RESUMO
BACKGROUND: Survey studies have shown that physicians believe managed care is having significant impact on many of their professional obligations. METHODS: Primary care physicians were asked about the impact of managed care on: (1) physician-patient relationships, (2) the ability of physicians to carry out their professional ethical obligations, and (3) quality of patient care. In 1996 we surveyed 1011 primary care physicians in Pennsylvania. The survey group's responses were graded on a Likert scale. Space was provided for respondents to include written comments. The SPSS statistical software (SPSS Inc, Chicago, Ill) was used to analyze the data. RESULTS: The response rate was 55%. Most respondents indicated that under managed care physicians are less able to avoid conflicts of interest and less able to place the best interests of patients first. The majority responded that quality of health care is compromised by limitations in location of diagnostic tests, length of hospital stay, and choice of specialists. A significant minority (27%-49%) noted a decrease in the physician's ability to carry out ethical obligations, to respect patient autonomy, and to respect confidentiality in physician-patient communication. Most physicians expressed that managed care made no impact on ability to obtain informed consent or to provide information. There were small but statistically significant sex differences, with female physicians more negative toward managed care. CONCLUSIONS: Many physicians surveyed believe managed care has significant negative effects on the physician-patient relationship, the ability to carry out ethical obligations, and on quality of patient care. These results have implications for health care system reform efforts.
Assuntos
Atitude do Pessoal de Saúde , Ética Médica , Programas de Assistência Gerenciada , Relações Médico-Paciente , Qualidade da Assistência à Saúde , Revelação , Feminino , Humanos , Masculino , Pessoa de Meia-Idade , Pennsylvania , Médicos de Família , Médicas , ConfiançaRESUMO
The randomized clinical trial is the preferred research design for evaluating competing diagnostic and therapeutic alternatives, but confidence in the conclusions from a randomized clinical trial depends on the authors' attention to acknowledged methodologic and statistical standards. This survey assessed the level of attention to the problem of multiple comparisons in the analyses of contemporary randomized clinical trials. Of the 67 trials surveyed, 66 (99 percent) performed multiple comparisons with a mean of 30 therapeutic comparisons per trial. When criteria for statistical impairment were applied, 50 trials (75 percent) had the statistical significance of at least one comparison impaired by the problem of multiple comparisons, and 15 (22 percent) had the statistical significance of all comparisons impaired by the problem of multiple comparisons. Although some statistical techniques are available, there still exists a great need for future work to clarify further the problem of multiple comparisons and determine how the impact of this problem can best be minimized in subsequent research.
Assuntos
Ensaios Clínicos como Assunto/métodos , Distribuição Aleatória , Projetos de Pesquisa , Estatística como Assunto , Reações Falso-Positivas , HumanosRESUMO
UNLABELLED: Two discriminant functions, incorporating baseline measurements of pulmonary function and measures of airway responsiveness, were developed to improve patient classification into groups of normal, asthma, or COPD. Accuracy of group classification was compared between the usual laboratory method (single discriminating cut-off) and these new mathematically developed functions. Forty-five normal subjects, 27 asthmatic patients, and ten well-defined COPD patients were entered into the analysis. Measurements of airway responsiveness were determined by measurement of both specific airway conductance (SGaw) and spirometry (FEV1) after sequential inhalation of methacholine. RESULTS: A single discriminant cut-off using measures of SGaw (PD35) or FEV1 (PD20) does not sufficiently discriminate asthma from groups that contain normal and COPD subjects (67 to 71 percent predictive value). On the other hand, our discriminant functions demonstrated improved patient classification (positive predictive value, 88 to 89 percent). We conclude that bronchoprovocation tests used to evaluate the diagnosis of asthma should incorporate measures of baseline lung function into the analysis. This, we believe, is especially necessary when baseline lung function demonstrates minimal airflow obstruction and the possibility of other causes of airway disease exist.
Assuntos
Testes de Provocação Brônquica , Pneumopatias Obstrutivas/classificação , Cloreto de Metacolina , Adulto , Asma/classificação , Asma/diagnóstico , Análise Discriminante , Fluxo Expiratório Forçado , Volume Expiratório Forçado , Humanos , Pneumopatias Obstrutivas/diagnóstico , Pessoa de Meia-Idade , Valor Preditivo dos Testes , Sensibilidade e Especificidade , Capacidade VitalRESUMO
This study was undertaken to determine if there is an association between medication use and the presence or absence of bacteriuria in elderly ambulatory women. Of 198 women who participated in three urine culture surveys (every 6 months) during the 18-month study period, 66 (34.4%) had bacteriuria on at least one survey. Both univariate and multivariate analyses for the demographics, age, place of residence, and medication use (by drug class) revealed that only place of residence had a significant association with the presence or absence of bacteriuria. In this regard, bacteriuric subjects more commonly resided in the nursing home and less commonly lived in the apartment-house complex compared with nonbacteriuric subjects (P less than .05). Therefore, this study demonstrates that in elderly ambulatory women, medication use does not appear to be associated with the presence or absence of bacteriuria.
Assuntos
Bacteriúria/etiologia , Efeitos Colaterais e Reações Adversas Relacionados a Medicamentos , Idoso , Idoso de 80 Anos ou mais , Análise de Variância , Distribuição de Qui-Quadrado , Feminino , Humanos , Análise Multivariada , Casas de Saúde , Análise de Regressão , Características de ResidênciaRESUMO
INTRODUCTION: Physicians need to be well trained in HIV risk assessment interview skills. Little has been written in the literature concerning training methods for this specialized interview. METHODS: One model to teach the HIV risk assessment interview has been developed and has been used to teach third-year medical students. We compared this interactive model, which uses simulated patients to teach HIV Risk Assessment, to a didactic one. Twelve medical residents were taken through either the interactive session or the didactic session. Pre-post changes from questionnaires were calculated to determine any differences in sessions. Also, Objective Structured Clinical Examinations (OSCEs) were used to grade all residents 2 weeks after their sessions. RESULTS: All pre-post changes were calculated and no statistically significant differences were seen (P > 0.50). OSCE interpersonal skills scores and content scores were calculated. The interactive group had statistically significantly higher scores (P < 0.05). CONCLUSION: The data supports the conclusion that an interactive method is more effective to use to train HIV risk assessment interview skills to medical residents when compared to the didactic method.
Assuntos
Infecções por HIV/prevenção & controle , Medicina Interna/educação , Internato e Residência/métodos , Simulação de Paciente , Ensino/métodos , Adulto , Atitude do Pessoal de Saúde , Competência Clínica , Feminino , Humanos , Masculino , Anamnese/normas , Relações Médico-Paciente , Medição de Risco/métodosRESUMO
Burkholderia (Pseudomonas) cepacia is an important pathogen amongst persons with cystic fibrosis (CF), and evidence suggests that transmission of strains within CF clinics contributes to pulmonary colonization of some patients. In order to optimize preventive strategies, the survival of B. cepacia on various environmental surfaces, including cotton cloth, stainless steel, latex and polyvinylchloride (PVC) tubing, was investigated. For surface inoculation, bacteria were suspended in phosphate buffered saline, sputum from CF patients, or sputum from persons without CF. The results demonstrate that amongst the strains examined, organisms survived significantly (P < 0.001) longer when suspended in sputum from CF patients than in either non-CF sputum or buffered saline. Significant (P < 0.001) differences in survival on the various surfaces were found; survival was greatest on PVC. Significant (P < 0.001) strain-to-strain differences in survival were also demonstrated; patient isolates representing predominant CF centre ribotypes survived longest. These data demonstrate that (1) B. cepacia can survive for long periods in respiratory droplets on environmental surfaces typically found in CF clinics, (2) undefined factors in sputum from patients with CF may contribute to survival of B. cepacia, and (3) strain-to-strain variation in survival time may affect strain transmissibility.
Assuntos
Burkholderia cepacia/crescimento & desenvolvimento , Microbiologia Ambiental , Contaminação de Equipamentos , Análise de Variância , Infecções por Burkholderia/microbiologia , Infecções por Burkholderia/transmissão , Burkholderia cepacia/classificação , Burkholderia cepacia/genética , Fibrose Cística/complicações , DNA Bacteriano/análise , Humanos , Sorotipagem , Escarro/microbiologia , Fatores de TempoRESUMO
PURPOSE: To investigate whether the incorporation of women's health into problem-based learning (PBL) cases affects students' tendency to identify learning issues related to women's health as they encounter patients in an ambulatory care setting. METHOD: Students in the PBL curriculum at the Allegheny University of the Health Sciences, MCP-Hahnemann School of Medicine, participate in a nine-week primary care practicum at the end of their first year, during which they spend three half-days per week in an ambulatory setting examining patients and completing patient logs that include any learning issues identified. Patient logs from 23 first-year PBL students who had not been exposed to a new women's health education program prior to their practicum in 1993 and from 22 first-year PBL students who had been exposed to the program prior to their practicum in 1994 were reviewed. For each women's health learning issue identified, the sex of the student and the sex, specialty, and practice setting of the student's preceptor were recorded. Data were analyzed with several statistical methods. RESULTS: There was no statistically significant difference in the numbers of men and women students or preceptors between the two years. In 1993 an average of 59% of the patients seen per student were women; in 1994 the average was 61%. The mean numbers of total learning issues identified (including women's health learning issues) were similar in the two years, but the mean percentage of clinical women's health learning issues identified increased significantly between 1993 and 1994, as did the mean percentage of community/preventive health women's health learning issues identified. There was a significant student-sex-by-preceptor-sex interaction for the total number of women's health learning issues identified (p = .024): for both years, the students paired with a preceptor of the same sex identified a higher number of women's health learning issues than did the students paired with a preceptor of the opposite sex. CONCLUSION: The results suggest that PBL is an effective way to increase students' awareness of women's health issues in a primary care clinical setting. More studies are needed to define the effect of PBL on the kind of reading and learning students will do when they get to the clinical setting.
Assuntos
Assistência Ambulatorial , Aprendizagem Baseada em Problemas , Saúde da Mulher , Adulto , Feminino , Humanos , Masculino , Pennsylvania , Preceptoria , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de SaúdeRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Medical students often experience difficulty comprehending anatomic relationships of complex operations to which they are exposed during surgical clerkship. Pancreaticoduodenectomy, the Whipple procedure, is one such operation. Although video recordings are available to facilitate the learning of the Whipple procedure, commercially available tapes are not self-explanatory to the uninitiated. Since we have previously demonstrated that third-year medical students could learn the operative steps of inguinal herniorraphy by a paper-cutting exercise, we set out to determine whether an exercise of similar design could enhance a student's comprehension of the Whipple procedure. METHODS: Using Adobe Illustrator 5.5 for MacIntosh, an exercise was developed on a 8.5 x 11-inch paper that could be distributed to students for self-administration. The exercise was performed using a #15 scalpel or an iris scissors. Thirty-seven students were randomized into two groups. Each student received a pretest of questions focusing on the Whipple procedure. Group I was shown an 18-minute commercially available teaching video on the Whipple procedure. Group II was given the Whipple origami exercise, which required 20 minutes to complete. A first posttest was administered to each group. Next, the groups switched exercises, and a second posttest was administered. RESULTS: There was no significant difference between the groups' pretest scores (two-tailed t test, P = 0.290). Group I improved its score from an average of 64.21 (SD 14.27) to 67.89 (SD 13.16) after watching the video, and further to 77.89 (SD 14.37) after completing the paper-cut exercise. Group II improved from 60.00 (SD 9.43) to 78.95 (SD 11.00) after performing the paper-cut, but derived no additional measurable benefit from watching the video, average score 74.74 (SD 18.37). After the first exercise, students who performed the paper-cut showed a significantly greater improvement in test scores compared with students who saw the video (P = 0.0035 by Mann-Whitney U). After both groups had completed the exercises, the mean changes from baseline were no longer significantly different (P = 0.58 by Mann-Whitney U). CONCLUSION: As a single educational intervention, the paper-cut exercise was a more effective teaching device than the video in the given time frame. The origami model may be generalized to a variety of surgical procedures and appears to be a valuable adjunct to traditional teaching.
Assuntos
Recursos Audiovisuais , Cirurgia Geral/educação , Pancreaticoduodenectomia/métodos , Materiais de Ensino , Educação de Pós-Graduação em Medicina , Cirurgia Geral/normas , Humanos , Pancreaticoduodenectomia/normas , Gravação em VídeoRESUMO
BACKGROUND: This study examined whether a single intervention with standardized patients (SPs) as a supplement to traditional teaching during the surgery clerkship would enhance the breast and abdominal examination skills of third-year medical students. METHODS: During the academic year 1994-1995, 153 students from two institutions were assigned to control or experimental groups. At institution A, all students underwent pretests and posttests with SPs; at institution B, no pretest was conducted. All experimental students received group and one-to-one instruction with SPs during the intervention session. RESULTS: At posttest, the experimental group performed better than the control group on breast examination (P = 0.002), professionalism during this examination (P <0.001), abdominal examination (P <0.001), and professionalism during the latter examination (P = 0.050). The improvement from pretest to posttest at institution A was significantly greater in the experimental group than the control group for the breast examination (P = 0.036) and the abdominal examination (P <0.001). Analyses on a variety of specific tasks within each examination were also performed. CONCLUSION: A single intervention with SPs teaching breast and abdominal examinations resulted in significant enhancement of these clinical skills.
Assuntos
Estágio Clínico , Competência Clínica , Cirurgia Geral/educação , Exame Físico , Ensino/métodos , Abdome , Adulto , Mama , HumanosRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: To compare the abilities of low-surface-area (LSA) vs 2 types of high-surface-area (HSA) activated charcoal given orally to adsorb acetaminophen in the gastrointestinal (GI) tract, as demonstrated by the impact of these agents on the serum levels and area under the curve (AUC) in a simulated human overdose model. METHODS: The main arm of the study was a prospective double-blind crossover trial in which 6 volunteers, serving as their own controls, ingested acetaminophen (50 mg/kg), followed randomly in 10 minutes by either powdered LSA charcoal (950 m2/g) or powdered HSA charcoal (2,000 m2/g) in a charcoal:drug ratio of 8:1. In a second arm of the study, 3 subjects additionally ingested an equal dose of a granular preparation of the HSA charcoal. Serial serum acetaminophen levels were analyzed at various intervals (30, 60, 90, 120, 180, 240, and 300 minutes postingestion), and a 5-hour AUC was calculated. The subjects also rated the charcoal preparations for palatability. RESULTS: Serum acetaminophen levels were lower at all measured times in the groups receiving both forms of the HSA charcoal vs the LSA product. With the powdered HSA charcoal, comparison serum levels were significantly lower at 120 minutes postingestion and all times thereafter (p < 0.05), reaching high significance at 4 and 5 hours (p < 0.001). The subjects receiving the granular HSA charcoal also had consistently lower serum acetaminophen levels than did those receiving the LSA product, and the difference in mean serum levels was significant at the 4- and 5-hour sample (p = 0.012). Compared with the LSA charcoal, at the 4-hour postingestion sample, serum acetaminophen levels were reduced by 44% to 85% by the powdered HSA charcoal. The total AUC for the 5-hour study period was also significantly reduced by the powdered HSA product (p = 0.005) and the granular HSA product (p = 0.043). All the subjects rated the powdered HSA charcoal to be more palatable and easier to drink than the powdered LSA charcoal. CONCLUSION: The surface area of oral activated charcoal is a major determining factor in its ability to limit acetaminophen absorption and to fulfill its adsorptive role in GI decontamination. In a human acetaminophen overdose model, 2 types of HSA charcoal, when compared with equal doses of LSA charcoal, significantly reduced serum levels and total acetaminophen absorption as measured by the AUC.
Assuntos
Acetaminofen/sangue , Analgésicos não Narcóticos/sangue , Antídotos/administração & dosagem , Carvão Vegetal/administração & dosagem , Absorção , Acetaminofen/farmacocinética , Administração Oral , Adulto , Área Sob a Curva , Estudos Cross-Over , Método Duplo-Cego , Overdose de Drogas , Feminino , Humanos , Masculino , Modelos Biológicos , Estudos ProspectivosRESUMO
Recent research shows that nonacademic variables must be taken into account when analyzing the indicators of medical student success. However, most previous studies have been limited to a single institution or population. This study investigated the relationship between nonacademic variables and performance at two very different medical schools. The Noncognitive Questionnaire was administered to 104 students at School A (predominantly white and historically oriented toward women) and 102 at School B (predominantly black). Correlation and multiple regression analyses were conducted to determine the relationship among nonacademic variables, undergraduate academic variables (Medical College Admission Test, undergraduate grade point average, and college quality), basic science grades, and US Medical Licensure Exam Step I (USMLE 1) scores. At School A, leadership/decisiveness, expected difficulty, and motivation predicted higher USMLE I scores and higher basic science grades each semester. At School B, expected difficulty was correlated with higher first semester grades only. For School A women, initiative/commitment was positively associated with both higher grades and higher USMLE scores. For black students of School B, expected difficulty was positively associated with higher grades. Identifying school-specific nonacademic variables of performance is critical to developing improved student support services.