Which are the most prevalent ethical conflicts for Spanish internists? / ¿Cuáles son los conflictos éticos más frecuentes para los internistas españoles?

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Clinicians face a multitude of ethical conflicts in their daily practice. There have been no studies on the types of ethical conflicts encountered most frequently and that are of most concern to clinicians in Spain. The aim of this study is to report the most common ethical conflicts faced by Spanish internists, as well as the importance that the practitioners attribute to each conflict. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Our observational cross-sectional study employed a voluntary and anonymous survey aimed at Spanish medical internists and distributed through an ad hoc platform of the Spanish Society of Internal Medicine. RESULTS: The most common and relevant ethical issues for Spanish internists are related to patients' end of life (decisions limiting therapeutic effort, use of palliative treatments, the establishment of do-not-resuscitate orders), the conflicts arising within the doctor-patient/family relationship, and making decisions with noncompetent patients. These results are similar to those of other English and European series. The ethical problems further complicate the healthcare activity of clinicians who more often notice these problems (50.3%) than those who do not notice them (16%). CONCLUSIONS: The most common and relevant ethical conflicts among Spanish internists are related to managing patients' end of life, followed by those related to the doctor-patient relationship and the management of noncompetent patients. It is essential that training programs be designed to better address and recognise these problems.

Do internists know what limitation of therapeutic effort means? / ¿Saben los internistas qué es la limitación del esfuerzo terapéutico?

OBJECTIVES: To ascertain whether internists know what limitation of therapeutic effort (LTE) means and whether training in palliative care affects this understanding. METHODS: A survey was administered to Spanish internists on their knowledge of LTE and the training in palliative care. RESULTS: A total of 273 respondents completed the survey (mean age, 42±12 years), 80.2% of whom were associates. Some 23.8% of the respondents identified the complete definition of LTE. The most often chosen responses were «not starting an active treatment¼(85.0%) and «withdrawing an active treatment¼ (65.9%). Forty-three percent of the respondents lacked training in palliative care, 73.3% considered their level of understanding to be good or very good, 62.3% stated that they became anxious when addressing the planning for end-of-life care with the patient, and 81.3% stated that they had had some conflict with their LTE decisions. CONCLUSIONS: Only 1 of every 4 internists knew the proper definition for LTE, with no association with the level of training in palliative care.

Characteristics of adults with Down syndrome hospitalised in Spanish internal medicine departments during 2005-2014. / Características de los adultos con síndrome de Down ingresados en los servicios de medicina interna españoles en el periodo 2005-2014.

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES: The clinical problems of adults with Down syndrome seem to differ from those of the general population. To better understand these differences, we list the demographic and clinical characteristics of adults with Down syndrome admitted to Spanish internal medicine departments during 2005-2014. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We conducted an observational retrospective study using data collected from the minimum basic data set on hospitalisation episodes of adults with Down syndrome in the internal medicine departments of Spain's National Health System from 2005 to 2014. We analysed the patients' epidemiological, clinical and societal data. RESULTS: A total of 7548 hospitalisation episodes from 3786 patients were recorded. Some 56.6% of the patients were male with a mean age (±SD) of 47±13 years, and 715 of the patients died (18.9%). The age-adjusted mortality was 26.6%, and the mean stay was 9.6±12 days. The hospitalisation was for respiratory disease in 3684 episodes (48.8%) and for cardiac origin in 760 (10%). The most common comorbidities were hypothyroidism (27.1%, 2043 episodes), epilepsy (24.1%, 1819 episodes) and dementia (15.4%, 1162 episodes). CONCLUSIONS: The hospitalisation of adults with Down syndrome in internal medicine departments has increased in the past decade. Although the reasons for hospitalisation, mean stay and cost per episode for this population are similar to those of the general population treated by internal medicine departments, the age-adjusted hospital mortality was significantly greater.

Healthcare workers' perception of the usefulness of a healthcare ethics consultation service.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Clinical ethics consultation services (CEC) have arisen from Healthcare Ethics Committees (HEC) to address ethical conflicts in real-time. Our aim was to determine the perception of usefulness of a CEC service among healthcare workers one year after its creation as well as to assess changes in trends in the use of the CEC and HEC between 2015 and 2021. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This observational, cross-sectional study was based on a standardized survey of healthcare workers at an urban tertiary care hospital. The results were also compared to those from an identical survey conducted in the same population in 2015. RESULTS: A total of 213 professionals participated (mean age 44 ± 11 years, 69% women). The professionals were more familiar with the HEC than the CEC service (94% vs 61%; p < 0.001). Forty-five individuals (21%) had consulted the CEC since its implementation; 95% of them found the consultation useful. Physicians knew about and used the CEC more than other groups of professionals. The degree of knowledge of the HEC increased significantly by 2021 compared to 2015 (94% v. 76%; p < 0.001). Some areas for improvement identified were the need for greater dissemination of the service, guaranteeing institutional resources to maintain the service, and encouraging greater participation from different professional groups. CONCLUSIONS: Knowledge of the institutional HEC and CEC services has increased in recent years among healthcare workers, who considered the CEC service to be useful for addressing ethical conflicts in daily practice.

Should the pharmaceutical industry be involved in continuing medical education?

INTRODUCTION: In July 2020, a draft bill was introduced in Spain's Congress which proposed that continuing medical education be funded exclusively by the Spanish government, barring involvement from private entities. AIMS: This work aims to gather physicians' and pharmacists' opinions on this draft bill, learn what they think about the funding of continuing medical education and possible conflicts of interest. METHODS: This work is a descriptive cross-sectional study conducted via voluntary anonymous surveys aimed at physicians and hospital pharmacists. RESULTS: Four hundred thirty-five surveys were analyzed, 59.8% of which were from women. Of the respondents, 87.6% were specialist physicians and 77.2% were part of a specialist department. A total of 55.2% did not agree with the draft bill while 92.4% agreed that the government and private institutes should subsidize training for their workers. Furthermore, 52.4% disagreed that each professional should pay for his or her own training while 14% agreed they should. A total of 19.8% have felt uncomfortable when a course or conference has been paid for by another entity and 74.5% believe that the involvement of private entities in funding does not influence prescribing. CONCLUSIONS: The majority of those surveyed did not agree with a draft bill aimed at prohibiting the pharmaceutical industry from funding continuing medical education. Nearly all agreed that the government and private institutions should fund training for their workers. In general, those surveyed did not find conflicts of interest in their relationship with the industry.

Description of the experience of a clinical ethics consultation service from 2019 to 2021.

INTRODUCTION: Clinical ethics consultation services (CEC) are useful model for ethical counselling, albeit with scarce implementation in European countries. This article shares the experience of one of the first ethics consultation services in Spain. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This work is a retrospective, observational study of all consultations received by the CEC service at La Princesa University Hospital (Madrid, Spain) from September 1, 2019 to August 31, 2021. The demographic, logistic, and ethical variables of the cases were analyzed. RESULTS: A total of 63 cases were analyzed in which a total of 124 ethical conflicts were identified. Forty-one percent of the cases (n = 26) were emergency consultations and 38% (n = 24) were preferential inquiries. An initial evaluation was performed with 24 h in 50 cases (79%). The department that consulted most often was the Intensive Care Unit (9; 14%). The preferred contact methods were via pager (36; 57%), the electronic medical record system (13; 21%), or direct conversations with consulting team (7; 11%). The most common ethical conflicts were those related to the adequacy of treatment measures (24; 19%), refusal of treatment (19; 15%), communication with the patient or his/her family (29; 23%), or the patient's capacity (13; 11%). CONCLUSION: CEC services provide quick, efficient assistance for resolving ethical problems in daily practice. Their implementation in Spain is feasible.

[Education in leadership: a need and a challenge of the modern internist]. / Educar en liderazgo: requisito y reto del internista actual.

Leadership is the ability to guide a team adequately, to ensure that it will be able to completely develop a given project. Being a leader means having the capacity of active listening and exercising a wide variety of communicational aptitudes. Leading means working together, and facilitating that work. A leader needs to have in-depth self-knowledge as well as a good share of humility and internal coherence. The development of many of these features is essential to ameliorate both patient-doctor relationships and professional relationships in the modern day-to-day medical practice. Even though not all of us are destined to lead work teams, there is a common obligation to exercise many of the skills that a leader should have.

Which are the most prevalent ethical conflicts for Spanish internists?

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Clinicians face a multitude of ethical conflicts in their daily practice. There have been no studies on the types of ethical conflicts encountered most frequently and that are of most concern to clinicians in Spain. The aim of this study is to report the most common ethical conflicts faced by Spanish internists, as well as the importance that the practitioners attribute to each conflict. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Our observational cross-sectional study employed a voluntary and anonymous survey aimed at Spanish medical internists and distributed through an ad hoc platform of the Spanish Society of Internal Medicine. RESULTS: The most common and relevant ethical issues for Spanish internists are related to patients' end of life (decisions limiting therapeutic effort, use of palliative treatments, the establishment of do-not-resuscitate orders), the conflicts arising within the doctor-patient/family relationship, and making decisions with noncompetent patients. These results are similar to those of other English and European series. The ethical problems further complicate the healthcare activity of clinicians who more often notice these problems (50.3%) than those who do not notice them (16%). CONCLUSIONS: The most common and relevant ethical conflicts among Spanish internists are related to managing patients' end of life, followed by those related to the doctor-patient relationship and the management of noncompetent patients. It is essential that training programs be designed to better address and recognise these problems.

Do internists know what limitation of therapeutic effort means?

OBJECTIVES: To ascertain whether internists know what limitation of therapeutic effort (LTE) means and whether training in palliative care affects this understanding. METHODS: A survey was administered to Spanish internists on their knowledge of LTE and training in palliative care. RESULTS: A total of 273 respondents completed the survey (mean age, 42±12 years), 80.2% of whom were associates. Some 23.8% of the respondents identified the complete definition of LTE. The most frequently selected responses were "not starting an active treatment" (85.0%) and "withdrawing an active treatment" (65.9%). Forty-three percent of the respondents lacked training in palliative care, 73.3% considered their level of understanding to be good or very good, 62.3% stated that they became anxious when addressing planning for end-of-life care with a patient, and 81.3% stated that they had experienced some conflict with their LTE decisions. CONCLUSIONS: Only 1 of every 4 internists knew the proper definition of LTE, with no association with the level of training in palliative care.

Haemodynamic profile of Spanish adults with Down syndrome. / Perfil hemodinámico de los adultos españoles con síndrome de Down.

OBJECTIVES: Although the reasons are unknown, the prevalence of arterial hypertension and atherosclerotic cardiovascular events in the adult population with Down syndrome (SD) is anecdotal. To better understand this finding, we evaluated the haemodynamic characteristics of a cohort of adults with SD. METHODS: We conducted a cross-sectional study of adults with SD recruited consecutively from the outpatient clinics of an internal medicine department between June and November 2018. We collected demographic, clinical and laboratory variables and employed a thoracic bioimpedance device (HOTMAN® System) for the haemodynamic measures. Outpatient blood pressure monitoring (OBPM) was conducted on a subgroup of participants. RESULTS: Twenty-six participants (mean age, 45±11years) participated in the study (50% men). The sample's mean blood pressure (BP) was 109/69±11/9mmHg, with a mean heart rate of 60±12bpm. None of the participants had hypertension. The predominant haemodynamic profile consisted of normal dynamism (65%), normal BP (96%), hypochronotropism (46%), normal inotropism (50%) and hypervolaemia (54%), with normal peripheral vascular resistance values (58%). Twelve participants underwent OBPM (46%). The mean 24-h systolic BP, diastolic BP, mean BP and mean heart rate were 105±11mmHg, 67±11mmHg, 80±11mmHg and 61±6bpm, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The most common haemodynamic profile observed in adults with SD consisted of hypochronotropism and hypervolaemia, with normal values for peripheral vascular resistance and optimal mean BP values. There were no participants with hypertension in our sample.

[Are we still our patients' keepers?: James Drane's contribution to clinical ethics in the current context]. / ¿Seguimos siendo guardianes de nuestros pacientes?: la contribución de James Drane a la ética clínica actual.

The current article analyzes the figure of the American bioethicist James Drane (1930). Drane not only played a crucial role in the birth of Bioethics in the United States, but was also instrumental in the inception and development of the field in Spain and Latin America. His «sliding scale¼ was the first dynamic tool encouraging a systematic evaluation of a patient's capacity to make healthcare-related decisions. However Drane's major contribution to the field was his application of virtue Ethics to the doctor-patient relationship. His proposal rests on the physician's compromise with the patient in all his/her dimensions. This goal will guide the physician's character and serve as compass, with which to exercise a virtuous practice, since only by exercising these virtues can doctors become truly good.

The internist as clinical ethics consultant: An antidote to "the barbarism of specialisation" in hospital practice. / El internista como consultor de ética clínica: un antídoto contra «la barbarie del especialismo¼ en la práctica hospitalaria.

The development of hospital clinical ethics in Spain depends almost exclusively on the healthcare ethics committees, which have been criticized for a lack of proximity to the patient's bedside in day-to-day ethical conflicts and for their scarce practical operation, reflected in the low number of consultations they receive. In this study, we reflect on the need to change the current healthcare model in clinical ethics so as to reactivate it and call attention to the essential role of internists as the engine for this change. To this end, we propose a model in which the healthcare ethics committees incorporate ethics consultants, who are better positioned to discuss cases at the patient's bedside. We then analyse the characteristics that these consultants should have.

Limitation of therapeutic effort in patients hospitalised in departments of internal medicine. / Limitación del esfuerzo terapéutico en pacientes hospitalizados en servicios de medicina interna.

INTRODUCTION: There is little information on the limitation of therapeutic effort (LTE) in patients admitted to hospital internal medicine units. OBJECTIVES: To describe the indicated LTE regimens in the departments of internal medicine and the characteristics of the patients who undergo them. PATIENTS AND METHODS: An observational, descriptive retrospective study was conducted on 4 hospitals of the Community of Madrid. The study collected demographic and comorbidity data and the LTE orders prescribed for all patients who died during a period of 6 months. RESULTS: The study included 382 patients with a mean age of 85±10 years; 204 were women (53.4%) and 222 (58.1%) came from their homes. Some 51.1% of the patients were terminal, 43.2% had moderate to severe dementia, and 95.5% presented at least moderate comorbidity. Some type of LTE was performed in 318 patients (83.7%); the most common orders were "No cardiopulmonary resuscitation" (292 patients, 76.4%; 95% CI 72.1-80.8), "Do not use aggressive measures" (113 patients, 16.4%; 95% CI 13.7-19.4) and "Do not transfer to an intensive care unit" (102 cases, 14.8%, 95% CI 12.3-17.7). Some type of LTE was performed in 318 patients (83.7%); the most common orders were "No cardiopulmonary resuscitation" (292 patients, 76.4%; 95% CI 72.1-80.8), "Do not use aggressive measures" (113 patients, 16.4%; 95% CI 13.7-19.4) and "Do not transfer to an intensive care unit" (102 cases, 14.8%, 95% CI 12.3-17.7). CONCLUSIONS: LTE is common among patients who die in Internal Medicine. The most widely used regimens were "No CPR" and the unspecific statement "Do not use aggressive measures". The patients were elderly and had significant comorbidity, terminal illness and advanced dementia.

Why dedicate yourself to bioethics? Seven reasons to get you started.

The aim of clinical bioethics is to promote rational clinical decisions that take into account the clinical facts and the preferences and values of individuals involved in a situation that entails a moral problem. The objective of the present study is to list the reasons why we consider bioethics knowledge and skills to be essential in daily practice and to promote a proactive mindset in clinical bioethics research. The arguments set forth include the need to adapt to changes in the clinical relationship in recent decades, the importance of an ethical approach both for the physician and the patient, the role of bioethics in preventing professional burnout, the ability of ethics to promote a more equitable distribution of resources and the possibility of conducting clinical research in bioethics, a field that has scarcely been explored in Spain.

[Withholding and withdrawing treatment in patients admitted in an Internal Medicine ward]. / Limitación del esfuerzo terapéutico en pacientes hospitalizados en el Servicio de Medicina Interna.

INTRODUCTION: Many of the patients admitted to a general medical ward have a compromised quality of life, or short life expectancy, so they are potential candidates for withhold/withdraw (WH/WD) treatment. The first objectif was to describe which measures were WH/WD among patients who died during their admission in a general medical ward from a tertiary hospital in Madrid. Secondly, to define the clinical characteristics of this population. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A cross-sectional descriptive study during 6 months from 2011 and 2012 of all the patients dead while their admission in the Internal Medicine Department. RESULTS: 2007 patients were admitted, 211 died (10.5%). 121 (57%) were female, with 85±9 years of mean age. 103 (48.8%) came from a residential facility and 105 fulfilled terminality criteria (49.8%). One decision to WH/WD treatment was made in 182 patients (86.3%, CI 95%: 81.4-91.1), two in 99 cases (46.9%, CI 95%: 39.9-53.9) and 3 or more in 31 subjects (14.7%, CI 95%: 9.6-19.7). The most frequent decisions involved do-not-resuscitate orders (154, 73.0%), rejection of «aggressive treatment measures¼ (80, 38.0%), use of antibiotics (19, 9.0%), admission in ICU (18, 8.5%), and/or surgical treatment (11, 5.2%). CONCLUSIONS: WH/WD treatment is very frequent among patients who died in a general medical ward. The most frequent involved do-not-resuscitate orders and rejection of «aggressive treatment measures¼. WH/WD decisions are adopted in an elderly population, with extensive comorbidity and an elevated prevalence of advanced dementia and/or terminal disease.

Clinical characteristics of the patients with systemic amyloidosis in 2000-2010.

BACKGROUND: The epidemiology of systemic amyloidosis has been changing in the last decades. We aim to describe the clinical characteristics of the patients seen at our institution with systemic amyloidosis in 2000-2010 and compare them with previous Spanish series. PATIENTS AND METHODS: An observational, retrospective study was performed on all patients admitted to a tertiary hospital in Madrid, Spain who had been diagnosed of amyloidosis from January 2000 to December 2010. Patients without a proven diagnosis of amyloidosis, with dialysis-associated, senile, or localized forms of amyloidosis were excluded from the study. A systematic review was made of the clinical records, collecting the demographic, clinical and biochemical variables at diagnosis and patients' outcome. RESULTS: A total of 55 patients were studied, 24 (44%) of whom had AL amyloidosis, 30 (56%) AA amyloidosis, and 1 a familiar form. The most frequent underlying disorders were rheumatoid arthritis (9 patients, 30%) and ankylosing spondylitis (4 cases, 13%). The kidneys were the most frequently involved organ (36 patients, 67%) with nephrotic-range proteinuria at diagnosis (3.4 ± 3.7 g/24 h). Median time to diagnosis was 3 months (interquartile range [IQR]: 1-17). Median follow-up time was 24 months (IQR: 10-91). During follow-up 31 patients died; 18 of those deaths were related to amyloidosis. CONCLUSIONS: Renal dysfunction dominates the course of systemic amyloidosis, which does not seem to have changed in the last decades. We have observed an important delay in the diagnosis of these processes. Therefore, it is necessary to maintain a high degree of clinical suspicion regarding these conditions.

[Reproducibility of the glucose tolerance test in patients with impaired fasting glucose]. / Reproducibilidad de la prueba de sobrecarga oral de glucosa en pacientes con glucosa alterada en ayunas.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Impaired fasting glucose (IFG) is defined by a fasting glucose between 5.6 and 6.9 mmol/l in subjects with no known diabetes. The present study objectives were: a) to analyze the glucose tolerance test (GTT) reproducibility and b) to assess this test's diagnostic classification agreement. PATIENTS AND METHOD: Cross-sectional study in adult patients diagnosed with IFG. Study subjects underwent a 75 g GTT in two occasions. RESULTS: Fifty-nine patients were studied. The interval between GTT tests was 37 +/- 26 days. Fasting and post-GTT plasma glucose intra-individual variation coefficients were 6.9 and 31.0%, respectively. Diagnostic agreement between the two tests (normal tolerance vs. abnormal tolerance) was measured using the kappa index: 0.62 (95% CI 0.42-0.82). Agreement ranged from 80% (95% CI, 70-90%) to 83% (95% CI, 73-93%) depending on whether the first GGT results were abnormal or normal, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: GTT reproducibility is moderate in patients diagnosed with IFG. Considering this fact, perhaps this test should be repeated before therapeutic decisions are made.