Early ontogenesis from embryo to juvenile in Senegalese sole Solea senegalensis under laboratory conditions.

Senegalese sole, Solea senegalensis, is a flatfish of high commercial value in the world. It has been identified as an interesting and promising species for marine commercial aquaculture diversification in Europe for at least four decades and was introduced to China in 2003. Early ontogenesis from embryo to juvenile stages in S. senegalensis was analysed under controlled laboratory conditions to provide morphological information for aquaculture. From 0 to 59 days post hatching (dph), 10-20 larvae were sampled and measured each day (0-17 dph) or every 2-6 days (17-59 dph). Morphological characteristics from the egg to the juvenile stage were described. The eggs were separate and spherical with multiple oil globules. After 3 dph, the yolk sac was completely absorbed, mouth and anus were open, a swim bladder appeared, and larvae began feeding on rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis). The larvae began metamorphosis as the notochord flexed upward and the left eye migrated upward after 10 dph. The left eye migrated to the dorsal midline at 15 dph. At 19 dph, the left eye was translocated to the right-ocular side, and the juveniles adopted a benthic lifestyle. The swim bladder degenerated, and the juveniles completed metamorphosis at 23 dph. The growth patterns of some parameters (TL, SL, BH, BW) during larval and juvenile development stages were identified. The inflection points, which are slopes of growth changes, were calculated in growth curves. Three inflection points occurring in the growth curves of larvae and juveniles were found to be associated with metamorphosis, weaning, and transitions in feeding habits. The basic information of embryo development and ontogenesis in this study represents a valuable contribution to the S. senegalensis industry, especially in artificial breeding and rearing techniques.

Sonic hedgehog (shh) gene from Pseudopleuronectes yokohamae (Teleostei: Pleuronectidae): Molecular cloning, characterization, and expression profile during early embryonic, juvenile, and adult stages.

The hedgehog signaling pathway plays an important role in early development and growth of most vertebrates. Sonic hedgehog (shh) gene is a critical regulator of embryonic development in many species, including humans. However, it is not clear what roles shh can play in the development of fish. In this paper, shh gene was cloned from Pseudopleuronectes yokohamae. The full-length complementary DNA (cDNA) of P. yokohamae sonic hedgehog gene (Pyshh) comprises 3194 bp, with a 1317-bp open reading frame (ORF) that encodes a polypeptide of 438 amino acids with a typical HH-signal domain and Hint-N domain. The conserved sequences of the protein among species were predicted by using multiple sequence comparison. The phylogenetic tree construction showed that PySHH is clustered in a branch of Pleuronectidae. To explore the expression of Pyshh gene in various tissues of P. yokohamae, we used real-time fluorescence quantitative PCR technology to detect it. The results showed that Pyshh gene is widely distributed in various tissues of P. yokohamae juveniles, different tissues of adult males and females, and is particularly expressed in immune organs. The Pyshh gene expression was higher in the muscle and brain of juvenile fish, and higher in bone, gill, and skin of male fish than that of female fish, suggesting that Pyshh might be involved in the formation of immune organs of P. yokohamae. The expression of Pyshh gene significantly upregulated from the gastrula stage to the hatching stage. Western blotting of the expression levels of PySHH during different embryonic development stages revealed that PySHH levels increased gradually during development stages from oosperm stage to hatching stage. These results indicate that Pyshh is highly conserved among species and plays a critical role in the complex process of embryonic development. Its precise regulation is essential for the proper formation of many organs and tissues in the body, and disruptions in its function may have serious consequences for the formation of immune organs in fish.

Sole head transcriptomics reveals a coordinated developmental program during metamorphosis.

Most teleosts undergo a thyroid hormone (TH) regulated larval to juvenile transition known as metamorphosis. In Pleuronectiformes (flatfish), metamorphosis is most dramatic, and one eye of the symmetric pelagic larvae migrates to the opposite side of the head, giving rise to an asymmetric benthic juvenile with both eyes on the same side of the body. Asymmetric development occurs mostly in the head. To understand the genetic mechanisms underlying this developmental change we have generated a Solea senegalensis metamorphosing flatfish head transcriptome. Our results reveal that THs acting as integrative factors direct a stepwise genetic program that initiates a specific organismal level response followed by cell specific responses that lead to the long-term changes that characterise the post-metamorphic identity and physiology of the head. Flatfish head asymmetric development during metamorphosis and its TH dependency is conserved thus we consider the findings in sole most likely representative of all flatfish species.

Expression and localization study of pIgR in the late stage of embryo development in turbot (Scophthalmus maximus).

The receptor responsible for maternofetal transmission of immunoglobulin (Igs) in the teleosts is not clear. Polymeric immunoglobulin receptor (pIgR) specifically binds with IgA and IgM and mediates the transcytosis of intracellular polymeric immunoglobulins (pIgs) at the mucosal surface to protect against pathogens. Hence there is a possibility that it may be involved in the transmission of maternal Igs. The aim of the present study was to detect the expression and localization of pIgR during embryonal development in turbot (Scophthalmus maximus). pIgR gene was first cloned from eggs and embryos of turbot with or without parent immunization. The expression and distribution of pIgR in unfertilized egg and in embryos ranging from day 1 to day 5 after fertilization were analyzed using reverse transcriptase quantitative polymerase chain reaction and in situ hybridization. pIgR gene was detected in all eggs and embryos at different stages of development, with the highest level detected on the 5th day. pIgR mRNA was observed to be first located in the whole blastoderm and enveloped the yolk sac. Later, it was located around entoderm including primary digestive tract and pronephric tubule tract, and finally it was located at the joint of abdomen and vitelline membrane. Then, Eukaryotic expression plasmid carrying pIgR gene was constructed and transfected into HEK293T cells. Results showed mature pIgR protein located on the cellular membrane, and could bound IgM in vitro. Our findings provide information for studying the involvement of pIgR in maternal Igs transportation in turbot.

Phylogeny, expression patterns and regulation of DNA Methyltransferases in early development of the flatfish, Solea senegalensis.

BACKGROUND: The identification of DNA methyltransferases (Dnmt) expression patterns during development and their regulation is important to understand the epigenetic mechanisms that modulate larval plasticity in marine fish. In this study, dnmt1 and dnmt3 paralogs were identified in the flatfish Solea senegalensis and expression patterns in early developmental stages and juveniles were determined. Additionally, the regulation of Dnmt transcription by a specific inhibitor (5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine) and temperature was evaluated. RESULTS: Five paralog genes of dnmt3, namely dnmt3aa, dnmt3ab, dnmt3ba, dnmt3bb.1 and dnmt3bb.2 and one gene for dnmt1 were identified. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that the dnmt gene family was highly conserved in teleosts and three fish-specific genes, dnmt3aa, dnmt3ba and dnmt3bb.2 have evolved. The spatio-temporal expression patterns of four dnmts (dnmt1, dnmt3aa, dnmt3ab and dnmt3bb.1) were different in early larval stages although all of them reduced expression with the age and were detected in neural organs and dnmt3aa appeared specific to somites. In juveniles, the four dnmt genes were expressed in brain and hematopoietic tissues such as kidney, spleen and gills. Treatment of sole embryos with 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine down-regulated dntm1 and up-regulated dntm3aa. Moreover, in lecithotrophic larval stages, dnmt3aa and dnmt3ab were temperature sensitive and their expression was higher in larvae incubated at 16 °C relative to 20 °C. CONCLUSION: Five dnmt3 and one dnmt1 paralog were identified in sole and their distinct developmental and tissue-specific expression patterns indicate that they may have different roles during development. The inhibitor 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine modified the transcript abundance of dntm1 and dntm3aa in embryos, which suggests that a regulatory feedback mechanism exists for these genes. The impact of thermal regime on expression levels of dnmt3aa and dnmt3ab in lecithotrophic larval stages suggests that these paralogs might be involved in thermal programing.

Cloning, expression profiling and promoter functional analysis of Bone morphogenetic protein 6 and 7 in tongue sole (Cynoglossus semilaevis).

Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) play crucial roles in vertebrate developmental process and are associated with the mechanisms which drive early skeletal development. As a first approach to elucidating the role of BMPs in regulating fish bone formation and growth, we describe the cloning, expression profiling and promoter functional analysis of bmp6 and bmp7 in tongue sole (Cynoglossus semilaevis). The full length of bmp6 and bmp7 cDNA sequences is 1939 and 1836 bp, which encodes a protein of 428 and 427 amino acids, respectively. Tissue expression distribution of bmp6 and bmp7 was examined in 14 tissues of mature individuals by quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR). The results revealed that bmp6 was predominantly expressed in the gonad, and bmp7 exhibited the highest expression level in the dorsal fin. Further comparison of bmp6 expression levels between female and male gonads showed that the expression in the ovary was significantly higher than in the testis. Moreover, bmp6 and bmp7 expression levels were detected at 15 sampling time points of early developmental stages (egg, larva, juvenile and fingerling stages). The highest expression level of bmp6 was observed in the egg stage (multi-cell and gastrula stage); while bmp7 exhibited the highest expression in the larva stage (1-4 days old). The high expression levels of BMP6 in the ovary as well as at early embryonic stages indicated that the maternally stored transcripts of bmp6 might play a role in early embryonic development. Whole-mount in situ hybridization showed that bmp6 and bmp7 exhibited similar spatial expression patterns. Both bmp6 and bmp7 signals were first detected in the head and anterior regions in newly hatched larvae, and then, the mRNAs appeared in the crown-like larval fin, jaw, operculum and fins (pectoral, dorsal, pelvic and anal) along with early development. Subsequently, we characterized the 5'-flanking regions of bmp6 and bmp7 by testing the promoter activity by luciferase reporter assays. Positive regulatory regions were, respectively, detected at the location of -272 to +28 and -740 to -396 in bmp6 and bmp7 gene. The predicted transcription factor binding sites (CREB, AP1 and methyl-CpG-binding protein) in the regions might participate in the transcriptional regulation of these two genes.

Maternally derived trypsin may have multiple functions in the early development of turbot (Scopthalmus maximus).

Trypsin is an important serine protease that is considered to be involved in digestion of protein in teleost fish. Nevertheless, studies on trypsin/trypsinogen in fish embryos are very limited. In this study, the trypsinogen of turbot (Scophthalmus maximus) (tTG) was identified and the expression patterns and activity of trypsinogen/trypsin were investigated. The results showed that the tTG mRNA was evenly distributed in the oocytes and was also expressed along the yolk periphery in early embryos. At later embryo stages and 1 days after hatching (dph), the tTG mRNA concentrated at the alimentary tract and head. Quantitative expression analysis showed that the tTG transcripts decreased after fertilization until the gastrula stage, then increased with the embryo and larvae development. This result was also confirmed by the specific activity analysis of trypsin and in-situ-hybridization (ISH). All of the results indicated that tTG in early embryo stages was maternally derived and expressed by itself after gastrula stages. Additionally, location of tTG mRNA in embryos and larvae was investigated; we considered that trypsin may have multiple functions during the embryo development process. Based on our results regarding trypsinogen in embryos and early development, we concluded that the trypsin/trypsinogen in turbot embryos was inherited from a maternal source and we suggested that trypsin in early development has multiple functions in the process of development.

Morphogenesis of the saccus vasculosus of turbot Scophthalmus maximus: assessment of cell proliferation and distribution of parvalbumin and calretinin during ontogeny.

The ontogenesis of the saccus vasculosus (SV) of turbot Scophthalmus maximus is described using histological and immunohistochemical methods to assess the general morphology, as well as the distribution of proliferative cells and several calcium-binding proteins (CaBP). The results reveal that the SV begins to differentiate on hatching, when immature coronet cells are morphologically distinguishable. Further morphogenesis involves the formation of a tubular avascular SV, which remains until premetamorphic larval stages. Folding and vascularization of the SV occurs mostly during metamorphosis, when S. maximus settle down on the bottom. Proliferative cells were placed within the SV itself and in the neighbouring infundibular hypothalamus. Their putative relationship with the growth of the SV is discussed. The CaBPs analysed are expressed in coronet cells. Parvalbumin is expressed in these cells from the beginning of their differentiation, while calretinin expression arises in the tubular SV and becomes more widespread over time. These data emphasize the importance of calcium buffering in the function of coronet cells.

Distinct expression profiles of three melatonin receptors during early development and metamorphosis in the flatfish Solea senegalensis.

Melatonin actions are mediated through G protein-coupled transmembrane receptors. Recently, mt1, mt2, and mel1c melatonin receptors were cloned in the Senegalese sole. Here, their day-night and developmental expressions were analyzed by quantitative PCR. These results revealed distinct expression patterns of each receptor through development. mel1c transcripts were more abundant in unfertilized ovulated oocytes and declined during embryonic development. mt1 and mt2 expression was higher at the earliest stages (2-6 days post-fertilization), decreasing before (mt2) or during (mt1) metamorphosis. Only mt1 and mel1c expression exhibited day-night variations, with higher nocturnal mRNA levels. These results suggest different roles and transcriptional regulation of these melatonin receptors during flatfish development and metamorphosis.

Germ line specific expression of a vasa homologue gene in turbot (Scophthalmus maximus): evidence for vasa localization at cleavage furrows in euteleostei.

Specification of primordial germ cells during early embryogenesis is a critical biological issue in reproduction and development. Yet, little is known in marine economic fish species. Vasa, a component of germ plasm, is the most-documented germ cell marker in teleosts. We isolated a full-length vasa cDNA (Smvas) from turbot (Scophthalmus maximus), a marine Euteleostei species, and investigated its expression patterns by RT-PCR and in situ hybridization during embryogenesis and gametogenesis to identify the germ cell lineage in this species. The deduced amino acid sequence of the isolated cDNA shared typical characteristics of Vasa protein and high identity to Vasa homologues in medaka (76.9%) and zebrafish (68.5%). The Smvas transcripts were exclusively detected in germ cells of testis and ovary, and exhibited an interesting dynamic localization pattern during oogenesis. The distribution pattern of Smvas during embyogenesis in this Euteleostei closely resembled the pattern observed in zebrafish (belonging to Osteriophysans) rather than medaka (belonging to Euteleostei). Thus, it is concluded that Smvas isolated in this study is a germ cell specific molecular marker in turbot. Furthermore, we hypothesize that Euteleostei could localize vasa mRNA by a special mode. The results not only facilitate the germ cell manipulation of the turbot, but also improve our understanding of germline development and evolution of vasa localization in teleost.

Malnutrition may affect common sole (Solea solea L.) growth, pigmentation and stress response: molecular, biochemical and histological implications.

In the last decades there have been several evidences that traditionally used live preys like rotifers and Artemia salina have nutritional deficiencies that result in a general decrease of fish health, causing anomalies in the development, in growth and in pigmentation. In this study a partial of total replacement of traditional live preys with preserved copepods that represent the natural food of the larvae was evaluated during Solea solea culture. In this study a positive effect of co-feeding preserved copepods in sole larviculture was observed since larvae fed this diet growth and survived better, showed a better tolerance to captive conditions and had a better response to the final thermal/density stress-test with respect to larvae fed a traditional diet. Morphometric data were fully supported by molecular and biochemical ones. Moreover, liver histological investigations, revealed that the inclusion of preserved copepods in the larval diet was able to improve lipid assimilation. In conclusion, preserved copepods may be considered a suitable food for sole when used as a supplement to the traditional diet based on rotifers and Artemia nauplii.

Identification of two arylalkylamine N-acetyltranferase 1 genes with different developmental expression profiles in the flatfish Solea senegalensis.

The existence of two arylalkylamine N-acetyltransferase 1 (Aanat1) genes in the genome of some teleosts has been reported recently by in silico analysis. However, there are no data concerning the similarities and/or differences between them and many questions remain to be answered, such as their expression sites, development, or kinetics. Here, we report the cloning of Aanat1a and Aanat1b cDNAs from the sole retina and show for the first time that at least three Aanat genes are expressed in a vertebrate species. Because melatonin is involved in fish ontogeny, we analyzed the developmental transcript levels of Aanat1a and Aanat1b by quantitative real-time PCR, showing their inverse and stage-specific expression patterns. Aanat1a was more abundant during early than late larval stages. Before metamorphosis, nocturnal expression was higher. At metamorphosis, Aanat1a expression decreased and lost these day-night variations. In contrast, the abundance of Aanat1b transcripts, low during early developing stages, rose significantly throughout metamorphosis. This situation seemed to apply to the adult because Aanat1a expression was lower than Aanat1b expression in the retina of adults, where the former did not exhibit day-night variations, while the latter did so with much higher nocturnal transcript levels. In situ hybridization analysis detected Aanat1a and Aanat1b messengers in the outer and inner nuclear layers of retina. The differences in abundance and distinct day-night expression patterns between Aanat1a and Aanat1b during sole development suggest different functions for these two enzymes as well as the existence of interactions between the melatoninergic and thyroid hormone systems during flatfish metamorphosis.

Cloning, expression and functional analysis of the desert hedgehog (dhh) gene in Chinese tongue sole (Cynoglossus semilaevis).

Desert hedgehog (dhh) is a gene that is crucial for spermatogenesis and Leydig cell differentiation, but little is known regarding its influence on gonadal differentiation and development in fish. To understand its function, we cloned and characterized the dhh gene from Cynoglossus semilaevis (csdhh). The full length csdhh cDNA was 2473 bp, including a 1386 bp open reading frame (ORF), a 475 bp 5'-UTR, and a 612 bp 3'-UTR, encoding a predicted protein of 461 amino acid residues. Phylogenetic analysis showed that the putative protein belongs to the hedgehog (HH) family, and contains typical HH-N and HH-C domains. Amino acid sequence analysis revealed that CsDhh shares many features with Dhh analogues in other teleost species. Real-time quantitative PCR showed that csdhh was detected in eight different tissues in male and female tongue sole. During early embryonic development, the relative expression of the csdhh was significantly higher in the neural stage than in other embryonic developmental stages (P < 0.05). csdhh was detected at 20 days after hatching (dah) and at the critical period of male gonadal differentiation (80-95 dah), the relative expression of the csdhh was significantly higher in the male gonads than the female gonads. In 5, 8, and 12 month old gonads, the relative expression of the csdhh was significantly higher in male and pseudo-male than in female fish. The in situ hybridization (ISH) results showed that the hybridization signal was strongly expressed in primary and secondary spermatocytes, spermatids, and sertoli cells of the 1-year-old fish testis, with only weak signal expression in the corresponding ovarian tissue. These results suggest that csdhh is highly conserved in evolution and plays an important role in spermatogenesis in males and pseudo-males.

Cloning, characterization, and expression analysis of a CC chemokine gene from turbot (Scophthalmus maximus).

The chemokines are a superfamily of chemotactic cytokines playing an important role in leukocyte chemotaxis. Here, a turbot head kidney cDNA library was constructed in which KC70 was identified as a CC chemokine. Unknown 5' and 3' parts of the cDNA were amplified by 5' and 3' rapid amplification of cDNA ends (RACE). The complete cDNA of KC70 contains a 59-bp 5' UTR, a 336-bp ORF, and a 152-bp 3' UTR. Four exons and three introns were identified in KC70. Phylogenetic analysis showed that KC70 was similar to CCL19. In normal turbot KC70 was expressed in all tissues except brain and skin. Infection of turbot with pathogenic bacteria significantly increased expression of KC70 in the liver. Expression of KC70 in head kidney first increased and then decreased after bacterial challenge. No significant change was observed in the spleen after bacterial challenge. During embryonic development, KC70 was highly expressed after the gastrula stage. These results indicated KC70 plays important and multiple roles in turbot immune response.

Effects of triclosan on early development of Solea senegalensis: from biochemical to individual level.

Harmful effects of triclosan (TCS) have been reported on several organisms; however, effects on early life stages of marine vertebrates are limited. Therefore, the objective of this work was to assess the effects of TCS during early development of the flatfish Solea senegalensis after initial characterization of cholinesterases (ChEs) and determination of selected biochemical markers baseline levels. Characterization of ChEs and determination of biochemical markers baseline levels of cholinergic activity, energy metabolism and oxidative stress were analysed in sole at 3 days after hatching (dah) and at the onset and end of metamorphosis. To assess TCS effects, fish were exposed during 96h to 30-500 µg L-1 TCS until 3 dah. Fish at 13 dah were exposed during 48h to 200-1,500 µg L-1 TCS and maintained until complete metamorphosis. Effects on survival, malformations, length, metamorphosis progression and biochemical markers were evaluated. The main ChE active form present in sole early life stages is acetylcholinesterase and baseline levels of oxidative stress and energy metabolism biomarkers changed according to fish developmental stage. Triclosan induced malformations (EC50 = 180 µg L-1 at 3 dah), decreased growth (95 µg L-1 at 3 dah; 548 µg L-1 at 24 dah) and affected metamorphosis progression (391 µg L-1 at 17 dah). Impairment of antioxidant system was observed, with TCS affecting catalase at the end of metamorphosis test, however, no oxidative damage on lipids was detected. Glutathione S-transferase was the most sensitive endpoint during early larval test (LOEC = 30 µg L-1). Exposure to TCS affected S. senegalensis at individual and sub-individual levels, both at early larval stage and during the critical period of metamorphosis.

Expression profiling and validation of potential reference genes during Paralichthys olivaceus embryogenesis.

Differential expression of genes is crucial to embryogenesis. The analysis of gene expression requires appropriate references that should be minimally regulated during the embryonic development. To select the most stable genes for gene normalization, the expression profiles of eight commonly used reference genes (ACTB, GAPDH, rpL17, alpha-Tub, EF1-alpha, UbcE, B2M, and 18S rRNA) were examined during Japanese flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) embryonic development using quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction. It was found that all seven mRNA genes appeared to be developmentally regulated and exhibited significant variation of expression. However, further analyses revealed the stage-specific expression stability. Hence when normalization using these mRNA genes, the differential and stage-related expression should be considered. 18S rRNA gene, on the other hand, showed the most stable expression and could be recommended as a suitable reference gene during all embryonic developmental stages in P. olivaceus. In summary, our results provided not only the appropriate reference gene for embryonic development research in P. olivaceus, but also possible guidance to reference gene selection for embryonic gene expression analyses in other fish species.

Functional characterization of Cynoglossus semilaevis R-spondin2 and its role in muscle development during embryogenesis.

R-spondin2 (Rspo2) is a member of the R-spondin family, which plays important roles in cell proliferation, cell fate determination and organogenesis. Rspo2 exhibits important functions during embryonic development and muscle maintenance in adult human, mouse and Xenopus. In the present study, the tongue sole Cynoglossus semilaevis Rspo2 (CsRspo2) gene was isolated and characterized, and its role in muscle development during embryogenesis was studied. Our results showed that CsRspo2 expression was abundant during gastrulation and significantly high during somite formation, but then decreased markedly after hatching. CsRspo2 expression was high in brain and gill, moderate in heart, ovary and testis, and almost undetectable in muscle and other tissues. Moreover, the potential involvement of Rspo2 in muscle development was investigated. We found that overexpression of CsRspo2 mRNA in zebrafish embryos resulted in slow development and abnormal muscle formation at the embryonic stage. Our work provides a fundamental understanding of the structure and potential functions of CsRspo2 during muscle development.

Phylogeny and expression patterns of two apolipoprotein E genes in the flatfish Senegalese sole.

The apolipoprotein E (ApoE) is a key component of several lipoproteins involved in lipid homeostasis. In this study, two cDNA sequences encoding ApoE (referred to as apoEa and apoEb) were characterized in the flatfish Solea senegalensis. The predicted peptides contained conserved structural blocks related with their capacity for lipid binding and lipoprotein receptor interaction. At genomic level, both genes contained five exons and four introns and they were organized into two tandem arrays with apoA-IV gene copies. The phylogenetic analysis clearly separated them into two well-supported clusters that matched with their organization in the genome of teleosts. Whole-mount in situ hybridization located the apoEa signal in the yolk syncytial layer (YSL) of lecitothrophic larval stages (0dph) and in the anterior intestine of exotrophic larvae and benthic fish. In the case of apoEb, hybridization signals were located in the YSL, tail bud, eyes and mouth at 0dph and in the otic vesicle, hindbrain, eyes, pharynx, mouth, heart and intestine at 1dph. In exotrophic larvae, apoEb was ubiquitously expressed in several tissues such as taste buds, brain, mouth, nostril, gills, intestine, liver and around the neuromasts and eyes. Quantification of mRNA levels in pools of whole larvae confirmed distinct expression patterns with a significant reduction of apoEa and an increase of apoEb mRNA levels throughout larval development. Moreover, only apoEa transcripts increased in response to food supply suggesting that this paralog mostly participates in the absorption and transport of dietary lipids and the apoEb in the redistribution of endogenous lipids as well as in neural tissue regeneration.