Criteria for ECG detection of acute myocardial ischemia: Sensitivity versus specificity.

BACKGROUND: Criteria for electrocardiographic detection of acute myocardial ischemia recommended by the Consensus Document of ESC/ACCF/AHA/WHF consist of two parts: The ST elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) criteria based on ST elevation (ST↑) in 10 pairs of contiguous leads and the other on ST depression (ST↓) in the same 10 contiguous pairs. Our aim was to assess sensitivity (SE) and specificity (SP) of these criteria-and to seek their possible improvements-in three databases of 12­lead ECGs. METHODS: We used (1) STAFF III data of controlled ischemic episodes recorded from 99 patients (pts) during percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) involving either left anterior descending (LAD) coronary artery, right coronary artery (RCA), or left circumflex (LCx) coronary artery. (2) Data from the University of Glasgow for 58 pts with acute myocardial infarction (AMI) and 58 pts without AMI, as confirmed by MRI. (3) Data from Lund University retrieved from a centralized ECG management system for 100 pts with various pathological ST changes-other than acute coronary occlusion-including ventricular pre-excitation, acute pericarditis, early repolarization syndrome, left ventricular hypertrophy, and left bundle branch block. ST measurements at J-point in ECGs of all 315 pts were obtained automatically on the averaged beat with manual review and the recommended criteria as well as their proposed modifications, were applied. Performance measures included SE, SP, positive predictive value (PPV), and benefit-to-harm ratio (BHR), defined as the ratio of true-positive vs. false-positive detections. RESULTS: We found that the SE of widely-used STEMI criteria can be indeed improved by the additional ST↓ criteria, but at the cost of markedly decreased SP. In contrast, using ST↑ in only 3 additional contiguous pairs of leads (STEMI13) can boost SE without any loss of SP. In the STAFF III database, SE/SP/PPV were 56/98/97% for the STEMI, 79/79/79% for the STEMI with added ST↓ and 67/97/96% for the STEMI13. In the Glasgow database, corresponding SE/SP/PPV were 43/98/96%, 84/90/89%, and 55/98/97%. For the Lund database, SP was 56% for the STEMI, 24% for the STEMI with ST↓, and 56% for the STEMI13. CONCLUSION: Current recommended criteria for detecting acute myocardial ischemia, involving ST↓, boost SE of widely-used STEMI criteria, at the cost of SP. To keep the SP high, we propose either the adjustment of threshold for the added ST↓ criteria or a selective use of ST↓ only in contiguous leads V2 and V3 plus ST↑ in lead pairs (aVL, -III) and (III, -aVL).

The Olson method for detection of acute myocardial ischemia in patients with coronary occlusion.

An automated ECG-based method may provide diagnostic support in the management of patients with acute coronary syndrome. The Olson method has previously proved to accurately identify the culprit artery in patients with acute coronary occlusion. METHODS: The Olson method was applied to 360 patients without acute myocardial ischemia and 52 patients with acute coronary occlusion. RESULTS: This study establishes the normal variation of the Olson wall scores in patients without acute myocardial ischemia, which provides the basis for implementation of the Olson method for triage of patients with acute coronary syndrome. All patients with acute occlusion had Olson wall scores above the upper limit of normal. CONCLUSION: The Olson method can be used for ischemia detection with very high sensitivity. Future studies are needed to explore specificity in patients with non-ischemic ST elevation.

Validation of the vessel-specific leads (VSLs) for detection of acute ischemia on a dataset with non-ischemic ST-segment deviation.

BACKGROUND: Existing criteria recommended by ACC/ESC for identifying patients with ST elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) from the 12-lead ECG perform with high specificity (SP) but low sensitivity (SE). In our previous studies, we found that the SE of acute ischemia detection can be markedly improved without any loss of SP by calculating, from the 12-lead ECG, ST deviation in 3 "optimal" vessel-specific leads (VSLs). To further validate the method, we evaluated the SP performance using a dataset with non-ischemic ST-segment changes. METHODS: 12-lead ECGs of 100 patients (75 males/25 females, age range 12-83years, average age 52years) were retrieved from a centralized ECG management system at Skåne University Hospital, Lund, Sweden. These ECGs were chosen to represent five subgroups with various causes of pathological ST deviation, other than acute coronary occlusion: a) ventricular preexcitation (n=12), b) acute pericarditis (n=26), c) early repolarization syndrome (ERS) (n=14), d) left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) with "strain" (n=26), and e) left bundle branch block (LBBB) (n=22). ECGs with inadequate signal quality, heart rate exceeding 120bpm and/or atrial flutter were not selected for this study population. Both STEMI criteria and VSLs criteria with and without a new augmented LVH-specific derived lead were tested. SP, calculated for each subgroup and combined, was used as the performance measure for comparison. RESULTS: SP test results for the STEMI criteria vs. the VSLs method without the augmented LVH lead were 100% vs. 92%, 4% vs. 88%, 29% vs. 100%, 100% vs. 77%, and 64% vs. 68% for the five subgroups with preexcitation, pericarditis, ERS, LVH, and LBBB, respectively. For the whole group, SP was 57% for the STEMI criteria and 83% for the VSLs criteria; this improvement was statistically significant (p<0.001). With the augmented LVH lead, SP for the VSLs improved from 77% to 96% for the LVH subgroup and SP for the other subgroups remained unchanged. For the whole study group, SP improved from 83% to 88%. CONCLUSION: Based on these results, we conclude that the VSLs criteria are not only more sensitive in detecting acute ischemia but also more specific in recognizing patients with non-ischemic ST deviation than the existing STEMI criteria. This finding needs to be further corroborated on a larger patient population with AMI prevalence typical of the population presenting to the emergency room.

Validation of improved vessel-specific leads (VSLs) for detecting acute myocardial ischemia.

BACKGROUND: Existing criteria recommended by ACC/ESC for identifying patients with ST elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) from the 12-lead ECG perform with high specificity (SP), but low sensitivity (SE). In our previous studies, we found that the SE of ischemia detection can be markedly improved without any loss of SP by calculating, from the 12-lead ECG, ST deviation in 3 "optimal" vessel-specific leads (VSLs). Our original VSLs, based on ΔST body-surface potential maps (BSPMs), have been modified by using the more appropriate J-point BSPMs at peak ischemia (without subtraction of pre-occlusion distributions). The aim of the present study was to compare the performance of these new VSLs with that achieved by the STEMI criteria used in current practice. METHODS: Two independent datasets of 12-lead ECGs were used: the STAFF III dataset acquired during ischemic episodes caused by balloon inflation in LAD (n=35), RCA (n=47), and LCx (n=17) coronary arteries, and the Glasgow dataset comprising admission 12-lead ECGs of 116 patients who were hospitalized for chest pain and underwent contrast-enhanced cardiac MRI that confirmed AMI in 58 patients (50%). RESULTS: We found that, in the STAFF III dataset, the detection of ischemic state by the STEMI criteria attained SE/SP of 60/97%, whereas SE/SP values of VSLs were 72/98%. In the Glasgow dataset, STEMI criteria yielded SE/SP of 43/98%, whereas the VSLs improved SE/SP to 60/98%. The most significant increase in diagnostic performance appeared in patients with LCx coronary artery occlusion: in STAFF III data (n=17) SE achieved by STEMI criteria was improved by the VSLs from 35% to 71%; in Glasgow data (n=12) SE of 31% achieved by STEMI criteria was improved by the VSLs to 69%. CONCLUSION: In our study population, existing ACC/ESC STEMI criteria complemented by the new VSLs yielded much improved sensitivity of ischemia detection without any detrimental effect on specificity. This finding needs to be corroborated on a larger chest-pain patient population with typical prevalence of acute ischemia presented to the emergency rooms.