Transcriptome analysis of human cumulus cells reveals hypoxia as the main determinant of follicular senescence.

STUDY QUESTION: Can RNA sequencing of human cumulus cells (CC) reveal molecular pathways involved in the physiology of reproductive aging? STUDY FINDING: Senescent but not young CC activate gene pathways associated with hypoxia and oxidative stress. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Shifts in socioeconomic norms are resulting in larger numbers of women postponing childbearing. The reproductive potential is sharply decreased with aging, and the reasons are poorly understood. Since CCs play an integral role in oocyte maturation and direct access to human oocytes is limited, we used whole transcriptome analysis of these somatic cells to gain insights into the molecular mechanisms playing a role in follicular senescence. STUDY DESIGN, SAMPLES/MATERIALS, METHODS: Twenty CC samples (from a total of 15 patients) were obtained from oocytes of either male factor or egg donor patients. RNA sequencing and bioinformatic tools were used to identify differentially expressed genes between CCs from seven aged and eight young patients (<35 (years old) y.o. vs >40 y.o.). Quantitative-PCR and immunoflourescent staining were used for validation. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: RNA sequencing identified 11 572 genes expressed in CC of both age cohorts, 45 of which were differentially expressed. In CC collected from patients >40 y.o., genes involved in the hypoxia stress response (NOS2, RORA and NR4A3), vasculature development (NR2F2, PTHLH), glycolysis (RALGAPA2 and TBC1D4) and cAMP turnover (PDE4D) were significantly overexpressed when compared with CC of patients younger than 35 y.o. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: This study focused almost exclusively on assessing the genetic differences in CC transcriptome between young and older women. These genetic findings were not fully correlated with embryonic development and clinical outcome. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: Our data provide a new hypothesis-follicular hypoxia-as the main mechanism leading to ovarian follicular senescence and suggest a link between cumulus cell aging and oocyte quality decay. If specific molecular findings of hypoxia would be confirmed also in oocytes, genetic platforms could screen CC for hypoxic damage and identify healthier oocytes. Protocols of ovarian stimulation in older patients could also be adjusted to diminish oocyte exposure time to hypoxic follicles. LARGE SCALE DATA: GEO accession number: GSE81579 STUDY FUNDING AND COMPETING INTERESTS: Funded in part by EMD Serono Grant for Fertility Innovation (GFI).

Ribozymes: a distinct class of metalloenzymes.

Ribozymes are an important new class of metalloenzymes that have an unlikely feature: they are made entirely of ribonucleic acid (RNA). Metal ions are essential for efficient chemical catalysis by ribozymes and are often required for the stabilization of ribozyme structure. Most ribozymes catalyze reactions at phosphorus centers through one of two major mechanistic pathways, and reaction has been observed at carbon centers. Creative experiments have revealed the position of metal ions in the active site of two ribozymes. The exploitation of variable metal geometry and reactivity has expanded ribozyme chemistry and has facilitated the application of in vitro selection for the creation of novel ribozymes.

Active disruption of an RNA-protein interaction by a DExH/D RNA helicase.

All aspects of cellular RNA metabolism and the replication of many viruses require DExH/D proteins that manipulate RNA in a manner that requires nucleoside triphosphates. Although DExH/D proteins have been shown to unwind purified RNA duplexes, most RNA molecules in the cellular environment are complexed with proteins. It has therefore been speculated that DExH/D proteins may also affect RNA-protein interactions. We demonstrate that the DExH protein NPH-II from vaccinia virus can displace the protein U1A from RNA in an active adenosine triphosphate-dependent fashion. NPH-II increases the rate of U1A dissociation by more than three orders of magnitude while retaining helicase processivity. This indicates that DExH/D proteins can effectively catalyze protein displacement from RNA and thereby participate in the structural reorganization of ribonucleoprotein assemblies.

Catalytic role of 2'-hydroxyl groups within a group II intron active site.

Domain 5 is an essential active-site component of group II intron ribozymes. The role of backbone substituents in D5 function was explored through synthesis of a series of derivatives containing deoxynucleotides at each position along the D5 strand. Kinetic screens revealed that eight 2'-hydroxyl groups were likely to be critical for activity of D5. Through two separate methods, including competitive inhibition and direct kinetic analysis, effects on binding and chemistry were distinguished. Depending on their function, important 2'-hydroxyl groups lie on opposite faces of the molecule, defining distinct loci for molecular recognition and catalysis by D5.

RNA binding activates RIG-I by releasing an autorepressed signaling domain.

The retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG-I) innate immune receptor is an important immunotherapeutic target, but we lack approaches for monitoring the physical basis for its activation in vitro. This gap in our understanding has led to confusion about mechanisms of RIG-I activation and difficulty discovering agonists and antagonists. We therefore created a novel fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based method for measuring RIG-I activation in vitro using dual site-specific fluorescent labeling of the protein. This approach enables us to measure the conformational change that releases the signaling domain during the first step of RIG-I activation, making it possible to understand the role of stimulatory ligands. We have found that RNA alone is sufficient to eject the signaling domain, ejection is reversible, and adenosine triphosphate plays but a minor role in this process. These findings help explain RIG-I dysfunction in autoimmune disease, and they inform the design of therapeutics targeting RIG-I.

The architectural organization and mechanistic function of group II intron structural elements.

Group II introns are large, self-splicing RNAs and mobile genetic elements that provide good model systems for studies of RNA folding. The structures and mechanistic functions of individual domains are being elucidated, and long-range tertiary interactions between the domains are being identified, thus helping to define the three-dimensional architecture of the intron.

RNA folding.

The number of known motifs for RNA folding and RNA tertiary organization is expanding rapidly as we learn more about the diverse biological functions of RNA. Problems in protein and RNA folding have melded in recent investigations of ribonucleoprotein folding. Theoretical and experimental models are rapidly being developed for the pathways and stabilizing forces involved in RNA folding.

Remarkable morphological variability of a common RNA folding motif: the GNRA tetraloop-receptor interaction.

One of the most common RNA tertiary interactions involves the docking of GNRA hairpin loops into stem-loop structures on other regions of RNA. Domain 5 of the group II intron interacts with Domain 1 through such an interaction, which has been characterized thermodynamically and kinetically for the ai5g intron. Using this system, it was possible to test the morphological tolerances of the GNRA tetraloop involved in tertiary interactions. The data presented herein show that a GNRA tetraloop can still participate in tertiary interaction after being physically cut at any phosphodiester linkage within the loop. The "nicked tetraloop" can be expanded by many nucleotides in either direction and the covalently continuous loop can also be expanded without loss of interaction energy. In the context of the nicked tetraloop, the second nucleotide of the tetraloop sequence can be completely deleted without loss of function. By examining radical alterations in tetraloop structure, this study helps define the minimal sequence and structural requirements of a GNRA motif involved in long-range tertiary interaction. It shows that "tetraloop"-like structures capable of forming tertiary interactions can be imbedded in unexpected contexts, such as internal loops and apparently open structure within RNA. It demonstrates that pentaloops and hexaloops can form the same type of interaction, with almost equal affinity, as a tetraloop. Taken together, these data suggest a more generic term for the GNRA tetraloop-receptor interaction: It is proposed herein that the term "GNRA tetraloop" be replaced by "GNn/RA", where n represents a variable number of nucleotides and / indicates that the loop can be divided and interrupted by other sequences.

Stepping through an RNA structure: A novel approach to conformational analysis.

Drawing from the growing database of complex three-dimensional RNA structures, a systematic method has been developed for classifying and analyzing the variety of conformations adopted by nucleic acids. This method is based on the development of a reduced representation for nucleic acid backbone conformation, simplifying the formidable eight-dimensional problem that has long complicated nucleic acid conformational analysis. Two pseudotorsion angles (eta and theta) have been defined, based on the selection of two appropriate pivot points along the RNA backbone, P and C4'. These pseudotorsions, together with a complete library of conventional torsion angles, can be calculated for any RNA structure or all-atom model using a new program called AMIGOS. Having computed eta and theta pseudotorsions for each position on an RNA molecule, they can be represented on a two-dimensional plot similar to the phi-phi plots that have traditionally been used for protein conformational analysis. Like a Ramachandran plot, clusters of residues appear at discrete regions on an eta-theta plot. Nucleotides within these clusters share conformational properties, often belonging to the same type of structural motif such as A-platforms, sheared tandem purine-purine pairs and GNRA tetraloops. An eta-theta plot provides a two-dimensional representation of the conformational properties of an entire RNA molecule, facilitating rapid analysis of structural features. In addition to the utility of eta-theta plots for intuitive visualization of conformational space, the pseudotorsional convention described here should significantly simplify approaches to macromolecular modeling of RNA structure.

Antagonistic substrate binding by a group II intron ribozyme.

In this study, the thermodynamic properties of substrate-ribozyme recognition were explored using a system derived from group II intron ai5gamma. Substrate recognition by group II intron ribozymes is of interest because any nucleic ac?id sequence can be targeted, the recognition sequence can be quite long (>/=13 bp), and reaction can proceed with a very high degree of sequence specificity. Group II introns target their substrates throug?h the formation of base-pairing interactions with two regions of the intron (EBS1 and EBS2), which are usually located far apart in the secondary structure. These structures pair with adjacent, corresponding sites (IBS1 and IBS2) on the substrate. In order to understand the relative energetic contribution of each base-pairing interaction (EBS1-IBS1 or EBS2-IBS2) to substrate binding energy, the free energy of each helix was measured. The individual helices were found to have base-pairing free energies similar to those calculated for regular RNA duplexes of the same sequence, suggesting that each recognition helix derives its binding energy from base-pairing interactions alone and that each helix can form independently. Most interestingly, it was found that the sum of the measured individual free energies (approximately 20 kcal/mol) was much higher than the known free energy for substrate binding (approximately 12 kcal/mol). This indicates that certain group II intron ribozymes can bind their substrates in an antagonistic fashion, paying a net energetic penalty upon binding the full-length substrate. This loss of binding energy is not due to weakening of individual helices, but appears to be linked to ribozyme conformational changes induced by substrate binding. This coupling between substrate binding and ribozyme conformational rearrangement may provide a mechanism for lowering overall substrate binding energy while retaining the full information content of 13 bp, thus resulting in a mechanism for ensuring sequence specificity.

Two competing pathways for self-splicing by group II introns: a quantitative analysis of in vitro reaction rates and products.

Self-splicing group II introns are found in bacteria and in the organellar genes in plants, fungi, and yeast. The mechanism for the first step of splicing is generally believed to involve attack of a specific intronic 2'-hydroxyl group on a phosphodiester linkage at the 5'-splice site, resulting in the formation of a lariat intron species. In this paper, we present kinetic and enzymatic evidence that in vitro there are two distinct pathways for group II intron self-splicing: one involves 2'-OH attack and another involves attack of water or hydroxide. These two pathways occur in parallel under all reaction conditions, although either can dominate in the presence of particular salts or protein cofactors. Both pathways are followed by a successful second step of splicing, and either pathway can be highly efficient. We find that the hydrolytic pathway prevails under physiological ionic conditions, while branching predominates at molar concentrations of ammonium ion. The intron is observed to adopt two major active conformations. In order to quantify their individual reaction rates, we applied a mechanistic model describing biphasic parallel kinetic behavior. Kinetic analysis throughout the investigation reveals that there is no coupling between the unproductive "spliced-exon-reopening" reaction (SER) and hydrolysis during the first step of splicing. Conditions that stimulate branching can promote the SER reaction just as efficiently as conditions that stimulate the hydrolytic pathway. Although there is little evidence that it exists in vivo, a hydrolytic splicing pathway for group II introns has important implications for the translation of intron-encoded proteins and the inhibition of intron migration into new genomic positions.

Branch-site selection in a group II intron mediated by active recognition of the adenine amino group and steric exclusion of non-adenine functionalities.

The 2'-hydroxyl on a specific bulged adenosine is the nucleophile during the first step of splicing by group II introns. To understand the means by which the ribozyme core recognizes this adenosine, it was mutagenized and effects on catalytic activity were quantified. The results indicate that a low level of mutational variability is tolerated at the branch-site of group II introns, with no apparent loss of fidelity. Analyses of mutant and modified nucleotides at the branch-site reveal that adenine is recognized primarily through the N6 amino group and by steric exclusion of functionalities found on other bases. The mutational and single atom effects reported here contrast with those observed during spliceosomal processing, suggesting that there are important differences in adenosine recognition by the two systems.

Guiding ribozyme cleavage through motif recognition: the mechanism of cleavage site selection by a group ii intron ribozyme.

The mechanism by which group II introns cleave the correct phosphodiester linkage was investigated by studying the reaction of mutant substrates with a ribozyme derived from intron ai5gamma. While fidelity was found to be quite high in most cases, a single mutation on the substrate (+1C) resulted in a dramatic loss of fidelity. When this mutation was combined with a second mutation that induces a bulge in the exon binding site 1/intron binding site 1 (EBS1/IBS1) duplex, the base-pairing register of the EBS1/IBS1 duplex was shifted and the cleavage site moved to a downstream position on the substrate. Conversely, when mismatches were incorporated at the EBS1/IBS1 terminus, the duplex was effectively truncated and cleavage occurred at an upstream site. Taken together, these data demonstrate that the cleavage site of a group II intron ribozyme can be tuned at will by manipulating the thermodynamic stability and structure of the EBS1/IBS1 pairing. The results are consistent with a model in which the cleavage site is not designated through recognition of specific nucleotides (such as the 5'-terminal residue of EBS1). Instead, the ribozyme detects a structure at the junction between single and double-stranded residues on the bound substrate. This finding explains the puzzling lack of phylogenetic conservation in ribozyme and substrate sequences near group II intron target sites.

Group II intron ribozymes that cleave DNA and RNA linkages with similar efficiency, and lack contacts with substrate 2'-hydroxyl groups.

BACKGROUND: Group II introns are self-splicing RNAs that have mechanistic similarity to the spliceosome complex involved in messenger RNA splicing in eukaryotes. These autocatalytic molecules can be reconfigured into highly specific, multiple-turnover ribozymes that cleave oligonucleotides in trans. We set out to use a simplified system of this kind to study the mechanism of cleavage. RESULTS: Unlike other catalytic RNA molecules, the group II ribozymes cleave DNA linkages almost as readily as RNA linkages. One ribozyme variant cleaves DNA linkages with an efficiency comparable to that of restriction endonuclease EcoRI. Single deoxynucleotide substitutions in the substrate showed that the ribozymes bind substrate without engaging 2'-hydroxyl groups. CONCLUSIONS: The ribose 2'-hydroxyl group at the cleavage site has little role in transition-state stabilization by group II ribozymes. Substrate 2'-hydroxyl groups are not involved in substrate binding, suggesting that only base-pairing is required for substrate recognition.

Stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopy of a group II intron ribozyme reveals that domain 1 is an independent folding unit with a requirement for specific Mg2+ ions in the tertiary structure.

A stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopic assay for RNA folding was used to monitor the association of a multicomponent ribozyme derived from group II intron ai5gamma. In the presence of Mg2+, association of a short fluorescein-labeled oligonucleotide substrate with intron domain 1 (D1) resulted in a unique fluorescein emission enhancement, which reflected ribozyme folding and substrate binding. It was found that substrate binding follows a simple bimolecular encounter model, with k(on) approaching the rate of simple duplex formation. The Kd between substrate and D1 was determined to be 11 nM, which is in close agreement with the Kd obtained through oligonucleotide cleavage assays requiring catalytic domain 5 (D5). Ribozyme variants D13 and D135, which contain D3 and/or D5 attached to D1 in-cis, bound substrate with very similar Kd values, suggesting that D1 can fold independently and contains all residues important for ground-state binding to substrate. Both stopped-flow fluorescence assays and chemical modification footprinting data showed that, in all three ribozymes, Mg2+ was required and sufficient for folding. The rates of substrate association and the fraction of active ribozyme showed similar [Mg2+] dependencies, indicating that folding and substrate binding in these three ribozymes are the result of similar processes involving specific, weakly bound Mg2+ ions. The apparent binding constants for the Mg2+ ions were found to be approximately 70 mM in each case. Together, these data show that D1 is an independent folding unit with respect to substrate binding and that specific Mg2+ ions are required for the formation of a distinct tertiary structure in group II introns.

Branch-point attack in group II introns is a highly reversible transesterification, providing a potential proofreading mechanism for 5'-splice site selection.

By examining the first step of group II intron splicing in the absence of the second step, we have found that there is an interplay of three distinct reactions at the 5'-splice site: branching, reverse branching, and hydrolytic cleavage. This approach has yielded the first kinetic parameters describing eukaryotic branching and establishes that group II intron catalysis can proceed on a rapid timescale. The efficient reversibility of the first step is due to increased conformational organization in the branched intermediate and it has several important mechanistic implications. Reversibility in the first step requires that the second step of splicing serve as a kinetic trap, thus driving splicing to completion and coordinating the first and second step of splicing. Facile reverse branching also provides the intron with a proofreading mechanism to control the fidelity of 5'-splice site selection and it provides a kinetic basis for the apparent mobility of group II introns.

Ribozyme recognition of RNA by tertiary interactions with specific ribose 2'-OH groups.

Shortened forms of the group I intron from Tetrahymena catalyse sequence-specific cleavage of exogenous oligonucleotide substrates. The association between RNA enzyme (ribozyme) and substrate is mediated by pairing between an internal guide sequence on the ribozyme and a complementary sequence on the substrate. RNA substrates and cleavage products associate with a binding energy greater than that of base-pairing by approximately 4 kcal-mol-1 (at 42 degrees C), whereas DNA associates with an energy around that expected for base-pairing. It has been proposed that the difference in binding affinity is due to specific 2'-OH groups on an RNA substrate forming stabilizing tertiary interactions with the core of the ribozyme, or that the RNA.RNA helix formed upon association of an RNA substrate and the ribozyme might be more stable than an RNA.DNA helix of the same sequence. To differentiate between these two models, chimaeric oligonucleotides containing deoxynucleotide residues at successive positions along the chain were synthesized, and their equilibrium binding constants for association with the ribozyme were measured directly by a new gel electrophoresis technique. We report here that most of the extra binding energy can be accounted for by discrete RNA-ribozyme interactions, the 2'-OH group on the sugar residue three nucleotides from the cleavage site contributing the most interaction energy. Thus, in addition to the well documented binding of RNA to RNA by base-pairing, 2'-OH groups within a duplex can also mediate association between RNA molecules.

Defining functional groups, core structural features and inter-domain tertiary contacts essential for group II intron self-splicing: a NAIM analysis.

Group II introns are self-splicing RNA molecules that are of considerable interest as ribozymes, mobile genetic elements and examples of folded RNA. Although these introns are among the most common ribozymes, little is known about the chemical and structural determinants for their reactivity. By using nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM), it has been possible to identify the nucleotide functional groups (Rp phosphoryls, 2'-hydroxyls, guanosine exocyclic amines, adenosine N7 and N6) that are most important for composing the catalytic core of the intron. The majority of interference effects occur in clusters located within the two catalytically essential Domains 1 and 5 (D1 and D5). Collectively, the NAIM results indicate that key tetraloop-receptor interactions display a specific chemical signature, that the epsilon-epsilon' interaction includes an elaborate array of additional features and that one of the most important core structures is an uncharacterized three-way junction in D1. By combining NAIM with site-directed mutagenesis, a new tertiary interaction, kappa-kappa', was identified between this region and the most catalytically important section of D5, adjacent to the AGC triad in stem 1. Together with the known zeta-zeta' interaction, kappa-kappa' anchors D5 firmly into the D1 scaffold, thereby presenting chemically essential D5 functionalities for participation in catalysis.