/FasL and perforin. These results demonstrate a novel microbial defense mechanism involving granzyme A-mediated triggering of TNF-α production by monocytes leading to intracellular mycobacterial growth suppression. This pathway may provide a protective mechanism relevant for the development of new vaccines and/or immunotherapies for macrophage-resident chronic microbial infections.

Effects of MACPF/CDC proteins on lipid membranes.

Recent work on the MACPF/CDC superfamily of pore-forming proteins has focused on the structural analysis of monomers and pore-forming oligomeric complexes. We set the family of proteins in context and highlight aspects of their function which the direct and exclusive equation of oligomers with pores fails to explain. Starting with a description of the distribution of MACPF/CDC proteins across the domains of life, we proceed to show how their evolutionary relationships can be understood on the basis of their structural homology and re-evaluate models for pore formation by perforin, in particular. We furthermore highlight data showing the role of incomplete oligomeric rings (arcs) in pore formation and how this can explain small pores generated by oligomers of proteins belonging to the family. We set this in the context of cell biological and biophysical data on the proteins' function and discuss how this helps in the development of an understanding of how they act in processes such as apicomplexan parasites gliding through cells and exiting from cells.

Perforin activity at membranes leads to invaginations and vesicle formation.

The cytotoxic cell granule secretory pathway is essential for immune defence. How the pore-forming protein perforin (PFN) facilitates the cytosolic delivery of granule-associated proteases (granzymes) remains enigmatic. Here we show that PFN is able to induce invaginations and formation of complete internal vesicles in giant unilamellar vesicles. Formation of internal vesicles depends on native PFN and calcium and antibody labeling shows the localization of PFN at the invaginations. This vesiculation is recapitulated in large unilamellar vesicles and in this case PFN oligomers can be seen associated with the necks of the invaginations. Capacitance measurements show PFN is able to increase a planar lipid membrane surface area in the absence of pore formation, in agreement with the ability to induce invaginations. Finally, addition of PFN to Jurkat cells causes the formation of internal vesicles prior to pore formation. PFN is capable of triggering an endocytosis-like event in addition to pore formation, suggesting a new paradigm for its role in delivering apoptosis-inducing granzymes into target cells.

Interleukin-1R signaling is essential for induction of proapoptotic CD8 T cells, viral clearance, and pathology during lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus infection in mice.

The T cell granule exocytosis pathway is essential to control hepatotropic lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus strain WE (LCMV-WE) but also contributes to the observed pathology in mice. Although effective antiviral T cell immunity and development of viral hepatitis are strictly dependent on perforin and granzymes, the molecular basis underlying induction of functionally competent virus-immune T cells, including participation of the innate immune system, is far from being resolved. We demonstrate here that LCMV-immune T cells of interleukin-1 receptor (IL-1R)-deficient mice readily express transcripts for perforin and granzymes but only translate perforin, resulting in the lack of proapoptotic potential in vitro. LCMV is not cleared in IL-1R-deficient mice, and yet the infected mice develop neither splenomegaly nor hepatitis. These results demonstrate that IL-1R signaling is central to the induction of proapoptotic CD8 T cell immunity, including viral clearance and associated tissue injuries in LCMV infection.

Human perforin employs different avenues to damage membranes.

Perforin (PFN) is a pore-forming protein produced by cytotoxic lymphocytes that aids in the clearance of tumor or virus-infected cells by a mechanism that involves the formation of transmembrane pores. The properties of PFN pores and the mechanism of their assembly remain unclear. Here, we studied pore characteristics by functional and structural methods to show that perforin forms pores more heterogeneous than anticipated. Planar lipid bilayer experiments indicate that perforin pores exhibit a broad range of conductances, from 0.15 to 21 nanosiemens. In comparison with large pores that possessed low noise and remained stably open, small pores exhibited high noise and were very unstable. Furthermore, the opening step and the pore size were dependent on the lipid composition of the membrane. The heterogeneity in pore sizes was confirmed with cryo-electron microscopy and showed a range of sizes matching that observed in the conductance measurements. Furthermore, two different membrane-bound PFN conformations were observed, interpreted as pre-pore and pore states of the protein. The results collectively indicate that PFN forms heterogeneous pores through a multistep mechanism and provide a new paradigm for understanding the range of different effects of PFN and related membrane attack complex/perforin domain proteins observed in vivo and in vitro.

Deregulation of mitochondrial membrane potential by mitochondrial insertion of granzyme B and direct Hax-1 cleavage.

The cytoplasm and the nucleus have been identified as activity sites for granzyme B (GrB) following its delivery from cytotoxic lymphocyte granules into target cells. Here we report on the ability of exogenous GrB to insert into and function within a proteinase K-resistant mitochondrial compartment. We identified Hax-1 (HS-1-associated protein X-1), a mitochondrial protein involved in the maintenance of mitochondrial membrane potential, as a GrB substrate within the mitochondrion. GrB cleaves Hax-1 into two major fragments: an N-terminal fragment that localizes to mitochondria and a C-terminal fragment that localizes to the cytosol after being released from GrB-treated mitochondria. The N-terminal Hax-1 fragment major cellular impact is on the regulation of mitochondrial polarization. Overexpression of wild-type Hax-1 or its uncleavable mutant form protects the mitochondria against GrB or valinomycin-mediated depolarization. The N-terminal Hax-1 fragment functions as a dominant negative form of Hax-1, mediating mitochondrial depolarization in a cyclophilin D-dependent manner. Thus, induced expression of the N-terminal Hax-1 fragment results in mitochondrial depolarization and subsequent lysosomal degradation of such altered mitochondria. This study is the first to demonstrate GrB activity within the mitochondrion and to identify Hax-1 cleavage as a novel mechanism for GrB-mediated mitochondrial depolarization.

Granzyme B-induced and caspase 3-dependent cleavage of gelsolin by mouse cytotoxic T cells modifies cytoskeleton dynamics.

Granule-associated perforin and granzymes (gzms) are key effector molecules of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (Tc cells) and natural killer cells and play a critical role in the control of intracellular pathogens and cancer. Based on the notion that many gzms, including A, B, C, K, H, and M exhibit cytotoxic activity in vitro, all gzms are believed to serve a similar function in vivo. However, more recent evidence supports the concept that gzms are not unidimensional but, rather, possess non-cytotoxic potential, including stimulation of pro-inflammatory cytokines and anti-viral activities. The present study shows that isolated mouse gzmB cleaves the actin-severing mouse protein, cytoplasmic gelsolin (c-gelsolin) in vitro. However, when delivered to intact target cells by ex vivo immune Tc cells, gzmB mediates c-gelsolin proteolysis via activation of caspases 3/7. The NH(2)-terminal c-gelsolin fragment generated by either gzmB or caspase 3 in vitro constitutively severs actin filaments without destroying the target cells. The observation that gzmB secreted by Tc cells initiates a caspase cascade that disintegrates the actin cytoskeleton in target cells suggests that this intracellular process may contribute to anti-viral host defense.

Granzyme B activates procaspase-3 which signals a mitochondrial amplification loop for maximal apoptosis.

Granzyme B (GrB), acting similar to an apical caspase, efficiently activates a proteolytic cascade after intracellular delivery by perforin. Studies here were designed to learn whether the physiologic effector, GrB-serglycin, initiates apoptosis primarily through caspase-3 or through BH3-only proteins with subsequent mitochondrial permeabilization and apoptosis. Using four separate cell lines that were either genetically lacking the zymogen or rendered deficient in active caspase-3, we measured apoptotic indices within whole cells (active caspase-3, mitochondrial depolarization [DeltaPsim] and TUNEL). Adhering to these conditions, the following were observed in targets after GrB delivery: (a) procaspase-3-deficient cells fail to display a reduced DeltaPsim and DNA fragmentation; (b) Bax/Bak is required for optimal DeltaPsim reduction, caspase-3 activation, and DNA fragmentation, whereas BID cleavage is undetected by immunoblot; (c) Bcl-2 inhibits GrB-mediated apoptosis (reduced DeltaPsim and TUNEL reactivity) by blocking oligomerization of caspase-3; and (d) in procaspase-3-deficient cells a mitochondrial-independent pathway was identified which involved procaspase-7 activation, PARP cleavage, and nuclear condensation. The data therefore support the existence of a fully implemented apoptotic pathway initiated by GrB, propagated by caspase-3, and perpetuated by a mitochondrial amplification loop but also emphasize the presence of an ancillary caspase-dependent, mitochondria-independent pathway.

A clathrin/dynamin- and mannose-6-phosphate receptor-independent pathway for granzyme B-induced cell death.

The 280-kD cation-independent mannose-6-phosphate receptor (MPR) has been shown to play a role in endocytic uptake of granzyme B, since target cells overexpressing MPR have an increased sensitivity to granzyme B-mediated apoptosis. On this basis, it has been proposed that cells lacking MPR are poor targets for cytotoxic lymphocytes that mediate allograft rejection or tumor immune surveillance. In the present study, we report that the uptake of granzyme B into target cells is independent of MPR. We used HeLa cells overexpressing a dominant-negative mutated (K44A) form of dynamin and mouse fibroblasts overexpressing or lacking MPR to show that the MPR/clathrin/dynamin pathway is not required for granzyme B uptake. Consistent with this observation, cells lacking the MPR/clathrin pathway remained sensitive to granzyme B. Exposure of K44A-dynamin-overexpressing and wild-type HeLa cells to granzyme B with sublytic perforin resulted in similar apoptosis in the two cell populations, both in short and long term assays. Granzyme B uptake into MPR-overexpressing L cells was more rapid than into MPR-null L cells, but the receptor-deficient cells took up granzyme B through fluid phase micropinocytosis and remained sensitive to it. Contrary to previous findings, we also demonstrated that mouse tumor allografts that lack MPR expression were rejected as rapidly as tumors that overexpress MPR. Entry of granzyme B into target cells and its intracellular trafficking to induce target cell death in the presence of perforin are therefore not critically dependent on MPR or clathrin/dynamin-dependent endocytosis.

Granzyme B translocates across the lipid membrane only in the presence of lytic agents.

Granzyme B (GrB), a component of the cytotoxic cell granule secretion pathway, is designed to kill infected and transformed cells after intracellular delivery by the pore forming protein, perforin. The mechanism of the delivery remains speculative. In this study we tested the hypothesis that GrB possesses capacity to bind and disrupt lipid membranes. Here in comparison to previous studies that show GrB interacts with carbohydrate moieties, the protease does not bind membrane phospholipids nor has intrinsic membranolytic properties. To study the transmembrane movement of GrB, we developed a model membrane system consisting of a high-molecular weight GrB substrate encapsulated in unilamellar vesicles. Intra-vesicle proteolysis clearly requires concentrations of lytic agents (streptolysin O, perforin or Triton X-100) that disrupt unilamellar membranes.

Cytotoxic granule-mediated apoptosis: unraveling the complex mechanism.

The molecular details of cytotoxic granule-mediated apoptosis have been gleaned from the study of the effects of isolated granzymes and perforin on target cells. Recent evidence indicates that the physiological apoptosis-inducing form is a multi-component macro-complex consisting of cationic granule proteins non-covalently linked to the chondroitin-sulfate proteoglycan, serglycin.

Granzyme A Contributes to Inflammatory Arthritis in Mice Through Stimulation of Osteoclastogenesis.

OBJECTIVE: Granzyme A (GzmA) levels are elevated in the plasma and synovium of patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), suggesting involvement of this protease in the pathogenesis of the disease. GzmA contributes to sepsis by regulating the production of proinflammatory cytokines. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the contribution of GzmA to the pathogenesis of RA in vivo and to examine the possibility that GzmA acting via tumor necrosis factor (TNF) stimulates osteoclastogenesis. METHODS: Inflammatory arthritis induced by type II collagen was evaluated in wild-type, GzmA-deficient, and perforin-deficient mice. The osteoclastogenic potential of GzmA was examined in vitro using bone marrow cells and colony-forming unit-granulocyte-macrophage (CFU-GM) cells and in vivo using GzmA-deficient mice. RESULTS: Gene deletion of GzmA attenuated collagen-induced arthritis, including serum levels of proinflammatory cytokines, joint damage, and bone erosion in affected mice, suggesting that osteoclast activity is reduced in the absence of GzmA. Accordingly, GzmA-treated bone marrow cells produced multinucleated cells that fulfilled the criteria for mature osteoclasts: tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) activity, ß integrin expression, calcitonin receptor expression, and resorptive activity on dentin slices. GzmA appeared to act without accessory cells, and its activity was not affected by osteoprotegerin, suggesting a minor contribution of RANKL. It also induced the expression and secretion of TNF. Neutralization of TNF or stimulation of CFU-GM cells from TNF-/- mice prevented GzmA-induced osteoclastogenesis. GzmA-deficient mice had reduced osteoclastogenesis in vivo (fewer calcitonin receptor-positive multinucleated cells and fewer transcripts for cathepsin K, matrix metalloproteinase 9, and TRAP in joints) and reduced serum levels of C-terminal telopeptide of type I collagen. CONCLUSION: GzmA contributes to the joint destruction of RA partly by promoting osteoclast differentiation.

Granzymes A and K differentially potentiate LPS-induced cytokine response.

Granzymes are serine proteases that, upon release from cytotoxic cells, induce apoptosis in tumor cells and virally infected cells. In addition, a role of granzymes in inflammation is emerging. Recently, we have demonstrated that extracellular granzyme K (GrK) potentiates lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-induced cytokine response from monocytes. GrK interacts with LPS, disaggregates LPS micelles, and stimulates LPS-CD14 binding and Toll-like receptor signaling. Here we show that human GrA also potentiates cytokine responses in human monocytes initiated by LPS or Gram-negative bacteria. Similar to GrK, this effect is independent of GrA catalytic activity. Unlike GrK, however, GrA does not bind to LPS, has little influence on LPS micelle disaggregation, and does not augment LPS-CD14 complex formation. We conclude that GrA and GrK differentially modulate LPS-Toll-like receptor signaling in monocytes, suggesting functional redundancy among cytotoxic lymphocyte proteases in the anti-bacterial innate immune response.

Detection of functional cell surface perforin by flow cytometry.

How perforin (PFN) delivers the granzymes during cytotoxic granule mediated apoptosis remains a mystery. A major obstacle has been the inability to visualize PFN in either monomeric or polymeric form after interaction with the target cell surface. An antibody based technique is described which detects cell surface PFN on intact cells by flow cytometry. The methodology requires the presence of calcium (Ca2+) at a concentration which supports binding but not polymerization of PFN. Functionality was ensured by showing the cell surface PFN was able to deliver GrB causing caspase-3 activation and mitochondrial depolarization. The technique demonstrates a role for heparan sulfate proteoglycans in PFN binding. Further, the variable sensitivity of effector versus target cell lines to the permeabilizing effects of PFN could not be attributed to differential binding of PFN.

Detection of human perforin by ELISpot and ELISA: ex vivo identification of virus-specific cells.

The perforin (PFN) protein is essential for the elimination of target cells by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and natural killer (NK) cells. The study of cells releasing PFN has been hampered by a lack of sensitive methods. We therefore produced PFN-reactive monoclonal antibodies (mAb) and developed capture enzyme-linked immunosorbent (ELISA) and enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISpot) assays. Three mAbs were generated and shown to react with unique determinants of PFN. All mAbs recognized intracellular PFN in human peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) as assessed by flow cytometry and immunohistochemistry. Functional PFN capture ELISA and ELISpot assays were developed utilizing two of the mAbs for capture and the third mAb for detection. When examining PFN release by the YT lymphoma cell line, the ELISpot displayed a greater detection sensitivity than the ELISA. Assessment of PFN release by a CTL clone using ELISpot gave results consistent with a parallel (51)Cr-release cytotoxicity assay. Moreover, PFN release by PBMC could be quantified by ELISpot and ELISA after ex vivo stimulation with defined CTL epitopes from common viruses. These novel immunoassays will be valuable for further investigations of the mechanisms underlying granule-mediated apoptosis. In addition, the capture immunoassays could provide tools for studying CTL responses in infectious and tumor diseases as well as for vaccine development.