Comparison of China-and Germany-made Electromagnetic Lithotripters for Upper Urinary Tract Calculi:Preliminary Report of Perspective Study / 中国微创外科杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To perspectively compare the clinical outcomes of China-and Germany-made electromagnetic lithotripters in the treatment of upper urinary tract calculi.Methods Between January 2005 and August 2005,60 cases of upper urinary tract calculi were randomly divided into two groupsChina-made and Germany-made groups(30 in each).Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy(ESWL)was performed by a same group of surgeons.Results The stone-free rate was 73%(22/30)in China-made group,and was 90%(27/30)in Germany-made group 3 weeks after ESWL(?2=2.283,P=0.095);and was 100% in both the groups 3 months postoperation.The retreatment rate was 27%(8/30)in China-made group,and 10%(3/30)in Germany-made group(?2=2.283,P=0.095).The rate of auxiliary procedure in both the groups was 0.The efficacy quotient(EQ)was 0.79 in China-made group,and was 0.91 in Germany-made group.Totally,39 ESWLs were performed on the patients in China-made group,while 33 ESWLs were carried out in Germany-made group.The rates of macroscopic hematuria,skin injury,and renal colic were 87%(34/39),64%(25/39),and 8%(3/39)respectively in China-made group,and were 91%(30/33),6%(2/33),and 6%(2/33)in Germany-made group(?2=0.016,P=0.900;?2=25.693,P=0.000;and ?2=0.000,P=1.000;respectively).One patient in China-made group developed fever after ESWL,while no one in Germany-made group had the symptom.In both the groups,no patients had hematuria,renal edema,or subcutaneous perinephric hemorrhage.Conclusion Both China-and Germany-made electromagnetic lithotripters are effective,safety,and non-invasive.