Evaluation of the microbiological efficacy of cleaning agents for tracheostomy inner cannulas.

ABSTRACT

PURPOSE: Biofilms are a significant cause of morbidity in patients with indwelling medical devices. Biofilms pose a potential risk with reusable inner cannulas by increasing the risk of infections. Effective decontamination is thus vital in decreasing bioburden. The current guidelines for cleaning inner cannulas are varied, with multiple techniques being recommended, which are not supported by strong evidence. This randomized, controlled, cross-over study attempted to enumerate the bacterial count of inner cannulas used in tracheostomy patients (n = 60) pre-and post-decontamination with detergent (A) or sterile water (B). MATERIALS AND METHODS: The patients were randomly allocated to sequence A > B or B > A in 11 fashion. The saline flushing of the inner cannulas was plated on trypticase soy agar with 5 % sheep blood to enumerate the bacterial count. RESULTS: The mean ratio [Log (CFU)post/Log (CFU)pre]A/[Log (CFU)post/Log (CFU)pre]B based on 53 samples was 0.918 ± 0.470, two-sided 90 % confidence interval (CI) 0.812, 1.024. The equivalence criterion was met as the mean ratio after cleaning fell within the equivalence region of 0.8 and 1.25. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated the microbiological efficacy of both detergent and sterile water in the decontamination of inner cannulas, and that sterile water was not less effective than detergent in reducing the bacterial load for safe re-use of inner cannulas. This has the potential to promote cost savings for patients with tracheostomy, both in the hospital and the community. The study findings may also be relevant in formulating tracheostomy care policies.