RESUMO
INTRODUCTION: Learning and growth in postgraduate medical education (PGME) often require vulnerability, defined as a state of openness to uncertainty, risk, and emotional exposure. However, vulnerability can threaten a resident's credibility and professional identity. Despite this tension, studies examining vulnerability in PGME are limited. As such, this study aims to explore residents' experiences of vulnerability, including the factors that influence vulnerability in PGME. METHODS: Using a constructivist grounded theory approach, individual semi-structured interviews were conducted with 15 residents from 10 different specialities. Interview transcripts were coded and analysed iteratively. Themes were identified and relationships among themes were examined to develop a theory describing vulnerability in PGME. RESULTS: Residents characterised vulnerability as a paradox represented by two overarching themes. 'Experiencing the tensions of vulnerability' explores the polarities between being a fallible, authentic learner and an infallible, competent professional. 'Navigating the vulnerability paradox' outlines the factors influencing the experience of vulnerability and its associated outcomes at the intrapersonal, interpersonal, and systems levels. Residents described needing to have the bandwidth to face the risks and emotional labour of vulnerability. Opportunities to build connections with social agents, including clinical teachers and peers, facilitated vulnerability. The sociocultural context shaped both the experience and outcomes of vulnerability as residents faced the symbolic mask of professionalism. CONCLUSION: Residents experience vulnerability as a paradox shaped by intrapersonal, interpersonal, and systems level factors. These findings capture the nuance and complexity of vulnerability in PGME and offer insight into creating supportive learning environments that leverage the benefits of vulnerability while acknowledging its risks. There is a need to translate this understanding into systems-based change to create supportive PGME environments, which value and celebrate vulnerability.
RESUMO
BACKGROUND: Our institution simultaneously transitioned all postgraduate specialty training programs to competency-based medical education (CBME) curricula. We explored experiences of CBME-trained residents graduating from five-year programs to inform the continued evolution of CBME in Canada. METHODS: We utilized qualitative description to explore residents' experiences and inform continued CBME improvement. Data were collected from fifteen residents from various specialties through focus groups, interviews, and written responses. The data were analyzed inductively, using conventional content analysis. RESULTS: We identified five overarching themes. Three themes provided insight into residents' experiences with CBME, describing discrepancies between the intentions of CBME and how it was enacted, challenges with implementation, and variation in residents' experiences. Two themes - adaptations and recommendations - could inform meaningful refinements for CBME going forward. CONCLUSIONS: Residents graduating from CBME training programs offered a balanced perspective, including criticism and recognition of the potential value of CBME when implemented as intended. Their experiences provide a better understanding of residents' needs within CBME curricula, including greater balance and flexibility within programs of assessment and curricula. Many challenges that residents faced with CBME could be alleviated by greater accountability at program, institutional, and national levels. We conclude with actionable recommendations for addressing residents' needs in CBME.
RESUMO
This study aims to test whether the efficacy of repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (rTMS) differs between patients who developed tinnitus following a traumatic brain injury (TBI), and those without a history of TBI. This was a parallel pilot, open-label, non-randomized, clinical trial to compare the efficacy of low frequency rTMS on tinnitus symptoms in patients with and without a TBI history. Patients with moderate to severe tinnitus symptoms based on the Tinnitus Handicap Inventory (THI) and the Tinnitus Functional Index (TFI) were enrolled in the study. Validated questionnaires (THI and TFI) were used to quantify the severity of tinnitus symptoms and hearing impairment (Hearing Handicap Index - HHI) before and after ten sessions of rTMS of the left primary auditory cortex. Hearing threshold levels as well as speech reception and speech discrimination thresholds were also compared. The number of patients who experienced a reduction in their subjective tinnitus symptoms was greater and sustained longer in patients without a history of TBI. The same was seen with subjective symptoms of hearing impairment. In conclusion, our preliminary results suggest tinnitus patients without a history of TBI respond better to low frequency rTMS than those with a history of TBI, suggesting that treatments could be more effective if tailored to tinnitus etiology.
Assuntos
Córtex Auditivo , Lesões Encefálicas Traumáticas , Zumbido , Lesões Encefálicas Traumáticas/complicações , Lesões Encefálicas Traumáticas/diagnóstico , Lesões Encefálicas Traumáticas/terapia , Humanos , Zumbido/diagnóstico , Zumbido/etiologia , Zumbido/terapia , Estimulação Magnética Transcraniana , Resultado do TratamentoAssuntos
Artrogripose/diagnóstico , COVID-19/prevenção & controle , Eletrodiagnóstico/métodos , Neuropatia Hereditária Motora e Sensorial/diagnóstico , Neurite (Inflamação)/diagnóstico , Traumatismos dos Nervos Periféricos/diagnóstico , Artrogripose/reabilitação , Artrogripose/cirurgia , Neurite do Plexo Braquial/diagnóstico , Neurite do Plexo Braquial/reabilitação , Neurite do Plexo Braquial/cirurgia , Gerenciamento Clínico , Cirurgia Geral , Neuropatia Hereditária Motora e Sensorial/reabilitação , Neuropatia Hereditária Motora e Sensorial/cirurgia , Humanos , Controle de Infecções/métodos , Neurite (Inflamação)/reabilitação , Neurite (Inflamação)/cirurgia , Neurologia , Terapia Ocupacional , Traumatismos dos Nervos Periféricos/reabilitação , Traumatismos dos Nervos Periféricos/cirurgia , Modalidades de Fisioterapia , Medicina Física e Reabilitação , Guias de Prática Clínica como Assunto , Encaminhamento e Consulta , SARS-CoV-2 , Telemedicina/métodosRESUMO
Coaching is an increasingly popular means to provide individualized, learner-centered, developmental guidance to trainees in competency based medical education (CBME) curricula. Aligned with CBME's core components, coaching can assist in leveraging the full potential of this educational approach. With its focus on growth and improvement, coaching helps trainees develop clinical acumen and self-regulated learning skills. Developing a shared mental model for coaching in the medical education context is crucial to facilitate integration and subsequent evaluation of success. This paper describes the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada's coaching model, one that is theory based, evidence informed, principle driven and iteratively and developed by a multidisciplinary team. The coaching model was specifically designed, fit for purpose to the postgraduate medical education (PGME) context and implemented as part of Competence by Design (CBD), a new competency based PGME program. This coaching model differentiates two coaching roles, which reflect different contexts in which postgraduate trainees learn and develop skills. Both roles are supported by the RX-OCR process: developing Relationship/Rapport, setting eXpectations, Observing, a Coaching conversation, and Recording/Reflecting. The CBD Coaching Model and its associated RX-OCR faculty development tool support the implementation of coaching in CBME. Coaching in the moment and coaching over time offer important mechanisms by which CBD brings value to trainees. For sustained change to occur and for learners and coaches to experience the model's intended benefits, ongoing professional development efforts are needed. Early post implementation reflections and lessons learned are provided.
Assuntos
Educação Médica , Tutoria , Propilenoglicóis , Cirurgiões , Humanos , CurrículoRESUMO
PURPOSE: The R2C2 (relationship, reaction, content, coaching) model is an iterative, evidence-based, theory-informed approach to feedback and coaching that enables preceptors and learners to build relationships, explore reactions and reflections, confirm content, and coach for change and cocreate an action plan. This study explored application of the R2C2 model for in-the-moment feedback conversations between preceptors and learners and the factors that influence its use. METHOD: A qualitative study using framework analysis through the lens of experiential learning was undertaken with 15 trained preceptor-learner dyads. Data were collected during feedback sessions and follow-up interviews between March 2021 and July 2022. The research team familiarized themselves with the data, used a coding template to document examples of the model's application, reviewed the initial framework and revised the coding template, indexed and summarized the data, created a summary document, examined the transcripts for alignment with each model phase, and identified illustrative quotations and overarching themes. RESULTS: Fifteen dyads were recruited from 8 disciplines (11 preceptors were paired with a single resident [n = 9] or a single medical student [n = 2]; 2 preceptors each had 2 residents). All dyads were able to apply the R2C2 phases of building relationships, exploring reactions and reflections, and confirming content. Many struggled with the coaching components, specifically in creating an action plan and follow-up arrangements. Preceptor skill in applying the model, time available for feedback conversations, and the nature of the relationship impacted how the model was applied. CONCLUSIONS: The R2C2 model can be adapted to contexts where in-the-moment feedback conversations occur shortly after a clinical encounter. Experiential learning approaches applying the R2C2 model are critical. Skillful application of the model requires that learners and preceptors go beyond confirming an area of change and deliberately engage in coaching and cocreating an action plan.
Assuntos
Internato e Residência , Tutoria , Humanos , Retroalimentação , Feedback Formativo , Comunicação , PreceptoriaRESUMO
Background: Coaching has gained traction in postgraduate medical education to enhance interactions between residents and clinical teachers, but these relationships present unique challenges and tensions. In order to realize the promises of coaching in medical education, we must understand how coaching relationships can be enacted to optimize resident development. The purpose of this study was to explore residents' perceptions of key characteristics for effective clinical teacher-resident (CT-R) coaching relationships. Methods: We conducted four focus groups and eight interviews with residents at a Canadian academic center. Using a social constructionist approach, focus groups and interviews were audio recorded, transcribed verbatim, and thematically analyzed. Results: Residents described three main characteristics that contributed to effective CT-R coaching relationships: safe, meaningful, and collaborative. Residents emphasized that these characteristics needed to be bidirectional in nature to be most effective, in that both the resident and clinical teacher embodied these characteristics. Conclusions: Residents identified that effective coaching relationships were shaped not only by clinical teacher behaviours, but importantly, the quality of the interpersonal relationship that was fostered. Thus, it is imperative to consider the bidirectional nature of the CT-R coaching relationship when striving to enhance resident development.
Contexte: Bien que le coaching ait gagné du terrain en éducation médicale postgraduée, notamment comme moyen de renforcer les interactions entre les résidents et les cliniciens enseignants, les rapports entre eux présentent néanmoins des défis et des tensions uniques. Pour atteindre les résultats souhaités en lien avec le coaching en éducation médicale, il faut comprendre comment ces interactions peuvent être mises à profit de façon à optimiser le perfectionnement des résidents. L'objectif de cette étude était d'explorer les perceptions des résidents quant aux caractéristiques clés d'une relation de coaching efficace entre le clinicien enseignant et le résident. Méthodes: Nous avons organisé quatre groupes de discussion et huit entretiens avec des résidents d'un centre universitaire canadien. Suivant une approche socioconstructiviste, les groupes de discussion et les entrevues ont été enregistrés, les verbatims ont été transcrits et ensuite analysés de façon thématique. Résultats: Les résidents ont décrit trois caractéristiques principales de la relation de coaching pouvant contribuer à son efficacité : elle doit être sécuritaire, significative et collaborative. Ils ont insisté sur le fait que pour atteindre une efficacité optimale des interactions de coaching, ces caractéristiques devaient être bidirectionnelles, à savoir présentes tant chez le résident que le clinicien enseignant. Conclusions: D'après les résidents, si l'efficacité de la relation de coaching est déterminée par les comportements des cliniciens enseignants, elle dépend surtout de la qualité des rapports interpersonnels cultivés. Il est donc impératif de tenir compte de la nature bidirectionnelle de la relation de coaching entre cliniciens enseignants et résidents lorsqu'on vise à améliorer le développement de ces derniers.
RESUMO
INTRODUCTION: Verbal feedback from trainees to supervisors is rare in medical education, although valuable for improvement in teaching skills. Research has mostly examined narrative comments on resident evaluations of their supervisors. This study aimed to explore supervisors' and residents' beliefs and experiences with upward feedback, along with recommendations to initiate and facilitate effective conversations. METHODS: Using 60-minute focus group discussions, a previous study explored opinions of internal medicine residents and clinical supervisors at the Brigham and Women's Hospital regarding the impact of institutional culture on feedback conversations. For this study, we conducted a thematic analysis of the transcribed, anonymous data to identify key concepts pertaining only to verbal upward feedback, through the theoretical lens of Positioning theory. RESULTS: Twenty-two supervisors and 29 residents participated in three and five focus groups, respectively. Identified themes were mapped to three research questions regarding (1) existing beliefs (lack of impact, risks to giving supervisors feedback, need for preparation and reflection), (2) experiences (nonspecific language, avoidance of upward feedback, bypassing the supervisor), and (3) recommended approaches (setting clear expectations, seeking specific feedback, emphasizing interest in growth). DISCUSSION: Study participants appeared to assume learner-teacher positions during feedback conversations, resulting in residents' concerns of adverse consequences, beliefs that supervisors will neither accept feedback nor change their behaviors, and avoidance of constructive upward feedback. Residents suggested that emphasis on mutual professional growth and regular feedback seeking by supervisors could encourage them to take on the role of feedback providers. Their recommendations could be a valuable starting point for faculty development initiatives on upward feedback.
Assuntos
Internato e Residência , Feminino , Humanos , Retroalimentação , Pesquisa Qualitativa , Feedback Formativo , Grupos Focais , Competência ClínicaRESUMO
Loss of upper extremity function following spinal cord injury (SCI) can have devastating consequences on quality of life. Peripheral nerve transfer surgery aims to restore motor control of upper extremities following cervical SCI and is poised to revolutionize surgical management in this population. The surgery involves dividing an expendable donor nerve above the level of the spinal lesion and coapting it to a recipient nerve arising from the lesional or infralesional segment of the injured cord. In order to maximize outcomes in this complex patient population, refinements in surgical technique need to be integrated with principles of spinal cord medicine and basic science. Deciding on the ideal timing of nerve transfer surgery is one aspect of care that is critical to maximizing recovery and has received very little attention to date in the literature. This complex topic is reviewed, with a focus on expectations for spontaneous recovery within upper motor neuron components of the injury, balanced against the need for expeditious re-innervation for lower motor neuron elements of the injury. The discussion also considers the case of a patient with C6 motor complete SCI in whom myotomes without electrodiagnostic evidence of denervation spontaneously improved by 6 months post-injury, thereby adjusting the surgical plan. The relevant concepts are integrated into a clinical algorithm with recommendations that consider maximal opportunity for spontaneous clinical improvement post-injury while avoiding excessive delays that may adversely affect patient outcomes.
Assuntos
Medula Cervical/lesões , Transferência de Nervo , Traumatismos da Medula Espinal/cirurgia , Tempo para o Tratamento , Humanos , Masculino , Recuperação de Função Fisiológica , Adulto JovemRESUMO
Critical illness-associated weakness (CIAW) is an umbrella term used to describe a group of neuromuscular disorders caused by severe illness. It can be subdivided into three major classifications based on the component of the neuromuscular system (i.e. peripheral nerves or skeletal muscle or both) that are affected. This includes critical illness polyneuropathy (CIP), critical illness myopathy (CIM), and an overlap syndrome, critical illness polyneuromyopathy (CIPNM). It is a common complication observed in people with critical illness requiring intensive care unit (ICU) admission. Given CIAW is found in individuals experiencing grave illness, it can be challenging to study from a practical standpoint. However, over the past 2 decades, many insights into the pathophysiology of this condition have been made. Results from studies in both humans and animal models have found that a profound systemic inflammatory response and factors related to bioenergetic failure as well as microvascular, metabolic, and electrophysiological alterations underlie the development of CIAW. Current management strategies focus on early mobilization, achieving euglycemia, and nutritional optimization. Other interventions lack sufficient evidence, mainly due to a dearth of large trials. The goal of this Physiology in Medicine article is to highlight important aspects of the pathophysiology of these enigmatic conditions. It is hoped that improved understanding of the mechanisms underlying these disorders will lead to further study and new investigations for novel pharmacologic, nutritional, and exercise-based interventions to optimize patient outcomes.
Assuntos
Doenças Musculares , Doenças Neuromusculares , Polineuropatias , Cuidados Críticos , Estado Terminal , Humanos , Unidades de Terapia Intensiva , Doenças Musculares/terapia , Polineuropatias/terapiaRESUMO
Background Post-traumatic seizure (PTS) is a major complication of traumatic brain injury (TBI). However, there has been controversy in the literature regarding whether anticonvulsants should be used prophylactically to prevent it, and there is significant variability in practice. The objective of this study is to describe seizure prophylaxis practices after moderate to severe TBI and to determine whether the use of seizure prophylaxis increased following the recommendations of the Quebec Institut National d'Excellence en Santé et Services Sociaux and the Ontario Neurotrauma Foundation (INESSS-ONF) guidelines. This study will also compare the characteristics of patients who receive the recommended prophylaxis and those who do not. Methods All adult patients admitted to a level-1 trauma centre for moderate to severe TBI were eligible for this study (n = 96). Medical records including patient age, sex, Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score, mechanism of injury, and occurrence of PTS were reviewed in a retrospective manner regarding the administration of recommended seizure prophylaxis. Results The proportion of patients receiving the recommended seizure prophylaxis was 8%. There was no significant increase after the release of the INESSS-ONF guidelines (p: 0.38). There were no significant differences in demographics, injury characteristics, or rates of early PTS between patients receiving the recommended prophylaxis and those not receiving it (p: >0.05). Conclusion The results indicate that the use of the recommended seizure prophylaxis after moderate to severe TBI is low and that the release of the INESSS-ONF guidelines did not increase its use. Patient and injury factors do not appear to influence the use of seizure prophylaxis. These results highlight variability in seizure prophylaxis practices and the importance of understanding local practice patterns. Implementation strategies should be identified to increase adherence to the recommendations and improve patient care.
RESUMO
BACKGROUND: The R2C2, a 4-phase feedback and coaching model, builds relationships, explores reactions, determines content and coaches for change, and facilitates formal feedback conversations between clinical supervisors/preceptors and residents. Formal discussions about performance are typically based on collated information from daily encounter sheets, objective structured clinical examinations, multisource feedback, and other data. This model has not been studied in settings where brief feedback and coaching conversations occur immediately after a specific clinical experience. OBJECTIVE: We explored how supervisors adapt the R2C2 model for in-the-moment feedback and coaching and developed a guide for its use in this context. METHODS: Eleven purposefully selected supervisors were interviewed in 2018 to explore where they used the R2C2 model, how they adapted it for in-the-moment conversations, and phrases used corresponding to each phase that could guide design of a new R2C2 in-the-moment model. RESULTS: Participants readily adapted the model to varied feedback situations; each of the 4 phases were relevant for conversations. Phase-specific phrases that could enable effective coaching conversations in a limited amount of time were identified. Data facilitated a revision of the original R2C2 model for in-the-moment feedback and coaching conversations and design of an accompanying trifold brochure to enable its effective use. CONCLUSIONS: The R2C2 in-the-moment model offers a systematic approach to feedback and coaching that builds on the original model, yet addresses time constraints and the need for an iterative conversation between the reaction and content phases. The model enables supervisors to coach and co-create an action plan with residents to improve performance.