Cost-effectiveness and budget impact of interferon-free direct-acting antiviral-based regimens for hepatitis C treatment: the French case.

We evaluated the cost-effectiveness and the budget impact of new DAA-based regimen use in France. A Markov model simulated chronic hepatitis C (CHC) treatment interventions with IFN-based and IFN-free regimens at stage of fibrosis ≥F3, ≥F2 or regardless of fibrosis stage, and treatment either with the least or the most expensive combination. It estimated quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs). It also assessed the budget impact over 5 years of treating all CHC-screened patients, regardless of fibrosis, assuming ≤20 000 patients treated/year and priority to ≥F3. Sensitivity analyses were also conducted. For genotypes (G) 1-4, the initiation of IFN-free regardless of fibrosis was a cost-effective strategy compared to prior standard of care (SOC) initiated at stage F2: €40 400-88 300/QALY gained in G1; similar results were obtained for patients infected with G4. Considering G2-3, the most cost-effective strategy was IFN-based regimens regardless of fibrosis compared to prior SOC initiated at stage F2: €21 300 and €19 400/QALY gained, respectively; the strategy with IFN-free regimens being more effective but not cost-effective at current costs. The budget impact of treating all CHC-screened patients over 5 years would range between 3.5 and 7.2 billion €, depending on whether one considers the least or the most expensive combination of new DAAs and whether one treats G2-3 with IFN-based or IFN-free new DAAs. In France, treatment initiation with new DDAs regardless of fibrosis stage is cost-effective, but would add 3.5-7.2 billion € to an already overburdened medical care system.

The impact of the prevention programme of hepatitis C over more than a decade: the French experience.

To assess the impact of the French national hepatitis C prevention programme initiated in 1999, we analysed trends in hepatitis C virus (HCV) prevalence, testing and characteristics of HCV-infected patient at first referral from 1994 to 2006. We used four data sources: Two national population-based sero-prevalence surveys carried out in 1994 and 2004; two surveillance networks, one based on public and private laboratories throughout France and the other on hepatology reference centres, which aim to monitor, respectively, trends of anti-HCV screening and of epidemiological-clinical characteristics of HCV patients at first referral. Between 1994 and 2004, the anti-HCV prevalence for adults aged 20-59 years decreased from 1.05 (95% confidence interval 0.75-1.34) to 0.71 (0.52-0.97). During the same period, those anti-HCV positive with detectable HCV RNA decreased from 81 to 57%, whereas, the proportion of anti-HCV positive persons aware of their status evolved from 24 to 56%. Anti-HCV screening activity increased by 45% from 2000 to 2005, but decreased in 2006 (-10%), while HCV positivity among those tested decreased from 4.3 to 2.9%. The proportion of cirrhosis at first referral remains around 10% between 2001 and 2006, with many patients with excessive alcohol consumption (34.7% among males) or viral co-infections (HIV seropositivity for 5.2% patients). Our analysis indicates that the national programme had a positive impact at the population level through improved prevention, screening and management. There is still a need to identify timely those at risk for earlier interventions, to assess co-morbidities better and for a multidisciplinary approach to HCV management.

Growth inhibitory properties of endothelin-1 in human hepatic myofibroblastic Ito cells. An endothelin B receptor-mediated pathway.

Ito cells play a pivotal role in the development of liver fibrosis associated with chronic liver diseases. During this process, Ito cells acquire myofibroblastic features, proliferate, and synthesize fibrosis components. Considering the reported mitogenic properties of endothelin-1 (ET-1), we investigated its effects on the proliferation of human Ito cells in their myofibroblastic phenotype. Both ET receptor A (ETA: 20%) and ET receptor B (ETB: 80%) binding sites were identified, using a selective ETA antagonist, BQ 123, and a selective ETB agonist, sarafotoxin S6C (SRTX-C). ET-1 did not stimulate proliferation of myofibroblastic Ito cells. In contrast, ET-1 inhibited by 60% DNA synthesis and proliferation of cells stimulated with either human serum or platelet-derived growth factor -BB (PDGF-BB). PD 142893, a nonselective ETA/ETB antagonist totally blunted this effect. SRTX-C was as potent as ET-1, while BQ 123 did not affect ET-1-induced growth inhibition. Analysis of the intermediate steps leading to growth-inhibition by ET-1 revealed that activation of mitogen-activated protein kinase by serum or PDGF-BB was decreased by 50% in the presence of SRTX-C. In serum-stimulated cells, SRTX-C reduced c-jun mRNA expression by 50% whereas c-fos or krox 24 mRNA expression were not affected. We conclude that ET-1 binding to ETB receptors causes a potent growth inhibition of human myofibroblastic Ito cells, which suggests that this peptide could play a key role in the negative control of liver fibrogenesis. Our results also point out that, in addition to its well known promitogenic effects, ET-1 may also exert negative control of growth on specific cells.

Growth inhibitory properties of endothelin-1 in activated human hepatic stellate cells: a cyclic adenosine monophosphate-mediated pathway. Inhibition of both extracellular signal-regulated kinase and c-Jun kinase and upregulation of endothelin B receptors.

During chronic liver diseases, hepatic stellate cells (HSC) acquire an activated myofibroblast-like phenotype, proliferate, and synthetize fibrosis components. We have shown that endothelin-1 (ET-1) inhibits the proliferation of activated human HSC via endothelin B (ETB) receptors. We now investigate the transduction pathway involved in the growth inhibitory effect of ET-1 in activated HSC. Endothelin-1 and the ETB receptor agonist, sarafotoxin-S6C, increased synthesis of PGI2 and PGE2, leading to elevation of cAMP. The cyclooxygenase inhibitor ibuprofen and the adenylyl cyclase inhibitor SQ22536 both blunted the growth inhibitory effect of ET-1. Analysis of early steps associated with growth inhibition indicated that: (a) similar to ET-1, forskolin decreased c-jun mRNA induction without affecting c-fos and krox 24 mRNA expression; (b) ET-1, sarafotoxin-S6C, as well as forskolin, reduced activation of both c-Jun kinase and extracellular signal-regulated kinase. Finally, forskolin, PGI2, and PGE2 raised by fivefold the number of ET binding sites after 6 h, and increased the proportion of ETB receptors from 50% in control cells to 80% in treated cells. In conclusion, ET-1 inhibits proliferation of activated HSC via ETB receptors, through a prostaglandin/cAMP pathway that leads to inhibition of both extracellular signal-regulated kinase and c-Jun kinase activities. Upregulation of ETB receptors by prostaglandin/cAMP raises the possibility of a positive feedback loop that would amplify the growth inhibitory response. These results suggest that ET-1 and agents that increase cAMP might be of interest to limit proliferation of activated HSC during chronic liver diseases.

Drug-induced vascular lesions of the liver.

The vascular lesions of the liver described in association with drug and toxic substance exposure are reviewed, with special reference to the abnormalities of the following: (1) the hepatic venous efferent system (ie, large and small hepatic vein obstruction); (2) the sinusoids (ie, sinusoidal dilatation, peliosis, perisinusoidal fibrosis); (3) the portal vein and its branches; and (4) the hepatic arterial tree. Drug-induced vascular tumors of the liver and vascular changes observed within nonvascular tumors of the liver are also envisaged. Finally, the pathophysiologic mechanisms of all these lesions are considered. The awareness of this type of hepatotoxicity and the knowledge of its epidemiology seem to be essential for both its early detection and prevention.

Hepatic vein obstruction in idiopathic hypereosinophilic syndrome.

We report an association between idiopathic hypereosinophilic syndrome and obstruction of the hepatic veins (Budd-Chiari syndrome). Budd-Chiari syndrome was assessed by liver biopsy and hepatic phlebography and documented by computed tomography. Postmortem examination revealed fibrous occlusion of the hepatic venous tree, as well as fibrosis of the endocardium and of myocardial and pulmonary vessels. To our knowledge, the association between idiopathic hypereosinophilic syndrome and Budd-Chiari syndrome has never previously been reported. Since it has been suggested that hypereosinophilia might cause endothelium damage, a link between these two entities is postulated.

Hepatitis B vaccination in diabetic patients. Randomized trial comparing recombinant vaccines containing and not containing pre-S2 antigen.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the immunogenicity of two recombinant hepatitis B vaccines containing S antigen alone (Engerix B) or both S and pre-S2 antigens (GenHevac B) in diabetic patients. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS: Of the adult diabetic patients, 71 (26 IDDM, 45 NIDDM) were randomized to receive Engerix B or GenHevac B at 0, 1, 2, and 12 months in a single-blind clinical trial; if the antibody to hepatitis B surface antigen (anti-HBs) titers were < 10 i.u./l at month 4, a fourth injection of vaccine was given. A positive response was defined by anti-HBs titer > or = 10 IU/l at month 13. RESULTS: The anti-HBs response rate and the titers of anti-HBs did not differ significantly between the two types of vaccine. Overall, > 90% of the patients responded at month 13. In patients vaccinated with GenHevac B, anti-pre-S2 antibodies appeared earlier than anti-HBs. The anti-HBs response tended to decrease with age (P = 0.07) and tended to be higher in IDDM patients than in NIDDM patients (P = 0.06). Metabolic control, as assessed by HbA1c level, did not influence the response rate. The presence of the HLA DQ2 allele was associated with a low response. CONCLUSIONS: A large majority of diabetic patients can be efficiently vaccinated against the hepatitis B virus using a booster dose at month 4. The choice of the vaccine (with or without pre-S2 antigen) appears to have little influence, if any, on the response rate.

Activity of the interferon-induced 2',5'-oligoadenylate synthetase in patients with chronic hepatitis C.

The interferon-induced 2',5'-oligoadenylate synthetase (2-5OAS) is responsible, at least in part, for the antiviral state established in cells in response to viral infections. The purpose of this work was to study the relationship between hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection and 2-5OAS in patients with chronic hepatitis C. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) of 27 patients with chronic hepatitis C were investigated, as well as PBMC of 10 control subjects. Then, the patients were treated with 3 mu interferon-alpha 2a three times per week. At month 3 of therapy, PBMC were sampled. Of the total PBMC samples obtained, half were used for determination of in vivo 2-5OAS activity. The remaining cells were cultured for 24 h in either the absence or presence of 500 U/ml of interferon-alpha 2a for the determination of in vitro 2-5OAS activity. The mean basal in vivo 2-5OAS activities were 3.6 +/- 2.8 nmol/10(6) cells in patients versus 1.6 +/- 1.1 nmol/10(6) cells in controls (p < 0.01). Basal in vivo 2-5OAS activity did not correlate with mean HCV viremia, quantified by a "branched DNA"-based assay. Before treatment, interferon-alpha was detected in the serum of 2 patients in 27. After a 24 h culture of PBMC in the presence of interferon, in vitro 2-5OAS activity was significantly induced in the PBMC of both the patients and the controls. However, in vitro induction of 2-5OAS activity was significantly lower in the PBMC of the patients than in the PBMC of the controls (p < 0.01). At month 3 therapy, in vivo 2-5OAS activity was significantly induced (20.5 +/- 17.9; p < 0.0001). In vitro IFN inductions of 2-5OAS activity in PBMC before treatment and at month 3 of therapy were not significantly different. In conclusion, in vivo 2-5OAS activity is significantly induced in patients with chronic hepatitis C, but endogenously produced interferon-alpha does not seem to be involved. Chronic induction of 2-5OAS activity results in a decreased sensitivity of PBMC to exogenous interferon induction. Whether this phenomenon plays a role in the resistance of chronic hepatitis C to interferon therapy remains uncertain.

Venocclusive disease of the liver after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation in man.

One hundred and fifty-one consecutive patients underwent allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (B.M.T.) following high-dose chemotherapy and single dose total body irradiation (T.B.I.) for hematologic malignancies between September 1980 and December 1985. All patients included in this study were treated using a 60 Co beam to deliver a prescribed dose of 10 Gy to the mid-plane of the abdomen. Total body irradiation was performed the day before B.M.T. The mean instantaneous dose-rate was 3.5 cGy/min (range: 2.6 to 4.7). The real dose received was measured using thermoluminescent dosimeters (lithium borate). The difference between the doses delivered to the liver and to the mid-plane of the abdomen did not exceed 5%. The mean real dose delivered to the reference point was 10 Gy (range 8.3 to 11.7). Ninety five per cent of the patients received a dose ranging from 9.1 Gy to 10.9 Gy. High-dose cyclophosphamide was given to 126 patients with a "standard-risk" of relapse (60 mg/kg on day 5 and 4 before B.M.T.). Chemotherapy was intensified by the addition of other drugs in 25 patients with "higher-risk" of relapse. We analyzed the effect of the following pretransplant characteristics on the subsequent posttransplant development of V.O.D.: age, sex, ASAT and/or ALAT before conditioning regimen, diagnosis and status of malignant disease, history of liver disease, interval between diagnosis of hematologic malignancy and B.M.T., conditioning regimen (i.e., classical or intensified) and dose delivered to the liver during T.B.I. Seventeen patients were classified as having clinical V.O.D. giving a prevalence of 11.2%. In the first 2 months following B.M.T., death occurred respectively in 9 of 17 (53%) and 23 of 134 (17%) patients with and without clinical V.O.D. Univariate analysis showed that four characteristics were significantly related to an increased prevalence of V.O.D.: sex (11/62 females vs 6/89 males; p less than 0.05); history of liver disease (7/28 vs 10/117 patients without antecedent; p less than 0.01); ASAT and/or ALAT levels greater than 1.5 upper normal limit (11/49 vs 6/102 patients with levels less than 1.5; p less than 0.01) and intensified conditioning regimen (6/25 vs 11/126 patients with classical regimen; p less than 0.05). The conditioning regimen and history of liver disease were highly correlated to transaminases levels. Only two factors, transaminases levels and female sex, remained significantly associated with V.O.D. after multivariate analysis.

Reuse of a liver graft five days after initial transplantation.

Brain death is a possible complication of orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT). In these cases, if the liver graft continues to function normally it could be resued for another recipient. To our knowledge this is the second reported case of liver graft reuse after brain death of the first recipient.

Orthotopic liver transplantation with preservation of the caval and portal flows. Technique and results in 62 cases.

Sixty-two OLTs in 61 patients were performed using a technical modification reported recently, including total hepatectomy with preservation of the inferior vena cava, partial clamping of the native vena cava, and side-to-side cavacaval anastomosis. We further modified the technique by adding the early construction of a temporary end-to-side portacaval shunt, and, more recently, by using an end-to-side caval reconstruction. With this technique, the caval and portal flows were maintained throughout the procedure. Hemodynamic parameters were analyzed prospectively during the operative period and remained stable at all stages of the procedure. Venous bypass was avoided in all cases without need for increased fluid infusion. Operative time and transfusion requirements were 6.8 +/- 1.6 hr and 9.8 +/- 4.3 U of packed RBC, respectively. There were no specific complications or deaths due to the technique used and hospital mortality was 10% (6/61). The technique used in this study is a safe adjunct to the technical armamentarium of clinical liver transplantation. Its main advantage seems to be hemodynamic stability throughout the procedure, obviating the need for venous bypass or fluid overload.

Serial quantitative determination of hepatitis C virus RNA levels after liver transplantation. A useful test for diagnosis of hepatitis C virus reinfection.

After liver transplantation for hepatitis C virus (HCV)-related cirrhosis, recurrent viral infection is almost constant, resulting in acute graft dysfunction in 30-75% of cases. Acute graft dysfunction in the post-transplant period may also be the result of various causes (such as rejection, CMV infection, sepsis, or technical problems). Therefore, the role of HCV reinfection is often difficult to document. The aim of this study was to assess the diagnostic value of serial HCV RNA quantitation in this setting. Fourteen patients transplanted with follow-up greater than 6 months were studied. HCV RNA was quantitated before and serially after transplantation, using branched DNA technology. In cases of acute graft dysfunction, usual investigations and additional HCV RNA quantitation were conducted. There were 15 episodes of acute graft dysfunction in 12 patients. Six episodes had a hepatitic biochemical pattern, and 5 of them were associated with a concomitant HCV RNA peak. Nine episodes had a mixed, hepatitic, and cholestatic biochemical pattern, and 5 of them were associated with a concomitant peak of HCV RNA. Overall, 10 of 15 (66%) episodes of acute graft dysfunction were associated with HCV RNA peak, which strongly suggests that HCV was the etiologic factor. In 9 of these 10 episodes, no other cause of dysfunction was found, and one had associated CMV disease. In 5 cases, no peak of HCV RNA was observed and the causes of dysfunction were CMV (in 2 cases) and rejection, granulomatosis, and unknown (in 1 case each). Serial quantitations of HCV RNA levels after liver transplantation for cirrhosis C provide a useful tool in the diagnosis of HCV reinfection of the graft.

Increased incidence of oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinomas after liver transplantation for alcoholic cirrhosis.

BACKGROUND: THE aim of this study was to describe the features of posttransplantation tumors observed in a series of liver transplant recipients with special reference to patients receiving a transplant for alcoholic cirrhosis. METHODS: Among 171 consecutive liver transplant recipients, 90 patients who had received a first liver allograft for cirrhosis were studied. After liver transplantation, detection of de novo malignancies was prospectively undertaken and the characteristics of the patients in whom tumors occurred were compared with those in whom tumors did not develop. RESULTS: With a follow-up of 45.2+/-21.2 months, 11 tumors were observed in 90 patients (overall incidence of 12.2%). The incidence of tumors was higher in patients receiving a transplant for alcoholic cirrhosis than in patients receiving a transplant for nonalcoholic cirrhosis (26.7% vs. 5.0%, P<0.01). Squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the oropharynx or esophagus and posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorders were mainly observed. SCC (uvula in two cases, tongue in one case, esophagus in one case, pharynx in one case) occurred exclusively in patients transplanted for alcoholic cirrhosis (16.7% vs. 0%, P=0.001). The incidence of posttransplant lymphoproliferative disorders was similar in alcoholics and nonalcoholics (6.7% vs. 5%, NS). Survival was not influenced by the occurrence of SCC. CONCLUSION: The incidence of oropharyngeal SCC could be high in patients receiving a transplant for alcoholic cirrhosis. This could be due to an additional effect of posttransplantation immunosuppression in patients exposed to alcohol and tobacco before transplant. Careful posttransplantation screening of oropharyngeal SCC is warranted after liver transplantation for alcoholic cirrhosis.

Inhibitor against coagulation factor V after liver transplantation.

A new case of anti-factor V inhibitor is described in a 46-year-old man, who received a liver transplantation for hepatocellular carcinoma, without exposure to bovine thrombin or fibrin glue during the operative course. The inhibition occurred on the 14th postoperative day, while the patient was being treated with oxacillin, azathioprine, and a new immunosuppressive drug, FK506. The inhibition was of short duration (3 days), and no bleeding complication occurred despite a very low plasmatic level of factor V activity and antigen (<5%). Plasma samples drawn after cessation of FK506 disclosed a dose-dependent inhibitory activity when alcoholic solutions of FK506 were exogeneously added; this suggests a possible role of the FK506 drug in the occurrence of this anti-factor V inhibitor.

The hot spot hepatobiliary scan in focal nodular hyperplasia.

A prospective study was performed on 14 patients with histologically proven focal nodular hyperplasia (FNH) using a hepatobiliary scan with trimethylbromoimino-diacetic acid (TBIDA) and a colloid scan with rhenium sulfur colloids. TBIDA uptake was relatively normal in the region of the tumor, but during the clearance phase 23/25 of the tumors were detected by a hot spot of radioactivity. Depending on the relative contrast achieved between the tumor and normal liver, this hot spot appeared early or later, but was always present at 60 min. In three tumors, a "doughnut" pattern was observed within the hot spot due to a central defect. Hypervascularization was observed during the perfusion phase in 76% of the tumoral sites and normal colloid uptake in only 64%. The detectability of FNH appears greater with TBIDA (92%) than with CT or MRI (84%). The high prevalence of hot spots may be due to careful technological conditions when obtaining hepatobiliary scans. Late images, overexposed films, multiple views and stimulation of gallbladder excretion increased tumor detectability. The hot spot sign may be a useful tool when combined with the results of other imaging modalities in the diagnosis of FNH. The peculiar pathology of FNH with fibrosis, hyperplastic hepatocytes and cholangiolar proliferation might explain this scintigraphic appearance.

Coagulation assays as diagnostic markers of hepatocellular carcinoma.

With the aim of improving the biological diagnosis of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), alpha-fetoprotein (AFP), des-gamma-carboxyprothrombin (DCP) and factor V levels were assayed in 119 patients with HCC and 60 cirrhotic patients without HCC. Among the patients with HCC, increased levels of AFP (greater than 300 ng/ml) and of DCP (greater than 15 mU/ml) were observed in 36% and 69% of the cases, respectively. None of the 60 patients without HCC had increased AFP, and one had abnormal DCP; in this patient, DCP level returned to normal value after vitamin K1 injection. No significant correlation was found between increased AFP and DCP, thus indicating that the two tests complement each other for the diagnosis. A factor V level higher than expected from the reduced prothrombin time test of the patient was detected in 50% of patients with HCC and only 7% of those without HCC. No correlation was found between increased factor V and abnormal AFP or DCP. The thrombin time, fibrinogen activity to antigen ratio, and polymerization index failed to differentiate between cirrhosis and HCC. We conclude that AFP, DCP and factor V may give complementary informations in the diagnosis of HCC, one of these markers at least being positive in 88% of the patients.

Impact of moderate alcohol consumption on histological activity and fibrosis in patients with chronic hepatitis C, and specific influence of steatosis: a prospective study.

AIM: To evaluate the effects of minimal to moderate alcohol consumption on the severity of histological lesions in patients with chronic hepatitis C. METHODS: Daily alcohol intake (none, 1-20, 21-30, 31-50 g/day) and histological activity and fibrosis were recorded in 260 patients with chronic hepatitis C. RESULTS: The proportion of patients with moderate (A2) or marked (A3) activity increased gradually from 53.8% in abstinent patients to 86.5% for an intake between 31 and 50 g/day (P = 0.003). In multivariate analysis, age > 40 years, alcohol intake between 31 and 50 g/day and moderate or severe steatosis were independently related to histological activity. The proportion of patients with moderate (F2) or marked (F3) fibrosis or cirrhosis (F4) gradually increased from 29.0% in abstinent patients to 67.6% for an intake between 31 and 50 g/day (P < 0.001). Multivariate analysis also showed that alcohol intake between 31 and 50 g/day, moderate or severe steatosis and histological activity were independently related to fibrosis. The deleterious effect of alcohol intake on histological lesions differed according to gender. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that both activity and fibrosis gradually increase according to the amount of alcohol ingested, and that even moderate alcohol consumption, as low as 31-50 g/day in men and 21-50 g/day in women, may aggravate histological lesions in patients with chronic hepatitis C.

Intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma. Results of aggressive surgical management.

OBJECTIVE: To report the results of a deliberately aggressive surgical management in patients with intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma. DESIGN: A case series of patients with intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma. SETTING: A tertiary care university hospital in a metropolitan area. PATIENTS: From 1989 to 1993, 19 patients with intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma underwent laparotomy, with a 74% resectability rate (14 liver resections). In addition, two selected patients with a slow-growing tumor underwent orthotopic liver transplantation after limited recurrence following resection in one case and after exploratory laparotomy in the other. INTERVENTIONS: The 14 liver resections included six right or left hepatectomies and eight extended right or left hepatectomies. Total vascular exclusion of the liver was used in nine cases (64%) and resection of the biliary confluence with reconstruction was used in six cases (43%). RESULTS: There was one postoperative death (7%). There were four postoperative biliary fistulas (28%). Overall actuarial 1- and 2-year survival rates were 58% and 32%, respectively. The 1- and 2-year survival rates were 100% after curative resection (no lymph node invasion, clearance margin of < or = 1 cm, and solitary tumor [five cases]) and 48% and 10% after palliative resection. Median survival was 14 months for the whole series and 27 and 9 months following curative and palliative resections, respectively. The two liver transplant recipients are alive and free of disease at 25 and 31 months. CONCLUSION: These results support aggressive surgical management in patients with intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma, including complex liver resection procedures and selective use of orthotopic liver transplantation.

What technique should be used for routine detection and quantification of HBV DNA in clinical samples?

Detection of hepatitis B virus (HBV) DNA in serum allows monitoring of HBV replication and assessing responses to antiviral treatment. HBV DNA quantification measures virus replication and can be used as a prognosis indicator of liver disease and an index of response to antiviral drugs. The aim of this study was to compare the performances of three HBV DNA detection and/or quantification techniques for assessing HBV replication. Three hundred unselected sera with a request for HBV DNA detection and quantification were tested with a molecular hybridisation technique without amplification (Digene Hybrid-Capture, Murex Diagnostics Ltd), a signal amplification assay based on branched DNA technology (Quantiplex HBV DNA, Chiron diagnostics), and an 'in-house' qualitative, non quantitative target amplification assay based on the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) with primers located in the S gene of the HBV genome. Hybrid-capture and branched DNA gave concordant results in 278 cases (93%). In the 128 samples positive by both assays, DNA titres in pg/ml were related significantly (r = 0.70, P < 0.0001). but branched DNA titres increased more rapidly than hybrid-capture titres when the amount of HBV DNA in the sample increased. Twenty-two sera (7%) were negative by hybrid-capture, but positive in branched DNA (detection rate gain: 15%). In these 22 patients, DNA titres were low, HBsAg was present in all instances and alanine aminotransferase activity was elevated in 18 patients (82%); HBeAg was present in seven patients (32%) and anti-HBe antibodies in 18 patients (82%); liver biopsy, undertaken in 18 patients, revealed chronic active hepatitis in all instances, associated with cirrhosis in eight cases. Qualitative, non-quantitative HBV DNA PCR was positive in 75 (50%) of the 150 hybrid-capture-negative, branched DNA-negative samples, including a significant proportion of patients without evidence of ongoing HBV-related liver disease. The results show that in general, the branched DNA assay detects HBV DNA in more patients than hybrid-capture and that this improved detection rate is relevant clinically and genome equivalents/ml are preferred to pg/ml to quantify HBV DNA in clinical specimens and finally qualitative, non-quantitative polymerase chain reaction can detect HBV DNA in patients without evidence of active HBV-related liver disease. This study emphasizes the need for more sensitive, university standardised quantitative HBV DNA assays and for the definition of clinically relevant cutoffs with these assays.

Routine detection and quantification of hepatitis B virus DNA in clinical laboratories: performance of three commercial assays.

The detection and quantification of hepatitis B virus (HBV) genomes in molecular biology-based assays appear to be the most reliable methods for monitoring HBV infection and assessing responses to antiviral treatment. The aim of this study was to evaluate the performance of three HBV-DNA detection and quantification assays currently used for the management of HBV-infected patients: a solution-hybridization assay based on hybrid-capture (Digene Hybrid-Capture, Murex Diagnostics, Dartford, UK); a signal-amplification assay based on 'branched-DNA' (bDNA) technology (Quantiplex HBV DNA, Bayer Diagnostics, Emeryville, CA); and a target-amplification assay based on competitive polymerase chain reaction (Amplicor HBV Monitor, Roche Molecular Systems, Pleasanton, CA). The Monitor assay was significantly more sensitive than both the hybrid-capture and bDNA methods. This better sensitivity appeared to be clinically relevant. The linear ranges of quantification in the hybrid-capture, bDNA and Monitor methods were 6.5-9 log10 genome copies/ml, 6.5-9.5 log10 genome equivalents/ml, and 3-5.5 log10 genome copies/ml, respectively. However, the HBV-DNA units used in the three assays were not comparable. The specificity of the hybrid-capture, bDNA and Monitor assays was 99.2% (95% confidence interval: 97.7-100.0%), 99.2% (97.7-100.0%), and 97.8% (95.3-100%), respectively. Their within-run coefficients of variation and log10 SDs were 5.5% (+/- 0.025 log10 copies/ml), 6.7% (+/- 0.029 log10 Eq/ml) and 21.0% (+/- 0.093 log10 copies/ml), respectively. Between-run coefficients of variation ranged from 4.4-39.1%, 5-39.5%, and 17.8-96.1%, respectively. The competitive PCR-based Monitor assay appears to be significantly more sensitive but slightly less specific and reproducible than the hybrid-capture and bDNA methods. Given their respective performance, these three assays should be used in complementary fashion in the management of HBV-infected patients.