Critical role for CD8 in T cell receptor binding and activation by peptide/major histocompatibility complex multimers.

Recent data using MHC/peptide tetramers and dimers suggests that the T cell coreceptors, CD4 and CD8, although important for T cell activation, do not play a direct role in facilitating T cell receptor (TCR) binding to multivalent MHC/peptide ligands. Instead, a current model proposes that coreceptors are recruited only after a stable TCR-MHC/peptide complex has already formed and signaled. In contrast, we show using multimeric class I MHC/peptide ligands that CD8 plays a critical (in some cases obligatory) role in antigen-specific TCR binding. T cell activation, measured by calcium mobilization, was induced by multimeric but not monomeric ligands and also showed CD8 dependency. Our analysis using anti-CD8 antibodies revealed that binding to different epitopes of CD8 can either block or augment TCR-MHC/peptide interaction. These effects on TCR binding to high-affinity agonist ligands were even more pronounced when binding to multimeric low-affinity ligands, including TCR antagonists, was studied. Our data have important implications for the role of CD8 in TCR binding to MHC/peptide ligands and in T cell activation. In addition, our results argue against the view that multimeric MHC/peptide ligands bind directly and solely to the TCR; rather, our data highlight a pivotal contribution of CD8 for this association.

T cell receptor (TCR) recognition of MHC class I variants: intermolecular second-site reversion provides evidence for peptide/MHC conformational variation.

We investigated mechanistic differences in antigen presentation between murine MHC class I variants H-2K(b) and H-2K(bm)8. H-2K(bm)8 differs from H-2K(b) by four residues at the floor of the peptide-binding site, affecting its B pocket which interacts with the second (P2) residue of the peptide. The rest of the molecule, including the T cell receptor (TCR)-contacting residues, is identical to H-2K(b). Due to this variation, CTLs that recognize the ovalbumin 257-264 and HSV gB 498-505 peptides on H-2K(b) cannot recognize them on H-2K(bm)8. This could be due to impaired peptide binding or an altered peptide: K(bm)8 conformation. Peptide binding studies ruled out the first explanation. Molecular modeling indicated that the most obvious consequence of amino acid variation between peptide/H-2K(b) and peptide/H-2K(bm)8 complexes would be a loss of the conserved hydrogen bond network in the B pocket of the latter. This could cause conformational variation of bound peptides. Intermolecular second-site reversion was used to test this hypothesis: P2-substituted OVA and HSV peptides, engineered to restore the hydrogen bond network of the B pocket, were the only ones which restored CTL recognition. These results provide a molecular understanding of peptide/MHC conformational variation.

Clone-specific T cell receptor antagonists of major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted cytotoxic T cells.

A previous report showed that the proliferative response of helper T cells to class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted antigens can be inhibited by analogues of the antigen, which act as T cell receptor (TCR) antagonists. Here we define and analyze peptide variants that antagonize various functions of class I MHC-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones. Of 64 variants at individual TCR contact sites of the Kb-restricted octamer peptide ovalbumin257-264 (OVAp), a very high proportion (40%) antagonized lysis by three OVAp-specific CTL clones. This effect was highly clone specific, since many antagonists for one T cell clone have differential effects on another. We show that this inhibition of CTL function is not a result of T cell-T cell interaction, precluding veto-like phenomena as a mechanism for antagonism. Moreover, we present evidence for direct interaction between the TCR and antagonist-MHC complexes. In further analysis of the T cell response, we found that serine esterase release and cytokine production are susceptible to TCR antagonism similarly to lysis. Ca2+ flux, an early event in signaling, is also inhibited by antagonists but may be more resistant to the antagonist effect than downstream responses.

Role of 2CT cell receptor residues in the binding of self- and allo-major histocompatibility complexes.

T cell clone 2C recognizes the alloantigen L(d) and the positive selecting major histocompatibility complex (MHC), K(b). To explore the molecular basis of T cell antigen receptor (TCR) binding to different peptide/MHC (pMHC) complexes, we performed alanine scanning mutagenesis of the 2C TCR. The TCR energy maps for QL9/L(d) and SIYR/K(b) were remarkably similar, in that 16 of 41 Valpha and Vbeta alanine mutants showed reduced binding to both ligands. Several TCR residues varied in the magnitude of energy contributed to binding the two ligands, indicating that there are also unique interactions. Residues in complementarity determining region 3alpha showed the most notable differences in binding energetics among the ligands QL9/L(d), SIYR/K(b), and the clonotypic antibody 1B2. Various lines of evidence suggest that these differences relate to the mobility of this loop and point to the key role of conformational dynamics in pMHC recognition.

Cloning and expression of class I major histocompatibility complex genes of the rat.

Little is known about the organization of class I genes in the rat although there is prima facie evidence that it is distinct from that of the mouse. We report the cloning of 61 nonclassical rat class I genes into cosmid clusters with a total mapped length of 1,264 kb. It is certain that the total number of class I genes in the rat must exceed this number. From restriction maps it is possible to identify substantial regions of duplication. By transfection of cosmids into mouse L cells, it has been possible to demonstrate at least seven different nonclassical rat class I genes that are expressible on the cell surface. Crossreaction of a single mouse monoclonal antibody with all of these class I molecules is consistent with sequence homogenization within the rat nonclassical system. Attempts to find rat homologues of the mouse Tla genes by crosshybridization of rat cosmids with a range of different TLa-specific probes were unsuccessful, suggesting that this large group of divergent class I genes is absent or nearly so from the rat. The large number of class I genes in the rat appears to have arisen by expansion of genes more closely related to the classical sequence.

Preselection thymocytes are more sensitive to T cell receptor stimulation than mature T cells.

During T cell development, thymocytes which are tolerant to self-peptides but reactive to foreign peptides are selected. The current model for thymocyte selection proposes that self-peptide-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) complexes that bind the T cell receptor with low affinity will promote positive selection while those with high affinity will result in negative selection. Upon thymocyte maturation, such low affinity self-peptide-MHC ligands no longer provoke a response, but foreign peptides can incidentally be high affinity ligands and can therefore stimulate T cells. For this model to work, thymocytes must be more sensitive to ligand than mature T cells. Contrary to this expectation, several groups have shown that thymocytes are less responsive than mature T cells to anti-T cell receptor for antigen (TCR)/CD3 mAb stimulation. Additionally, the lower TCR levels on thymocytes, compared with T cells, would potentially correlate with decreased thymocyte sensitivity. Here we compared preselection thymocytes and mature T cells for early activation events in response to peptide-MHC ligands. Remarkably, the preselection thymocytes were more responsive than mature T cells when stimulated with low affinity peptide variants, while both populations responded equally well to the antigenic peptide. This directly demonstrates the increased sensitivity of thymocytes compared with T cells for TCR engagement by peptide-MHC complexes.

T-cell selection.

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules in the thymus select from the repertoire of germline receptors those that will be most useful in mounting responses to antigen in the periphery. Recent data has shed light on the involvement of self peptides presented by the MHC in this process, and has indicated that a requirement for the constant recognition of 'self' may be essential for T-cell longevity in the periphery.

The ligand for positive selection of T lymphocytes in the thymus.

T cells are spared from programmed cell death in the thymus after an appropriate interaction between the T-cell receptor and a self peptide/MHC complex; this step is referred to as positive selection. Recent work has focused on precise identification of the positively selecting ligand, and the cell that presents it. First, it was shown that bone marrow derived cells or fibroblasts can substitute for epithelial cells in providing the ligand for positive selection. Second, in a T-cell receptor transgenic system, variants of the antigenic peptides were found to induce positive selection. Peptides that served as antagonists or weak agonists for the T-cell receptor efficiently selected immature thymocytes for survival. It appears that the peptide ligands for positive selection of T cells are self peptides, which serve as mimics or look alikes for the universe of pathogen peptides. The challenge remains to identify a naturally occurring thymic self peptide that can cause positive selection and determine the range of reactivities to foreign peptides which it can select.

Dissection of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and T cell receptor contact residues in a Kb-restricted ovalbumin peptide and an assessment of the predictive power of MHC-binding motifs.

The effect of alanine substitution on the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) binding and T cell receptor recognition of the Kb-restricted ovalbumin 257-264 peptide was investigated. Positions 3, 5 and 8 of the octamer were important for Kb binding, as predicted from the motifs found in Kb-associated peptides, while mutations at positions 4, 6 and 7 affected cytotoxic T lymphocyte recognition. Substitutions at positions 1 and 2 had very minor effects on T cell recognition. In addition, we tested the capacity of sequence motifs to predict MHC binding by analysis of a series of peptides which all bear the minimal Kb motif. We found that possession of good motifs was not always sufficient to give strong MHC binding, indicating secondary effects of the residues flanking the "MHC anchor" positions.

Homeostatic expansion and phenotypic conversion of naïve T cells in response to self peptide/MHC ligands.

Recent data suggest that survival of resting, naïve T cells requires an interaction with self MHC molecules. From analysis of the class I MHC-restricted T cell receptor transgenic strain OT-I, we report a different response. Rather than merely surviving, these T cells proliferated slowly after transfer into T-depleted syngeneic hosts. This expansion required both T cell "space" and expression of normal levels of self class I MHC molecules. Furthermore, we demonstrate that during homeostatic expansion in a suitable environment, naïve phenotype (CD44(low)) OT-I T cells converted to memory phenotype (CD44(med/high)), despite the absence of foreign antigenic stimulation. On the other hand, cells undergoing homeostatic expansion did not acquire cytolytic effector function. The significance of these data for reactivity of T cells with self peptide/MHC ligands and the implications for normal and abnormal T cell homeostasis are discussed.

Functional mapping of the orientation for TCR recognition of an H2-Kb-restricted ovalbumin peptide suggests that the beta-chain subunit can dominate the determination of peptide side chain specificity.

T cells recognize a complex of antigenic peptide bound to the class I or class II products of the MHC. Crystallographic analysis of the interaction between MHC class I-bound peptide fragments and specific TCR have recently been described and highlight the importance of the CDR3 in determining peptide specificity. The results presented here show functional data for TCR recognition of the H2-Kb class-I restricted determinant derived from OVA (SIINFEKL) that are consistent with the TCR orientation defined by these crystal structures. In addition, we also found that the beta-chain CDR3 dominates side chain specificity for the most exposed regions within this peptide. The data also suggest that this orientation and pattern of beta-chain dominance may extend to the recognition of a second H2-Kb-restricted peptide from the herpes simplex virus type 1 glycoprotein B (SSIEFARL), which shares a common alpha-chain contact with the OVA peptide. These results are discussed in terms of a common orientation for TCR-ligand interaction and the greater potential for TCR beta-chain CDR3 diversity in determining peptide side chain specificity.

Specificity and flexibility in thymic selection.

During positive selection, developing thymocytes are rescued from programmed cell death by T-cell receptor (TCR)-mediated recognition of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. MHC-bound peptides contribute to this process. Recently we identified individual MHC-binding peptides which can induce positive selection of a single TCR. Here we examine peptide fine specificity in positive selection. These data suggest that a direct TCR-peptide interaction occurs during this event, and strengthens the correlation between selecting peptides and TCR antagonists. Certain positively selecting peptides are weakly antigenic. We demonstrate that thymocytes 'educated' on such a peptide are specifically non-responsive to it and have decreased CD8 expression levels. Similar reduction of CD8 expression on mature T cells converts a TCR agonist into a TCR antagonist. These data indicate that thymocytes may maintain self-tolerance towards a positively selecting ligand by regulating co-receptor expression.

V beta 5+ T cell receptors skew toward OVA+H-2Kb recognition.

T cells recognize a complex of peptide Ag bound within the groove of MHC-encoded molecules. Although many studies have attempted to correlate TCR gene expression with specificity for particular Ag/MHC combinations, it is still not clear exactly how the TCR physically interacts with its cognate ligand. We have analyzed transgenic mice that carry a rearranged gene encoding a V beta 5.2+ TCR beta-chain derived from the CD8+ CTL clone B3, which is specific for chicken OVA+H-2Kb. Surprisingly, we have found that peripheral lymphocytes isolated from naïve V beta 5.2 transgenic mice can generate a strong primary anti-OVA CTL response when stimulated in vitro with OVA+H-2b, whereas generation of even a weak anti-OVA response from nontransgenic littermates requires in vivo priming. This response is Ag specific, because the transgenic mice are unable to respond with or without priming to vesicular stomatitis virus, which contains a dominant epitope presented in the context of H-2Kb. The precursor frequency of OVA-specific CTL in unprimed V beta 5.2 transgenic mice is approximately 30-fold higher than that in nontransgenic littermate controls. Reverse transcription-PCR analyses demonstrate that OVA-specific CTL lines derived from unprimed V beta 5.2 transgenic mice express a variety of TCR V alpha elements, indicating that the transgenic anti-OVA response is not solely due to the reconstitution of the original B3 TCR. In fact, our data suggest that even a nontransgenic V beta 5+ TCR is intrinsically OVA specific. First, five separate OVA-specific oligoclonal CTL lines derived from individual nontransgenic mice demonstrate dramatic skewing toward expression of V beta 5.1+ or V beta 5.2+ TCR over the course of several in vitro stimulations. Second, sorting for V beta 5+CD8+ nontransgenic cells enriches for OVA-specific CTL. However, peptide antagonism experiments using mutant forms of the Kb-restricted OVA peptide reveal distinct differences between the recognition patterns of two individual OVA-specific CTL lines derived from unprimed V beta 5.2 transgenic mice. These experiments support the notion that a discrete portion of the responding TCR can heavily influence but not necessarily be solely sufficient for the recognition of a peptide Ag presented in the cleft of an MHC-encoded molecule.

A thymic epithelial cell line induces both positive and negative selection in the thymus.

TCR engagement in the thymus results in both survival and elimination signals for developing thymocytes. To examine whether both signals can be provided by the same cell type, we investigated the ability of a thymic epithelial cell (TEC) line 427.1, previously shown to allow positive selection in the thymus, to induce clonal deletion of immature thymocytes. [H-2b/s-->H-2s] bone marrow chimeras are non-responsive to antigens in the context of H-2b. However, chimeras that underwent intrathymic injection of H-2b/s 427.1 cells expressing vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) nucleocapsid antigen acquired the ability to raise influenza, but not VSV specific H-2b restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses. The ability of 427.1 cells to delete CD4+CD8+ thymocytes was determined using mice transgenic for the TCR specific for ovalbumin (OVA) in the context of H-2Kb. OVA transfected, but not mock transfected 427.1 TECs, induced in vitro deletion of CD4+CD8+ TCR transgenic thymocytes manifested as a down-modulation of CD4 and CD8 molecules, a shift in the side versus forward scatter characteristics of thymocytes, and appearance of thymocytes with subdiploid content of DNA indicated the ongoing process of DNA fragmentation. The finding that the same TEC line is capable of inducing both positive and negative selection in the thymus suggests that thymocytes bearing TCRs specific for self peptides expressed by positively selecting thymic epithelium can be deleted. Therefore the expression of a unique set of MHC associated peptides by TECs does not appear to be the basis for the positive outcome of the TCR ligation on immature thymocytes.

Strong agonist ligands for the T cell receptor do not mediate positive selection of functional CD8+ T cells.

Positive selection of functional CD8+ T cells expressing an MHC class I-restricted T cell receptor can be induced in fetal thymus organ culture by class I-binding peptides related to the antigenic peptide ligand. Peptides that act as antagonist or weak agonist/antagonist ligands for mature T cells work efficiently in this regard. In the present study, we have investigated whether low concentrations of the original agonist peptide, or variants that still have a strong agonist activity can also mediate positive selection. The antigenic peptide did not induce positive selection at any concentration tested. A strong agonist variant was capable of stimulating the differentiation of TCRhi CD8+ cells, giving the appearance of phenotypic positive selection. However, these cells lacked biological function, since they could not proliferate in response to antigen. The most efficient positive selection resulted with ligands that did not activate mature T cells or stimulate negative selection.

Positive selection of thymocytes.

Differentiation of alpha beta T cell receptor (TCR)-expressing T cells involves an obligatory interaction with self-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules in the thymus. This process, called positive selection, both rescues thymocytes from programmed cell death and induces their differentiation into mature T cells. Another critical event in thymic development is to prevent maturation of hazardous autoreactive T cells; thus, mechanisms exist to eliminate T cells with self-reactive receptors (negative selection). How can these two pathways be distinguished? This question, which has long taxed immunologists, is more opposite because many features of the interactions in positive and negative selection are shared: Both processes are exquisitely MHC-allele specific, they involve MHC-bound peptide recognition, and employ at least some overlapping signal transduction pathways. However, resolution of this paradox has become much more feasible with the advent of powerful systems for withdrawing and reconstituting individual components involved in positive selection. This review describes recent advances in our understanding of the cells, receptors, ligands, and signaling pathways involved in this process. A pivotal part of this puzzle is the basis for discrimination between TCR ligands that induce positive vs negative selection. Recent work suggests that the peptide/MHC ligand for positive selection may bind with low avidity to the TCR. The implications of these data for the nature of T cell recognition during positive selection are discussed below.

Positive selection is limited by available peptide-dependent MHC conformations.

Recent data suggest that the diversity of self peptides presented in the thymus during development contributes to positive selection of a diverse T cell repertoire. We sought to determine whether a previously defined "hole in the immunological repertoire" could be explained by the absence of an appropriate selecting self peptide. The repertoire defect in question is the inability of bm8 mice to make an H-2K-restricted response to OVA. Like other OVA-specific, H-2K-restricted receptors, OT-I-transgenic T cells are not positively selected in bm8 mice. Using criteria we had previously established for identifying positive selection ligands, we found peptides that could restore positive selection of OT-I thymocytes in bm8 mice. Thus, the T cell repertoire can be limited by a requirement for specific self peptides during development. Data with MHC-specific Abs suggested that peptides might be able to force MHC residues to adopt different conformations in Kb vs Kbm8. This shows that peptides can potentially contribute to ligand diversity both directly (via variability in the solvent-exposed side chains) and indirectly (through their effect on the MHC conformation). Our data support a model where self peptide diversity allows selection of T cells specific for a broad range of MHC conformations.

A T cell receptor V alpha region selectively expressed in CD4+ cells.

The peripheral TCR V beta repertoire is strongly influenced by the processes of negative selection (deletion) and positive selection in the thymus. In order to investigate whether such selection events influence the V alpha repertoire, we have produced an anti-V alpha 11 mAb. This antibody was made by immunization with a chimeric TCR:Ig protein containing V alpha 11 in place of the VH of an IgG2a, lambda Ig. This scheme optimizes the specificity of immunization and facilitates the screening procedure. The antibody recognizes a panel of V alpha 11-expressing T cell clones. Analysis of mouse strains indicates that the antibody recognizes V alpha 11 only in mice of the C57 background. The expression of the epitope on peripheral T cells is strongly biased to the CD4+ subset, suggesting positive selection of V alpha 11 on class II MHC molecules. In some strain comparisons, the percentage of V alpha 11-expressing T cells in the CD4+ subset was elevated in I-E+ relative to I-E- strains. These data suggest that V alpha 11 can differentially influence the selection of T cells into the CD4+/CD8+ subsets.