Electron Transport over 2D Molecular Materials and Assemblies.

ConspectusTwo-dimensional (2D) molecular materials, in which the major interactions are confined in 2D planes with contrasted force fields acting in between the planes, have been key electronic functional materials since the past decade. Even without referring to the functionals of graphene-based systems, 2D electronic conjugated systems are expected to show extrawide dynamic ranges in electronic density of states (DOS) tuning, effective electron mass, electron mobility, and conductivity. A major advantage of 2D electronic systems is their compatibility with the ubiquitous electronic devices designed using planar structures, such as transistors and memories, which is associated with the utility of 2D active materials. The mobility of electrons in 2D systems is the key to their utility, and various conjugated molecular and 2D materials have been designed to optimize the mobility. This Account begins with an introduction for mobility assessment: using noncontact time-resolved microwave conductivity (TRMC) measurements as a technique to probe differential conductivity upon transient charge carrier injection into the materials. Electronic transport over 2D electronic materials such as graphenes, covalent organic frameworks (COFs), and metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) is discussed with a special emphasis on molecular building blocks, fine-tuning conducting species and linkages, topology of the framework, and controlling molecular doping. The superiority of ß-ketoenamine-linked COF over imine-linked COF films in charge transport and dominant in-plane charge carrier mobility over out-of-plane mobility is also illustrated. Systematic molecular engineering of the building blocks of ß-ketoenamine-linked COFs with varying degrees of donor-acceptor (D-A) conjugation, torsional angles, and reaction conditions resulted in the modulation of the efficiency of charge carrier generation/transport as well as exciton migration. The advantages of 2D systems are finally discussed in terms of the mobility interplaying with spatial arrangements of molecules as well as the substantial role of intermolecular interactions in stabilizing their condensed phases. The strong correlation between the dispersion of mobility and hierarchical intermolecular interactions sheds light on the way to overcome structural fluctuation on the optimization of charge transport in molecular electronic materials. The point of singularity in the dispersion at an intermolecular distance of d ∼ 0.3 nm is deduced from the overall mobility assessment in condensed phases of conjugated molecules, suggesting key roles of intermolecular electronic coupling: the new concept of electronic conjugation. Exceptional electronic coupling with relatively high charge carrier mobility was also observed, particularly in 2D spatial arrangements of chiral molecules in contrast to 3D analogues, where the reduction of gravitational density of the molecular condensates was impacting DOS: the Wallach's rule. 2D electronic systems are strong candidates for the violation of the long-lasting Wallach's rule in terms of DOS.

π-Extended 9b-Boraphenalenes: Synthesis, Structure, and Physical Properties.

Boraphenalenes, compounds in which one carbon atom in the phenalenyl skeleton is replaced with a boron atom, have attracted attention for their solid-state and electronic structures; however, the construction of boraphenalene skeletons remains challenging because of the lack of suitable methods. Through this study, we showed that the tandem borylative cyclization of C3-symmetric dehydrobenzo[12]annulenes produces a new class of fully fused boron-atom-embedded polycyclic hydrocarbons possessing a 9b-boraphenalene skeleton. The obtained compounds exhibited high electron-accepting characteristics, and their two-step redox process was reversible in the reductive region, involving interconversion of 9b-boraphenalene between Hückel aromaticity and antiaromaticity. Notably, the benzo[b]fluorene-fused derivative exhibited a stepwise single-crystal-to-single-crystal (SCSC) phase transition triggered by thermal annealing. Intermolecular electron coupling calculation of the crystal structures suggested a significant improvement of charge transporting ability associated with the SCSC phase transition. Moreover, adequate photoconductivity was observed for the single crystals before and after the SCSC phase transition through flash photolysis-time-resolved microwave conductivity.

Synthesis of Aza[n]helicenes up to n = 19: Hydrogen-Bond-Assisted Solubility and Benzannulation Strategy.

Synthetic challenges toward anomalous structures and electronic states often involve handling problems such as insolubility in common organic solvents and oxidative degradation under aerobic conditions. We designed benzo-annulated aza[n]helicenes, which benefit from both the suppressed elevation of highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) energies and high solubility due to hydrogen bonding with solvent molecules to overcome these challenges. This strategy enabled the synthesis of six new aza[n]helicenes ([n]AHs) of different lengths (n = 9-19) from acyclic precursors via one-pot intramolecular oxidative fusion reactions. The structures of all of the synthesized aza[n]helicenes were determined by X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis, and their electrochemical potentials were measured by cyclic voltammetry. Among the synthesized aza[n]helicenes, [17]AH and [19]AH are the first heterohelicenes with a triple-layered helix. The noncovalent interaction (NCI) plots confirm the existence of an effective π-π interaction between the layers. The absorption and fluorescence spectra red-shifted as the helical lengths increased, without any distinct saturation points. The optical resolutions of N-butylated [9]AH, [11]AH, [13]AH, and [15]AH were accomplished, and their circular dichroism (CD) and circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) were measured. Thus, the structural, (chir)optical, and electrochemical properties of the aza[n]helicenes were comprehensively analyzed.

Sulfur-Bridged Cationic Diazulenomethenes: Formation of Charge-Segregated Assembly with High Charge-Carrier Mobility.

Sulfur-bridged cationic diazulenomethenes were synthesized and exhibited high stability even under basic conditions due to the delocalization of positive charge over the whole π-conjugated skeleton. As a result of the effective delocalization and the absence of orthogonally oriented bulky substituents, the cationic π-conjugated skeletons formed a π-stacked array with short interfacial distances. A derivative with SbF6- as a counter anion formed a charge-segregated assembly in the crystalline state, rather than the generally favored charge-by-charge arrangement of oppositely charged species based on electrostatic interactions. Theoretical calculations suggested that the destabilization caused by electrostatic repulsion between two positively charged π-conjugated skeletons is compensated by the dispersion forces. In addition, the counter anion SbF6- played a role in regulating the molecular alignment through F⋯H-C and F-S interactions, which resulted in the charge-segregated alignment of the cationic π-skeletons. This characteristic assembled structure gave rise to a high charge-carrier mobility of 1.7 cm2 V-1 s-1 as determined using flash-photolysis time-resolved microwave conductivity.

Carrier Transport Switching of Ferroelectric BTBT Derivative.

Alkylamide-substituted [1]benzothieno[3,2-b][1]benzothiophene (BTBT) derivative of BTBT-NHCOC14H29 (1), which has ferroelectric N-H···O= hydrogen-bonding network of alkylamide group and two-dimensional (2D) electric structure of BTBT π-cores, was prepared to design the external electric field-responsive organic semiconductors. The short-chain derivative of BTBT-NHCOC3H7 (1') revealed the coexistence of a 2D electronic band structure based on the herringbone BTBT arrangement and the one-dimensional (1D) hydrogen-bonding chain. 1 formed a smectic E (SmE) liquid crystal phase above 412 K and showed ferroelectric hysteresis in the electric field-polarization (P-E) curves at 403-433 K. The remanent polarization (Pr) and coercive electric field (Ec) of 1 at 408 K, 0.1 Hz were 24.0 µC cm-2 and 5.54 V µm-1, respectively. By thermal annealing of thin-film 1 at 443 K, the molecular assembly structure of 1 changed from a monolayer to a bilayer structure with high crystallinity, resulting in conducting layers of BTBT parallel to the substrate surface. The organic field-effect transistor (OFET) device with thermally annealed thin-film 1 showed p-type semiconducting behavior with the hole mobility of 1.0 × 10-3 cm2 V-1 s-1. Furthermore, device 1 showed switching behavior of semiconducting properties by electric field poling and thermal annealing cycle. The electric field response of ferroelectrics modulated the molecular orientation and conduction properties of organic semiconductors, resulting in external electric field control of carrier transport properties.

Ultrafine Spatial Modulation of Diazapyrene-Based Two-Dimensional Conjugated Covalent Organic Frameworks.

Tailormade bottom-up synthesis of covalent organic frameworks (COFs) from various functional building blocks offer not only tunable topology and pore size but also multidimensional properties. High crystallinity is one of the prerequisites for their structures and associated physicochemical properties. Among different π-conjugated motifs for constructing COFs, pyrene-based tetragonal structures are effective in achieving highly ordered and crystalline states. In the present research, we demonstrated that the substitution of pyrene with 2,7-diazapyrene produces nearly "flat" structures of two-dimensional (2D) COF layers by controlling the torsional angle of linker molecules. Featuring finite pore diameters and excellent thermodynamic stability of ∼500 °C, ordered face-to-face (slipped AA) stacking arrangements were produced. Extended electrical conjugation spanning 2D frames with modest optical bandgaps (Eg) of ∼2.1 eV shows the planar character of diazapyrene-based COFs. The stacking of the conjugated 2D frames with small Eg values is also beneficial for the formation of highly stable conducting pathways in the crystalline state, which was confirmed by the results of the microwave conductivity measurements. Nitrogen centers in diazapyrene units also play a key role as the active sites for proton transfer, and the maximum proton conductivity of σ = 10-2 S cm-1 was achieved along the cocontinuous nanopore structures surrounded by the active sites. Results show that tetragonal COFs based on diazapyrene can be used as a highly crystalline two-dimensional material with special electrical and proton-conducting capabilities.

Responsive Chirality: Tailoring Supramolecular Assemblies with External Stimuli as Future Platforms for Electronic/ Spintronic Materials.

Supramolecular chirality is the major branch of supramolecular chemistry, which not only plays important roles in biological processes but also in synthetically designed aggregated systems.  To understand the complex processing of biological systems, the only way is to design supramolecular chiral ensembles that mimic natural biomolecules such as Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), Ribonucleic acid (RNA), amino acids, etc.  In addition, chiral systems and self-assemblies as molecular motifs with breaking spatial inversion symmetry have been regarded as key substances in electronics and spintronics as well as in fundamental chemistry and physics. Here, in this review, our major concern is understanding modulation in spatial arrangements and packing modes under the impact of any external stimuli, which results in tailoring the handedness of resulted supramolecular chiral superstructures. We, in this review, highlighted the role of external stimuli such as solvent, chemical additives, photo exposure, etc. in altering the supramolecular chirality for their future utility as "active switches" in optoelectronic and spintronic devices and applications.

Urea-Comprising Single Core Diketopyrrolopyrrole Derivatives: Exploring the Synthesis, Self-Assembly and Charge Transport Properties.

Supramolecular electronics exploits the distinctive features stemming from noncovalent interactions, guiding the self-assembly of molecules to craft materials endowed with customized electronic functionalities. Hydrogen-bonded materials, characterized by their capacity to establish dynamic and stable networks, introduce an extra dimension to the development of supramolecular electronic systems. This study presents a comparative analysis of two remarkably small semiconductors utilizing diketopyrrolopyrrole functionalized with urea units as hydrogen-bonding motifs, strategically positioned at opposing ends of the conjugated core. We show how the subtle distinction in functionalization not only influences morphology and self-assembly dynamics via hydrogen-bonding and π-π stacking formation, but also holds significant consequences for ultimate charge transport properties. Our observations into the interplay of noncovalent interactions provide valuable insights and strategic pathways for the design of novel materials with enhanced electronic characteristics.

Amplified spontaneous emission from a liquid crystalline phase: anisotropic property and active modulation.

Amplified spontaneous emission (ASE) is considered to be a primary indication of optical gain in active media without an external resonator. Molecular materials with ASE are expected to be one of the suitable light sources for specific applications such as optical coherent tomography owing to their low coherence and flexible tunability. Concentration quenching of emissive excited states has been a critical issue to boost the quantum efficiency of molecular materials in their condensed phases. The rod-like design of molecules with excited state intramolecular proton transfer (ESIPT) has been demonstrated to overcome this issue in highly-concentrated molecularly-doped systems, as represented by C4alkyne-HBT (2-(4-(1-hexynyl)-2-hydroxyphenyl)-benzothiazole). We designed an ESIPT molecule-doped liquid crystalline (LC) system for optical amplification via the ASE regime with its wide tunability of emission intensity. Detailed ASE behaviour and optical gain of a LC blend of C4alkyne-HBT and 4-pentyl-4'-cyano biphenyl (5CB) was evaluated to afford a maximum optical gain of 16.5 cm-1 with an estimated ASE threshold of optical pumping at 0.6-0.7 mJ cm-2. Although most ASE studies focus on homogeneous solutions, solids, or crystalline states, ASE from a soft-flexible LC phase is quite limited and advantageous for the design of an external optical resonator/cavity structure. Optical excitation parallel and perpendicular to the director resulted in the strong modulation of the ASE. By using the benefits of a LC phase, the ASE was actively modulated under the external electric field by the reorientation of the molecular dipole moment.

Two-Step Synthesis of B2 N2 -Doped Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon Containing Pentagonal and Heptagonal Rings with Long-Lived Delayed Fluorescence.

Pentagon-heptagon embedded polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) have aroused increasing attention in recent years due to their unique physicochemical properties. Here, for the first time, this report demonstrates a facile method for the synthesis of a novel B2 N2 -doped PAH (BN-2) containing two pairs of pentagonal and heptagonal rings in only two steps. In the solid state of BN-2, two different conformations, including saddle-shaped and up-down geometries, are observed. Through a combined spectroscopic and calculation study, the excited-state dynamics of BN-2 is well-investigated in this current work. The resultant pentagon-heptagon embedded B2 N2 -doped BN-2 displays both prompt fluorescence and long-lived delayed fluorescence components at room temperature, with the triplet excited-state lifetime in the microsecond time region (τ = 19 µs). The triplet-triplet annihilation is assigned as the mechanism for the observed long-lived delayed fluorescence. Computational analyses attributed this observation to the small energy separation between the singlet and triplet excited states, facilitating the intersystem crossing (ISC) process which is further validated by the ultrafast spectroscopic measurements.

Intracardiac Thrombosis and Systemic Embolism in a Patient with Cardiac Amyloidosis in Sinus Rhythm.

Intracardiac thrombosis formation in patients in sinus rhythm is a rare phenomenon. An 84-year-old woman was admitted because of worsening dyspnea on exertion. An electrocardiogram showed sinus rhythm, left atrial overload, marked left axis deviation, low voltage, and poor r-wave progression in leads V1-4. An echocardiogram showed relatively preserved left ventricular ejection fraction with minimal wall thickening. Her serum level of B-type natriuretic peptide (931 pg/mL) was markedly elevated and a diagnosis of worsening heart failure was made. During the course of treatment for heart failure, she was complicated by acute abdominal aortic thromboembolism together with left atrial thrombus. An emergency abdominal aortic thrombectomy was followed by the removal of a left atrial thrombus 2 days later. Left ventricular biopsy performed during the surgery revealed amyloid deposits in the myocardial interstitium. Immunohistochemical study confirmed the diagnosis of transthyretin cardiac amyloidosis. It is postulated that the risk of intracardiac thrombosis and systemic embolism is increased even in sinus rhythm in patients with cardiac amyloidosis.

Synthesis of Closed-Heterohelicenes Interconvertible between Their Monomeric and Dimeric Forms.

Oxidative fusion reaction of cyclic heteroaromatic pentads consisting of pyrrole and thiophene gave closed-heterohelicene monomers and dimers depending on the oxidation conditions. Specifically, oxidation with [bis(trifluoroacetoxy)iodo]benzene (PIFA) gave closed-[7]helicene dimers connected at the ß-position of one of the pyrrole units with remarkably elongated C-C bonds of about 1.60 Å. Although this bond was intact against thermal and physical activations, homolytic bond dissociation took place in DMSO upon irradiation with UV light to give the corresponding monomers. Thus, interconversion between the closed-helicene monomer and dimer was achieved. The optically pure dimer was photo-dissociated into the monomers associated with a turn-on of circularly polarized luminescence (CPL).

Single Crystalline, Non-stoichiometric Cocrystals of Hydrogen-Bonded Organic Frameworks.

Porous frameworks composed of non-stoichiometrically mixed multicomponent molecules attract much attention from a functional viewpoint. However, their designed preparation and precise structural characterization remain challenging. Herein, we demonstrate that cocrystallization of tetrakis(4-carboxyphenyl)hexahydropyrene and pyrene derivatives (CP-Hp and CP-Py, respectively) yields non-stoichiometric mixed frameworks through networking via hydrogen bonding. The composition ratio of CP-Hp and CP-Py in the framework was determined by single crystalline X-ray crystallographic analysis, indicating that the mixed frameworks were formed over a wide range of composition ratios. Furthermore, microscopic Raman spectroscopy on the single crystal indicates that the components are not uniformly distributed such as ideal solid solution, but are done gradationally or inhomogeneously.

Charge-Segregated Stacking Structure with Anisotropic Electric Conductivity in NIR-Absorbing and Emitting Positively Charged π-Electronic Systems.

Squarylium-based π-electronic cation with an augmented dipole was synthesized by methylation of zwitterionic squarylium. The cation formed various ion pairs in combination with anions, and the ion pairs exhibited distinct photophysical properties in the dispersed state, ascribed to the formation of J- and H-aggregates. The ion pairs provided solid-state assemblies based on cation stacking. It is noteworthy that complete segregation of cations and anions was observed in a pseudo-polymorph of the ion pair with pentacyanocyclopentadienide as a π-electronic anion. In the crystalline state, the ion pairs exhibited photophysical properties and electric conductivity derived from cation stacking. In particular, the charge-segregated ion-pairing assembly induces an electric conductive pathway along the stacking axis. The charge-segregated mode and fascinating properties were derived from the reduced electrostatic repulsion between adjacent π-electronic cations via dipole-dipole interactions.

Twelve-month safety and effectiveness of TCD-17187 drug-coated balloon for the treatment of atherosclerotic lesions in the superficial femoral and proximal popliteal artery.

PURPOSE: The aim of this preapproval trial was to evaluate the 12-month safety and effectiveness of the TCD-17187 drug-coated balloon (DCB) for the treatment of atherosclerotic lesions in the superficial femoral artery (SFA) and/or proximal popliteal artery (PA). METHODS: This was a prospective, multicenter, core laboratory adjudicated, single-arm trial. From October 2019 to November 2020, a total of 121 symptomatic peripheral artery disease patients with SFA and/or proximal PA lesions were enrolled. The primary effectiveness endpoint was 12-month primary patency defined as freedom from restenosis as determined by duplex ultrasonography in the absence of clinically driven target lesion revascularization (CD-TLR). The safety endpoint was the major adverse event (MAE) rate defined as freedom from a composite of device- and procedure-related death within 30 days, and index limb major amputation and/or CD-TLR through follow-up. RESULTS: Average age was 74.5 ± 7.3 years and the frequency of diabetes mellitus was 67.5%. Average lesion length and vessel diameter were 106.0 ± 52.6 and 5.2 ± 0.8 mm, respectively. The frequency of chronic total occlusion and bilateral calcification was 17.5% and 50.8% of patients, respectively. The 12-month primary patency rate calculated by Kaplan-Meier analysis was 81.1%, while 12-month freedom from CD-TLR was 95.8%. The MAE rate at 30 days was 1.7% and all events comprised CD-TLR. There were no instances of device- or procedure-related deaths, major amputations, or thrombosis throughout the 12-month evaluation period. CONCLUSION: This preapproval trial confirmed the safety and effectiveness of TCD-17187 DCB in the treatment of atherosclerotic lesions in the SFA and/or proximal PA.

Incidence and Clinical Characteristics of Takotsubo Syndrome in Patients with Subarachnoid Hemorrhage.

Although takotsubo syndrome (TTS) has been reported in patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH), its incidence and relation to the severity of SAH are unknown.Of 319 consecutive patients with aneurysmal SAH, 245 patients who underwent both the ECG and echocardiography were analyzed.The incidence of TTS was 6.9% (22 patients (21 women), median age 68 years (range, 60-83) ). Regional wall motion abnormalities were present as apical (64%), mid-ventricular (9%), basal (4%) and focal (23%) forms. Heart failure was found in 10 patients (45%) but there was no cardiac death. Regarding SAH severity, 10 patients (45%) with TTS were in World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies classification grade V, as compared to 40 patients (18%) without TTS (P = 0.005). Seven patients (32%) with TTS died during hospitalization, as compared to 26 patients (12%) without TTS (P = 0.018). Four patients (18%) with TTS were estimated as independent at discharge, as compared to 100 patients (45%) without TTS (P = 0.013).The incidence of TTS in patients with SAH was estimated as 6.9% with significant predominance of women. The severity of SAH was significantly greater in patients with TTS than in those without TTS.

Dibenzodiazapyracylenes: Doubly N-Doped Cyclopenta-Fused Polycyclic Molecules That Exhibit High Carrier Mobility.

Pyracylene is a unique cyclopenta-fused polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (CP-PAH) that exhibits dual aromatic characteristics. Herein we report the synthesis of doubly N-doped benzannulated pyracylenes, namely dibenzodiazapyracylenes, by oxidative N-N linking reaction of [2.2](2,5)pyrrolophane-type precursors. Dibenzodiazapyracylenes displayed well-ordered π-stacked molecular packing in the solid state, which were feasible for effective hole-transporting along the stacking direction. High carrier mobility was estimated by microwave conductivity measurements as compared to dibenzoullazine. The high HOMO level of dibenzodiazapyracylene was verified by electrochemistry and its persistent radical cation species has been detected.

A Supramolecular Polymer Constituted of Antiaromatic NiII Norcorroles.

For the creation of next-generation organic electronic materials, the integration of π-systems has recently become a central theme. Such functional materials can be assembled by supramolecular polymerization when aromatic π-systems are used as monomers, and the properties of the resulting supramolecular polymer strongly depend on the electronic structure of the monomers. Here, we demonstrate the construction of a supramolecular polymer consisting of an antiaromatic π-system as the monomer. An amide-functionalized NiII norcorrole derivative formed a one-dimensional supramolecular polymer through π-π stacking and hydrogen-bonding interactions, ensuring the persistency of the conducting pathway against thermal perturbation, which results in higher charge mobility along the tightly bound linear aggregates than that of the aromatic analogue composed of ZnII porphyrins.

Crystal Lattice Design of H2O-Tolerant n-Type Semiconducting Dianionic Naphthalenediimide Derivatives.

Dianionic bis(propionate)-naphthalenediimide (PCNDI2-) formed simple 2:1 cation-anion salts of (M+)2(PCNDI2-)·(H2O)n (M+ = Li+, Na+, K+, Rb+, and Cs+), which exhibited reversible H2O adsorption-desorption behavior because of the presence of their electrostatically binding crystal lattices. The maximum H2O adsorption amounts (n) for M+ = Li+, Na+, K+, Rb+, and Cs+ were 0.25, 6.0, 4.0, 6.0, and 2.0, respectively, whereas the reversible gate-opening (gate-closing) H2O adsorption-desorption isotherms were observed at 273 and 298 K, except for M+ = Li+. High ionic conductivities of around 10-4-10-5 S cm-1 were observed in M+ = Na+ and K+ salts, whereas short-range thermal fluctuations occurred in large cations of M+ = Rb+ and Cs+. The change in the electrostatic lattice energy for M+ = Na+ and K+ salts during the H2O adsorption-desorption cycles was significantly larger than those for M+ = Rb+ and Cs+. Therefore, the Na+ and K+ salts had a considerably flexible electrostatic crystal lattice with a large amplitude of lattice modulation during the H2O sorption cycle. In contrast, the lattice modulation for M+ = Rb+ and Cs+ salts involved a low magnitude of ion displacements, forming a relatively rigid cation-anion electrostatic crystal lattice. The flash-photolysis time-resolved microwave conductivity and transition absorption spectroscopy results revealed the high electron mobility of H2O-adsorbed thin films, wherein the crystallized H2O molecules did not act as electron-trapping sites. The values of electron mobility increased in the order of Cs+ ≈ Rb+ > K+ > Na+ > Li+.

Dendritic-Like Molecules Built on a Pillar[5]arene Core as Hole Transporting Materials for Perovskite Solar Cells.

Multi-branched molecules have recently demonstrated interesting behaviour as charge-transporting materials within the fields of perovskite solar cells (PSCs). For this reason, extended triarylamine dendrons have been grafted onto a pillar[5]arene core to generate dendrimer-like compounds, which have been used as hole-transporting materials (HTMs) for PSCs. The performances of the solar cells containing these novel compounds have been extensively investigated. Interestingly, a positive dendritic effect has been evidenced as the hole transporting properties are improved when going from the first to the second-generation compound. The stability of the devices based on the best performing pillar[5]arene material has been also evaluated in a high-throughput ageing setup for 500 h at high temperature. When compared to reference devices prepared from spiro-OMeTAD, the behaviour is similar. An analysis of the economic advantages arising from the use of the pillar[5]arene-based material revealed however that our pillar[5]arene-based material is cheaper than the reference.