DNA binding by proteins.

Study of proteins that recognize specific DNA sequences has yielded much information, but the field is still in its infancy. Already two major structural motifs have been discovered, the helix-turn-helix and zinc finger, and numerous examples of DNA-binding proteins containing either of them are known. The restriction enzyme Eco RI uses yet a different motif. Additional motifs are likely to be found as well. There is a growing understanding of some of the physical chemistry involved in protein-DNA binding, but much remains to be learned before it becomes possible to engineer a protein that binds to a specific DNA sequence.

DNA looping and unlooping by AraC protein.

Expression of the L-arabinose BAD operon in Escherichia coli is regulated by AraC protein which acts both positively in the presence of arabinose to induce transcription and negatively in the absence of arabinose to repress transcription. The repression of the araBAD promoter is mediated by DNA looping between AraC protein bound at two sites near the promoter separated by 210 base pairs, araI and araO2. In vivo and in vitro experiments presented here show that an AraC dimer, with binding to half of araI and to araO2, maintains the repressed state of the operon. The addition of arabinose, which induces the operon, breaks the loop, and shifts the interactions from the distal araO2 site to the previously unoccupied half of the araI site. The conversion between the two states does not require additional binding of AraC protein and appears to be driven largely by properties of the protein rather than being specified by the slightly different DNA sequences of the binding sites. Slight reorientation of the subunits of AraC could specify looping or unlooping by the protein. Such a mechanism could account for regulation of DNA looping in other systems.

Structural basis for ligand-regulated oligomerization of AraC.

The crystal structure of the arabinose-binding and dimerization domain of the Escherchia coli gene regulatory protein AraC was determined in the presence and absence of L-arabinose. The 1.5 angstrom structure of the arabinose-bound molecule shows that the protein adopts an unusual fold, binding sugar within a beta barrel and completely burying the arabinose with the amino-terminal arm of the protein. Dimer contacts in the presence of arabinose are mediated by an antiparallel coiled-coil. In the 2.8 angstrom structure of the uncomplexed protein, the amino-terminal arm is disordered, uncovering the sugar-binding pocket and allowing it to serve as an oligomerization interface. The ligand-gated oligomerization as seen in AraC provides the basis of a plausible mechanism for modulating the protein's DNA-looping properties.

Arac/XylS family of transcriptional regulators.

The ArC/XylS family of prokaryotic positive transcriptional regulators includes more than 100 proteins and polypeptides derived from open reading frames translated from DNA sequences. Members of this family are widely distributed and have been found in the gamma subgroup of the proteobacteria, low- and high-G + C-content gram-positive bacteria, and cyanobacteria. These proteins are defined by a profile that can be accessed from PROSITE PS01124. Members of the family are about 300 amino acids long and have three main regulatory functions in common: carbon metabolism, stress response, and pathogenesis. Multiple alignments of the proteins of the family define a conserved stretch of 99 amino acids usually located at the C-terminal region of the regulator and connected to a nonconserved region via a linker. The conserved stretch contains all the elements required to bind DNA target sequences and to activate transcription from cognate promoters. Secondary analysis of the conserved region suggests that it contains two potential alpha-helix-turn-alpha-helix DNA binding motifs. The first, and better-fitting motif is supported by biochemical data, whereas existing biochemical data neither support nor refute the proposal that the second region possesses this structure. The phylogenetic relationship suggests that members of the family have recruited the nonconserved domain(s) into a series of existing domains involved in DNA recognition and transcription stimulation and that this recruited domain governs the role that the regulator carries out. For some regulators, it has been demonstrated that the nonconserved region contains the dimerization domain. For the regulators involved in carbon metabolism, the effector binding determinants are also in this region. Most regulators belonging to the AraC/XylS family recognize multiple binding sites in the regulated promoters. One of the motifs usually overlaps or is adjacent to the -35 region of the cognate promoters. Footprinting assays have suggested that these regulators protect a stretch of up to 20 bp in the target promoters, and multiple alignments of binding sites for a number of regulators have shown that the proteins recognize short motifs within the protected region.

Regulation of the L-arabinose operon of Escherichia coli.

Over forty years of research on the L-arabinose operon of Escherichia coli have provided insights into the mechanism of positive regulation of gene activity. This research also discovered DNA looping and the mechanism by which the regulatory protein changes its DNA-binding properties in response to the presence of arabinose. As is frequently seen in focused research on biological subjects, the initial studies were primarily genetic. Subsequently, the genetic approaches were augmented by physiological and then biochemical studies. Now biophysical studies are being conducted at the atomic level, but genetics still has a crucial role in the study of this system.

The araE low affinity L-arabinose transport promoter. Cloning, sequence, transcription start site and DNA binding sites of regulatory proteins.

The promoter for the gene encoding the low affinity L-arabinose uptake protein in Escherichia coli was studied. The promoter was cloned, sequenced, its transcription start site determined by S1 nuclease mapping, the proteins required for in vitro transcription were determined, and the regulatory protein binding sites located by DNase footprinting. The araE promoter shows no evidence of an operator site upstream from the CRP binding site, but otherwise it is similar to the araBAD promoter.

Mapping arm-DNA-binding domain interactions in AraC.

AraC protein, the regulator of the l-arabinose operon in Escherichia coli has been postulated to function by a light switch mechanism. According to this mechanism, it should be possible to find mutations in the DNA-binding domain of AraC that result in weaker arm-DNA-binding domain interactions and which make the protein constitutive, that is, it no longer requires arabinose to activate transcription. We isolated such mutations by randomizing three contiguous leucine residues in the DNA-binding domain, and then by systematically scanning surface residues of the DNA-binding domain with alanine and glutamic acid. As a result, a total of 20 constitutive mutations were found at ten different positions. They form a contiguous trail on the DNA-distal face of the DNA-binding domain, and likely define the region where the N-terminal arm that extends from the N-terminal dimerization domain contacts the C-terminal DNA-binding domain.

Determining residue-base interactions between AraC protein and araI DNA.

Depurination/depyrimidation binding-interference experiments (missing contact probing) identified specific candidate residue-base interactions lost by mutants of Escherichia coli L-arabinose operon regulatory protein, AraC, to one of its binding sites, araI. These candidates were then checked more rigorously by comparing the affinities of wild-type and alanine-substituted AraC protein to variants of araI with alterations in the candidate contacted positions. Residues 208 and 212 apparently contact DNA and support, but do not prove the existence of a helix-turn-helix structure in this region of AraC protein whereas contacts by mutants with alterations at positions 256, 257 and 261 which are within another potential helix-turn-helix region do not support the existence of such a structure there. The missing contacts displayed by three AraC mutants are found within two major groove regions of the DNA and are spaced 21 base-pairs apart in a pattern indicating a direct repeat orientation for the subunits of AraC.

AraC protein can activate transcription from only one position and when pointed in only one direction.

At the araBAD promoter, the RNA polymerase-proximal half-site for AraC binding partially overlaps the -35 region. Random and explicit spacing experiments show that both this partial overlapping and AraC binding to the polymerase-proximal half-site are necessary and sufficient for strong transcriptional activation. Normally, this occupancy is generated by the presence of arabinose, which shifts AraC from a DNA looping interaction involving the polymerase-distal half-site and the araO2 site 210 base-pairs away, to an interaction with the two half-sites adjacent to RNA polymerase. Changing the polymerase-proximal half-site to a higher affinity AraC binding site gives activation in the absence of arabinose. Thus, arabinose is not required to transform AraC into an activating conformation. Because the two half-sites of araI are direct repeats, the RNA polymerase proximal and distal surfaces of AraC are not identical. When the araI site was turned around, no spacings were found from which AraC could activate transcription. In light of the strict spacing and orientation requirements for AraC activation, the interactions between AraC and RNA polymerase are likely to be specific and inflexible.

Transcription of Escherichia coli ara in vitro. The cyclic AMP receptor protein requirement for PBAD induction that depends on the presence and orientation of the araO2 site.

The mechanism by which the cyclic AMP receptor protein, CRP, stimulates transcription of the Escherichia coli araBAD promoter was studied in vitro. Under one set of conditions, CRP stimulated by eightfold the rate of RNA polymerase open complex formation on supercoiled DNA template containing the normal wild-type araBAD regulatory region. Since previous studies in vivo had identified an upstream site termed araO2 that is involved in both repression and in the CRP requirement for PBAD induction, we performed similar experiments in vitro. Deletion of araO2 or alterations of its orientation with respect to the araI site by half integral numbers of turns greatly reduced the CRP requirement for induction of PBAD. Linearizing the DNA has the same effect as deleting araO2 from the supercoiled DNA template. The similarity of conditions that relieve the classical repression of PBAD in vivo and the conditions that eliminate the requirement for CRP for maximal activity in vitro suggest a close relationship between repression in the ara system and the role of CRP. At lower concentrations of AraC protein and slightly different conditions than those used in the above-mentioned experiments, CRP does stimulate transcription from linear or supercoiled templates lacking araO2. On linear DNA under these conditions, one dimer of AraC protein binds to linear araPBAD DNA, but is incapable of stimulating transcription without the additional binding of CRP. The responses of the ara system under the second set of conditions are unlike its behavior in vivo.

Transcription from the rha operon psr promoter.

S1 nuclease mapping experiments performed with RNA extracted from cell lines that were unable to metabolize L-rhamnose demonstrated that L-rhamnose and not a metabolite was the inducer of the L-rhamnose operons of Escherichia coli. In vitro transcription studies showed that purified RhaR activates transcription from the psr promoter in the presence of L-rhamnose. In the absence of L-rhamnose, RhaR binds to the psr promoter but does not activate transcription until L-rhamnose is added.

Deletion analysis of the Escherichia coli ara PC and PBAD promoters.

Deletions extending various distances into the ara PC-PBAD regulatory region were studied to define the sites required in vivo for the activity of these promoters. Deletions from the PC side entering the CRP site, which is located from -80 to -120 with respect to the PBAD transcription start site, reduced activity of this promoter. Similarly, deletions entering this site from the PBAD side reduced activity of the PC promoter. Cyclic AMP receptor protein bound at this site apparently functions to stimulate transcription of both flanking promoters.

Upstream repression and CRP stimulation of the Escherichia coli L-arabinose operon.

Repression of the Escherichia coli araBAD promoter, PBAD, was studied using a mutant PBAD promoter (cip-5) that is expressed in the absence of the two proteins required for PBAD induction, AraC protein and the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP-cAMP). Like the wild type promoter, cip-5 was repressed by AraC protein, and this repression required a site well upstream of the transcriptional start site. cip-5 was used to determine whether repression results from interference with the functioning of either AraC protein at araI and/or CRP-cAMP. Repression of cip-5 was eliminated by a point mutation within the AraC protein binding site araI but was not affected in the absence of CRP-cAMP. These results suggest that repression involves an interaction between two AraC protein binding sites located over 200 nucleotides apart. Our results also suggest that the majority of the CRP requirement for PBAD is a result of PBAD repression. When repression was abolished by deletion of the araO2 site, the requirement for CRP-cAMP in PBAD induction was greatly reduced.

Equilibrium DNA-binding of AraC protein. Compensation for displaced ions.

Experiments on the AraC regulatory protein of Escherichia coli suggest a mechanism that DNA-binding proteins can use to reduce potentially drastic alterations in their affinity for DNA resulting from changes in salt concentration. Measurement of the net number of ions apparently displaced as AraC protein binds DNA and of fluorescence changes in the protein lead to the following picture. About 14 ions are displaced from the DNA as the protein binds the araI site. As the protein binds the DNA, however, it undergoes a conformational change and binds about ten ions. Consequently, the net order of the reaction is reduced from 15th to about fourth order in salt concentration.

Regulation of the Escherichia coli L-arabinose operon studied by gel electrophoresis DNA binding assay.

DNA binding properties of the proteins required for induction of the Escherichia coli L-arabinose operon were measured using a polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis assay. The mechanisms of induction and repression were studied by observing the multiple interactions of RNA polymerase, cyclic AMP receptor protein and araC protein with short DNA fragments containing either the araC or araBAD promoter regions. These studies show that binding of araC protein to the operator site, araO1, directly blocks RNA polymerase binding at the araC promoter, pC. We find that cyclic AMP receptor protein and araC protein do not bind co-operatively at their respective sites to linear DNA fragments containing the pBAD promoter. Nevertheless, both these positive effectors must be present on the DNA to stimulate binding of RNA polymerase. Additionally, binding of the proteins to the DNA is not sufficient; araC protein must also be in the inducing state, for RNA polymerase to bind. Equilibrium binding constraints and kinetics were determined for araC protein binding to the araI and the araO1 sites. In the presence of inducer, L-arabinose, araC protein binds with equal affinity to DNA fragments containing either of these sites. In the presence of anti-inducer, D-fucose, the affinity for both sites is reduced 40-fold. The apparent equilibrium binding constants for both states of the protein vary in parallel with the buffer salt concentration. This result suggests that the inducing and repressing forms of araC protein displace a similar number of cations upon binding DNA.

Purification and properties of RhaR, the positive regulator of the L-rhamnose operons of Escherichia coli.

The product of the rhaR gene, which regulates the level of mRNA produced from the four L-rhamnose-inducible promoters of the rhamnose operon, has been hypersynthesized and purified by a two-column procedure. The purified protein is a 33 kDa DNA-binding protein that binds to an inverted repeat structure located within the psr promoter, the promoter for the rhaS and rhaR genes. The equilibrium binding constants and kinetic constants have been determined under a variety of solution conditions. The protein binds with high affinity and its binding is sensitive to salt concentration and the presence of L-rhamnose. The nucleotides and phosphate residues contacted by RhaR were identified by chemical interference assays. All of the contacts are made to one face of the DNA and the symmetrical pattern matches the inverted repeat sequence proposed for the binding site. An unusual property of the binding site is that the two half-sites of the inverted repeat are separated from one another by 17 base-pairs of uncontacted DNA. Significant binding is retained if the 17 base-pairs are extended by insertions of integral turns of DNA, but not by half-integral turns. The complex of RhaR-DNA appears to be sharply bent, approximately 160 degrees.

AraC-DNA looping: orientation and distance-dependent loop breaking by the cyclic AMP receptor protein.

The arabinose operon promoter, pBAD, is negatively regulated in the absence of arabinose by AraC protein, which forms a DNA loop by binding to two sites separated by 210 base-pairs, araO2 and araI1. pBAD is also positively regulated by AraC-arabinose and the cyclic AMP receptor protein, CRP. We provide evidence that CRP breaks the araO2-araI1 repression loop in vitro. The ability of CRP to break the loop in vitro and to activate pBAD in vivo is dependent upon the orientation and distance of the CRP binding site relative to araI1. An insertion of one DNA helical turn, 11 base-pairs, between CRP and araI only partially inhibits CRP loop breaking and activation of pBAD, while an insertion of less than one DNA helical turn, 4 base-pairs, not only abolishes CRP activation and loop breaking, but actually causes CRP to stabilize the loop and increases the araO2-mediated repression of pBAD. Both integral and non-integral insertions of greater than one helical turn completely abolish CRP activation and loop breaking in vitro.

DNA-dependent renaturation of an insoluble DNA binding protein. Identification of the RhaS binding site at rhaBAD.

Previous work has indicated that the RhaS protein directly activates the L-rhamnose catabolic operon, rhaBAD, and that the likely RhaS binding site lies downstream of position -84 relative to the rhaBAD transcription start point. Biochemical analysis of RhaS binding to this DNA site had not been possible due to the extreme insolubility of overproduced RhaS protein. Here we have been able to analyze directly the DNA binding properties of RhaS by developing a method to refold insoluble RhaS protein into a form with specific DNA binding activity. We found that active RhaS protein could be recovered only if the renaturation reaction was performed in the presence of DNA. We also found that the recovery of DNA-binding activity from the related AraC protein, after denaturation in urea, was dependent upon added DNA. To test the specificity of the recovered RhaS DNA-binding activity, and to define the binding site for comparison with other AraC family binding sites, we then investigated the details of the RhaS binding site. Using refolded RhaS protein in a DNase footprinting assay, we found that RhaS protects a region of the rhaBAD promoter from position -83 to -28. Analysis of the effects of single base mutations in the rhaBAD promoter region indicates that RhaS binds to an inverted repeat of two 17 bp half-sites separated by 16 bp, located between -81 and -32 relative to the rhaBAD transcription start site.

Characterization of the Escherichia coli araFGH and araJ promoters.

The identities of two cloned, arabinose-inducible promoters were tested by hybridizing promoter DNA fragments with restriction digests of chromosomal DNA containing Mudlac phage inserted in either araFGH or in araE transport operons. One promoter, thought to be araE, is within 10(3) base-pairs of a Mudlac insertion in the araE gene. The second promoter was not found within several thousand base-pairs of either of the known transport genes. This promoter is now named araPJ (araJ). The DNA sequence of the fragment containing the araFGH promoter was determined. The start site of transcription in vivo was located to within +/- 1 base-pair (bp) by S1 nuclease mapping. DNase 1 footprinting revealed that, in comparison with the araBAD and araE promoters, the locations of the AraC and cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) binding sites are reversed with CRP lying between AraC and RNA polymerase. The central location of the CRP binding site may explain why the araFGH promoter is more catabolite sensitive than the other ara promoters. AraC and CRP were both required for maximal transcription in vitro, although a low level of transcription was detected with CRP alone. S1 nuclease mapping of mRNA-DNA hybrids from the araJ promoter located the transcription start point to within #/- 3 bp, and demonstrates that the promoter is dependent upon AraC protein and CRP in vivo. DNase footprinting showed that the location of the AraC protein binding site on araJ is adjacent to the RNA polymerase site, as seen at the araBAD and araE promoters. Two CRP sites were observed; one is upstream from the AraC site and one is downstream from the transcription start site.

Apo-AraC actively seeks to loop.

In the absence of arabinose and interactions with other proteins, AraC, the activator-repressor that regulates the araBAD operon in Escherichia coli, was found to prefer participating in DNA looping interactions between the two well-separated DNA half-sites, araI1 and araO2 at their normal separation of 211 base-pairs rather than binding to these same two half-sites when they are adjacent to one another. On the addition of arabinose, AraC preferred to bind to the adjacently located half-sites. Inverting the distally located araO2 half-site eliminated the looping preference. These results demonstrate that apo-AraC possesses an intrinsic looping preference that is eliminated by the presence of arabinose. We developed a method for the accurate determination of the relative affinities of AraC for the DNA half-sites araI1, araI2, and araO2 and non-specific DNA. These affinities allowed accurate calculation of basal level and induced levels of expression from pBAD under a wide variety of natural and mutant conditions. The calculations independently predicted the looping preference of apo-AraC.