The global diffusion of organ transplantation: trends, drivers and policy implications.

Rising incomes, the spread of personal insurance, lifestyle factors adding to the burden of illness, ageing populations, globalization and skills transfer within the medical community have increased worldwide demand for organ transplantation. The Global Observatory on Donation and Transplantation, which was built in response to World Health Assembly resolution WHA57.18, has conducted ongoing documentation of global transplantation activities since 2007. In this paper, we use the Global Observatory's data to describe the current distribution of - and trends in - transplantation activities and to evaluate the role of health systems factors and macroeconomics in the diffusion of transplantation technology. We then consider the implications of our results for health policies relating to organ donation and transplantation. Of the World Health Organization's Member States, most now engage in organ transplantation and more than a third performed deceased donor transplantation in 2011. In general, the Member States that engage in organ transplantation have greater access to physician services and greater total health spending per capita than the Member States where organ transplantation is not performed. The provision of deceased donor transplantation was closely associated with high levels of gross national income per capita. There are several ways in which governments can support the ethical development of organ donation and transplantation programmes. Specifically, they can ensure that appropriate legislation, regulation and oversight are in place, and monitor donation and transplantation activities, practices and outcomes. Moreover, they can allocate resources towards the training of specialist physicians, surgeons and transplant coordinators, and implement a professional donor-procurement network.

La hausse des revenus, le développement des assurances personnelles, les facteurs de mode de vie ajoutant à la charge de morbidité des maladies, le vieillissement des populations, la mondialisation et le transfert des compétences au sein de la communauté médicale ont augmenté la demande mondiale de transplantation d'organe. L'Observatoire Mondial du Don et de la Transplantation, qui a été fondé en réponse à la résolution WHA57.18 de l'Organisation mondiale de la Santé, a rassemblé une documentation sur les activités de transplantation dans le monde de façon continue depuis 2007. Dans cet article, nous utilisons les données de l'Observatoire Mondial pour décrire la distribution actuelle (et les tendances) des activités de transplantation et pour évaluer le rôle des facteurs de systèmes de santé et de la macroéconomie dans la diffusion des technologies de transplantation. Nous considérons ensuite les implications de nos résultats sur les politiques de santé relatives au don et à la transplantation d'organe. La majorité des États Membres de l'Organisation mondiale de la Santé s'engagent maintenant dans la transplantation d'organe et plus d'un tiers d'entre eux ont réalisé des transplantations avec des organes provenant de donneurs décédés en 2011. En général, les États Membres qui se sont engagés dans la transplantation d'organe, ont un meilleur accès aux services médicaux et des dépenses totales de santé plus élevées par habitant que les États Membres où la transplantation d'organe n'est pas réalisée. La disponibilité de la transplantation avec des organes provenant de donneurs décédés était étroitement associée avec des niveaux élevés de revenu national brut par habitant. Il existe plusieurs manières possibles pour les gouvernements de soutenir le développement éthique des programmes de don et de transplantation d'organe. En particulier, ils peuvent s'assurer que la législation, la réglementation et la surveillance sont en place, et contrôler les activités, les pratiques et les résultats des dons et des transplantations. En outre, ils peuvent affecter des ressources pour la formation des médecins spécialistes, des chirurgiens et des coordinateurs de transplantation, et mettre en œuvre un réseau professionnel de recrutement des donneurs.

El aumento de la renta, la proliferación de los seguros personales y los factores del estilo de vida, sumados a la carga de enfermedades, el envejecimiento de la población, la globalización y la transferencia de conocimientos en la comunidad médica, han aumentado la demanda mundial de trasplantes de órganos. El Observatorio Mundial de Donación y Trasplante, creado en respuesta a la resolución WHA57.18 de la Asamblea Mundial de la Salud, ha llevado a cabo una documentación continua de las actividades mundiales de trasplantes desde 2007. En este informe, se emplean los datos del Observatorio Global para describir la distribución actual (y las tendencias) de las actividades de trasplante y para evaluar el papel de los factores de los sistemas sanitarios y de la macroeconomía en la difusión de la tecnología de trasplante. A continuación, se consideraron las repercusiones de los resultados en las políticas de salud relacionadas con la donación y el trasplante de órganos. En la actualidad, la mayoría de los Estados miembros de la Organización Mundial de la Salud participa en el trasplante de órganos y más de un tercio realizó trasplantes de donantes fallecidos en 2011. En general, los Estados miembros que participan en el trasplante de órganos cuentan con mayor acceso a los servicios médicos y tienen un mayor gasto total en salud per cápita que los Estados miembros donde no se realizan el trasplantes de órganos. La prestación de los trasplantes de donantes fallecidos se asoció estrechamente con altos niveles de renta nacional bruta per cápita. Existen varias formas en que los gobiernos pueden fomentar el desarrollo ético de los programas de donación y trasplante de órganos. En concreto, pueden garantizar que se adopte una legislación, regulación y supervisión adecuadas, así como realizar un seguimiento de las actividades, las prácticas y los resultados de la donación y el trasplante. Además, pueden destinar recursos a la formación de médicos especialistas, cirujanos y coordinadores de trasplantes, así como poner en marcha una red profesional de adquisición de donantes.

A call for government accountability to achieve national self-sufficiency in organ donation and transplantation.

Roughly 100,000 patients worldwide undergo organ transplantation annually, but many other patients remain on waiting lists. Transplantation rates vary substantially across countries. Affluent patients in nations with long waiting lists do not always wait for donations from within their own countries. Commercially driven transplantation, however, does not always ensure proper medical care of recipients or donors, and might lengthen waiting times for resident patients or increase the illegal and unethical purchase of organs from living donors. Governments should systematically address the needs of their countries according to a legal framework. Medical strategies to prevent end-stage organ failure must also be implemented. In view of the Madrid Resolution, the Declaration of Istanbul, and the 63rd World Health Assembly Resolution, a new paradigm of national self-sufficiency is needed. Each country or region should strive to provide a sufficient number of organs from within its own population, guided by WHO ethics principles.

The critical pathway for deceased donation: reportable uniformity in the approach to deceased donation.

The critical pathway of deceased donation provides a systematic approach to the organ donation process, considering both donation after cardiac death than donation after brain death. The pathway provides a tool for assessing the potential of deceased donation and for the prospective identification and referral of possible deceased donors.

Emergency and essential surgical services in Afghanistan: still a missing challenge.

BACKGROUND: In Afghanistan, the number of surgically amenable injuries related to civil unrest and ongoing conflict or consequent to road traffic accidents, trauma, or pregnancy-related complications is rising and becoming a major cause of death and disability. This study was designed to evaluate availability of basic lifesaving and disability-preventive emergency surgical and anesthesia interventions representing most of the country. METHODS: Evaluation was performed outside Kabul to represent a cross-section of the country. Data were collected from Afghanistan health facilities, using the WHO Tool for Situation Analysis to Assess Emergency and Essential Surgical Care, covering case volume, travel distances, infrastructures, human resources, supplies, equipment, and interventions characterizing basic trauma, surgery, and anesthesia capacities. RESULTS: In 30% of the 17 facilities examined, oxygen supply is limited and irregular; uninterrupted running water is not accessible in 40%; electrical power is not available continuously in 66%. Shortage of equipment and personnel is evident in peripheral health facilities: certified surgeons are present in 63.6% and certified anesthesiologists in 27.2%. Continuous 24 h surgical service is available in 29.4%. Lifesaving procedures are performed in 17-42% of peripheral hospitals; 23.5% are without emergency obstetric service. CONCLUSIONS: Limited access to surgery is highly remarkable in Afghanistan, with a severe shortage of emergency surgical capacities in provincial and district hospitals, where availability of basic and emergency surgical care is far from satisfactory. A comprehensive approach for strengthening basic surgical capacities at the primary health care level should be introduced.

One million haemopoietic stem-cell transplants: a retrospective observational study.

BACKGROUND: The transplantation of cells, tissues, and organs has been recognised by WHO as an important medical task for its member states; however, information about how to best organise transplantation is scarce. We aimed to document the activity worldwide from the beginning of transplantation and search for region adapted indications and associations between transplant rates and macroeconomics. METHODS: Between Jan 1, 2006, and Dec 31, 2014, the Worldwide Network for Blood and Marrow Transplantation collected data for the evolution of haemopoietic stem-cell transplantation (HSCT) activity and volunteer donors in the 194 WHO member states. FINDINGS: 953,651 HSCTs (553,350 [58%] autologous and 400,301 [42%] allogeneic) were reported by 1516 transplant centres from 75 countries. No transplants were done in countries with fewer than 300,000 inhabitants, a surface area less than 700 km(2), and a gross national income per person of US$1260 or lower. Use of HSCT increased from the first transplant in 1957 to almost 10,000 by 1985. We recorded a cumulative total of about 100,000 transplants by 1995, and an estimated 1 million by December, 2012. Unrelated donor registries contributed 22·3 million typed volunteer donors and 645,646 cord blood products by 2012. Numbers of allogeneic HSCTs increased in the past 35 years with no signs of saturation (R(2)=0·989). Transplant rates were higher in countries with more resources, more transplant teams, and an unrelated donor infrastructure. INTERPRETATION: Our findings show achievements and high unmet needs and give guidance for decisions; to grant access for patients, to provide a donor infrastructure, and to limit overuse by defining risk and region adapted indications for HSCT as an efficient and cost-effective approach for life-threatening, potentially curable diseases. FUNDING: Funding for this study was indirectly provided by support of the WBMT.

Essential emergency surgical, procedures in resource-limited facilities: a WHO workshop in Mongolia.

A WHO 'Training of Trainers' workshop on essential emergency surgical procedures was organised in collaboration with the Ministry of Health, Mongolia. The participants included doctors and nurses from the six selected aimags (provinces). Facilitators of the workshop included experts from the Faculty of Health Science University, Mongolian Surgeon's Association and Mongolian Association of Anaesthesiologists association with the Swiss Surgical Team of the International College of Surgeons, Surgical Department of Nurse's College, Trauma Orthopaedic Clinical Hospital, the Department of Quality Assurance of the Directorate of Medical Services, Ministry of Health. Facilitators from the Hospital University of Geneva, Geneva Foundation of Medical Education and Research (RHR) and Evidence and Information for Policy in Geneva, Switzerland participated via video link. The workshop included lectures, discussions, role playing and 'hands on' basic skills training. Videoconference and e-learning sessions using the WHO e-learning tools were conducted at the Global Development Learning Centre. The topics covered during this training workshop included team responsibility and organisation in a health care facility; patient safety; disaster planning; appropriate use of oxygen; management of bleeding, burns and trauma; basic anaesthetic and resuscitation techniques; prevention of HIV transmission; sterilisation of equipment; waste disposal; hygiene; record keeping, monitoring and evaluation of quality of care and checklists prior to surgery to assure that the correct patient gets the correct surgery on the correct side at the correct time. Recommendations were made by the participants on the next steps after this training.

International guideline development for the determination of death.

INTRODUCTION AND METHODS: This report summarizes the results of the first phase in the development of international guidelines for death determination, focusing on the biology of death and the dying process, developed by an invitational forum of international content experts and representatives of a number of professional societies. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Precise terminology was developed in order to improve clarity in death discussion and debate. Critical events in the physiological sequences leading to cessation of neurological and/or circulatory function were constructed. It was agreed that death determination is primarily clinical and recommendations for preconditions, confounding factors, minimum clinical standards and additional testing were made. A single operational definition of human death was developed: 'the permanent loss of capacity for consciousness and all brainstem functions, as a consequence of permanent cessation of circulation or catastrophic brain injury'. In order to complete the project, in the next phase, a broader group of international stakeholders will develop clinical practice guidelines, based on comprehensive reviews and grading of the existing evidence.

Global Database on Donation and Transplantation: goals, methods and critical issues (www.transplant-observatory.org).

The Global Database on Donation and Transplantation represents the most comprehensive source to date of worldwide data concerning activities in organ donation and transplantation derived from official sources, as well as information on legal and organizational aspects. The objectives are to collect, analyse and disseminate this kind of information of the WHO Member States and to facilitate a network of focal persons in the field of transplantation. They are responsible for providing the legislative and organizational aspects and the annual activity practices through a specific questionnaire. 104 out of the 194 WHO Member States that cover the 90% of the global population contribute to this project.Although we know the numerous limitations and biases as a result of the different interpretations of the questions, based on cultural factors and language, there is no other similar approach to collect information on donation and transplantation practices all over the world. The knowledge of demand for transplantation, availability of deceased and living donor organs and the access to transplantation is essential to monitor global trends in transplantation needs and donor organ availability. Information regarding the existence of regulatory oversight is fundamental to ensure the ethical practice of organ donation and transplantation.

Eye banking and corneal transplantation communicable adverse incidents: current status and project NOTIFY.

PURPOSE: Evidence of the transmission of disease via donor ocular tissue has been demonstrated for adenocarcinoma, rabies, hepatitis B virus, cytomegalovirus, herpes simplex virus, Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, and a variety of bacterial and fungal infections. METHODS: Although there is no evidence to date of disease transmission for HIV infection, syphilis, hepatitis C, hepatitis A, tuberculosis, HTLV-1 and -2 infection, active leprosy, active typhoid, smallpox, and active malaria, these entities remain contraindications for transplantation for all eye banks nationally and internationally. The potential sources of contamination include infected donors, during the process of removing tissue from cadaveric donors, the processing environment, and contaminated supplies and reagents used during processing. The transmissions of Herpes simplex virus and HSV via corneal graft have been shown to be responsible for primary graft failure. HSV-1 may also be an important cause of PFG. RESULTS: The long latency period of some diseases, the emergence of new infectious disease, and the reemergence of others emphasize the need for long-term record maintenance and effective tracing capabilities. CONCLUSIONS: The standardization of definitions for adverse events and reactions will be necessary to support the prevention and transmission of disease. International classification of a unique identification system for donors will be increasingly important for vigilance and traceability in cross-national exportation of human cells, tissues, and cellular- and tissue-based products. Opportunities for continuous improvement exist as does the need for constant vigilance and surveillance.

2009 global data in organ donation and transplantation: activities, laws, and organization.

The Global Observatory on Donation and Transplantation represents the most comprehensive source of worldwide data concerning activities in organ donation and transplantation and information on legal and organizational aspects. Of the countries reporting information, 84.7% have a national structure supervising or coordinating donation and transplantation and 91% have specific legislation. Worldwide approximately 104,065 solid organ transplants are performed each year. There is a vast difference in rates of kidney and liver transplantation, especially from deceased donor depending on the level of development. This analysis provides an overview of existing organizational structures, related legislation, and activities.

Implementing Liberia's poverty reduction strategy: An assessment of emergency and essential surgical care.

OBJECTIVE: To document infrastructure, personnel, procedures performed, and supplies and equipment available at all county hospitals in Liberia using the World Health Organization Tool for Situational Analysis of Emergency and Essential Surgical Care. DESIGN: Survey of county hospitals using the World Health Organization Tool for Situational Analysis of Emergency and Essential Surgical Care. SETTING: Sixteen county hospitals in Liberia. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Infrastructure, personnel, procedures performed, and supplies and equipment available. RESULTS: Uniformly, gross deficiencies in infrastructure, personnel, and supplies and equipment were identified. CONCLUSIONS: The World Health Organization Tool for Situational Analysis of Emergency and Essential Surgical Care was useful in identifying baseline emergency and surgical conditions for evidenced-based planning. To achieve the Poverty Reduction Strategy and delivery of the Basic Package of Health and Social Welfare Services, additional resources and manpower are needed to improve surgical and anesthetic care.

International human xenotransplantation inventory.

BACKGROUND: Xenotransplantation carries inherent risks of infectious disease transmission to the recipient and even to society at large, and it should only be carried out with strict regulation and oversight. In collaboration with the International Xenotransplantation Association, the University Hospital Geneva, and the World Health Organization, an international inventory has been established (www.humanxenotransplant.org) aiming to collect basic data on all types of currently ongoing or recently performed xenotransplantation procedures in humans. METHODS: We collected information from publications in scientific journals, presentations at international congresses, the internet, and declarations of International Xenotransplantation Association members on xenotransplantation procedures in humans performed during the past 15 years. RESULTS: We identified a total of 29 human applications of xenotransplantation, including 7 that were currently ongoing. Procedures involved transplantation of xenogeneic cells, i.e., islets of Langerhans, kidney cells, chromaffin cells, embryonic stem cells, fetal and adult cells from various organs or extracorporeal perfusion using hepatocytes, liver, spleen, or kidney. The treatments were performed in 12 different countries, 9 of them having no national regulation on xenotransplantation. CONCLUSION: Several clinical applications of cell xenotransplantation are ongoing around the world, often without any clear governmental regulation. This information should be used to inform national health authorities, healthcare staff, and the public, with the objective of encouraging good practices, with internationally harmonized guidelines and regulation of xenotransplantation.

Addressing the Millennium Development Goals from a surgical perspective: essential surgery and anesthesia in 8 low- and middle-income countries.

HYPOTHESIS: Surgical and anesthetic care is increasingly recognized as a neglected but cost-effective component of primary health care in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Strengthening delivery can help achieve Millennium Development Goals 4, 5, and 6. Large gaps in access to essential surgical care in LMICs result in considerable morbidity and mortality. The goal of this study was to provide a baseline overview of essential surgical and anesthetic capacity at district-level health facilities in multiple LMICs. DESIGN: Survey. SETTING: District-level health facilities in multiple LMICs MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: A standardized World Health Organization tool was used at selected district-level hospitals to assess infrastructure, supplies, and procedures relating to essential surgical and anesthetic capacity. The analysis included facilities from countries that assessed more than 5 health facilities. All data were aggregated and blinded to avoid intercountry comparisons. RESULTS: Data from 132 facilities were analyzed from 8 countries: Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka (n = 32), Mongolia (n = 31), United Republic of Tanzania (n = 25), Islamic State of Afghanistan (n = 13), Republic of Sierra Leone (n = 11), Republic of Liberia (n = 9), Republic of The Gambia (n = 6), and Democratic Republic of São Tomé and Príncipe (n = 5). Universally, facilities demonstrated shortfalls in basic infrastructure (water, electricity, oxygen) and functioning anesthesia machines. Although 73% of facilities reported performing incision and drainage of abscesses, only 48% were capable of undertaking an appendectomy. In line with Millennium Development Goals 4, 5, and 6, only 32% of facilities performed congenital hernia repairs, 44% of facilities performed cesarean sections, and few facilities always had goggles and aprons to protect surgical health care workers from human immunodeficiency virus. CONCLUSION: Enormous shortfalls in infrastructure, supplies, and procedures undertaken are common at district-level health facilities in LMICs.