Renal dysfunction, rod-cone dystrophy, and sensorineural hearing loss caused by a mutation in RRM2B.

More than two decades ago, a recessive syndromic phenotype affecting kidneys, eyes, and ears, was first described in the endogamous Afrikaner population of South Africa. Using whole-exome sequencing of DNA from two affected siblings (and their carrier parents), we identified the novel RRM2B c.786G>T variant as a plausible disease-causing mutation. The RRM2B gene is involved in mitochondrial integrity, and the observed change was not previously reported in any genomic database. The subsequent screening revealed the variant in two newly presenting unrelated patients, as well as two patients in our registry with rod-cone dystrophy, hearing loss, and Fanconi-type renal disease. All patients with the c.786G>T variant share an identical 1.5 Mb haplotype around this gene, suggesting a founder effect in the Afrikaner population. We present ultrastructural evidence of mitochondrial impairment in one patient, to support our thesis that this RRM2B variant is associated with the renal, ophthalmological, and auditory phenotype.

Haplogroup Context is Less Important in the Penetrance of Mitochondrial DNA Complex I Mutations Compared to mt-tRNA Mutations.

Mitochondrial diseases are a highly complex, heterogeneous group of disorders. Mitochondrial DNA variants that are linked to disease can exhibit variable expression and penetrance. This has an implication for mitochondrial diagnostics as variants that cause disease in one individual may not in another. It has been suggested that the sequence context in which a variant arises could influence the genotype-phenotype relationship. However, the consequence of sequence variation between different haplogroups on the expression of disease is not well understood. European haplogroups are the most widely studied. To ensure accurate diagnostics for patients globally, we first need to understand how, if at all, the sequence context in which a variant arises contributes to the manifestion of disease. To help us understand this, we used 2752 sequences from 33 non-human species that do not have disease. We searched for variants in the seven complex I genes that are associated with disease in humans. Our findings indicate that only three reported pathogenic complex I variants have arisen in these species. More importantly, only one of these, m.3308T>C, has arisen with its associated amino acid change in the studied non-human species. With the status of m.3308T>C as a disease causing variant being a matter of debate. This is a stark contrast to previous findings in the mitochondrial tRNA genes and suggests that sequence context may be less important in the complex I genes. This information will help us improve the identification and diagnosis of mitochondrial DNA variants in non-European populations.

Maternally inherited diabetes and deafness with a variable presentation across three generations within a pedigree, South Africa.

Introduction: Maternally inherited diabetes and deafness (MIDD) is caused by the m.3243A>G pathogenic variant in maternally inherited mitochondrial DNA. Diabetes is prevalent in our setting; however, MIDD is rarely diagnosed. This study, undertaken in Pretoria, South Africa, highlights the variable presentation of MIDD in different patients within the same family. Case presentation: A 45-year-old man (proband) with hearing impairment was referred to the endocrine unit in July 2015 due to poor glycaemic control (HbA1c = 13%). His clinical and biochemical features were in keeping with MIDD. A genetic study of accessible maternal relatives was pursued. His mother had difficulty hearing and reportedly died from an unspecified cardiovascular cause. Two sisters with diabetes and deafness died of cardiac-related conditions. One nephew had diabetes (HbA1c = 7.7%), hearing loss and tested positive for m.3243A>G. A third sister tested positive for m3243A>G, but aside from bilateral mild hearing loss in higher frequencies, showed no other signs of target organ damage. Her daughter developed end-stage kidney failure necessitating a transplant, while her son had no biochemical abnormalities and was negative for m.3243A>G. Management and outcome: A multidisciplinary team managed and screened for complications of the patient and his maternal relatives. Proband died prior to genetic testing. Conclusion: Most MIDD patients initially present with symptoms of diabetes only, and it is probable that many cases remain undiagnosed. A high index of suspicion is necessary when encountering a family history of both diabetes and impaired hearing, and screening should be offered to the patient's maternal relatives. What the study adds: This study demonstrates the importance of proper assessment when evaluating a patient with diabetes and a family history of hearing loss.

A novel mitochondrial DNA variant in MT-ND6: m.14430A>C p.(Trp82Gly) identified in a patient with Leigh syndrome and complex I deficiency.

Leigh syndrome is a severe progressive mitochondrial disorder mainly affecting children under the age of 5 years. It is caused by pathogenic variants in any one of more than 75 known genes in the nuclear or mitochondrial genomes. A 19-week-old male infant presented with lactic acidosis and encephalopathy following a 2-week history of irritability, neuroregression and poor weight gain. He was hypotonic with pathological reflexes, impaired vision, and nystagmus. Brain MRI showed extensive bilateral symmetrical T2 hyperintense lesions in basal ganglia, thalami, and brainstem. Metabolic workup showed elevated serum alanine, and heavy lactic aciduria with increased ketones, fumarate, malate, and alpha-ketoglutarate as well as reduced succinate on urine organic acid analysis. Lactic acidemia persisted, with only a marginally elevated lactate:pyruvate ratio (16.46, ref. 0-10). He demised at age 7 months due to respiratory failure. Exome sequencing followed by virtual gene panel analysis for pyruvate metabolism and mitochondrial defects could not identify any nuclear cause for Leigh syndrome. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) genome sequencing revealed 88% heteroplasmy for a novel variant, NC_012920.1(MT-ND6):m.14430A>C p.(Trp82Gly), in blood DNA. This variant was absent from the unaffected mother's blood, fibroblast, and urine DNA, and detected at a level of 5% in her muscle DNA. Mitochondrial respiratory chain analysis revealed markedly reduced mitochondrial complex I activity in patient fibroblasts (34% of parent and control cells), and reduced NADH-linked respirometry (less than half of parental and control cells), while complex II driven respirometry remained intact. The combined clinical, genetic, and biochemical findings suggest that the novel MT-ND6 variant is the likely cause of Leigh syndrome in this patient. The mitochondrial ND6 protein is a subunit of complex I. An interesting finding was the absence of a significantly elevated lactate:pyruvate ratio in the presence of severe lactatemia, which directed initial diagnostic efforts towards excluding a pyruvate metabolism defect. This case highlights the value of a multidisciplinary approach and complete genetic workup to diagnosing mitochondrial disorders in South African patients.

Clinical, biochemical, and genetic spectrum of MADD in a South African cohort: an ICGNMD study.

BACKGROUND: Multiple acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (MADD) is an autosomal recessive disorder resulting from pathogenic variants in three distinct genes, with most of the variants occurring in the electron transfer flavoprotein-ubiquinone oxidoreductase gene (ETFDH). Recent evidence of potential founder variants for MADD in the South African (SA) population, initiated this extensive investigation. As part of the International Centre for Genomic Medicine in Neuromuscular Diseases study, we recruited a cohort of patients diagnosed with MADD from academic medical centres across SA over a three-year period. The aim was to extensively profile the clinical, biochemical, and genomic characteristics of MADD in this understudied population. METHODS: Clinical evaluations and whole exome sequencing were conducted on each patient. Metabolic profiling was performed before and after treatment, where possible. The recessive inheritance and phase of the variants were established via segregation analyses using Sanger sequencing. Lastly, the haplotype and allele frequencies were determined for the two main variants in the four largest SA populations. RESULTS: Twelve unrelated families (ten of White SA and two of mixed ethnicity) with clinically heterogeneous presentations in 14 affected individuals were observed, and five pathogenic ETFDH variants were identified. Based on disease severity and treatment response, three distinct groups emerged. The most severe and fatal presentations were associated with the homozygous c.[1067G > A];c.[1067G > A] and compound heterozygous c.[976G > C];c.[1067G > A] genotypes, causing MADD types I and I/II, respectively. These, along with three less severe compound heterozygous genotypes (c.[1067G > A];c.[1448C > T], c.[740G > T];c.[1448C > T], and c.[287dupA*];c.[1448C > T]), resulting in MADD types II/III, presented before the age of five years, depending on the time and maintenance of intervention. By contrast, the homozygous c.[1448C > T];c.[1448C > T] genotype, which causes MADD type III, presented later in life. Except for the type I, I/II and II cases, urinary metabolic markers for MADD improved/normalised following treatment with riboflavin and L-carnitine. Furthermore, genetic analyses of the most frequent variants (c.[1067G > A] and c.[1448C > T]) revealed a shared haplotype in the region of ETFDH, with SA population-specific allele frequencies of < 0.00067-0.00084%. CONCLUSIONS: This study reveals the first extensive genotype-phenotype profile of a MADD patient cohort from the diverse and understudied SA population. The pathogenic variants and associated variable phenotypes were characterised, which will enable early screening, genetic counselling, and patient-specific treatment of MADD in this population.

Mitochondrial molecular genetic results in a South African cohort: divergent mitochondrial and nuclear DNA findings.

AIMS: Mitochondrial diseases form one of the largest groups of inborn errors of metabolism. The birth prevalence is approximately 1/5000 in well-studied populations, but little has been reported from Sub-Saharan Africa. The aim of this study was to describe the genetics underlying mitochondrial disease in South Africa. METHODS: An audit was performed on all mitochondrial disease genetic testing performed in Cape Town, South Africa. RESULTS: Of 1614 samples tested for mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) or nuclear DNA (nDNA) variants in South Africa between 1994 and 2019, there were 155 (9.6 %) positive results. Pathogenic mtDNA variants accounted for 113 (73%)/155, from 96 families. Mitochondrial encephalopathy with lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes, 37 (33%)/113, Leber's hereditary optic neuropathy, 26 (23%)/113, and single large mtDNA deletions, 22 (20%)/113, accounted for 76%. Thirty eight of 42 nDNA-positive results were homozygous for the MPV17 pathogenic variant c.106C>T (p.[Gln36Ter, Ser25Profs*49]) causing infantile neurohepatopathy, one of the largest homozygous groups reported in the literature. The other nDNA variants were in TAZ1, CPT2, BOLA3 and SERAC1. None were identified in SURF1, POLG or PDHA1. CONCLUSIONS: Finding a large group with a homozygous nuclear pathogenic variant emphasises the importance of looking for possible founder effects. The absence of other widely described pathogenic nDNA variants in this cohort may be due to reduced prevalence or insufficient testing. As advances in therapeutics develop, it is critical to develop diagnostic platforms on the African subcontinent so that population-specific genetic variations can be identified.

A case for genomic medicine in South African paediatric patients with neuromuscular disease.

Paediatric neuromuscular diseases are under-recognised and under-diagnosed in Africa, especially those of genetic origin. This may be attributable to various factors, inclusive of socioeconomic barriers, high burden of communicable and non-communicable diseases, resource constraints, lack of expertise in specialised fields and paucity of genetic testing facilities and biobanks in the African population, making access to and interpretation of results more challenging. As new treatments become available that are effective for specific sub-phenotypes, it is even more important to confirm a genetic diagnosis for affected children to be eligible for drug trials and potential treatments. This perspective article aims to create awareness of the major neuromuscular diseases clinically diagnosed in the South African paediatric populations, as well as the current challenges and possible solutions. With this in mind, we introduce a multi-centred research platform (ICGNMD), which aims to address the limited knowledge on NMD aetiology and to improve genetic diagnostic capacities in South African and other African populations.

Increased blood-derived mitochondrial DNA copy number in African ancestry individuals with Parkinson's disease.

INTRODUCTION: Altered levels of mitochondrial DNA copy number (mtDNA-CN) have been proposed as a proxy for mitochondrial dysfunction. Following reports of mtDNA depletion in the blood and substantia nigra of Parkinson's disease (PD) cases, mtDNA-CN was also suggested as a possible biomarker for PD. Therefore, this study aimed to investigate whether blood mtDNA-CN levels of African ancestry PD cases would be altered compared to controls, as previously reported in individuals of Asian and European ancestry. METHODS: Droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (ddPCR) was performed to quantify blood-derived mtDNA-CN levels as a ratio of a mitochondrial gene (MT-TL1) to a nuclear gene (B2M) in 72 PD cases and 79 controls of African ancestry (i.e. individuals with African mtDNA haplogroups) from South Africa. mtDNA-CN per cell was calculated by the formula 2 × MT-TL1/B2M. RESULTS: Accepting study limitations, we report significantly higher mtDNA-CN in whole blood of our PD cases compared to controls (median difference = 81 copies/cell), independent of age (95% CI [64, 98]; P < 0.001]). These findings contradict previous reports of mtDNA depletion in PD cases. CONCLUSIONS: We caution that the observed differences in mtDNA-CN between the present and past studies may be a result of unaccounted-for factors and variability in study designs. Consequently, larger well-designed investigations may help determine whether mtDNA-CN is consistently altered in the blood of PD cases across different ancestries and whether it can serve as a viable biomarker for PD.

Glutaric aciduria type 1 in South Africa-high incidence of glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency in black South Africans.

Glutaric Aciduria type 1 (GA 1) is an inherited disorder of lysine and tryptophan catabolism that typically manifests in infants with acute cerebral injury associated with intercurrent illness. We investigated the clinical, biochemical and molecular features in 14 known GA 1 patients in South Africa, most of whom were recently confirmed following the implementation of sensitive urine organic acid screening at our laboratory. Age at diagnosis ranged from 3days to 5years and poor clinical outcome reflected the delay in diagnosis in all but one patient. Twelve patients were unrelated black South Africans of whom all those tested (n=11) were found homozygous for the same A293T mutation in the glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH) gene. Excretion of 3-hydroxyglutarate (3-OHGA) was >30.1µmol/mmol creatinine (reference range <2.5) in all cases but glutarate excretion varied with 5 patients considered low excretors (glutarate <50µmol/mmol creatinine). Fibroblast GCDH activity was very low or absent in all of five cases tested. Heterozygosity for the A293T mutation was found 1 in 36 (95% CI; 1/54 - 1/24) unrelated black South African newborns (n=750) giving a predicted prevalence rate for GA 1 of 1 in 5184 (95% CI; 1/11664 - 1/2304) in this population. GA 1 is a treatable but often missed inherited disorder with a previously unrecognised high carrier frequency of a single mutation in the South African black population.

Validation of PHASE for deriving N-acetyltransferase 2 haplotypes in the Western Cape mixed ancestry population.

BACKGROUND: There is a shortage of data on the accuracy of statistical methods for the prediction of N-acetyltransferase 2 (NAT2) haplotypes in the mixed ancestry population of the Western Cape. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to identify the NAT2 haplotypes and assess the accuracy of PHASE version 2.1.1 in assigning NAT2 haplotypes to a mixed ancestry population from the Western Cape. METHODS: This study was conducted between 2013 and 2016. The NAT2 gene was amplified and sequenced from the DNA of 100 self-identified mixed ancestry participants. Haplotyping was performed by molecular and computational techniques. Agreement was assessed between the two techniques. RESULTS: Haplotypes were assigned to 93 samples, of which 67 (72%) were ambiguous. Haplotype prediction by PHASE demonstrated 94.6% agreement (kappa 0.94, p < 0.001) with those assigned using molecular techniques. Five haplotype combinations (from 10 chromosomes) were incorrectly predicted, four of which were flagged as uncertain by the PHASE software. Only one resulted in the assignment of an incorrect acetylation phenotype (intermediate to slow), although the software flagged this for further analysis. The most common haplotypes were NAT2*4 (28%) followed by NAT2*5B (27.4%), NAT2*6A (21.5%) and NAT2*12A (7.5%). Four rare single nucleotide variants (c.589C>T, c.622T>C, c.809T>C and c.387C>T) were detected. CONCLUSION: PHASE accurately predicted the phenotype in 92 of 93 samples (99%) from genotypic data in our mixed ancestry sample population, and is therefore a suitable alternative to molecular methods to individualise isoniazid therapy in this high burden tuberculosis setting.

Pitfalls of relying on genetic testing only to diagnose inherited metabolic disorders in non-western populations - 5 cases of pyruvate dehydrogenase deficiency from South Africa.

Pyruvate dehydrogenase complex (PDHC) deficiencies are a group of mainly infantile onset disorders stemming from defects in pyruvate catabolism. They are characterised by severe lactic acidosis and progressive neurodegeneration.Although the PDHA1 gene is implicated in most cases of PDHC deficiency worldwide, no pathogenic variants have been reported in South African patients to date, despite availability of PDHA1 sequencing in the state diagnostic setting. METHODS: DNA from five patients with low to absent PDHC activity in fibroblasts were subjected to PDHC deficiency gene panel analysis. Included in the panel were: PDHA1, PDHB, DLAT, DLD, PDHX, BOLA3, GLRX5, IBA57, LIAS, LIPT1, LIPT2, NFU1, PDP1, PDP2, SLC19A2, SLC19A3, SLC25A19, SLC25A26, TPK1 and FBXL4. RESULTS: No pathogenic variants were identified in 4 out of 5 cases investigated. A homozygous frame-shift mutation was detected in the BOLA3 gene in one patient, supporting a diagnosis of multiple mitochondrial dysfunction syndrome type 2. DISCUSSION: A single, novel, homozygous BOLA3 frame-shift mutation was detected in a black South African child with severe neurodegenerative disease and very low to absent PDHC enzyme activity. This finding of a homozygous mutation in a patient from a non-consanguineous background may indicate a need for further investigation in clinically similar cases as well as heterozygous carrier rates in unaffected individuals from the same ethnic background.The paucity of identifiable mutations in 4 out of 5 South African patients with confirmed PDHC deficiency highlights the dangers in relying on Western population based genetic panels for diagnosing rare metabolic disease in genetically understudied populations.

MT-ND5 Mutation Exhibits Highly Variable Neurological Manifestations at Low Mutant Load.

Mutations in the m.13094T>C MT-ND5 gene have been previously described in three cases of Leigh Syndrome (LS). In this retrospective, international cohort study we identified 20 clinically affected individuals (13 families) and four asymptomatic carriers. Ten patients were deceased at the time of analysis (median age of death was 10years (range: 5·4months-37years, IQR=17·9years). Nine patients manifested with LS, one with mitochondrial encephalomyopathy, lactic acidosis and stroke-like episodes (MELAS), and one with Leber hereditary optic neuropathy. The remaining nine patients presented with either overlapping syndromes or isolated neurological symptoms. Mitochondrial respiratory chain activity analysis was normal in five out of ten muscle biopsies. We confirmed maternal inheritance in six families, and demonstrated marked variability in tissue segregation, and phenotypic expression at relatively low blood mutant loads. Neuropathological studies of two patients manifesting with LS/MELAS showed prominent capillary proliferation, microvacuolation and severe neuronal cell loss in the brainstem and cerebellum, with conspicuous absence of basal ganglia involvement. These findings suggest that whole mtDNA genome sequencing should be considered in patients with suspected mitochondrial disease presenting with complex neurological manifestations, which would identify over 300 known pathogenic variants including the m.13094T>C.

Liddle's syndrome in an African male due to a novel frameshift mutation in the beta-subunit of the epithelial sodium channel gene.

Resistant hypertension is a common clinical problem in South Africa and is frequently associated with low renin and aldosterone levels, especially in black Africans. In South Africa, novel variants in the epithelial sodium channel (ENaC) have been described to be associated with varying degrees of hypokalaemia and hypertension due to primary sodium retention. We report here a case of Liddle's syndrome due to a novel c.1709del11 (p.Ser570Tyrfs*20) deletion in the beta-subunit of the ENaC in a young black African male. We discuss the likely pathogenesis of hypertension in this setting as well as the treatment options available in South Africa aimed at the ENaC. This case highlights the need for vigilance in detecting and appropriately treating low-renin and low-aldosterone hypertension in view of the frequency of the described variants of the ENaC channel in our country. Specific therapy such as amiloride should be made more widely available.

Could we offer mitochondrial donation or similar assisted reproductive technology to South African patients with mitochondrial DNA disease?

The decision of the UK House of Commons in 2015 to endorse the use of pioneering in vitro fertilisation techniques to protect future generations from the risk of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) disease has sparked worldwide controversy and debate. The availability of such technologies could benefit women at risk of transmitting deleterious mutations. MtDNA disease certainly occurs in South Africa (SA) in all population groups. However, diagnostic strategies and practices for identifying individuals who would benefit from technologies such as IVF have in the past been suboptimal in this country. New developments in the molecular diagnostic services available to SA patients, as well as better education of referring clinicians and the implementation of more structured, population-appropriate diagnostic strategies, may open the floor to this debate in SA.