Spore germination of the psychrotolerant, red meat spoiler, Clostridium frigidicarnis.

AIMS: To determine germination triggers of Clostridium frigidicarnis, an important spoilage bacterium of chilled vacuum-packed meat. METHODS AND RESULTS: Germination of Cl. frigidicarnis spores in the presence of a range of potential nutrient and non-nutrient germinants was tested by monitoring the fall in optical density and by phase-contrast microscopy. The amino acid L-valine induced strong germination when paired with L-lactate in sodium phosphate under anaerobic conditions. Several other amino acids promoted germination when paired with L-lactate in sodium phosphate and the co-germinants NaHCO3 and L-cysteine. Heat activation, while not necessary for germination, increased the rate of germination. Spore germination was not observed when spores were incubated aerobically. CONCLUSIONS: Spores of psychrotolerant Cl. frigidicarnis germinated in the presence of L-valine in combination with L-lactate in sodium phosphate buffer under anaerobic conditions. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Anaerobic conditions, L-valine and L-lactate, have been identified as triggering germination in Cl. frigidicarnis, and are all present in packs of fresh, vacuum-packaged, red meat. This new information adds to what is known about red meat spoilage by cold tolerant clostridia and can be used to develop intervention strategies to prevent meat spoilage.

Lag time variability in individual spores of Clostridium botulinum.

Quantifying lag times from individual spores and the associated variability is an important part of understanding the hazard associated with spore-forming pathogens such as Clostridium botulinum. Knowledge of the underlying distribution would allow greater refinement of risk assessments. To date most studies have either examined lag time indirectly by measuring time to growth or have only examined the first stage of lag, germination. Recent studies have attempted to quantify the variability of spores during the different stages of lag phase and to examine the relationships between these stages. The effect of incubation temperature (22 °C, 15 °C, 10 °C or 8 °C), heat treatment (unheated or 80 °C for 20 s) and sodium chloride concentration in both the sporulation medium (0 or 3% w/v) or growth medium (0 or 2% w/v) on growth from individual spores has been examined. These studies found spores within a single population are very heterogeneous with large variability in all stages of lag. The duration and variability of times for germination, outgrowth and first doubling depended on both the historic treatment of the spores and the prevailing growth conditions, and the stage of lag most affected was treatment dependant.

Quantitative risk assessment for hazards that arise from non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum in minimally processed chilled dairy-based foods.

A modular process risk model has been constructed that describes the manufacture of dairy dessert products and hazards that arise from non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum. The model describes batch manufacture and consumer storage of a family size generic dairy dessert but includes a realistic quantification that could apply to a specific food product. The dairy dessert sector is an expanding part of the UK market. The model includes modules that describe spore loads in raw materials, spore inactivation during thermal processing, volume partition and the population kinetics for non-proteolytic C. botulinum during sequential isothermal storage regimes. Where possible elements of uncertainty and variability are identified explicitly. The model is constructed as a belief network from published data and expert opinions. The model provides marginal probabilities, and associated sensitivities, for a range of endpoint measures centred on the toxicity of a single retail unit after an extended period of storage. The decimal reduction time for non-proteolytic C. botulinum spore populations at the highest (hold) temperature of the primary thermal process and the highest temperature experienced during poorly controlled (consumer) storage are dominant factors determining risks. Priorities for additional information to support risk assessments have been identified.

Modelling the growth of Clostridium perfringens during the cooling of bulk meat.

A dynamic predictive model was developed to describe the effects of temperature, pH and NaCl concentration on the growth of Clostridium perfringens type A. The model for the specific growth rate was based on 81 growth curves generated in our laboratory or obtained from the publicly available ComBase database. Growth curves obtained during cooling were fitted with the dynamic model of Baranyi and Roberts. This made it possible to determine the parameter value reflecting the physiological state of C. perfringens after heating profiles typically applied to bulk meat. The model with the obtained parameters provided a good description of growth of C. perfringens in 24 heating/cooling curves generated specifically for this work (various non-isothermal treatments with a range of combinations of pH and NaCl concentration), and also for existing literature data. The dynamic model was implemented in Perfringens Predictor, a web-based application that can be accessed free of charge via www.combase.cc. It is anticipated that the use of this model and Perfringens Predictor will contribute to a reduction in the food poisoning incidence associated with C. perfringens.

Germination and growth from spores: variability and uncertainty in the assessment of food borne hazards.

We have developed a model for the variability of spore lag times and shown that variability has an important role in the quantitative assessment of risks associated with spore forming bacteria in food. The model includes two sequential independent delay times that contribute to the lag time for a single spore. We have shown that a population of variable spores also has a variable lag time, and we have emphasised the significance of this variability in quantitative representations of population dynamics for small populations. We have made a Bayesian estimate for the extent of the variability in spore lag times and made a comparison with direct microscopic observations of individual spores of nonproteolytic Clostridium botulinum. We conclude that Bayesian inference is a practical method for quantifying variability and hence a significant element in the development of quantitative risk assessments for hazards associated with spore forming bacteria.

Probabilistic representation of the exposure of consumers to Clostridium botulinum neurotoxin in a minimally processed potato product.

We have examined the potential of a well-specified, minimally processed potato product as a vehicle for the exposure of consumers to Clostridium botulinum neurotoxin. The product is a relatively simple combination of raw potato flakes, flour, starch and other minor ingredients and has an extended lifetime under refrigeration conditions. A combination of information and data, from a variety of sources that includes the manufacturer, has shown that the product is particularly safe with respect to non-proteolytic C. botulinum hazards. The model concentrates on a simple end point, the toxicity of an individual retail unit of the product at the point of consumer preparation, which is related to an individual risk. The probabilistic analysis was built using Bayesian Belief Network (BBN) techniques.

Prevalence of Clostridium species and behaviour of Clostridium botulinum in gnocchi, a REPFED of italian origin.

Sales and consumption of refrigerated processed foods of extended durability (REPFEDs) have increased many-fold in Europe over the last 10 years. The safety and quality of these convenient ready-to-eat foods relies on a combination of mild heat treatment and refrigerated storage, sometimes in combination with other hurdles such as mild preservative factors. The major hazard to the microbiological safety of these foods is Clostridium botulinum. This paper reports on the prevalence and behaviour of proteolytic C. botulinum and non-proteolytic C. botulinum in gnocchi, a potato-based REPFED of Italian origin. Attempts to isolate proteolytic C. botulinum and non-proteolytic C. botulinum from gnocchi and its ingredients were unsuccessful. Based on assessment of the adequacy of the methods used, it was estimated that for proteolytic C. botulinum there was < 25 spores/kg of gnocchi and < 70 spores/kg of ingredients. The total anaerobic microbial load of gnocchi and its ingredients was low, with an estimated 1 MPN/g in processed gnocchi. Most of the anaerobic flora was facultatively anaerobic. A few obligately anaerobic bacteria were isolated from gnocchi and its ingredients and belonged to different Clostridium species. The protection factor, number of decimal reductions in the probability of toxigenesis from a single spore, was determined for eight different gnocchi formulations by challenge test studies. For all gnocchi stored at 8 degrees C (as recommended by the manufacturer) or 12 degrees C (mild temperature abuse), growth and toxin production were not detected in 75 days. The protection factor was >4.2 for proteolytic C. botulinum, and >6.2 for non-proteolytic C. botulinum. When inoculated packs were stored at 20 degrees C (severe temperature abuse), toxin production in 75 days was prevented by the inclusion of 0.09% (w/w) sorbic acid (protection factors as above), however in the absence of sorbic acid the packs became toxic before the end of the intended shelf-life and the protection factors were lower. Providing sorbic acid (0.09% w/w) is included in the gnocchi, the safety margin would seem to be very large with respect to the foodborne botulism hazard.

Predictive model of the effect of temperature, pH and sodium chloride on growth from spores of non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum.

Non-proteolytic strains of Clostridium botulinum are capable of growth at chill temperatures and thus pose a potential hazard in minimally-processed chilled foods. The combined effect of pH (5.0-7.3), NaCl concentration (0.1-5.0%) and temperature (4-30 degrees C) on growth of non-proteolytic C. botulinum in laboratory media was studied. Growth curves at various combinations of pH, NaCl concentration and temperature were fitted by the Gompertz and Baranyi models, and parameters derived from the curve-fit were modelled. Predictions of growth from the models were compared with data in the literature and this showed them to be suitable for use with fish, meat and poultry products. This model should contribute to ensuring the safety of minimally-processed foods with respect to non-proteolytic C. botulinum.

Predictive models of the effect of temperature, pH and acetic and lactic acids on the growth of Listeria monocytogenes.

The combined effect of temperature (1-20 degrees C), pH (4.5-7.2) and acetic acid (0-10,000 mg/l; model 1) or lactic acid (0-20,000 mg/l; model 2) on growth of Listeria monocytogenes in laboratory media was studied. Growth curves at various combinations of temperature, pH and acid concentration were fitted by the model of Baranyi and Roberts (1994), and specific growth rates derived from the curve fit were modelled. Predictions of growth from the models were compared with data in the literature, and this showed the models to be suitable for use in predicting growth of L. monocytogenes in a range of foods including meat, poultry, fish, egg and milk and dairy products. The two models are compatible, i.e. they give similar predictions for cases when no acid is present.

Predictive model of the effect of CO2, pH, temperature and NaCl on the growth of Listeria monocytogenes.

The growth responses of L. monocytogenes as affected by CO2 concentration (0-100% v/v, balance nitrogen), NaCl concentration (0.5-8.0% w/v), pH (4.5-7.0) and temperature (4-20 degrees C) were studied in laboratory medium. Growth curves were fitted using the model of Baranyi and Roberts, and specific growth rates derived from the curve fit were modelled. Predictions for specific growth rate, doubling time and time to a 1000-fold increase could be made for any combination of conditions within the matrix. Predictions of growth from the model were compared with published data and this showed the model to be suitable for predicting growth of L. monocytogenes in a range of foods packaged under a modified atmosphere.

Mathematical modelling of the growth, survival and death of Yersinia enterocolitica.

This paper discusses the development of a novel mathematical equation capable of handling the growth, survival and death of microorganisms. The equation was used in combination with second-order polynomials to fit a response surface to data representing the growth, survival and death of Yersinia enterocolitica as affected by temperature (0-30 degrees C), sodium chloride (0-10.5% w/v), pH (3.5-7.0) and undissociated lactic acid (0-9.63 g/l). The resulting predictive model showed a good correlation over the entire range of the experimental data. Predictions from the model have been compared with independent data from both published literature and inoculated food studies. Analysis of the results showed a good correlation, particularly for data from milk and meat products.

Modelling the growth, survival and death of microorganisms in foods: the UK food micromodel approach.

Techniques for the development of mathematical models in the area of predictive microbiology have greatly improved recently, allowing better and more accurate descriptions of microbial responses to particular environmental conditions, thus enabling predictions of those responses to be made with greater confidence. Recognising the potential value of applying these techniques in the food industry, the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (MAFF) initiated a nationally coordinated five-year programme of research into the growth and survival of microorganisms in foods, with the aim of developing a computerised Predictive Microbiology Database in the UK. This initiative has resulted in the systematic generation of data, through protocols which ensure consistency of methodology, so that data in the database are truly comparable and compatible, and lead to reliable predictive models. The approaches taken by scientists involved in this programme are described and the various stages in the development of mathematical models summarized. It is hoped that this initiative and others being developed in the USA, Australia, Canada and other countries, will encourage a more integrated approach to food safety which will influence all stages of food production and, eventually, result in the development of an International Predictive Microbiology Database.

Research on factors allowing a risk assessment of spore-forming pathogenic bacteria in cooked chilled foods containing vegetables: a FAIR collaborative project.

Vegetables are frequent ingredients of cooked chilled foods and are frequently contaminated with spore-forming bacteria (SFB). Therefore, risk assessment studies have been carried out, including the following: hazard identification and characterisation--from an extensive literature review and expertise of the participants, B. cereus and C. botulinum were identified as the main hazards; exposure assessment--consisting of determination of the prevalence of hazardous SFB in cooked chilled foods containing vegetables and in unprocessed vegetables, and identification of SFB representative of the bacterial community in cooked chilled foods containing vegetables, determination of heat-resistance parameters and factors affecting heat resistance of SFB, determination of the growth kinetics of SFB in vegetable substrate and of the influence of controlling factors, validation of previous work in complex food systems and by challenge testing and information about process and storage conditions of cooked chilled foods containing vegetables. The paper illustrates some original results obtained in the course of the project. The results and information collected from scientific literature or from the expertise of the participants are integrated into the microbial risk assessment, using both a Bayesian belief network approach and a process risk model approach, previously applied to other foodborne hazards.

Investigation of the ability of proteolytic Clostridium botulinum to multiply and produce toxin in fresh Italian pasta.

The ability of proteolytic Clostridium botulinum (types A, B, and F) to produce toxin in filled fresh Italian pasta (tortelli) packed under a modified atmosphere was investigated. Four types of tortelli (filled with artichoke, meat, ricotta-spinach, or salmon) were inoculated with a suspension of heat-shocked spores to give an initial concentration of approximately 10(3) spores per piece. Samples were incubated at both 12 and 20 degrees C for up to 50 days and examined at selected time intervals for the presence of toxin by an ELISA and the mouse test. Toxin was not detected in any tortelli stored at 12 degrees C. When storage was at 20 degrees C, toxin was detected in the salmon-filled tortelli at day 30, in the meat and ricotta-spinach tortelli at day 50, but not in the artichoke-filled tortelli at day 50.

Factors affecting growth from heat-treated spores of non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum.

Heat treatment of spores of non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum at 85°C for 120 min followed by enumeration of survivors on a medium containing lysozyme resulted in a 4.1 and 4.8 decimal reduction in numbers of spores of strains 17B (type B) and Beluga (type E), respectively. Only a small proportion of heated spores formed colonies on medium containing lysozyme; this proportion could be increased by treatments designed to increase the permeability of heated spores. The results indicate that the germination system in spores of non-proteolytic Cl. botulinum was destroyed by heating, that lysozyme could replace this germination system, and that treatments that increased the permeability of the spore coat could increase the proportion of heated spores that germinated on medium containing lysozyme. These results are important in relation to the assessment of heat-treatments required to reduce the risk of survival and growth of non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum in processed (pasteurized) refrigerated foods for extended storage.

The effect of recovery medium on the estimated heat-inactivation of spores of non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum.

Heating spores of non-proteolytic strains of Clostridium botulinum at 85°C, followed by enumeration of survivors on a highly nutrient medium indicated a 5 decimal kill in less than 2 min. The inclusion of lysozyme or egg yolk emulsion in the recovery medium substantially increased apparent spore heat-resistance, with as little as 0.1 µg lysozyme/ml sufficient to give an increase in the number of survivors. After heating at 85°C for 2 min between 0.1% and 1% of the spores of 11 strains (5 type B, 4 type E, 2 type F) formed colonies on medium containing 10 µg lysozyme/ml. Enumeration of survivors on a medium containing lysozyme showed that heating at 85°C for 5 min resulted in an estimated 2.6 decimal kill of spores of strain 17B (type B). These findings are important in the assessment of heat-treatments required to ensure the safety with respect to non-proteolytic Clostridium botulinum of processed (pasteurized) refrigerated foods for extended storage such as sous-vide foods.

The microbiological quality of hot water-washed broccoli florets and cut green beans.

AIMS: To determine the effect of hot water washing on the microbiological quality of cut broccoli florets and trimmed green beans. METHODS AND RESULTS: Broccoli florets and trimmed beans were washed for 90 s in tap water at either 20 degrees C or 52 degrees C and stored at 7 and 10 degrees C. The numbers of naturally occurring aerobic mesophilic organisms, Pseudomonas spp., Enterobacteriaceae, yeast and moulds and lactobacilli or lactic acid bacteria were enumerated at intervals for up to 2 weeks. The ability of Listeria monocytogenes, Bacillus cereus and Escherichia coli O157:H7 inoculated onto the tissue post heat treatment to survive or grow was also measured to mimic the effect of postprocess contamination. Using a hot wash treatment improved the initial appearance of the vegetables and resulted in a small, but significant, reduction in populations of all groups of endogenous flora measured. The number of yeast and moulds on the vegetables washed at 52 degrees C remained below the levels observed on the 20 degrees C washed vegetables throughout the observation period, but Pseudomonas spp., lactobacilli and Enterobacteriaceae were better able to grow on the hot-washed vegetables such that the counts at the end of storage were greater on hot-washed than ambient-washed vegetables. All three of the pathogens tested were better able to grow on hot-washed broccoli and beans than on equivalent product washed at 20 degrees C. CONCLUSIONS: Hot water washing can be used to control enzymic browning or yeast and moulds growth but it can also allow more rapid and extensive growth by pathogens and spoilage organisms. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Reduced protection against growth by pathogens means that the hot wash treatment of vegetables should be used with caution and requires careful assessment of risk.

Clostridium botulinum and the safety of minimally heated, chilled foods: an emerging issue?

Foodborne botulism is caused by consumption of preformed botulinum neurotoxin, with as little as 30 ng of neurotoxin being potentially lethal. Consumption of minute quantities of neurotoxin-containing food can result in botulism. In view of the severity of foodborne botulism, it is essential that new foods be developed safely without an increase in incidence of this disease. Minimally heated, chilled foods are a relatively new type of food, sales of which are currently increasing by about 10% per annum. These products meet consumer demand for high-quality foods that require little preparation time. Their safety and quality depends on mild heat treatment, chilled storage, restricted shelf life and sometimes on intrinsic properties of the foods. The principal microbiological hazard is nonproteolytic Clostridium botulinum, and there is a concern that this may become an emerging issue. A considerable amount of research and development over the last 15 years has underpinned the safe production of commercial, minimally heated, chilled foods with respect to foodborne botulism, and it is essential that safe food continues to be developed. In particular, the desire to use lighter heat processes and a longer shelf life presents a challenge that will only be met by significant developments in quantitative microbiological food safety.