Meta-analysis of Oral Chinese Medicine for Adjuvant Treatment of Primary Hepatic Carcinoma and Screening of Basic Chinese Herbs / 中国实验方剂学杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective:To systematically evaluate the efficacy of oral Chinese herbal prescriptions combined with transcatheter arterial chemoembolization （TACE） against primary hepatic carcinoma （PHC） and screen the basic Chinese herbs，in order to provide certain reference for clinical medication. Method:The randomized controlled trials concerning the treatment of PHC with oral Chinese herbal prescriptions plus TACE were retrieved from CBM，China National Knowledge Infrastructure （CNKI），Chongqing Weipu Database for Chinese Technical Periodicals （VIP），and Wanfang Data Knowledge Service Platform.The quality of the included trials was evaluated by Cochrane handbook，and the Meta-analysis was performed using RevMan 5.3.The enumeration data were expressed by odds ratio （OR），the measurement data by mean difference （MD） or standardized mean difference （SMD），and the effect size by 95% confidence interval （CI）.The data of oral Chinese herbal prescriptions involved in trials were sorted out and subjected to association rule analysis and frequency analysis based on the Traditional Chinese Medicine Inheritance Support System （TCMISS），for exploring the basic Chinese herbs and their dosages against PHC. Result:A total of 75 randomized controlled trials were included，involving 7 406 cases. As revealed by the Meta-analysis，oral Chinese herbal prescriptions combined with TACE was significantly better than TACE alone in improving the short-term curative effect ［OR=2.05，95%CI（1.83，2.29）］，decreasing alpha fetoprotein （AFP） ［MD=-59.02，95%CI（-79.03，-39.01）］，ameliorating liver function ［SMD=-1.23，95%CI（-1.58，-0.88）］，boosting immunity ［SMD=1.08，95%CI（0.84，1.32）］，adjusting Karnofsky Performance Status （KPS） scale score ［OR=2.7，95%CI（1.11，11.02）］，elevating survival rate ［OR=2.31，95%CI（1.96，2.71）］，and reducing adverse reactions ［OR=0.38，95%CI（0.34，0.43）］.Data mining results showed that the basic Chinese herbs against PHC were Bupleuri Radix，Paeoniae Alba Radix，Atractylodis Macrocephalae Rhizoma，Poria，and Glycyrrhizae Radix et Rhizoma，with their clinical dosages listed as follows：6-15 g for Bupleuri Radix，10-15 g for Paeoniae Alba Radix，9-15 g for Atractylodis Macrocephalae Rhizoma，10-15 g for Poria，and 3-10 g for Glycyrrhizae Radix et Rhizoma. Conclusion:The oral Chinese herbal prescriptions combined with TACE produce better effects in treatment of PHC as compared with TACE alone.These five basic Chinese herbs have anti-cancer effect，and their dosages are within the ranges stipulated in 2020 edition of <italic>Chinese Pharmacopoeia.</italic>This Meta-analysis has provided certain reference for clinical medication.