Validation of the repeatable battery for the assessment of neuropsychological status--effort index in a veteran sample.

ABSTRACT

The RBANS Effort Index (RBANS-EI; Silverberg, Wertheimer, & Fichtenberg, 2007) is an embedded measure of effort within a frequently employed neuropsychological screening battery. While it has been criticized for inadequate specificity in older non-litigating samples (Hook, Marquine, & Hoelzle, 2009; Warren et al., 2010), the RBANS-EI has yet to be investigated in a non-geriatric veteran sample. Archival data were collected from 85 veterans who completed the RBANS and WMT within either a routine neuropsychological evaluation (n = 66) or compensation evaluation (n = 19). At a cutoff of >3 RBANS-EI exhibited strong specificity (.94) yet limited sensitivity (.31) in the prediction of WMT performance. Examination of RBANS-EI component subtests found that List Recognition <17 had strong specificity (.90) and moderate sensitivity (.52) in discriminating WMT performance groups. In contrast, Digit Span performance was comparable between those passing and failing the WMT. Present findings indicate that both the RBANS-EI and List Recognition subtest may be useful in detecting suboptimal effort yet raise questions regarding the Digit Span component of the RBANS-EI.