Cancer genetics: from Boveri and Mendel to microarrays.

The human genome has now been sequenced, a century after the re-discovery of Mendel's Laws, and the publication of Theodor Boveri's chromosomal theory of heredity. Tracing the historical landmarks of cancer genetics from these early days to the present time not only gives us an appreciation of how far we have come, but also emphasizes the challenges that we face if we are to unravel the genetic basis of hereditary and sporadic cancers in the next century.

p53-deficient mice are extremely susceptible to radiation-induced tumorigenesis.

Mice constitutively lacking alleles of the p53 tumour suppressor gene spontaneously develop lymphomas and sarcomas. We report here that a single dose of 4 Gy radiation dramatically decreases the latency for tumour development in p53 heterozygous mice. The pattern of genetic alterations at the remaining wild type allele in these tumours differs substantially from spontaneous tumours from similar mice indicating that p53 itself may have been a target for radiation-induced alterations. Lower dose irradiation (1 Gy) of preweanling p53 null mice also significantly decreases tumour latency, suggesting that there are additional genetic targets involved in radiation-induced malignancy. Thus p53-deficient mice provide a sensitive model system for studies of the consequences of radiation exposure.

TGF-beta signaling in tumor suppression and cancer progression.

Epithelial and hematopoietic cells have a high turnover and their progenitor cells divide continuously, making them prime targets for genetic and epigenetic changes that lead to cell transformation and tumorigenesis. The consequent changes in cell behavior and responsiveness result not only from genetic alterations such as activation of oncogenes or inactivation of tumor suppressor genes, but also from altered production of, or responsiveness to, stimulatory or inhibitory growth and differentiation factors. Among these, transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) and its signaling effectors act as key determinants of carcinoma cell behavior. The autocrine and paracrine effects of TGF-beta on tumor cells and the tumor micro-environment exert both positive and negative influences on cancer development. Accordingly, the TGF-beta signaling pathway has been considered as both a tumor suppressor pathway and a promoter of tumor progression and invasion. Here we evaluate the role of TGF-beta in tumor development and attempt to reconcile the positive and negative effects of TGF-beta in carcinogenesis.

Distinct genetic loci control development of benign and malignant skin tumours in mice.

Genetic susceptibility to chemically induced skin cancer in mice is controlled by multiple unlinked genetic loci. Mus spretus mice have dominant resistance genes which confer resistance to interspecific F1 hybrids with susceptible Mus musculus strains. We have mapped three major resistance loci using a combination of Mapmaker/QTL analysis and multiple regression analysis to mouse chromosomes 5 and 7. At least two independent loci on chromosome 7 exert their effects primarily during benign tumour development and have very little influence on tumour progression. On the other hand, probably a single locus on chromosome 5 affects both early and late stages of malignancy. The results indicate that benign and malignant tumours are largely under independent genetic control.

Genetic polymorphism in Methylenetetrahydrofolate Reductase chloride transport protein 6 (MTHFR CLCN6) gene is associated with keratinocyte skin cancer in a cohort of renal transplant recipients.

Background: Renal transplant recipients (RTRs) are at increased risk of keratinocyte cancer (KC), especially cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma (cSCC). Previous studies identified a genetic variant of the Methylenetetrahydrofolate Reductase (MTHFR) gene, C677T, which conferred a risk for diagnosis of cSCC in Irish RTRs. Objective: We sought to find further genetic variation in MTHFR and overlap genes that may be associated with a diagnosis of KC in RTRs. Methods: Genotyping of a combined RTR population (n = 821) from two centres, Ireland (n = 546) and the USA (n = 275), was performed. This included 290 RTRs with KC and 444 without. Eleven single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the MTHFR gene and seven in the overlap gene MTHFR Chloride transport protein 6 (CLCN6) were evaluated and association explored by time to event analysis (from transplant to first KC) using Cox proportional hazards model. Results: Polymorphism at MTHFR CLCN6 (rs9651118) was significantly associated with KC in RTRs (HR 1.50, 95% CI 1.17-1.91, p < 0.00061) and cSCC (HR 1.63, 95% CI 1.14-2.34, p = 0.007). A separate SNP, MTHFR C677T, was also significantly associated with KC in the Irish population (HR 1.31, 95% CI 1.05-1.63, p = 0.016), but not American RTRs. Conclusions: We report the association of a SNP in the MTHFR overlap gene, CLCN6 and KC in a combined RTR population. While the exact function of CLCN6 is not known, it is proposed to be involved in folate availability. Future applications could include incorporation in a polygenic risk score for KC in RTRs to help identify those at increased risk beyond traditional risk factor assessment.

Building 'validated' mouse models of human cancer.

As a model system for the understanding of human cancer, the mouse has proved immensely valuable. Indeed, studies of mouse models have helped to define the nature of cancer as a genetic disease and demonstrated the causal role of genetic events found in tumors. As the scientific and medical community's understanding of human cancer becomes more sophisticated, however, limitations and potential weaknesses of existing models are revealed. How valid are these murine models for the understanding and treatment of human cancer? The answer, it appears, depends on the nature of the research requirement. Certain models are better suited for particular applications. Using novel molecular tools and genetic strategies, improved models have recently been described that accurately mimic many aspects of human cancer.

Guidelines for the welfare and use of animals in cancer research.

Animal experiments remain essential to understand the fundamental mechanisms underpinning malignancy and to discover improved methods to prevent, diagnose and treat cancer. Excellent standards of animal care are fully consistent with the conduct of high quality cancer research. Here we provide updated guidelines on the welfare and use of animals in cancer research. All experiments should incorporate the 3Rs: replacement, reduction and refinement. Focusing on animal welfare, we present recommendations on all aspects of cancer research, including: study design, statistics and pilot studies; choice of tumour models (e.g., genetically engineered, orthotopic and metastatic); therapy (including drugs and radiation); imaging (covering techniques, anaesthesia and restraint); humane endpoints (including tumour burden and site); and publication of best practice.

The conversion of mouse skin squamous cell carcinomas to spindle cell carcinomas is a recessive event.

Squamous carcinomas of both human and rodent origin can undergo a transition to a more invasive, metastatic phenotype involving reorganization of the cytoskeleton, loss of cell adhesion molecules such as E-cadherin and acquisition of a fibroblastoid or spindle cell morphology. We have developed a series of cell lines from mouse skin tumors which represent different stages of carcinogenesis, including benign papillomas, and clonally related squamous and spindle carcinomas derived from the same primary tumor. Some spindle cells continue to express keratins, but with a poorly organized keratin filament network, whereas in others no keratin expression is detectable. All of the spindle cells lack expression of the cell adhesion molecule E-cadherin and the desmosomal component desmoplakin. Loss of these cell surface proteins therefore appears to precede the destabilization of the keratin network. At the genetic level, it is not known whether such changes involve activation of dominantly acting oncogenes or loss of a suppressor function which controls epithelial differentiation. To examine this question, we have carried out a series of fusion experiments between a highly malignant mouse skin spindle cell carcinoma and cell lines derived from premalignant or malignant mouse skin tumors, including both squamous and spindle carcinoma variants. The results show that the spindle cell phenotype as determined by cell morphology and lack of expression of keratin, E-cadherin, and desmoplakin proteins, is recessive in all hybrids with squamous cells. The hybrids expressed all of these differentiation markers, and showed suppression of tumorigenicity to a variable level dependent upon the tumorigenic properties of the less malignant fusion partner. Our results suggest that acquisition of the spindle cell phenotype involves functional loss of a gene(s) which controls epithelial differentiation.

α-PD-1 therapy elevates Treg/Th balance and increases tumor cell pSmad3 that are both targeted by α-TGFß antibody to promote durable rejection and immunity in squamous cell carcinomas.

BACKGROUND: Checkpoint blockade immunotherapy has improved metastatic cancer patient survival, but response rates remain low. There is an unmet need to identify mechanisms and tools to circumvent resistance. In human patients, responses to checkpoint blockade therapy correlate with tumor mutation load, and intrinsic resistance associates with pre-treatment signatures of epithelial mesenchymal transition (EMT), immunosuppression, macrophage chemotaxis and TGFß signaling. METHODS: To facilitate studies on mechanisms of squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) evasion of checkpoint blockade immunotherapy, we sought to develop a novel panel of murine syngeneic SCC lines reflecting the heterogeneity of human cancer and its responses to immunotherapy. We characterized six Kras-driven cutaneous SCC lines with a range of mutation loads. Following implantation into syngeneic FVB mice, we examined multiple tumor responses to α-PD-1, α-TGFß or combinatorial therapy, including tumor growth rate and regression, tumor immune cell composition, acquired tumor immunity, and the role of cytotoxic T cells and Tregs in immunotherapy responses. RESULTS: We show that α-PD-1 therapy is ineffective in establishing complete regression (CR) of tumors in all six SCC lines, but causes partial tumor growth inhibition of two lines with the highest mutations loads, CCK168 and CCK169. α-TGFß monotherapy results in 20% CR and 10% CR of established CCK168 and CCK169 tumors respectively, together with acquisition of long-term anti-tumor immunity. α-PD-1 synergizes with α-TGFß, increasing CR rates to 60% (CCK168) and 20% (CCK169). α-PD-1 therapy enhances CD4 + Treg/CD4 + Th ratios and increases tumor cell pSmad3 expression in CCK168 SCCs, whereas α-TGFß antibody administration attenuates these effects. We show that α-TGFß acts in part through suppressing immunosuppressive Tregs induced by α-PD-1, that limit the anti-tumor activity of α-PD-1 monotherapy. Additionally, in vitro and in vivo, α-TGFß acts directly on the tumor cell to attenuate EMT, to activate a program of gene expression that stimulates immuno-surveillance, including up regulation of genes encoding the tumor cell antigen presentation machinery. CONCLUSIONS: We show that α-PD-1 not only initiates a tumor rejection program, but can induce a competing TGFß-driven immuno-suppressive program. We identify new opportunities for α-PD-1/α-TGFß combinatorial treatment of SCCs especially those with a high mutation load, high CD4+ T cell content and pSmad3 signaling. Our data form the basis for clinical trial of α-TGFß/α-PD-1 combination therapy (NCT02947165).

Convergence of congenic mapping and allele-specific alterations in tumors for the resolution of the Skts1 skin tumor susceptibility locus.

Although several familial cancer genes with high-penetrance mutations have been identified, the major genetic component of susceptibility to sporadic cancers is attributable to low-penetrance alleles. These 'weak' tumor susceptibility genes do not segregate as single Mendelian traits and are therefore difficult to find in studies of human populations. Previously, we have proposed that a combination of germline mapping and analysis of allele-specific imbalance in tumors may be used to refine the locations of susceptibility genes using mouse models of cancer. Here, we have used linkage analysis and congenic mouse strains to map the major skin tumor susceptibility locus Skts1 within a genetic interval of 0.9 cM on proximal chromosome 7. This interval lies in an apparent recombination cold spot, and corresponds to a physical distance of about 15 Mb. We therefore, used patterns of allele-specific imbalances in tumors from backcross and congenic mice to refine the location of Skts1. We demonstrate that this single tumor modifier locus has a dramatic effect on the allelic preference for imbalance on chromosome 7, with at least 90% of tumors from the congenics showing preferential gain of markers on the chromosome carrying the susceptibility variant. Importantly, these alterations enabled us to refine the location of Skts1 at higher resolution than that attained using the congenic mice. We conclude that low-penetrance susceptibility genes can have strong effects on patterns of allele-specific somatic genetic changes in tumors, and that analysis of the directionality of these somatic events provides an important and rapid route to identification of germline genetic variants that confer increased cancer risk.

Integration of positive and negative growth signals during ras pathway activation in vivo.

Expression of RAS proteins can have either positive or negative effects on cell growth, differentiation and death. New technologies are being developed for the generation of animal models to address the questions of where, when and how much Ras is expressed during tumorigenesis, and how these disparate signals are integrated during multistage carcinogenesis.

Cancer. Exploring the bowels of DNA methylation.

Recent studies of mice lacking methyltransferase, and of genes that modify cancer susceptibility, have shed light on the long-standing problem of how DNA methylation affects carcinogenesis.

The malignant capacity of skin tumours induced by expression of a mutant H-ras transgene depends on the cell type targeted.

BACKGROUND: . Pinpointing the cells from which tumours arise is a major challenge n tumour biology. Previous work has shown that the targeted expression of a mutant ras gene within the interfollicular cell compartment of mouse skin induces the formation of benign papillomas, but these do not spontaneously progress to malignancy. We have investigated the carcinogenic effects of expressing the same oncogene in a different population of epidermal cells. RESULTS: Expression of mutant ras from a truncated keratin 5 gene promoter, which directs expression to the follicular and interfollicular cells of newborn mice and the hair follicle cells of adults, stimulated the development of acanthotic areas in newborn mice. Within one week of birth, the acanthotic skin developed areas of carcinoma in situ and adult mice developed papillomas and keratoacanthomas, the latter having a high frequency of spontaneous malignant transformation to squamous and occasionally spindle carcinomas. The benign tumours that arose had several hallmarks of tumours at a high risk of malignant progression, including suprabasal cell proliferation and heterogeneous expression of keratin 13. In contrast to tumours induced by expressing mutant ras under the control of the keratin 10 or keratin 1 gene promoters, the formation of these lesions was not dependent on wounding or a tumour promoter. CONCLUSIONS: Benign tumours that are at a risk of malignant conversion are primarily derived from cells located within the hair follicle, and the nature of the cell in which tumour initiation occurs is a major determinant of malignant potential.

Cancer resistance genes in mice: models for the study of tumour modifiers.

Smokers have frequently been heard to defend their habit by recounting anecdotes about relatives or friends who have smoked heavily for many years without developing cancer. While individuals who have survived many years of repeated mutagen exposure are probably very rare, their existence suggests that some people are intrinsically resistant to the effects of carcinogens, probably because of their genetic background. This interpretation is supported by studies on mouse strains that are highly resistant to the development of tumours induced by treatment with exogenous carcinogens. In this review we discuss the advantages of the mouse as a model system for the isolation of cancer-resistance genes that have potentially important uses in diagnostics, prevention and tumour therapy.

Histone phosphorylation and synthesis of DNA and RNA during phases of proliferation and differentiation induced in mouse epidermis by the tumor promoter 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate.

The tumor promoter 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate (TPA) induces discrete waves of proliferation and differentiation when applied to mouse epidermis. The aim of this study was to elucidate the temporal relationship between histone phosphorylation and synthesis of DNA and RNA in mouse epidermis during the process of tumor promotion. This investigation as facilitated by choosing a low but nevertheless strongly tumor-promoting dose of TPA (0.002 micronmole/mouse), which induced the epidermal cells to go through only one round of DNA synthesis and cell division. Histones were isolated from mouse epidermis, and the rates of phosphorylation of the individual histone species were determined at different times after treatment with TPA. The results demonstrated that the phosphorylation of H1 histone was initiated at about the same time as the synthesis of DNA but continued past the S phase and reached a maximum simultaneously with the maximum in the epidermal mitotic rate. The only other histone that phosphorylated to any significant extent was Histone H2A. From the results obtained, it was concluded that histone phosphorylation in the epidermis is related to the processes of DNA replication and mitosis after stimulation with TPA. Positive evidence for the activation of specific genes, which has been proposed by other authors to be important in the promotion of epidermal tumors, was not found in this investigation.

Allelotype analysis of mouse skin tumors using polymorphic microsatellites: sequential genetic alterations on chromosomes 6, 7, and 11.

Allelotype analysis of human tumors has been instrumental in the effort to discover and clone novel tumor suppressor genes. However, this approach has not been systematically applied to animal models of carcinogenesis. We describe here the first attempt to allelotype a nonhuman tumor, i.e., chemically induced mouse skin tumors, using a panel of polymorphic microsatellite markers. The results indicated that markers on chromosomes 6 and 7 were imbalanced, consistent with trisomy in both benign and malignant skin tumors. A proportion of carcinomas also showed loss of heterozygosity on chromosome 11, where the p53 gene is located, and more rarely, on chromosomes 4, 6, and 15. The significance of these alterations is highlighted by the observations of no allelic imbalance for markers on 12 other chromosomes.

Lack of transforming growth factor-beta 1 expression in benign skin tumors of p53null mice is prognostic for a high risk of malignant conversion.

Expression of transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGF beta 1) protein was examined in chemically induced benign skin tumors with genetically defined empirical risks for malignant conversion. Benign tumors induced in mice which have both alleles of the p53 gene deleted have a malignant conversion frequency of approximately 50%, whereas similar tumors induced in wildtype and heterozygous p53 mice have conversion probabilities of 3 and 8%, respectively (Kemp et al., Cell, 74: 813-822, 1993). The TGF beta 1 antibody, anti-CC (1-30-1), was shown to stain either the proliferative keratinocyte compartment of the tumor or the tumor stroma, whereas another TGF beta 1 antibody, anti-LC (1-30-1), stained highly differentiated granular cells of the tumors. A strong correlation was found between staining of the proliferative keratinocyte compartment of tumors with the anti-CC (1-30-1) antibody and tumor genotype. Only 18% (6 of 32) of homozygous p53 null tumors showed any basal keratinocyte staining with this antibody, whereas over 80% (32 of 38) of heterozygous and wild-type tumors showed positive staining. Additionally, in most tumors examined, the spatial distribution of staining for the proliferating cell nuclear antigen appeared to be mutually exclusive with that of TGF beta 1 on adjacent serial sections. This suggests that, in these cases, tumor keratinocytes are sensitive to negative growth regulation by TGF beta. TGF beta 1 protein staining in benign tumors is thus prognostic for a low probability of malignant conversion, and its expression may be mechanistically involved in limiting malignant conversion since, at the benign tumor stage examined, keratinocytes are still sensitive to growth inhibition by TGF beta 1.

Progression of squamous carcinoma cells to spindle carcinomas of mouse skin is associated with an imbalance of H-ras alleles on chromosome 7.

Analysis of benign and malignant mouse skin tumors had previously shown that amplification of a mutant H-ras allele or loss of the normal allele was generally seen only in high grade or spindle cell tumors. The normal:mutant ras gene dosage has been studied directly by polymerase chain reaction amplification of DNA derived from paraffin sections of carcinomas of defined histological types. Some tumors had virtually no signal corresponding to the normal allele and these were invariably spindle cell carcinomas. In four cases where both squamous and spindle cell components could be identified within the same tumor the spindle cell component had a higher mutant:normal gene ratio. Additional experiments on cell lines derived from squamous or spindle cell tumors have demonstrated a good correlation between the ratio of normal:mutant ras and the degree of invasiveness of the cells in in vitro assays.

Spontaneous and ionizing radiation-induced chromosomal abnormalities in p53-deficient mice.

Chromosomal abnormalities have been assessed in p53-deficient mice. The in vivo frequency of spontaneous stable aberrations in bone marrow cells was elevated by approximately 20-fold in p53 nulls and 13-fold in p53 heterozygotes compared to wild-type. No excessive induction of stable aberrations by gamma-irradiation was observed, but p53 deficiency resulted in excess radiation-induced hyperploidy (> 10-fold wild-type frequency). No influence of p53 genotype on sister chromatid exchange or G2 chromatid damage was observed in mitogen-stimulated spleen cell cultures; however, a p53 effect on postirradiation mitotic entry was seen. Abnormalities in chromosome segregation and mitotic delay following irradiation in p53-deficient mice suggest a G2-M checkpoint role for p53 and are broadly consistent with data on tumorigenesis in these animals.

Epistatic interactions between skin tumor modifier loci in interspecific (spretus/musculus) backcross mice.

The development of cancer is influenced both by exposure to environmental carcinogens and by the host genetic background. Epistatic interactions between genes are important in determining phenotype in plant and animal systems and are likely to be major contributors to cancer susceptibility in humans. Several tumor modifier loci have been identified from studies of mouse models of human cancer, and genetic interactions between modifier loci have been detected by genome scanning using recombinant congenic strains of mice (R. Fijneman et al., Nat. Genet., 14: 465-467, 1996; T. van Wezel et al., Nat. Genet., 14: 468-470, 1996; W. N. Frankel et al., Nat. Genet., 14, 371-373, 1996). We demonstrate here that strong genetic interactions between skin tumor modifier loci can be detected by hierarchical whole genome scanning of a complete interspecific backcross [outbred Mus spretus X Mus musculus (NIH/Ola)]. A locus on chromosome 7 (Skts1) showed a highly significant interaction with Skts5 on chromosome 12 (P < 10(-16)), whereas additional significant interactions were detected between loci on chromosomes 4 and 5, and 16 and 15. Some of these quantitative trait loci and their interactions, in particular the Skts1-Skts5 interaction, were confirmed in two completely independent backcrosses using inbred spretus strains (SEG/Pas and SPRET/Ei) and NIH/Ola. These results, therefore, illustrate the general use of interspecific crosses between Mus musculus and Mus spretus for the detection of strong genetic interactions between tumor modifier genes.