Predicting femoral neck strength from bone mineral data. A structural approach.

An interactive computer program was developed to derive femoral neck geometry from raw bone mineral image data for an estimate of hip strength using single plane engineering stress analysis. The program, which we call Hip Strength Analysis (HSA), was developed as an attempt to improve the predictive value of hip bone mineral data for osteoporosis fracture risk assessment. We report a series of experiments with an aluminum phantom and with cadaver femora, designed to test the accuracy of derived geometric measurements and strength estimates. Using data acquired with both Lunar DP3 (DPA) and Hologic QDR-1000 (x-ray) scanners, HSA computed femoral neck cross-sectional areas (CSA) and cross-sectional moments of inertia (CSMI) on an aluminum phantom were in excellent agreement with actual values (r greater than .99). Using Lunar DP3 data, CSA and CSMI measurements at mid-femoral necks of 22 cadaver specimens were in good general agreement with literature values. HSA computed cross-sectional properties of three of these specimens were compared with measurements derived from sequential CT cross-sectional images. Discrepancy between the two methods averaged less than 10% along the length of the femoral neck. Finally, breaking strengths of 20 of the femora were measured with a materials testing system, showing better agreement with HSA predicted strength (r = .89, percent standard of the estimate (%SEE) = 21%) than femoral neck bone mineral density (r = .79, %SEE = 28%).

Early time-dependent decompression for spinal cord injury: vascular mechanisms of recovery.

Although surgical decompression is often advocated for acute spinal cord injury, the timing and efficacy of early treatment have not been clinically proven. Our objectives were to determine the importance of early spinal cord decompression on recovery of evoked potential conduction under precision loading conditions and to determine if regional vascular mechanisms could be linked to electrophysiologic recovery. Twenty-one mature beagles were anesthetized and mechanically ventilated to maintain normal respiratory and acid-base balance. Somatosensory-evoked potentials from the upper and lower extremities were measured at regular intervals. The spinal cord at T-13 was loaded dorsally under precision loading conditions until evoked potential amplitudes had been reduced by 50%. At this functional endpoint, spinal cord displacement was maintained for either 30 (n = 7), 60 (n = 8), or 180 min (n = 6). Spinal cord decompression was followed by a 3-h monitoring period. Regional spinal cord blood flow was measured with fluorescent microspheres at baseline (following laminectomy) immediately after stopping dynamic cord compression, 5, 15, and 180 min after decompression. Within 5 min after stopping dynamic compression, evoked potential signals were absent in all dogs. We observed somatosensory-evoked potential recovery in 6 of 7 dogs in the 30-min compression group, 5 of 8 dogs in the 60-min compression group, and 0 of 6 dogs in the 180-min compression group. Recovery in the 30- and 60-min groups varied significantly from the 180-min group (p < 0.05). Regional spinal cord blood flow at baseline, 21.4+/-2.2 ml/100/g/min (combined group mean +/- SE) decreased to 4.1+/-0.7 ml/100 g/min after stopping dynamic compression. Reperfusion flows after decompression were inversely related to duration of compression. Of the 7 dogs in the 30 min compression group, 5 min after decompression the blood flow was 49.1+/-3.1 ml/100 g/min, which was greater than two times baseline. In the 180-min compression group early post-decompression blood flow, 19.8+/-6.2 ml/100 g/min, was not significantly different than baseline. Of the 8 dogs in the 60-min compression group, 5 who recovered evoked potential conduction revealed a lower spinal cord blood flow sampled immediately after stopping dynamic compression, 2.1+/-0.4 ml/100 g/min, compared to the 3 who did not recover where blood flow was 8.4+/-2.1 ml/100 g/min (p < 0.05). Reperfusion flows measured as the interval change in blood flow between the time dynamic compression was stopped to 5, 15, or 180 min after decompression, were significantly greater in those dogs that recovered evoked potential function (p < 0.05). Three hours after decompression, spinal cord blood flow in the 3 dogs in the 60-min compression group with no recovery, 11.1+/-2.1 ml/100 g/min, was significantly less than the spinal cord blood flow of the recovered group (n = 5), 20.5+/-2.2 ml/100 g/min. These data illustrate the importance of early time-dependent events following precision dynamic spinal cord loading and sustained compression conditions. Spinal cord decompression performed within 1 h of evoked potential loss resulted in significant electrophysiologic recovery after 3 h of monitoring. This study showed that the degree of early reperfusion hyperemia after decompression was inversely proportional to the duration of spinal cord compression and proportional to electrophysiologic recovery. Residual blood flow during the sustained compression period was significantly higher in those dogs that did not recover evoked potential function after decompression suggesting a reperfusion injury. These results indicate that, after precise dynamic spinal cord loading to a point of functional conduction deficit (50% decline in evoked potential amplitude), a critical time period exists where intervention in the form of early spinal cord decompression can lead to effective recovery of electrophysiologic function in the 1- to 3-h post-decompression p

Biomechanical study of sternal closure techniques.

Median sternotomy is the most commonly used incision in cardiothoracic surgery. Closure of this incision is usually performed with parasternal wires, but alternate techniques have been proposed to improve closure stability. This study compares biomechanical stability of standard wire (No. 5 stainless steel) with that of three types of band closure: 5-mm Mersilene ribbon, 5-mm stainless steel band, and 5-mm plastic band. Eight bisected cadaver sterna were reapproximated using each method of sternal fixation and tested for biomechanical stability using an MTS Bionix 858 Biomechanical Tester. Loads of 50, 100, 150, and 200 Newtons (1 Newton = 1 kg.m/s2) were applied as a distracting force across the closure. A linear regression line of displacement as a function of increasing load was determined for each closure method; the slope of this line is inversely proportional to fixation stability. Displacement and load correlated linearly for each closure (r = 0.99). Mean slopes were 0.012 mm/Newton (95% confidence limits, 0.0098 to 0.0142 mm/Newton) for No. 5 stainless steel wire, 0.014 mm/Newton (95% confidence limits, 0.0118 to 0.0162 mm/Newton) for plastic band, 0.017 mm/Newton (95% confidence limits, 0.0148 to 0.0192 mm/Newton) for Mersilene ribbon, and 0.017 mm/Newton (95% confidence limits, 0.0148 to 0.0192 mm/Newton) for 5-mm steel band. No. 5 stainless steel wire provided the most stable closure, although statistical significance was achieved only in comparison with Mersilene ribbon and stainless steel band (p < 0.05). The superior stability of stainless steel wire closure may be due to tightening of the wires by twisting, which results in more tension across the reapproximated sternal halves than with other methods.

Roentgenographic and biomechanical analysis of lumbar fusions: a canine model.

An animal model of anterior and posterior column instability was developed to allow in vivo observation of bone remodeling and arthrodesis after spinal instrumentation. Various combinations of spinal fusions and instrumentation procedures were performed after an initial anterior and posterior destabilizing lesion was created at the L5-L6 vertebral levels in 35 adult beagles. After 6 months of postoperative observation, there was improved probability of achieving a spinal fusion if spinal instrumentation had been used. All biomechanical testing was performed after removal of instrumentation to test the inherent stiffnesses and quality of the spinal fusions. The fusions performed in conjunction with instrumentation (group V = Harrington instrumentation and posterolateral fusion; group VI = Luque instrumentation and posterolateral fusion) demonstrated the greatest axial rotation stiffnesses (group V, p less than .05); axial compressive stiffness (group V, p less than .05); and flexural stiffness (group VI, p less than .05). The results show that a spinal fusion can be more reliably achieved and will be more rigid if it is accompanied by spinal instrumentation.

Biomechanical evaluation of methods of posterior stabilization of the spine and posterior lumbar interbody arthrodesis for lumbosacral isthmic spondylolisthesis. A calf-spine model.

In order to evaluate biomechanically the efficacy of four types of posterior instrumentation for the stabilization of isthmic spondylolisthesis of the lumbosacral spine, mechanical non-destructive cyclic testing in axial compression, flexion, extension, and rotation was performed on six fresh lumbosacral spines from calves. Each segment contained four motion segments, including the lumbosacral junction. Isthmic spondylolisthesis was created by sectioning the pars interarticularis of the sixth lumbar vertebra and all posterior ligaments between the fifth and sixth lumbar levels. Eight constructs were tested sequentially: (1) the intact spine, (2) the destabilized spine, (3) the spine fixed with Harrington double-distraction rods, (4) the spine treated with transpedicular Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation with a transverse approximating device, (5) the spine treated with Steffee transpedicular screws and plates, (6) the spine treated with posterior lumbar interbody arthrodesis, (7) the spine treated with Cotrel-Dubousset instrumentation and posterior lumbar interbody arthrodesis, and (8) the spine treated with Steffee instrumentation and posterior lumbar interbody arthrodesis. One motion segment was involved in each construct, except for the spine that was fixed with Harrington instrumentation, which involved three segments. Strain across the supraspinous and anterior longitudinal ligaments was measured with two extensometers that were attached at the spondylolisthetic level and at the intact motion segments adjacent to the fixed level. Harrington instrumentation was the least rigid construct under any type of loading except axial compression (p less than 0.05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cervical stability after foraminotomy. A biomechanical in vitro analysis.

Laminectomy or facetectomy of the cervical spine, or both, may be needed for decompression of the spinal cord or of the nerve-roots. Acute stability of the cervical spine was tested after laminectomy and progressive staged foraminotomies in an in vitro model. Twelve cervical spines from human cadavera were used in the experiment. Biomechanical testing included the application of an axial load, the application of a flexion and extension moment, and the application of a torsional moment. Each specimen was tested intact, after laminectomy of the fifth cervical vertebra, and after progressive foraminotomy of the sixth cervical root. Foraminotomy was performed by resection of 25, 50, 75, and 100 per cent of the facet joint and capsule. Torsional stiffness decreased dramatically when more than 50 per cent of the facet had been resected. Statistically equivalent subsets were the intact specimen, laminectomy, 25 per cent facetectomy, and 50 per cent facetectomy in one subset, and 75 and 100 per cent facetectomy in the least-stiff subset. Flexion-moment testing showed that the posterior strain did not differ among three groups: the intact specimens, those that had been treated with laminectomy, and those that had been treated with a 25 per cent facetectomy. The 50 per cent facetectomy resulted in a 2.5 per cent increase in posterior strain, and the 75 or 100 per cent facetectomy, in a 25 per cent increase in posterior strain compared with the intact specimen. Segmental hypermobility of the cervical spine results if a foraminotomy involves resection of more than 50 per cent of the facet.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Anterior spinal fixation after lumbar corpectomy. A study in dogs.

An animal model was developed to simulate an unstable lumbar burst fracture that had been treated with corpectomy. A fifth lumbar laminectomy, partial facetectomy, and corpectomy was performed in twenty-one dogs. In seven dogs (the control group), a biodegradable polymer spacer was used to create a definite failure of fusion (Group I). Seven dogs were treated with a traditional anterior arthrodesis with an autogenous ulnar strut and without instrumentation (Group II). The remaining seven dogs were treated with an ulnar strut and anterior Kaneda instrumentation that was of an appropriate size for the dog (Group III). At twenty-four weeks, the results were analyzed in terms of the rate of fusion, biomechanical rigidity, neuropathological findings, and histomorphometric data on the vertebral response. The rate of fusion was significantly higher in Group III, in which the Kaneda device had been used, than it was in either Group I or Group II, in which instrumentation had not been used. Biomechanically, the spines in Group III were stiffer in torsion than those in Group I or II. There was no difference between groups in terms of the number of neuropathological changes in the spinal cord. Histomorphometric analysis showed that no meaningful device-related osteopenia occurred in the vertebrae that were spanned by the fixation device. Trabecular density was increased in the vertebrae in which the instrumentation was anchored.

A biomechanical evaluation of cervical spinal stabilization methods in a bovine model. Static and cyclical loading.

A bovine model was developed for biomechanical evaluation of surgical procedures stabilizing traumatic cervical injuries disrupting the anterior and posterior spinal column. Cervical spinal segments and C4-5 functional spinal units were tested statically, and C4-5 functional spinal units were tested cyclically in evaluation of 1) the intact cervical spine, 2) Rogers' wiring method, 3) Bohlman's triple-wire technique, 4) sublaminar wiring, 5) anterior cervical plate instrumentation, and 6) posterior hook plate stabilization. Anterior cervical plate instrumentation proved inadequate, and was the least rigid, with axial and flexural loading (P less than 0.05). There was no significant difference between each of the three posterior wiring methods, and all generally restored stability to equal that of the uninjured intact cervical spine. Posterior hook plating with an interspinous bone graft serving as an extension block was the most effective method in reducing flexural stress across the injured C4-5 segment (P less than 0.05). Cyclical in vitro testing was the most sensitive method in highlighting mechanical differences between instrumentation systems, particularly with "on-line" continuous measurement of anterior and posterior strains. Anterior cervical plate stabilization does not appear to confer enough stability in cervical facet injuries to obviate the need for posterior cervical stabilization procedures. The recently developed posterior hook plate technique offers biomechanical advantages that should be weighed against the greater technical precision needed for insertion and the increased potential for neurologic and vascular complications.

Influence of bone mineral density on the fixation of thoracolumbar implants. A comparative study of transpedicular screws, laminar hooks, and spinous process wires.

Posteriorly directed load to failure testing of four different types of spinal implants was performed in individual T5 to S1 vertebra harvested from seven fresh-frozen human cadaveric spines. The implants tested were: 1) Drummond spinous process wires, 2) Harrington laminar hooks, 3) Cotrel-Dubousset transpedicular screws, and 4) Steffee VSP transpedicular screws. The ultimate failure of each implant was compared with the bone mineral density of each vertebra to determine which implants, if any, were particularly advantageous in osteoporotic vertebrae. Before biomechanical testing, the spines were analyzed in vitro by dual photon absorptiometry to determine the bone mineral densities (gm/cm2) of each vertebra. The mean tensile loads to failure for each of the implants tested were as follows: Cotrel-Dubousset transpedicular screws: 345 Newtons; spinous process wire/button: 382 Newtons; Steffee transpedicular screws: 430 Newtons; and laminar hooks: 646 Newtons. The difference between the loads to failure for laminar hooks and the other implants was significant (P less than 0.05) using one-way analysis of variance. The overall correlation coefficient for bone mineral density with ultimate load to failure was 0.30 (P less than 0.001). The correlation coefficients were 0.47 (P less than 0.001) for spinous process wires alone; 0.096 (not significant) for laminar hooks alone; 0.37 (P less than 0.001) for Cotrel-Dubousset pedicle screws; and 0.48 (P less than 0.001) for Steffee pedicle screws. Of the four different implants tested, laminar hooks were most resistant to failure from posteriorly directed forces.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Influence of disc degeneration on mechanism of thoracolumbar burst fractures.

In order to clarify the pathomechanism of thoracolumbar burst fractures and to evaluate the influence of disc degeneration and bone mineral density, a biomechanical study was performed using cadaveric spines. Eleven motion segments of thoracolumbar spines from human cadavers were compressed vertically until a fracture occurred. In addition, bone mineral density and degree of disc degeneration were determined for each specimen. Compression of 7 of 11 specimens resulted in the typical burst fracture characterized by retropulsion of a bony fragment into the spinal canal and an increase of the interpedicular distance. All seven specimens showed disruptions of the middle end plate and disc materials in the vertebral body. The fracture line was located between the middle of the end plate and the middle of the posterior wall cortex. No burst fractures were seen in the specimens with severely degenerated discs and osteoporosis. In order to confirm the stress state in a vertebra that induces the burst fracture, finite element analysis of one motion segment was also carried out under the same mechanical conditions as the experiments in this study. As a result of calculation for the healthy disc, the highest stresses under axial compression were concentrated in the following areas: the middle of the end plate, the cancellous bone under the nucleus pulposus, and the middle of the posterior wall cortex. This implies that the above regions are more vulnerable to vertical compressive load. In the analysis of specimens with severely degenerated discs, stresses were very low at the end plate and cancellous bone under the nucleus.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Quantitative histologic study of the influence of anterior spinal instrumentation and biodegradable polymer on lumbar interbody fusion after corpectomy. A canine model.

Histomorphometric and microradiographic studies were performed to investigate whether there are different rates of bone remodeling based on the intrinsic stability with anterior spinal instrumentation and to evaluate if biodegradable polymer could be used clinically as the material of choice for anterior spinal instrumentation. Twenty-one coon hounds underwent anterior and posterior spinal destabilizing procedures to produce a reproducible amount of spinal instability: corpectomy of L5, discectomies and partial facetectomies of L4-5 and L5-6, resections of L5 lamina, spinous process, supra- and interspinous ligament, and ligamentum flavum. Group 1 (N = 7) underwent anterior autogenous ulna strut graft alone at L4-6; group 2 (N = 7) underwent anterior biodegradable polymer strut alone at the same level; group 3 (N = 7) underwent same bone graft as in group 1, augmented by anterior Kaneda device. Six months after surgery quantitative histologic study showed that device-related osteopenia occurred in spines treated with Kaneda device. Within the L5 vertebral body the volumetric density of bone (mm3/cm3) was less for the group with Kaneda device (group 3) compared with that without instrumentation (group 1, P less than 0.05). In the spine treated with biodegradable polymer, no adverse host tissue responses were observed histologically. In addition, osteoconductive abilities of the polymer were suggested microscopically. Its mechanical property, however, was not rigid enough to stabilize the corpectomized spine.

Biomechanical evaluation of cervical spinal stabilization methods in a human cadaveric model.

The authors have previously reported in vitro testing of various posterior and anterior constructs (sublaminar, Rogers', and Bohlman's triple-wire wiring; AO hook plate fixation; and Caspar anterior plate fixation) in a bovine model with multiaxial biomechanical testing. This study was undertaken to evaluate the above constructs and other constructs in human cadaveric spines. Six subaxial human cervical spine specimens were biomechanically tested at the C5-C6 motion segment both intact and with a simulated distractive-flexion Stage 3 injury created at the C5-C6 level with complete disruption of the supraspinous ligament, interspinous ligament, ligamentum flavum, posterior longitudinal ligament, and facet joint capsules; with sufficient disruption of the intervertebral disc to allow a bilateral C5-C6 facet dislocation. The specimens were tested with a six-channel Bionix MTS 858 materials tester (M.T.S., Minneapolis, Minnesota) using cyclic loads to simulate cervical compression, flexion, extension, and rotation with measurements of axial load, axial displacement, torque, rotation, and anterior and posterior strains. Eight constructs were tested nondestructively: the intact spinal segment, sublaminar wiring, Rogers' wiring, Bohlman's wiring method (triple-wire technique), Roy-Camille posterior plate fixation, AO posterior hook-plate fixation, Caspar anterior plate fixation, and AO posterior hook-plate with Caspar anterior plate fixation. There was no significant difference in flexural stiffness and torsional stiffness between any of the constructs tested; however, there was a significant (P less than 0.05) increase in the posterior strain during flexion and axial loading tests between the Caspar plate construct and all other tested constructs, including the combined posterior and anterior plating construct. These differences persisted after cyclic testing of 100 cycles. Biomechanical testing demonstrated no significant differences between any of the posterior stabilization methods tested. Caspar anterior plating is clearly an inferior method of treating distractive flexion injuries of the cervical spine when compared with all posterior fixation techniques. Also, there is little biomechanical justification for the use of potentially dangerous sublaminar wire fixation and posterior plating methods in these injuries (with intact bony posterior elements), since the relatively safe interspinous wiring methods (Rogers' and Bohlman) are just as rigid as these other posterior fixation techniques.

Triangulation of pedicular instrumentation. A biomechanical analysis.

Tensile load-to-failure pullout tests were performed on 54 cadaveric spinal segments. The vertebrae were grouped by adjacent levels and matched for bone mineral density (g/cm2), which was measured by dual-photon absorptiometry. Triangulation of Steffee screws and CD pedicle screws was accomplished by transverse plates specifically designed to increase fixation within the same vertebra before the longitudinal Steffee plate or CD rod was applied. A transverse plate with adjustable length was also tested to accommodate variable interpedicular distances. Comparative pullout load-to-failures were as follows: laminar hook, 809 SE 99.4 N; single CD pedicular screws, 863 SE 108 N; single Steffee pedicular screw, 1245 SE 75.3 N; adjustable transverse plate, 1341 SE 114; triangulated Steffee pedicle screws with a transverse plate, 1701 SE 151 N; and triangulated CD pedicle screws with a transverse plate, 2096 SE 115 N. Three triangulated constructs with pedicle screws and a transverse plate (CD, Steffee, and Kirschner) provided significantly greater fixation than conventional pedicular or laminar hook based instrumentation systems (P less than 0.05). Improved treatment of spinal deformities in the elderly and osteoporotic population is dependent on improving the fixation at the metal-bone interface of spinal implants Particularly in osteoporotic vertebrae, the strength of fixation of two triangulated pedicle screws is better than either laminar hooks or single pedicle screws. The strength of fixation of triangulated pedicle screws connected by a transverse plate is superior to a single pedicle screw because it is dependent on the mass of bone between the screws rather than simply the amount of bone within the screw thread.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Two-point fixation of the lumbar spine. Differential stability in rotation.

Single vertebral motion segments were tested in torsion. The adjacent vertebrae were transfixed by two 3-mm Steinman pins placed vertically. These were applied in five different positions: between the anterior vertebral bodies, posterior vertebral bodies, pedicles, transverse processes, and lamina. Rotational displacement was limited the most by transfixation between the vertebral bodies (position one or two). Disrupting the anulus fibrosus significantly increased rotation in all positions except those in the vertebral body. These findings may imply that spinal fixation devices that engage the vertebral bodies may offer inherent advantages over purely posterior devices in stabilizing a vertebral motion segment. In addition, an interbody arthrodesis may prevent intervertebral motion better than a posterior or posterolateral fusion.

Biomechanical evaluation of posterior cervical stabilization after a wide laminectomy.

STUDY DESIGN: In vitro biomechanical investigation with nondestructive and destructive testing in a human cadaveric model simulating a wide postlaminectomy condition. OBJECTIVES: To determine the relative stability conferred by a posterior cervical spinal rod system and posterior cervical plating. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Posterior cervical plate fixation has been shown to be biomechanically superior to wiring techniques, but lateral mass screws may injure neurovascular structures or facet joints if they are inserted improperly. A cervical rod system has been developed to enhance the safety of lateral mass instrumentation. METHODS: The cervical spines of 12 cadavers underwent biomechanical testing. After completion of the nondestructive intact testing, a wide laminectomy with subtotal facetectomies from C4 to C6 was performed. The specimens in two subgroups (group A, cervical spine rods with unicortical fixation, and group B, reconstruction plates with bicortical fixation) were tested in flexion, lateral bending, and torsion. Finally, destructive testing in flexion was performed. Stiffness, neutral zone, failure moment, energy to failure, and mechanism of failure were determined for each specimen. The data were analyzed using paired t tests and ANOVA. RESULTS: Group B had a greater mean screw torque value. The instrumented constructs had a greater stiffness ratio (instrumented/intact) than the intact specimens in flexion, lateral bending, and torsional testing. Group A had a significantly greater flexural stiffness than Group B. Neutral zone ratio values were significantly lower during flexural testing for the cervical rod construct. Destructive testing resulted in significantly greater failure moment and energy-to-failure values for group A. In the cervical rod construct, failure occurred primarily by superior screw loosening with pull-out from the lateral mass. Reconstruction plates consistently failed with fracture of the lateral mass and superior screw loosening. CONCLUSION: Significantly greater stability was noted in the cervical rod construct during nondestructive and destructive flexural testing.

Anterior spinal fixators. A biomechanical in vitro study.

In vitro calf spine testing was performed in flexion, rotation, and axial load, using a vertebral body corpectomy and anterior iliac crest bone grafting model. Anterior spinal fixation devices then were sequentially tested, and axial stiffness, torsional stiffness, and flexural strain determined. The constructs tested were the Contoured Anterior Spinal Plate (CASP), the Kaneda device, the Kostuik-Harrington device (KH), and the Texas Scottish Rite Hospital (TSRH) vertebral body screw construct. In torsion, the Kaneda device returned spinal stability to that of the intact spine. The Kostuik-Harrington device was unstable in torsion. In axial loading and flexion, the Kaneda device and the TSRH construct proved the most stiff, with the KH and CASP systems significantly lower in stiffness. The authors believe that the Kaneda device and the TSRH vertebral body screw construct are effective in restoring acute stability to the lumbar spine after corpectomy.

1989 Volvo Award in basic science. Device-related osteoporosis with spinal instrumentation.

An animal model of anterior and posterior column instability was developed to allow in vivo observation of bone remodeling and arthrodesis after spinal instrumentation. After an initial anterior and posterior destabilizing lesion was created at the L5-L6 vertebral levels in 42 adult beagles, various spinal reconstructive surgical procedures were performed--with or without bilateral posterolateral bone grafting, and with or without spinal instrumentation (Harrington distraction; Luque rectangular, or Cotrel-Dubousset transpedicular methods). After 6 months' postoperative observation, there was a significantly improved probability of achieving a spinal fusion if spinal instrumentation had been used (P = 0.058). Nondestructive mechanical testing after removal of all metal instrumentation in torsion, axial compression, and flexion revealed that the fusions performed in conjunction with spinal instrumentation were more rigid (P less than 0.05). Quantitative histomorphometry showed that the volumetric density of bone was significantly lower (ie, device-related osteoporosis occurred) for fused versus unfused spines; and Harrington- and Cotrel-Dubousset-instrumented dogs became more osteoporotic than the other three groups. The rigidity of spinal instrumentation led to device-related osteoporosis (stress shielding) of the vertebra. However, as the rigidity of spinal instrumentation increased, there was an increased probability of achieving a successful spinal fusion. The improved mechanical properties of spinal instrumentation on spinal arthrodesis more than compensate for the occurrence of device-related osteoporosis in the spine.

The effect of spinal implant rigidity on vertebral bone density. A canine model.

An animal model of anterior and posterior column instability was developed to allow in vivo observation of bone remodeling and arthrodesis following spinal instrumentation. After an initial anterior and posterior destabilizing lesion was created at the L5-L6 vertebral levels in 63 adult beagles, various spinal reconstructive surgical procedures were performed--with or without bilateral posterolateral bone grafting, with or without bilateral oophorectomies, and with or without spinal instrumentation (Harrington distraction, Luque rectangular, Cotrel-Dubousset pedicular, or Steffee pedicular implants). Observation 6 months after surgery revealed a significantly improved probability of achieving a spinal fusion if spinal instrumentation had been used (X2 = 5.84, P = .016). Nondestructive mechanical testing after removal of all metal instrumentation in torsion, axial compression, and flexion revealed that the fusions performed in conjunction with spinal instrumentation were more rigid (P less than .05). Quantitative histomorphometry showed that the volumetric density of bone was significantly lower (ie, device-related osteoporosis occurred) for fused versus unfused spines. In addition, a linear correlation occurred between decreasing volumetric density of bone and increasing rigidity of the spinal implant (r = .778); ie, device-related osteoporosis occurred secondary to Harrington, Cotrel-Dubousset, and Steffee pedicular instrumentation. Oophorectomized dogs became more osteoporotic than their surgically matched controls (posterolateral bone grafting alone, Cotrel-Dubousset pedicular instrumentation, and Steffee pedicular instrumentation); device-related osteoporosis added to the degree of hormonally induced osteoporosis (t = 5.0, P less than .0001). This is the first study to date documenting the occurrence of stress shielding in the spine secondary to spinal instrumentation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Viscoelastic relaxation and regional blood flow response to spinal cord compression and decompression.

STUDY DESIGN: To better understand the relationships between primary mechanical factors of spinal cord trauma and secondary mechanisms of injury, this study evaluated regional blood flow and somatosensory evoked potential function in an in vivo canine model with controlled velocity spinal cord displacement and real-time piston-spinal cord interface pressure feedback. OBJECTIVES: To determine the effect of regional spinal cord blood flow and viscoelastic cord relaxation on recovery of neural conduction, with and without spinal cord decompression. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The relative contribution of mechanical and vascular factors on spinal cord injury remains undefined. METHODS: Twelve beagles were anesthetized and underwent T13 laminectomy. A constant velocity spinal cord compression was applied using a hydraulic loading piston with a subminiature pressure transducer rigidly attached to the spinal column. Spinal cord displacement was stopped when somatosensory evoked potential amplitudes decreased by 50% (maximum compression). Six animals were decompressed 5 minutes after maximum compression and were compared with six animals who had spinal cord displacement maintained for 3 hours and were not decompressed. Regional spinal cord blood flow was measured with a fluorescent microsphere technique. RESULTS: At maximum compression, regional spinal cord blood flow at the injury site fell from 19.0 +/- 1.3 mL/100 g/min to 12.6 +/- 1.0 mL/100 g/min, whereas piston-spinal cord interface pressure was 30.5 +/- 1.8 kPa, and cord displacement measured 2.1 +/- 0.1 mm (mean +/- SE). Five minutes after the piston translation was stopped, the spinal cord interface pressure had dissipated 51%, whereas the somatosensory evoked potential amplitudes continued to decrease to 16% of baseline. In the sustained compression group, cord interface pressure relaxed to 13% of maximum within 90 minutes; however, no recovery of somatosensory evoked potential function occurred, and regional spinal cord blood flow remained significantly lower than baseline at 30 and 180 minutes after maximum compression. In the six animals that underwent spinal cord decompression, somatosensory evoked potential function and regional spinal cord blood flow recovered to baseline 30 minutes after maximum compression. CONCLUSIONS: Despite rapid cord relaxation of more than 50% within 5 minutes after maximum compression, somatosensory evoked potential conduction recovered only with early decompression. Spinal cord decompression was associated with an early recovery of regional spinal cord blood flow and somatosensory evoked potential recovery. By 3 hours, spinal cord blood flow was similar in both the compressed and decompressed groups, despite that somatosensory evoked potential recovery occurred only in the decompressed group.

The biomechanical and histomorphometric properties of anterior lumbar fusions: a canine model.

An in vivo model was developed to compare the biomechanical stability, incidence of radiographic union, bone formation rate, and bone graft remodeling parameters of anterior interbody fusions. Eighteen 1-year-old beagles underwent anterior and posterior spinal destabilization procedures at L5-L6 to produce a reproducible amount of spinal instability--resection of the anterior longitudinal ligament, L5-L6 intervertebral disk, L5 and L6 lamina, spinous processes, zygoopophyseal joints, and ligamentum flavum. Group I (N = 6) were surgically destabilized controls; Group II (N = 6) underwent anterior L5-L6 interbody fusion with iliac crest bone graft; and Group III (N = 6) underwent anterior stabilization with a longitudinal fibular strut graft in addition to the same operative procedure as Group II. Six months postoperatively the group with the highest incidence of successful radiographic L5-L6 arthrodesis was Group III, anterior interbody fusion and fibular stabilization (p less than .10). The rank order of biomechanical stability was the same for the three groups for both torsional and axial compressive stiffness, with Group I (destabilized controls) being the least rigid, then Group II (anterior fusion with iliac crest grafting only), and the most rigid to both torsion and axial compressive loading was Group III (anterior fusion with fibular stabilization and iliac crest bone graft). The bone formation rate [mm3/(mm3 x year) x 10(3)], which was derived from the distance between fluorochrome markers, revealed that the more stable the individual spinal construct, the lower the bone formation rate. In summary, the beagle provided a successful model for studying in vivo the response of anterior bone grafts over a 6-month interval and provided comparative biomechanical and histomorphometric data on spinal interbody fusion techniques.