TBAJ-876 Retains Bedaquiline's Activity against Subunits c and ε of Mycobacterium tuberculosis F-ATP Synthase.

The antituberculosis drug bedaquiline (BDQ) inhibits Mycobacterium tuberculosis F-ATP synthase by interfering with two subunits. Drug binding to the c subunit stalls the rotation of the c ring, while binding to the ε subunit blocks coupling of c ring rotation to ATP synthesis at the catalytic α3:ß3 headpiece. BDQ is used for the treatment of drug-resistant tuberculosis. However, the drug is highly lipophilic, displays a long terminal half-life, and has a cardiotoxicity liability by causing QT interval prolongation. Recent medicinal chemistry campaigns have resulted in the discovery of 3,5-dialkoxypyridine analogues of BDQ that are less lipophilic, have higher clearance, and display lower cardiotoxic potential. TBAJ-876, which is a new developmental compound of this series, shows attractive antitubercular activity and efficacy in a murine tuberculosis model. Here, we asked whether TBAJ-876 and selected analogues of the compound retain BDQ's mechanism of action. Biochemical assays showed that TBAJ-876 is a potent inhibitor of mycobacterial F-ATP synthase. Selection of spontaneous TBAJ-876-resistant mutants identified missense mutations at BDQ's binding site on the c subunit, suggesting that TBAJ-876 retains BDQ's targeting of the c ring. Susceptibility testing against a strain overexpressing the ε subunit and a strain harboring an engineered mutation in BDQ's ε subunit binding site suggest that TBAJ-876 retains BDQ's activity on the ε subunit. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) titration studies confirmed that TBAJ-876 binds to the ε subunit at BDQ's binding site. We show that TBAJ-876 retains BDQ's antimycobacterial mode of action. The developmental compound inhibits the mycobacterial F-ATP synthase via a dual-subunit mechanism of interfering with the functions of both the enzyme's c and ε subunits.

Structure of the γ-ε complex of cyanobacterial F1-ATPase reveals a suppression mechanism of the γ subunit on ATP hydrolysis in phototrophs.

F1-ATPase forms the membrane-associated segment of F0F1-ATP synthase - the fundamental enzyme complex in cellular bioenergetics for ATP hydrolysis and synthesis. Here, we report a crystal structure of the central F1 subcomplex, consisting of the rotary shaft γ subunit and the inhibitory ε subunit, from the photosynthetic cyanobacterium Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1, at 1.98 Šresolution. In contrast with their homologous bacterial and mitochondrial counterparts, the γ subunits of photosynthetic organisms harbour a unique insertion of 35-40 amino acids. Our structural data reveal that this region forms a ß-hairpin structure along the central stalk. We identified numerous critical hydrogen bonds and electrostatic interactions between residues in the hairpin and the rest of the γ subunit. To elaborate the critical function of this ß-hairpin in inhibiting ATP hydrolysis, the corresponding domain was deleted in the cyanobacterial F1 subcomplex. Biochemical analyses of the corresponding α3ß3γ complex confirm that the clinch of the hairpin structure plays a critical role and accounts for a significant interaction in the α3ß3 complex to induce ADP inhibition during ATP hydrolysis. In addition, we found that truncating the ß-hairpin insertion structure resulted in a marked impairment of the interaction with the ε subunit, which binds to the opposite side of the γ subunit from the ß-hairpin structure. Combined with structural analyses, our work provides experimental evidence supporting the molecular principle of how the insertion region of the γ subunit suppresses F1 rotation during ATP hydrolysis.

Modulation of coupling in the Escherichia coli ATP synthase by ADP and Pi: Role of the ε subunit C-terminal domain.

The ε-subunit of ATP-synthase is an endogenous inhibitor of the hydrolysis activity of the complex and its α-helical C-terminal domain (εCTD) undergoes drastic changes among at least two different conformations. Even though this domain is not essential for ATP synthesis activity, there is evidence for its involvement in the coupling mechanism of the pump. Recently, it was proposed that coupling of the ATP synthase can vary as a function of ADP and Pi concentration. In the present work, we have explored the possible role of the εCTD in this ADP- and Pi-dependent coupling, by examining an εCTD-lacking mutant of Escherichia coli. We show that the loss of Pi-dependent coupling can be observed also in the εCTD-less mutant, but the effects of Pi on both proton pumping and ATP hydrolysis were much weaker in the mutant than in the wild-type. We also show that the εCTD strongly influences the binding of ADP to a very tight binding site (half-maximal effect≈1nM); binding at this site induces higher coupling in EFOF1 and increases responses to Pi. It is proposed that one physiological role of the εCTD is to regulate the kinetics and affinity of ADP/Pi binding, promoting ADP/Pi-dependent coupling.

On the ATP binding site of the ε subunit from bacterial F-type ATP synthases.

F-type ATP synthases are reversible machinery that not only synthesize adenosine triphosphate (ATP) using an electrochemical gradient across the membrane, but also can hydrolyze ATP to pump ions under certain conditions. To prevent wasteful ATP hydrolysis, subunit ε in bacterial ATP synthases changes its conformation from the non-inhibitory down- to the inhibitory up-state at a low cellular ATP concentration. Recently, a crystal structure of the ε subunit in complex with ATP was solved in a non-biologically relevant dimeric form. Here, to derive the functional ATP binding site motif, we carried out molecular dynamics simulations and free energy calculations. Our results suggest that the ATP binding site markedly differs from the experimental resolved one; we observe a reorientation of several residues, which bind to ATP in the crystal structure. In addition we find that an Mg(2+) ion is coordinated by ATP, replacing interactions of the second chain in the crystal structure. Thus we demonstrate more generally the influence of crystallization effects on ligand binding sites and their respective binding modes. Furthermore, we propose a role for two highly conserved residues to control the ATP binding/unbinding event, which have not been considered before. Additionally our results provide the basis for the rational development of new biosensors based on subunit ε, as shown previously for novel sensors measuring the ATP concentration in cells.

Inhibition of F1-ATPase rotational catalysis by the carboxyl-terminal domain of the ϵ subunit.

Escherichia coli ATP synthase (F0F1) couples catalysis and proton transport through subunit rotation. The ϵ subunit, an endogenous inhibitor, lowers F1-ATPase activity by decreasing the rotation speed and extending the duration of the inhibited state (Sekiya, M., Hosokawa, H., Nakanishi-Matsui, M., Al-Shawi, M. K., Nakamoto, R. K., and Futai, M. (2010) Single molecule behavior of inhibited and active states of Escherichia coli ATP synthase F1 rotation. J. Biol. Chem. 285, 42058-42067). In this study, we constructed a series of ϵ subunits truncated successively from the carboxyl-terminal domain (helix 1/loop 2/helix 2) and examined their effects on rotational catalysis (ATPase activity, average rotation rate, and duration of inhibited state). As expected, the ϵ subunit lacking helix 2 caused about ½-fold reduced inhibition, and that without loop 2/helix 2 or helix 1/loop 2/helix 2 showed a further reduced effect. Substitution of ϵSer(108) in loop 2 and ϵTyr(114) in helix 2, which possibly interact with the ß and γ subunits, respectively, decreased the inhibitory effect. These results suggest that the carboxyl-terminal domain of the ϵ subunit plays a pivotal role in the inhibition of F1 rotation through interaction with other subunits.

Elastic rotation of Escherichia coli F(O)F(1) having ε subunit fused with cytochrome b(562) or flavodoxin reductase.

Intra-molecular rotation of FOF1 ATP synthase enables cooperative synthesis and hydrolysis of ATP. In this study, using a small gold bead probe, we observed fast rotation close to the real rate that would be exhibited without probes. Using this experimental system, we tested the rotation of FOF1 with the ε subunit connected to a globular protein [cytochrome b562 (ε-Cyt) or flavodoxin reductase (ε-FlavR)], which is apparently larger than the space between the central and the peripheral stalks. The enzymes containing ε-Cyt and ε-FlavR showed continual rotations with average rates of 185 and 148 rps, respectively, similar to the wild type (172 rps). However, the enzymes with ε-Cyt or ε-FlavR showed a reduced proton transport. These results indicate that the intra-molecular rotation is elastic but proton transport requires more strict subunit/subunit interaction.

Epsilon subunit of T-complex protein-1 from Leishmania donovani: A tetrameric chaperonin.

The cytosolic T-complex protein-1 ring complex (TRiC), also referred as chaperonin containing TCP-1(CCT), comprising eight different subunits stacked in double toroidal rings, binds to around 10 % of newly synthesized polypeptides and facilitates their folding in ATP dependent manner. In Leishmania, among five subunits of TCP1 complex, identified either by transcriptome or by proteome analysis, only LdTCP1γ has been well characterized. It forms biologically active homo-oligomeric complex and plays role in protein folding and parasite survival. Lack of information regarding rest of the TCP1 subunits and its structural configuration laid down the necessity to study individual subunits and their role in parasite pathogenicity. The present study involves the cloning, expression and biochemical characterization of TCP1ε subunit (LdTCP1ε) of Leishmania donovani, the causative agent of visceral leishmaniasis. LdTCP1ε exhibited significant difference in primary structure as compared to LdTCP1γ and was evolutionary close to LdTCP1 zeta subunit. Recombinant protein (rLdTCP1ε) exhibited two major bands of 132 kDa and 240 kDa on native-PAGE that corresponds to the dimeric and tetrameric assembly of the epsilon subunit, which showed the chaperonin activity (ATPase and luciferase refolding activity). LdTCP1ε also displayed an increased expression upto 2.7- and 1.8-fold in the late log phase and stationary phase promastigotes and exhibited majorly vesicular localization. The study, thus for the first time, provides an insight for the presence of highly diverge but functionally active dimeric/tetrameric TCP1 epsilon subunit in Leishmania parasite.

Regulation of bacterial ATP synthase activity: A gear-shifting or a pawl-ratchet mechanism?

The F1 Fo -ATP synthase, a widely distributed nanomotor responsible of ATP synthesis, rotates its central rotor reversibly: In the clockwise direction when viewed from the Fo (with the observer facing the positive side of the energy transducing membrane and looking down into the negative side of the membrane), it functions as ATP synthase, while in counterclockwise sense, it operates as a proton-pumping ATP hydrolase. Regulation exerted by naturally occurring inhibitory proteins of the enzyme appears to function by avoiding ATP hydrolysis while preserving ATP synthesis. The work of Liu et al. describes an unbiased, elegant analytical pipeline that provides important insights into the inhibitory role of the ε-subunit of the bacterial F1 Fo -ATP synthase in vivo. We discuss if a gear-shifting versus a pawl-ratchet mechanism may explain the regulatory role of the ε-subunit.

Regulation of ATP hydrolysis by the ε subunit, ζ subunit and Mg-ADP in the ATP synthase of Paracoccus denitrificans.

F1FO-ATP synthase is a crucial metabolic enzyme that uses the proton motive force from respiration to regenerate ATP. For maximum thermodynamic efficiency ATP synthesis should be fully reversible, but the enzyme from Paracoccus denitrificans catalyzes ATP hydrolysis at far lower rates than it catalyzes ATP synthesis, an effect often attributed to its unique ζ subunit. Recently, we showed that deleting ζ increases hydrolysis only marginally, indicating that other common inhibitory mechanisms such as inhibition by the C-terminal domain of the ε subunit (ε-CTD) or Mg-ADP may be more important. Here, we created mutants lacking the ε-CTD, and double mutants lacking both the ε-CTD and ζ subunit. No substantial activation of ATP hydrolysis was observed in any of these strains. Instead, hydrolysis in even the double mutant strains could only be activated by oxyanions, the detergent lauryldimethylamine oxide, or a proton motive force, which are all considered to release Mg-ADP inhibition. Our results establish that P. denitrificans ATP synthase is regulated by a combination of the ε and ζ subunits and Mg-ADP inhibition.

ATP-binding affinity of the ε subunit of thermophilic F1-ATPase under label-free conditions.

The ε subunits of several bacterial F1-ATPases bind ATP. ATP binding to the ε subunit has been shown to be involved in the regulation of F1-ATPase from thermophilic Bacillus sp. PS3 (TF1). We previously reported that the dissociation constant for ATP of wild-type ε subunit of TF1 at 25 °C is 4.3 µM by measuring changes in the fluorescence of the dye attached to the ε subunit (Kato, S. et al. (2007) J. Biol. Chem. 282, 37618). However, we have recently noticed that this varies with the dye used. In this report, to determine the affinity for ATP under label-free conditions, we have measured the competitive displacement of 2'(3')-O-N'-methylaniloyl-aminoadenosine-5'-triphosphate (Mant-ATP), a fluorescent analog of ATP, by ATP. The dissociation constant for ATP of wild-type ε subunit of TF1 at 25 °C was determined to be 0.29 µM, which is one order of magnitude higher affinity than previously reported values.

C-terminal regulatory domain of the ε subunit of Fo F1 ATP synthase enhances the ATP-dependent H+ pumping that is involved in the maintenance of cellular membrane potential in Bacillus subtilis.

The ε subunit of Fo F1 -ATPase/synthase (Fo F1 ) plays a crucial role in regulating Fo F1 activity. To understand the physiological significance of the ε subunit-mediated regulation of Fo F1 in Bacillus subtilis, we constructed and characterized a mutant harboring a deletion in the C-terminal regulatory domain of the ε subunit (ε∆C ). Analyses using inverted membrane vesicles revealed that the ε∆C mutation decreased ATPase activity and the ATP-dependent H+ -pumping activity of Fo F1 . To enhance the effects of ε∆C mutation, this mutation was introduced into a ∆rrn8 strain harboring only two of the 10 rrn (rRNA) operons (∆rrn8 ε∆C mutant strain). Interestingly, growth of the ∆rrn8 ε∆C mutant stalled at late-exponential phase. During the stalled growth phase, the membrane potential of the ∆rrn8 ε∆C mutant cells was significantly reduced, which led to a decrease in the cellular level of 70S ribosomes. The growth stalling was suppressed by adding glucose into the culture medium. Our findings suggest that the C-terminal region of the ε subunit is important for alleviating the temporal reduction in the membrane potential, by enhancing the ATP-dependent H+ -pumping activity of Fo F1 .

Re-Understanding the Mechanisms of Action of the Anti-Mycobacterial Drug Bedaquiline.

Bedaquiline (BDQ) inhibits ATP generation in Mycobacterium tuberculosis by interfering with the F-ATP synthase activity. Two mechanisms of action of BDQ are broadly accepted. A direct mechanism involves BDQ binding to the enzyme's c-ring to block its rotation, thus inhibiting ATP synthesis in the enzyme's catalytic α3ß3-headpiece. An indirect mechanism involves BDQ uncoupling electron transport in the electron transport chain from ATP synthesis at the F-ATP synthase. In a recently uncovered second direct mechanism, BDQ binds to the enzyme's ε-subunit to disrupt its ability to link c-ring rotation to ATP synthesis at the α3ß3-headpiece. However, this mechanism is controversial as the drug's binding affinity for the isolated ε-subunit protein is moderate and spontaneous resistance mutants in the ε-subunit cannot be isolated. Recently, the new, structurally distinct BDQ analogue TBAJ-876 was utilized as a chemical probe to revisit BDQ's mechanisms of action. In this review, we first summarize discoveries on BDQ's mechanisms of action and then describe the new insights derived from the studies of TBAJ-876. The TBAJ-876 investigations confirm the c-ring as a target, while also supporting a functional role for targeting the ε-subunit. Surprisingly, the new findings suggest that the uncoupler mechanism does not play a key role in BDQ's anti-mycobacterial activity.

Single mutations in the ε subunit from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 generate a high binding affinity site for ATP.

The ε subunit from ATP synthases acts as an ATP sensor in the bacterial cell to prevent ATP hydrolysis and thus the waste of ATP under conditions of low ATP concentration. However, the ATP binding affinities from various bacterial organisms differ markedly, over several orders of magnitude. For example, the ATP synthases from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 and Escherichia coli exhibit affinities of 4 µM and 22 mM, respectively. The recently reported R103A/R115A double mutant of Bacillus PS3 ATP synthase demonstrated an increased binding affinity by two orders of magnitude with respect to the wild type. Here, we used atomic-resolution molecular dynamics simulations to determine the role of the R103A and R115A single mutations. These lead us to predict that both single mutations also cause an increased ATP binding affinity. Evolutionary analysis reveals R103 and R115 substitutions in the ε subunit from other bacillic organisms, leading us to predict they likely have a higher ATP binding affinity than previously expected.

Structure of a thermophilic F1-ATPase inhibited by an ε-subunit: deeper insight into the ε-inhibition mechanism.

F1-ATPase (F1) is the catalytic sector in F(o)F1-ATP synthase that is responsible for ATP production in living cells. In catalysis, its three catalytic ß-subunits undergo nucleotide occupancy-dependent and concerted open-close conformational changes that are accompanied by rotation of the γ-subunit. Bacterial and chloroplast F1 are inhibited by their own ε-subunit. In the ε-inhibited Escherichia coli F1 structure, the ε-subunit stabilizes the overall conformation (half-closed, closed, open) of the ß-subunits by inserting its C-terminal helix into the α3ß3 cavity. The structure of ε-inhibited thermophilic F1 is similar to that of E. coli F1, showing a similar conformation of the ε-subunit, but the thermophilic ε-subunit stabilizes another unique overall conformation (open, closed, open) of the ß-subunits. The ε-C-terminal helix 2 and hook are conserved between the two structures in interactions with target residues and in their positions. Rest of the ε-C-terminal domains are in quite different conformations and positions, and have different modes of interaction with targets. This region is thought to serve ε-inhibition differently. For inhibition, the ε-subunit contacts the second catches of some of the ß- and α-subunits, the N- and C-terminal helices, and some of the Rossmann fold segments. Those contacts, as a whole, lead to positioning of those ß- and α- second catches in ε-inhibition-specific positions, and prevent rotation of the γ-subunit. Some of the structural features are observed even in IF1 inhibition in mitochondrial F1.

Regulatory conformational changes of the ε subunit in single FRET-labeled FoF1-ATP synthase.

Subunit ε is an intrinsic regulator of the bacterial FoF1-ATP synthase, the ubiquitous membrane-embedded enzyme that utilizes a proton motive force in most organisms to synthesize adenosine triphosphate (ATP). The C-terminal domain of ε can extend into the central cavity formed by the α and ß subunits, as revealed by the recent X-ray structure of the F1 portion of the Escherichia coli enzyme. This insertion blocks the rotation of the central γ subunit and, thereby, prevents wasteful ATP hydrolysis. Here we aim to develop an experimental system that can reveal conditions under which ε inhibits the holoenzyme FoF1-ATP synthase in vitro. Labeling the C-terminal domain of ε and the γ subunit specifically with two different fluorophores for single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) allowed monitoring of the conformation of ε in the reconstituted enzyme in real time. New mutants were made for future three-color smFRET experiments to unravel the details of regulatory conformational changes in ε.

The regulatory switch of F1-ATPase studied by single-molecule FRET in the ABEL Trap.

F1-ATPase is the soluble portion of the membrane-embedded enzyme FoF1-ATP synthase that catalyzes the production of adenosine triphosphate in eukaryotic and eubacterial cells. In reverse, the F1 part can also hydrolyze ATP quickly at three catalytic binding sites. Therefore, catalysis of 'non-productive' ATP hydrolysis by F1 (or FoF1) must be minimized in the cell. In bacteria, the ε subunit is thought to control and block ATP hydrolysis by mechanically inserting its C-terminus into the rotary motor region of F1. We investigate this proposed mechanism by labeling F1 specifically with two fluorophores to monitor the C-terminus of the ε subunit by Förster resonance energy transfer. Single F1 molecules are trapped in solution by an Anti-Brownian electrokinetic trap which keeps the FRET-labeled F1 in place for extended observation times of several hundreds of milliseconds, limited by photobleaching. FRET changes in single F1 and FRET histograms for different biochemical conditions are compared to evaluate the proposed regulatory mechanism.