Biomechanical Study of Minimally Invasive Nonfusion Surgery for Treatment of Disc Herniation Associated with Adjacent Segment Disease: A Finite Element Analysis.

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVE: We explored the biomechanical changes of 2 conventional minimally invasive nonfusion surgical methods for treating disc herniation in adjacent segment disease using 3-dimensional finite element analysis. METHODS: A model comprising L3 to the sacrum was validated and used to establish an L4-L5 fusion model, and an adjacent segment disease (ASD) model was developed by modifying the material properties of the intervertebral discs. The ASD model was used to simulate 2 conventional minimally invasive nonfusion surgical methods, which resulted in the creation of 2 postoperative models (M1 and M2). The range of motion and the equivalent stress for each model were recorded under 6 different working conditions. The data are descriptive and were analyzed comparatively under a normal load. RESULTS: Compared with the ASD group, the range of motion of the adjacent segment in the M1 and M2 groups remained unaffected. However, significant Von-Mises stress changes were found in the annulus fibrosus and nucleus pulposus (NP), especially during extension, ipsilateral bending, and rotation. Stress in the NP also shifted toward the surgical incision in the annulus fibrosus during these movements. The maximum Von-Mises stress in the NP of the cephalic segment increased more than did that of the caudal segment. CONCLUSIONS: Minimal nonfusion surgery for ASD might not affect adjacent segment stability significantly. Nonetheless, it can lead to segmental degeneration deterioration and postoperative recurrence. The cephalic segment is affected more than the caudal segment. Therefore, consideration of disc degeneration and appropriate selection of surgical methods for ASD are crucial.