Photosynthesis tunes quantum-mechanical mixing of electronic and vibrational states to steer exciton energy transfer.

Photosynthetic species evolved to protect their light-harvesting apparatus from photoxidative damage driven by intracellular redox conditions or environmental conditions. The Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) pigment-protein complex from green sulfur bacteria exhibits redox-dependent quenching behavior partially due to two internal cysteine residues. Here, we show evidence that a photosynthetic complex exploits the quantum mechanics of vibronic mixing to activate an oxidative photoprotective mechanism. We use two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2DES) to capture energy transfer dynamics in wild-type and cysteine-deficient FMO mutant proteins under both reducing and oxidizing conditions. Under reducing conditions, we find equal energy transfer through the exciton 4-1 and 4-2-1 pathways because the exciton 4-1 energy gap is vibronically coupled with a bacteriochlorophyll-a vibrational mode. Under oxidizing conditions, however, the resonance of the exciton 4-1 energy gap is detuned from the vibrational mode, causing excitons to preferentially steer through the indirect 4-2-1 pathway to increase the likelihood of exciton quenching. We use a Redfield model to show that the complex achieves this effect by tuning the site III energy via the redox state of its internal cysteine residues. This result shows how pigment-protein complexes exploit the quantum mechanics of vibronic coupling to steer energy transfer.

Redox conditions correlated with vibronic coupling modulate quantum beats in photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes.

Quantum coherences, observed as time-dependent beats in ultrafast spectroscopic experiments, arise when light-matter interactions prepare systems in superpositions of states with differing energy and fixed phase across the ensemble. Such coherences have been observed in photosynthetic systems following ultrafast laser excitation, but what these coherences imply about the underlying energy transfer dynamics remains subject to debate. Recent work showed that redox conditions tune vibronic coupling in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) pigment-protein complex in green sulfur bacteria, raising the question of whether redox conditions may also affect the long-lived (>100 fs) quantum coherences observed in this complex. In this work, we perform ultrafast two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy measurements on the FMO complex under both oxidizing and reducing conditions. We observe that many excited-state coherences are exclusively present in reducing conditions and are absent or attenuated in oxidizing conditions. Reducing conditions mimic the natural conditions of the complex more closely. Further, the presence of these coherences correlates with the vibronic coupling that produces faster, more efficient energy transfer through the complex under reducing conditions. The growth of coherences across the waiting time and the number of beating frequencies across hundreds of wavenumbers in the power spectra suggest that the beats are excited-state coherences with a mostly vibrational character whose phase relationship is maintained through the energy transfer process. Our results suggest that excitonic energy transfer proceeds through a coherent mechanism in this complex and that the coherences may provide a tool to disentangle coherent relaxation from energy transfer driven by stochastic environmental fluctuations.

The influence of quaternary structure on the stability of Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) antenna complexes.

The trimeric nature of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) protein antenna complex from green sulfur phototrophic bacteria was investigated. Mutations were introduced into the protein at positions 142 and 198, which were chosen to destabilize the intra-trimer salt bridges between adjacent monomers. Strains bearing the mutations R142L, R198L, or their combination, exhibited altered optical absorption spectra of purified membranes and fluoresced more intensely than the wild type. In particular, the introduction of the R142L mutation resulted in slower culture growth rates, as well as an FMO complex that was not able to be isolated in appreciable quantities, while the R198L mutation yielded an FMO complex with increased sensitivity to sodium thiocyanate and Triton X-100 treatments. Native and denaturing PAGE experiments suggest that much of the FMO complexes in the mutant strains pool with the insoluble material upon membrane solubilization with n-dodecyl ß-D-maltoside, a mild nonionic detergent. Taken together, our results suggest that the quaternary structure of the FMO complex, the homotrimer, is an important factor in the maintenance of the complex's tertiary structure.

Evidence for a cysteine-mediated mechanism of excitation energy regulation in a photosynthetic antenna complex.

Light-harvesting antenna complexes not only aid in the capture of solar energy for photosynthesis, but regulate the quantity of transferred energy as well. Light-harvesting regulation is important for protecting reaction center complexes from overexcitation, generation of reactive oxygen species, and metabolic overload. Usually, this regulation is controlled by the association of light-harvesting antennas with accessory quenchers such as carotenoids. One antenna complex, the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) antenna protein from green sulfur bacteria, completely lacks carotenoids and other known accessory quenchers. Nonetheless, the FMO protein is able to quench energy transfer in aerobic conditions effectively, indicating a previously unidentified type of regulatory mechanism. Through de novo sequencing MS, chemical modification, and mutagenesis, we have pinpointed the source of the quenching action to cysteine residues (Cys49 and Cys353) situated near two low-energy bacteriochlorophylls in the FMO protein from Chlorobaculum tepidum Removal of these cysteines (particularly removal of the completely conserved Cys353) through N-ethylmaleimide modification or mutagenesis to alanine abolishes the aerobic quenching effect. Electrochemical analysis and electron paramagnetic resonance spectra suggest that in aerobic conditions the cysteine thiols are converted to thiyl radicals which then are capable of quenching bacteriochlorophyll excited states through electron transfer photochemistry. This simple mechanism has implications for the design of bio-inspired light-harvesting antennas and the redesign of natural photosynthetic systems.

Energy landscape of the intact and destabilized FMO antennas from C. tepidum and the L122Q mutant: Low temperature spectroscopy and modeling study.

We discuss the excitonic energy landscape of the typically studied wild-type (WT) Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) antenna protein from the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobaculum tepidum (referred to as WTM), which is described as a mixture of intact (WTI) and destabilized (WTD) complexes. Optical spectra of WTM and the L122Q mutant (where leucine 122 near BChl 8 is replaced with glutamine) are compared to WTI FMO. We show that WTM and L122Q samples are mixtures of two subpopulations of proteins, most likely induced by protein conformational changes during the isolation/purification procedures. Absorption, emission, and HB spectra of WTM and L122Q mutant are very similar, in which the low-energy trap (revealed by the nonresonant HB spectra) shifts to higher energies as a function of fluence, supporting a mixture model. No fluence-dependent shift is observed in the WTI FMO trimers. New Hamiltonians are provided for WTI and WTD proteins. Resonant HB spectra show that the internal energy relaxation times in the WTM and L122Q mutant are similar, and depend on excitation frequency. Fast average relaxation times (excited state lifetimes) are observed for burning into the main broad absorption band near 805nm. Burning at longer wavelengths reveals slower total dephasing times. No resonant bleach is observed at λB≤803nm, implying much faster (femtosecond) energy relaxation in this spectral range in agreement with 2D electronic spectroscopy frequency maps.

Light harvesting in phototrophic bacteria: structure and function.

This review serves as an introduction to the variety of light-harvesting (LH) structures present in phototrophic prokaryotes. It provides an overview of the LH complexes of purple bacteria, green sulfur bacteria (GSB), acidobacteria, filamentous anoxygenic phototrophs (FAP), and cyanobacteria. Bacteria have adapted their LH systems for efficient operation under a multitude of different habitats and light qualities, performing both oxygenic (oxygen-evolving) and anoxygenic (non-oxygen-evolving) photosynthesis. For each LH system, emphasis is placed on the overall architecture of the pigment-protein complex, as well as any relevant information on energy transfer rates and pathways. This review addresses also some of the more recent findings in the field, such as the structure of the CsmA chlorosome baseplate and the whole-cell kinetics of energy transfer in GSB, while also pointing out some areas in need of further investigation.

Native Mass Spectrometry Analysis of Oligomerization States of Fluorescence Recovery Protein and Orange Carotenoid Protein: Two Proteins Involved in the Cyanobacterial Photoprotection Cycle.

The orange carotenoid protein (OCP) and fluorescence recovery protein (FRP) are present in many cyanobacteria and regulate an essential photoprotection cycle in an antagonistic manner as a function of light intensity. We characterized the oligomerization states of OCP and FRP by using native mass spectrometry, a technique that has the capability of studying native proteins under a wide range of protein concentrations and molecular masses. We found that dimeric FRP is the predominant state at protein concentrations ranging from 3 to 180 µM and that higher-order oligomers gradually form at protein concentrations above this range. The OCP, however, demonstrates significantly different oligomerization behavior. Monomeric OCP (mOCP) dominates at low protein concentrations, with an observable population of dimeric OCP (dOCP). The ratio of dOCP to mOCP, however, increases proportionally with protein concentration. Higher-order OCP oligomers form at protein concentrations beyond 10 µM. Additionally, native mass spectrometry coupled with ion mobility allowed us to measure protein collisional cross sections and interrogate the unfolding of different FRP and OCP oligomers. We found that monomeric FRP exhibits a one-stage unfolding process, which could be correlated with its C-terminal bent crystal structure. The structural domain compositions of FRP and OCP are compared and discussed.

Probing the excitonic landscape of the Chlorobaculum tepidum Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex: a mutagenesis approach.

In this paper we report the steady-state optical properties of a series of site-directed mutants in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex of Chlorobaculum tepidum, a photosynthetic green sulfur bacterium. The FMO antenna complex has historically been used as a model system for energy transfer due to the water-soluble nature of the protein, its stability at room temperature, as well as the availability of high-resolution structural data. Eight FMO mutants were constructed with changes in the environment of each of the bacteriochlorophyll a pigments found within each monomer of the homotrimeric FMO complex. Our results reveal multiple changes in low temperature absorption, as well as room temperature CD in each mutant compared to the wild-type FMO complex. These datasets were subsequently used to model the site energies of each pigment in the FMO complex by employing three different Hamiltonians from the literature. This enabled a basic approximation of the site energy shifts imparted on each pigment by the changed amino acid residue. These simulations suggest that, while the three Hamiltonians used in this work provide good fits to the wild-type FMO absorption spectrum, further efforts are required to obtain good fits to the mutant minus wild-type absorption difference spectra. This demonstrates that the use of FMO mutants can be a valuable tool to refine and iterate the current models of energy transfer in this system.

Structural and kinetic properties of Rhodobacter sphaeroides photosynthetic reaction centers containing exclusively Zn-coordinated bacteriochlorophyll as bacteriochlorin cofactors.

The Zn-BChl-containing reaction center (RC) produced in a bchD (magnesium chelatase) mutant of Rhodobacter sphaeroides assembles with six Zn-bacteriochlorophylls (Zn-BChls) in place of four Mg-containing bacteriochlorophylls (BChls) and two bacteriopheophytins (BPhes). This protein presents unique opportunities for studying biological electron transfer, as Zn-containing chlorins can exist in 4-, 5-, and (theoretically) 6-coordinate states within the RC. In this paper, the electron transfer perturbations attributed exclusively to coordination state effects are separated from those attributed to the presence, absence, or type of metal in the bacteriochlorin at the HA pocket of the RC. The presence of a 4-coordinate Zn(2+) ion in the HA bacteriochlorin instead of BPhe results in a small decrease in the rates of the P*→P(+)HA(-)→P(+)QA(-) electron transfer, and the charge separation yield is not greatly perturbed; however coordination of the Zn(2+) by a fifth ligand provided by a histidine residue results in a larger rate decrease and yield loss. We also report the first crystal structure of a Zn-BChl-containing RC, confirming that the HA Zn-BChl was either 4- or 5-coordinate in the two types of Zn-BChl-containing RCs studied here. Interestingly, a large degree of disorder, in combination with a relatively weak anomalous difference electron density was found in the HB pocket. These data, in combination with spectroscopic results, indicate partial occupancy of this binding pocket. These findings provide insights into the use of BPhe as the bacteriochlorin pigment of choice at HA in both BChl- and Zn-BChl-containing RCs found in nature.

Nano-mechanical mapping of the interactions between surface-bound RC-LH1-PufX core complexes and cytochrome c 2 attached to an AFM probe.

Electron transfer pathways in photosynthesis involve interactions between membrane-bound complexes such as reaction centres with an extrinsic partner. In this study, the biological specificity of electron transfer between the reaction centre-light-harvesting 1-PufX complex and its extrinsic electron donor, cytochrome c 2, formed the basis for mapping the location of surface-attached RC-LH1-PufX complexes using atomic force microscopy (AFM). This nano-mechanical mapping method used an AFM probe functionalised with cyt c 2 molecules to quantify the interaction forces involved, at the single-molecule level under native conditions. With surface-bound RC-His12-LH1-PufX complexes in the photo-oxidised state, the mean interaction force with cyt c 2 is approximately 480 pN with an interaction frequency of around 66 %. The latter value lowered 5.5-fold when chemically reduced RC-His12-LH1-PufX complexes are imaged in the dark to abolish electron transfer from cyt c 2 to the RC. The correspondence between topographic and adhesion images recorded over the same area of the sample shows that affinity-based AFM methods are a useful tool when topology alone is insufficient for spatially locating proteins at the surface of photosynthetic membranes.

Role of Rhodobacter sphaeroides photosynthetic reaction center residue M214 in the composition, absorbance properties, and conformations of H(A) and B(A) cofactors.

In the native reaction center (RC) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides, the side chain of (M)L214 projects orthogonally toward the plane and into the center of the A branch bacteriopheophytin (BPhe) macrocycle. The possibility that this side chain is responsible for the dechelation of the central Mg(2+) of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) was investigated by replacement of (M)214 with residues possessing small, nonpolar side chains that can neither coordinate nor block access to the central metal ion. The (M)L214 side chain was also replaced with Cys, Gln, and Asn to evaluate further the requirements for assembly of the RC with BChl in the HA pocket. Photoheterotrophic growth studies showed no difference in growth rates of the (M)214 nonpolar mutants at a low light intensity, but the growth of the amide-containing mutants was impaired. The absorbance spectra of purified RCs indicated that although absorbance changes are associated with the nonpolar mutations, the nonpolar mutant RC pigment compositions are the same as in the wild-type protein. Crystal structures of the (M)L214G, (M)L214A, and (M)L214N mutants were determined (determined to 2.2-2.85 Å resolution), confirming the presence of BPhe in the HA pocket and revealing alternative conformations of the phytyl tail of the accessory BChl in the BA site of these nonpolar mutants. Our results demonstrate that (i) BChl is converted to BPhe in a manner independent of the aliphatic side chain length of nonpolar residues replacing (M)214, (ii) BChl replaces BPhe if residue (M)214 has an amide-bearing side chain, (iii) (M)214 side chains containing sulfur are not sufficient to bind BChl in the HA pocket, and (iv) the (M)214 side chain influences the conformation of the phytyl tail of the BA BChl.

Porphyrin Excretion Resulting From Mutation of a Gene Encoding a Class I Fructose 1,6-Bisphosphate Aldolase in Rhodobacter capsulatus.

This paper describes a mutant (called SB1707) of the Rhodobacter capsulatus wild type strain SB1003 in which a transposon-disrupted rcc01707 gene resulted in a ∼25-fold increase in the accumulation of coproporphyrin III in the medium of phototrophic (anaerobic) cultures grown in a yeast extract/peptone medium. There was little or no stimulation of pigment accumulation in aerobic cultures. Therefore, this effect of rcc01707 mutation appears to be specific for the anaerobic coproporphyrinogen III oxidase HemN as opposed to the aerobic enzyme HemF. The protein encoded by rcc01707 is homologous to Class I fructose 1,6-bisphosphate aldolases, which catalyze a glycolytic reaction that converts fructose 1, 6-bisphosphate to dihydroxyacetone phosphate and glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate, precursors of pyruvate. There were significant differences in coproporphyrin III accumulation using defined media with individual organic acids and sugars as the sole carbon source: pyruvate, succinate and glutamate stimulated accumulation the most, whereas glucose suppressed coproporphyrin III accumulation to 10% of that of succinate. However, although quantitatively lesser, similar effects of carbon source on the amount of accumulated pigment in the culture medium were seen in a wild type control. Therefore, this mutation appears to exaggerate effects also seen in the wild type strain. It is possible that mutation of rcc01707 causes a metabolic bottleneck or imbalance that was not rectified during growth on the several carbon sources tested. However, we speculate that, analogous to other fructose 1,6-bisphosphate aldolases, the rcc01707 gene product has a "moonlighting" activity that in this case is needed for the maximal expression of the hemN gene. Indeed, it was found that the rcc01707 gene is needed for maximal expression of a hemN promoter-lacZ reporter. With the decrease in hemN expression due to the absence of the rcc01707 gene product, coproporphyrinogen III accumulates and is released from the cell, yielding the spontaneous oxidation product coproporphyrin III.

Electronic coherence lifetimes of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex and light harvesting complex II.

The study of coherence between excitonic states in naturally occurring photosynthetic systems offers tantalizing prospects of uncovering mechanisms of efficient energy transport. However, experimental evidence of functionally relevant coherences in wild-type proteins has been tentative, leading to uncertainty in their importance at physiological conditions. Here, we extract the electronic coherence lifetime and frequency using a signal subtraction procedure in two model pigment-protein-complexes (PPCs), light harvesting complex II (LH2) and the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex (FMO), and find that the coherence lifetimes occur at the same timescale (<100 fs) as energy transport between states at the energy level difference equal to the coherence energy. The pigment monomer bacteriochlorophyll a (BChla) shows no electronic coherences, supporting our methodology of removing long-lived vibrational coherences that have obfuscated previous assignments. This correlation of timescales and energy between coherences and energy transport reestablishes the time and energy scales that quantum processes may play a role in energy transport.

Excitonic Energy Landscape of the Y16F Mutant of the Chlorobium tepidum Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) Complex: High Resolution Spectroscopic and Modeling Studies.

We report high-resolution (low-temperature) absorption, emission, and nonresonant/resonant hole-burned (HB) spectra and results of excitonic calculations using a non-Markovian reduced density matrix theory (with an improved algorithm for parameter optimization in heterogeneous samples) obtained for the Y16F mutant of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) trimer from the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum. We show that the Y16F mutant is a mixture of FMO complexes with three independent low-energy traps (located near 817, 821, and 826 nm), in agreement with measured composite emission and HB spectra. Two of these traps belong to mutated FMO subpopulations characterized by significantly modified low-energy excitonic states. Hamiltonians for the two major subpopulations (Sub821 and Sub817) provide new insight into extensive changes induced by the single-point mutation in the vicinity of BChl 3 (where tyrosine Y16 was replaced with phenylalanine F16). The average decay time(s) from the higher exciton state(s) in the Y16F mutant depends on frequency and occurs on a picosecond time scale.

Coherent wavepackets in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson complex are robust to excitonic-structure perturbations caused by mutagenesis.

Femtosecond pulsed excitation of light-harvesting complexes creates oscillatory features in their response. This phenomenon has inspired a large body of work aimed at uncovering the origin of the coherent beatings and possible implications for function. Here we exploit site-directed mutagenesis to change the excitonic level structure in Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complexes and compare the coherences using broadband pump-probe spectroscopy. Our experiments detect two oscillation frequencies with dephasing on a picosecond timescale-both at 77 K and at room temperature. By studying these coherences with selective excitation pump-probe experiments, where pump excitation is in resonance only with the lowest excitonic state, we show that the key contributions to these oscillations stem from ground-state vibrational wavepackets. These experiments explicitly show that the coherences-although in the ground electronic state-can be probed at the absorption resonances of other bacteriochlorophyll molecules because of delocalization of the electronic excitation over several chromophores.

Excitation energy transfer kinetics and efficiency in phototrophic green sulfur bacteria.

A series of spectroscopic measurements were performed on membrane fractions and detergent-solubilized complexes from the green sulfur bacterium (GSB) Chlorobaculum (Cba.) tepidum. The excitation migration through the entire GSB photosynthetic apparatus cannot be observed upon excitation of membranes in the chlorosome region at 77 K. In order to observe energy transfer from the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) protein to the reaction center (RC), FMO was directly excited at ~800 nm in transient absorption experiments. However, interpretation of the results is complicated by the spectral overlap between FMO and the RC. The availability of the Y16F FMO mutant, whose absorption spectrum is drastically different from that of the WT, has enabled the selection of spectral regions where either only FMO or the RC contributes. The application of a directed kinetic modeling approach, or target analysis, revealed the various decay and energy transfer pathways within the pigment-protein complexes. The calculated FMO-to-RC excitation energy transfer efficiencies are approximately 25% and 48% for the Y16F and WT samples, respectively.

Redox Conditions Affect Ultrafast Exciton Transport in Photosynthetic Pigment-Protein Complexes.

Pigment-protein complexes in photosynthetic antennae can suffer oxidative damage from reactive oxygen species generated during solar light harvesting. How the redox environment of a pigment-protein complex affects energy transport on the ultrafast light-harvesting time scale remains poorly understood. Using two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy, we observe differences in femtosecond energy-transfer processes in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) antenna complex under different redox conditions. We attribute these differences in the ultrafast dynamics to changes to the system-bath coupling around specific chromophores, and we identify a highly conserved tyrosine/tryptophan chain near the chromophores showing the largest changes. We discuss how the mechanism of tyrosine/tryptophan chain oxidation may contribute to these differences in ultrafast dynamics that can moderate energy transfer to downstream complexes where reactive oxygen species are formed. These results highlight the importance of redox conditions on the ultrafast transport of energy in photosynthesis. Tailoring the redox environment may enable energy transport engineering in synthetic light-harvesting systems.

Ultrafast Spectroscopic Investigation of Energy Transfer in Site-Directed Mutants of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) Antenna Complex from Chlorobaculum tepidum.

Ultrafast transient absorption (TA) and time-resolved fluorescence (TRF) spectroscopic studies were performed on several mutants of the bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) a-containing Fenna-Matthews-Olson (FMO) complex from the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobaculum tepidum. These mutants were generated to perturb a particular BChl a site and determine its effects on the optical spectroscopic properties of the pigment-protein complex. Measurements conducted at 77 K under both oxidizing and reducing conditions revealed changes in the dynamics of the various spectral components as compared to the data set from wild-type FMO. TRF results show that under reducing conditions all FMO samples decay with a similar lifetime in the ∼2 ns range. The oxidized samples revealed varying fluorescence lifetimes of the terminal BChl a emitter, considerably shorter than those recorded for the reduced samples, indicating that the quenching mechanism in wild-type FMO is still present in the mutants. Global fitting of TA data yielded similar overall results, and in addition, the lifetimes of early decaying components were determined. Target analyses of TA data for select FMO samples generated kinetic models that better simulate the TA data. A comparison of the lifetime of excitonic components for all samples reveals that the mutations affect mainly the early kinetic components, but not that of the lowest energy exciton, which reflects the flexibility of energy transfer in FMO.

Absence of Selection for Quantum Coherence in the Fenna-Matthews-Olson Complex: A Combined Evolutionary and Excitonic Study.

We present a study on the evolution of the Fenna-Matthews-Olson bacterial photosynthetic pigment-protein complex. This protein complex functions as an antenna. It transports absorbed photons-excitons-to a reaction center where photosynthetic reactions initiate. The efficiency of exciton transport is therefore fundamental for the photosynthetic bacterium's survival. We have reconstructed an ancestor of the complex to establish whether coherence in the exciton transport was selected for or optimized over time. We have also investigated the role of optimizing free energy variation upon folding in evolution. We studied whether mutations which connect the ancestor to current day species were stabilizing or destabilizing from a thermodynamic viewpoint. From this study, we established that most of these mutations were thermodynamically neutral. Furthermore, we did not see a large change in exciton transport efficiency or coherence, and thus our results predict that exciton coherence was not specifically selected for.