Validation of a decision aid for familial hypercholesterolemia

ABSTRACT

Introduction: We validated the “Familial Hypercholesterolemia (FH) Decision Aid” to promote shared decision making (SDM) about lipid lowering therapy, based on patient-clinician encounters. Methods: Validation of the DA included an assessment of whether the content and design of the tool facilitated SDM and patient engagement and to determine how well the tool integrated with clinical workflow. Validation was conducted during patient-clinician encounters in the Mayo preventive cardiology clinic. As inclusion criteria we considered an upcoming appointment in the clinic, an LDL-C level ≥ ∼160 mg/dL, and no prior diagnosis of FH. Prior to the encounters, each clinician viewed a demonstration of the online, interactive DA. During the encounters, the DA was shared with patients using the clinic room computer screen, either in-person or virtually. Patientclinician encounters were video recorded for further analysis by two design researchers and experts in SDM. Results: Ten patients were enrolled in the study (7 male;average age 51 years). The average patient LDL-C level was 207 mg/dL, range 157 - 248 mg/dL. Review and qualitative analysis of the encounter recordings yielded 4 key findings: i) clinicians primarily used the cardiovascular risk estimate in the DA to guide conversation with patients;ii) highly trained specialists needed to change their usual approach to care and conversation to integrate the DA with their clinical workflows;iii) as clinicians became more familiar with the DA, they moved through the tool at a more efficient pace;and iv) each clinician developed his/her own style of navigating the DA, either moving through it one screen at a time or focusing on one specific section for the duration of the conversation. The DA effectively guided conversation and facilitated active patient engagement in 6 of 10 encounters. Social distancing and use of telemedicine encounters, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, limited patient engagement in 2 of 10 encounters. Overall, the DA promoted SDM regarding FH management in 9 of 10 encounters. Conclusion: Using patient-clinician encounters, we found the FH DA to facilitate SDM regarding lipid-lowering therapy. The tool has potential to improve care of FH patients and increase patient engagement and knowledge.