Antibody Response to Paramyxoviruses in Paget's Disease of Bone.

Paget's disease of bone (PDB) is a common skeletal disorder characterised by focal abnormalities of increased and disorganised bone turnover. Genetic factors play a central role in the pathogenesis of PDB but environmental factors also contribute. Measles virus (MV), respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) and canine distemper virus (CDV) have all been implicated as potential disease triggers but the data are conflicting. Since chronic paramyxovirus infection with measles is known to be accompanied by increased production of antiviral antibodies, we have analysed circulating concentrations of antibodies to MV, CDV, and RSV as well as mumps, rubella and varicella zoster virus (VZV) in 463 patients with PDB and 220 aged and gender-matched controls. We also studied the relation between viral antibody concentrations and various markers of disease severity and extent in 460 PDB patients. A high proportion of cases and controls tested positive for antiviral antibodies but there was no significant difference in circulating antibody concentrations between PDB cases and controls for MV, CDV, RSV, rubella or VZV. However, mumps virus antibody levels were significantly higher in the PDB cases (mean ± SD = 3.1 ± 0.84 vs. 2.62 ± 0.86. p < 0.001). There was no association between disease severity and circulating antibody concentrations to any of the viruses. In conclusion, we found no evidence to suggest that PDB is associated with abnormalities of immune response to measles or other paramyxoviruses, although there was evidence of a greater antibody response to mumps. The results do not support that hypothesis that PDB is associated with a persistent infection with measles or other paramyxoviruses.

Failure to detect measles virus ribonucleic acid in bone cells from patients with Paget's disease.

BACKGROUND: Paget's disease is a condition of focal accelerated bone turnover. Electron-microscopy investigations of osteoclasts from pagetic lesions have identified nuclear inclusion bodies that have a similar appearance to viral nucleocapsid particles. Subsequently, RNA from several paramyxoviruses has been detected in pagetic tissue, and it was suggested that these viruses, in particular measles, might play a role in the etiology of Paget's disease. We have tested for measles virus sequences in osteoblasts and bone marrow cells collected from pagetic lesions and healthy bone. METHODS: Bone and bone marrow samples were taken from Paget's patients and control subjects, and cells were cultured from each of these tissues. RNA was extracted from 13 osteoblast cultures and 13 cultures of bone marrow cells derived from pagetic lesions, and from 26 and 23 control osteoblast and bone marrow cultures, respectively. These samples were sourced from 22 patients with Paget's disease and 31 controls. RT-PCR-nested PCR amplification was used for the detection of the genes for the measles nucleocapsid and matrix proteins. RESULTS: Measles virus sequences were not detected in any of the pagetic or control samples. However, measles virus sequences were identified in samples of a measles virus culture isolate included as a positive control, and in a brain sample from a patient with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis, a condition associated with chronic measles infection. CONCLUSION: The results of the study do not support the hypothesis that measles virus plays a role in the pathogenesis of Paget's disease.

Multicenter blinded analysis of RT-PCR detection methods for paramyxoviruses in relation to Paget's disease of bone.

UNLABELLED: Conflicting results have been reported on the detection of paramyxovirus transcripts in Paget's disease, and a possible explanation is differences in the sensitivity of RT-PCR methods for detecting virus. In a blinded study, we found no evidence to suggest that laboratories that failed to detect viral transcripts had less sensitive RT-PCR assays, and we did not detect measles or distemper transcripts in Paget's samples using the most sensitive assays evaluated. INTRODUCTION: There is conflicting evidence on the possible role of persistent paramyxovirus infection in Paget's disease of bone (PDB). Some workers have detected measles virus (MV) or canine distemper virus (CDV) transcripts in cells and tissues from patients with PDB, but others have failed to confirm this finding. A possible explanation might be differences in the sensitivity of RT-PCR methods for detecting virus. Here we performed a blinded comparison of the sensitivity of different RT-PCR-based techniques for MV and CDV detection in different laboratories and used the most sensitive assays to screen for evidence of viral transcripts in bone and blood samples derived from patients with PDB. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Participating laboratories analyzed samples spiked with known amounts of MV and CDV transcripts and control samples that did not contain viral nucleic acids. All analyses were performed on a blinded basis. RESULTS: The limit of detection for CDV was 1000 viral transcripts in three laboratories (Aberdeen, Belfast, and Liverpool) and 10,000 transcripts in another laboratory (Manchester). The limit of detection for MV was 16 transcripts in one laboratory (NIBSC), 1000 transcripts in two laboratories (Aberdeen and Belfast), and 10,000 transcripts in two laboratories (Liverpool and Manchester). An assay previously used by a U.S.-based group to detect MV transcripts in PDB had a sensitivity of 1000 transcripts. One laboratory (Manchester) detected CDV transcripts in a negative control and in two samples that had been spiked with MV. None of the other laboratories had false-positive results for MV or CDV, and no evidence of viral transcripts was found on analysis of 12 PDB samples using the most sensitive RT-PCR assays for MV and CDV. CONCLUSIONS: We found that RT-PCR assays used by different laboratories differed in their sensitivity to detect CDV and MV transcripts but found no evidence to suggest that laboratories that previously failed to detect viral transcripts had less sensitive RT-PCR assays than those that detected viral transcripts. False-positive results were observed with one laboratory, and we failed to detect paramyxovirus transcripts in PDB samples using the most sensitive assays evaluated. Our results show that failure of some laboratories to detect viral transcripts is unlikely to be caused by problems with assay sensitivity and highlight the fact that contamination can be an issue when searching for pathogens by sensitive RT-PCR-based techniques.

Osteoclasts expressing the measles virus nucleocapsid gene display a pagetic phenotype.

Osteoclasts (OCLs) in Paget's disease are markedly increased in number and size, have increased numbers of nuclei per multinucleated cell, and demonstrate increased resorption capacity and increased sensitivity to 1,25-(OH)(2)D(3), the active form of vitamin D. These cells also contain nuclear inclusions, reminiscent of those seen in paramyxovirus-infected cells, which cross-react with antibodies to measles virus nucleocapsid (MVNP) antigen. To elucidate the role of MV in the abnormal OCL phenotype of Paget's disease, we transduced normal OCL precursors with retroviral vectors expressing MVNP and the MV matrix (MVM) genes. The transduced cells were then cultured with 1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) for14 or 21 days to induce formation of OCL-like multinucleated cells. The MVNP-transduced cells formed increased numbers of multinucleated cells, which contained many more nuclei and had increased resorption capacity compared with multinucleated cells derived from empty vector-transduced (EV-transduced) and MVM-transduced or normal bone marrow cells. Furthermore, MVNP-transduced cells showed increased sensitivity to 1, 25-(OH)(2)D(3), and formed OCLs at concentrations of 1, 25-(OH)(2)D(3) that were 1 log lower than that required for normal, EV-transduced, or MVM-transduced cells. These results demonstrate that expression of the MVNP gene in normal OCL precursors stimulates OCL formation and induces OCLs that express a phenotype similar to that of pagetic OCLs. These results support a potential pathophysiologic role for MV infection in the abnormal OCL activity and morphology that are characteristic of pagetic OCLs.

Canine distemper virus induces human osteoclastogenesis through NF-kappaB and sequestosome 1/P62 activation.

UNLABELLED: Previous studies have implicated CDV in the pathogenesis of Paget's disease; however, there has been no direct evidence that CDV can infect human cells. We studied the effects of CDV on osteoclastogenesis in vitro and showed that CDV had a dose-dependent effect on osteoclastogenesis, through a possible mechanism involving activation of NF-kappaB and sequestosome 1/p62. INTRODUCTION: Paget's disease is characterized by a dramatic increase in size and number of osteoclasts. The etiology of the disorder is still unclear; however, evidence points to either a viral infection or a genetic susceptibility or a combination of both. Previously, we have shown that canine distemper virus (CDV) RNA is present in Pagetic bone. However, the effects of CDV on human osteoclast formation in vitro have not been studied previously. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Replicate cultures (n = 5) of purified human osteoclast precursors were infected with increasing doses of CDV and cultured on dentine slices for 14 days. Osteoclasts were stained for TRACP, and the dentine slices were examined for evidence of resorption. Control cells were incubated in the absence of virus. In each case, 10 high-power microscopy fields were analyzed. Immunocytochemical analyses were performed for p65, Gab2, sequestosome 1/p62, and ubiquitin. RESULTS: CDV dose-dependently increased osteoclast number and size (p < 0.0001, ANOVA), and there was a concomitant increase in resorption (p < 0.0001, ANOVA). CDV infection induced nuclear translocation of p65 and led to a dramatic increase in sequestosome 1/p62 and ubiquitin expression. CONCLUSIONS: These results provide the first conclusive proof that CDV can infect and replicate in human osteoclast precursors, raising possible zoonotic implications for CDV. The increased osteoclastogenesis is accompanied by NF-kappaB and sequestosome 1/p62 activation. This study provides further evidence for the possible role of paramyxoviruses in the pathogenesis of Paget's disease.

Expression of measles virus nucleocapsid protein in osteoclasts induces Paget's disease-like bone lesions in mice.

UNLABELLED: We targeted the MVNP gene to the OCL lineage in transgenic mice. These mice developed abnormal OCLs and bone lesions similar to those found in Paget's patients. These results show that persistent expression of MVNP in OCLs can induce pagetic-like bone lesions in vivo. INTRODUCTION: Paget's disease (PD) of bone is the second most common bone disease. Both genetic and viral factors have been implicated in its pathogenesis, but their exact roles in vivo are unclear. We previously reported that transfection of normal human osteoclast (OCL) precursors with the measles virus nucleocapsid (MVNP) or measles virus (MV) infection of bone marrow cells from transgenic mice expressing a MV receptor results in formation of pagetic-like OCLs. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Based on these in vitro studies, we determined if the MVNP gene from either an Edmonston-related strain of MV or a MVNP gene sequence derived from a patient with PD (P-MVNP), when targeted to cells in the OCL lineage of transgenic mice with the TRACP promoter (TRACP/MVNP mice), induced changes in bone similar to those found in PD. RESULTS: Bone marrow culture studies and histomorphometric analysis of bones from these mice showed that their OCLs displayed many of the features of pagetic OCLs and that they developed bone lesions that were similar to those in patients with PD. Furthermore, IL-6 seemed to be required for the development of the pagetic phenotype in OCLs from TRACP/MVNP mice. CONCLUSIONS: These results show that persistent expression of the MVNP gene in cells of the OCL lineage can induce pagetic-like bone lesions in vivo.

Measles virus nucleocapsid protein increases osteoblast differentiation in Paget's disease.

Paget's disease (PD) is characterized by focal and dramatic bone resorption and formation. Treatments that target osteoclasts (OCLs) block both pagetic bone resorption and formation; therefore, PD offers key insights into mechanisms that couple bone resorption and formation. Here, we evaluated OCLs from 3 patients with PD and determined that measles virus nucleocapsid protein (MVNP) was expressed in 70% of these OCLs. Moreover, transgenic mice with OCL-specific expression of MVNP (MVNP mice) developed PD-like bone lesions that required MVNP-dependent induction of high IL-6 expression levels in OCLs. In contrast, mice harboring a knockin of p62P394L (p62-KI mice), which is the most frequent PD-associated mutation, exhibited increased bone resorption, but not formation. Evaluation of OCLs from MVNP, p62-KI, and WT mice revealed increased IGF1 expression in MVNP-expressing OCLs that resulted from the high IL-6 expression levels in these cells. IL-6, in turn, increased the expression of coupling factors, specifically ephrinB2 on OCLs and EphB4 on osteoblasts (OBs). IGF1 enhanced ephrinB2 expression on OCLs and OB differentiation. Importantly, ephrinB2 and IGF1 levels were increased in MVNP-expressing OCLs from patients with PD and MVNP-transduced human OCLs compared with levels detected in controls. Further, anti-IGF1 or anti-IGF1R blocked Runx2 and osteocalcin upregulation in OBs cocultured with MVNP-expressing OCLs. These results suggest that in PD, MVNP upregulates IL-6 and IGF1 in OCLs to increase ephrinB2-EphB4 coupling and bone formation.

Measles virus nucleocapsid transcript expression is not restricted to the osteoclast lineage in patients with Paget's disease of bone.

Abundant evidence supports a viral etiology for Paget's disease of bone (PD), however, an infectious virus has not been isolated from PD patients. Thus, it is unclear how the virus is maintained for the many years that the disease persists in patients. We considered if a primitive multipotential hematopoietic stem cell (HSC), which is self-renewing, passes the virus to its differentiated progeny and serves as a reservoir for the pathogen. If a primitive stem cell harbored measles virus (MV), then other hematopoietic lineages derived from this stem cell in PD patients should also express MV transcripts. Therefore, because the human hematopoietic stem cell has not been clearly identified or isolated in large numbers, we isolated RNA from highly purified erythroid and multipotential hematopoietic progenitors that are the precursors for erythroid, granulocyte, megakaryocyte and macrophages (CFU-GEMM), and used RT-PCR to determine if MV nucleocapsid transcripts were present. MV transcripts were detected in PD patients in early erythroid (BFU-E) and more primitive multipotential myeloid progenitors (CFU-GEMM). Nonhematopoietic stromal cells from PD patients did not express MV transcripts. The expression of MV transcripts in erythroid progenitors was further confirmed by in situ hybridization using antisense riboprobes to MV nucleocapsid transcripts. Thus, our findings suggest that the pluripotent HSCs may be a potential reservoir for the virus. We propose that when HSCs, which contain MV, divide they produce a second HSC that serves as a reservoir for the virus and also transmit the virus to their more differentiated progeny in the erythroid and myeloid lineages. This mechanism would permit a defective virus to persist in HSCs of PD patients for many years, since HSCs are usually in G0 phase, and then be transmitted to more differentiated cells. This model further suggests that a mature complete virus that affects cell function could only act pathogenetically in the osteoclast lineage, which offers a permissive milieu.

Sequence analysis of measles virus nucleocapsid transcripts in patients with Paget's disease.

It has been debated for almost 30 years whether Paget's disease of bone results from paramyxoviral infection of osteoclasts (OCs). Paramyxoviral-like nuclear inclusions are found in OCs from patients with Paget's disease, and measles virus (MV) or canine distemper virus (CDV) messenger RNA (mRNA) transcripts have been detected by in situ hybridization in bone cells from pagetic lesions. Furthermore, immunocytochemical studies have shown the presence of several paramyxoviral species in OCs from patients with Paget's disease. However, others have been unable to detect paramyxoviral transcripts in bone samples from patients with Paget's disease or marrow cultures from involved sites of patients with Paget's disease. Furthermore, no one has been able to isolate an infectious virus from pagetic bone samples or marrow cells from patients with Paget's disease, and a full-length viral gene has not been sequenced from pagetic samples. In this study, we have obtained the full-length sequence for the MV nucleocapsid (MVNP) gene in bone marrow from an involved site from a patient with Paget's disease and more than 700 base pairs (bps) of MVNP sequence in 3 other patients with Paget's disease. These sequences were undetectable in four normal marrow samples studied simultaneously. The sequences from the patients contained multiple mutations that differed from the Edmonston strain MVNP gene. These findings are consistent with the presence of a chronic MV infection in affected sites from these patients with Paget's disease.

Detection of measles virus nucleocapsid transcripts in circulating blood cells from patients with Paget disease.

Paget disease of bone is characterized by abnormalities in all phases of bone remodeling, but the fundamental cellular abnormality resides in the osteoclast (OCL). Osteoclasts in bone involved by Paget disease contain viral-like nuclear and cytoplasmic inclusions that react with antibodies directed against paramyxovirus nucleocapsid proteins, such as measles virus, respiratory syncytial virus, or canine distemper virus. However, the identity of the virus or the mechanisms responsible for its persistence or pathologic role in Paget disease is unclear. Furthermore, although Paget disease persists for many years, it remains a highly localized process with new lesions rarely if ever developing in previously unaffected bones. Since osteoclasts are formed by fusion of mononuclear precursors derived from colony forming unit-granulocyte macrophage (CFU-GM), the granulocyte-macrophage progenitor, we used reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analysis to determine if CFU-GM, more differentiated osteoclast precursors, and peripheral blood cells derived from CFU-GM express measles virus nucleocapsid (MV-N) transcripts. We found that osteoclast precursors, as well as peripheral blood mononuclear cells, express MV transcripts in 9 of 13 patients. Sequence analysis of the PCR amplified products confirmed nucleotide identity of MV-N transcripts expressed in peripheral blood and bone marrow-derived cells from the same patient. In contrast, MV-N transcripts were not detected in OCL precursors or the peripheral blood from 10 normal subjects. In situ hybridization studies using 35S-labeled antisense riboprobes to MV-N transcripts further confirmed the expression of MV transcripts in these cells. Sequence analysis of the PCR amplified product from one of these patients also identified a novel mutation that converted lysine441 to glutamic acid441 in the MV-N transcript. These data demonstrate that OCL precursors and circulating peripheral blood cells also express MV transcripts in patients with Paget disease and suggest that the pagetic marrow microenvironment plays a critical role in maintaining the highly localized nature of the lesions in Paget disease.

A negative search for a paramyxoviral etiology of Paget's disease of bone: molecular, immunological, and ultrastructural studies in UK patients.

Paget's disease of bone is a common bone disease characterized by increased and disorganized bone remodeling at focal sites throughout the skeleton. The etiology of the disease is unresolved. A persistent viral infection has long been suggested to cause the disease. Antigen and/or nucleic acid sequences of paramyxoviruses (in particular measles virus [MV], canine distemper virus [CDV], and respiratory syncytial virus [RSV]) have been reported in pagetic bone by a number of groups; however, others have been unable to confirm this and so far no virus has been isolated from patients. Here, we reexamined the question of viral involvement in Paget's disease in a study involving 53 patients with established disease recruited from seven centers throughout the United Kingdom. Thirty-seven patients showed clear signs of active disease by bone scan and/or histological assessment of the bone biopsy specimens and 12 of these had not received any therapy before samples were taken. Presence of paramyxovirus nucleic acid sequences was sought in bone biopsy specimens, bone marrow, or peripheral blood mononuclear cells using reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) with a total of 18 primer sets (7 of which were nested), including 10 primer sets (including 3 nested sets) specifically for MV or CDV. For each patient at least one sample was tested with all primer sets by RT-PCR and no evidence for the presence of paramyxovirus RNA was found in any patient. In 6 patients, bone biopsy specimens with clear histological evidence of active disease tested negative for presence of measles and CDV using immunocytochemistry (ICC) and in situ hybridization (ISH). Intranuclear inclusion bodies, similar to those described by others previously, were seen in pagetic osteoclasts. The pagetic inclusions were straight, smooth tubular structures packed tightly in parallel bundles and differed from nuclear inclusions, known to represent MV nucleocapsids, in a patient with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE) in which undulating, diffuse structures were found, arranged loosely in a nonparallel fashion. In the absence of amplification of viral sequences from tissues that contain frequent nuclear inclusions and given that identical inclusions are found in other bone diseases with a proven genetic, rather than environmental, etiology, it is doubtful whether the inclusions in pagetic osteoclasts indeed represent viral nucleocapsids. Our findings in this large group of patients recruited from throughout the United Kingdom do not support a role for paramyxovirus in the etiology of Paget's disease.

Bone marrow mononuclear cells from patients with Paget's disease contain measles virus nucleocapsid messenger ribonucleic acid that has mutations in a specific region of the sequence.

Ultrastructural, immunocytochemical, and in situ hybridization studies have suggested that paramyxoviruses, such as measles virus (MV), are present in Pagetic osteoclasts and may contribute to the abnormality in osteoclast function. However, little additional information is known about potential viruses present in Pagetic osteoclasts. As there are increased numbers of osteoclast precursors among the marrow mononuclear cells of Paget's patients, we used the reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction to amplify the nucleocapsid sequence of MV from freshly isolated bone marrow-derived mononuclear cells to examine the potential role of these viruses in cells in the osteoclast lineage. We detected MV nucleocapsid transcripts in 5 of 6 individual Paget's patients' marrow samples. MV transcripts were not detected in marrow samples from 10 normal subjects. Sequence analysis of the PCR products revealed that 1 patient had the same sequence as the Edmonston strain of MV. The remaining 4 patients had point mutations clustered between position 1360-1371 base pairs. Two of the patients exhibited identical mutations at this region. In total, 3 different point mutations were identified that resulted in amino acid substitutions. These data show that 1) unlike those from normal subjects, marrow mononuclear cells from Paget's patients express MV nucleocapsid messenger ribonucleic acid; and 2) mutations of a specific region of the MV nucleocapsid gene were present in 4 of 5 patients and suggest a persistent MV infection in Pagetic osteoclast precursors. These data further suggest that osteoclasts are infected by fusion with infected precursors.

Paramyxoviruses and Paget's disease: the affirmative view.

Evidence has accumulated over the past 20 years to implicate paramyxoviruses in the etiopathology of Paget's disease. In the USA, the predominant virus detected is MV, whereas in northwestern England, CDV is most prevalent. The viruses are known to be easily spread by aerosol transmission to the respiratory tissues, from which they gain entry to the skeletal tissues via the hematopoietic system. Another characteristic of these viruses is their ability to persist at very low levels, thus evading the host immune response. Further studies have shown that IL-6, c-fos, and Bcl-2 are all elevated in Paget's disease--all of these factors can be activated by virally induced ROS. The genetic predisposition to Paget's disease and the perplexing focal nature of the disorder can also be explained by viral infection. Finally, the bisphosphonates, the class of drugs used so successfully to treat Paget's disease, have been shown to act, at least in part, by counteracting two of the major effects of the viruses in Paget's disease. The weight of evidence in support of a viral etiology for Paget's disease is overwhelming.

Detection of canine distemper virus in 100% of Paget's disease samples by in situ-reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction.

Previous evidence implicating paramyxoviruses in the aetiopathology of Paget's disease of bone has been controversial. While several groups have demonstrated the presence of paramyxoviruses using electron microscopy, immunohistochemistry, and molecular biological techniques, others have found no evidence of viruses using reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). We have previously provided evidence that canine distemper virus (CDV) is present in approximately 65% of samples of pagetic bone, using in situ hybridization and RT-PCR; however, these results have been criticized. To further investigate the possible Role of CDV, we have now developed the technique of in situ-RT-PCR (IS-RT-PCR) to examine for the presence of CDV-nucleocapsid (CDV-N) ribonucleic acid (RNA) in pagetic bone. Control samples consisted of uninvolved sites from patients with the disease, normal bone, and several active remodeling states. IS-RT-PCR was optimized to detect CDV-N using distemper-infected vero cells. The specificity of the technique was confirmed using vero cells infected with CDV, which showed amplified signal following IS-RT-PCR, and cells infected with measles virus (MV), in which no positive signal for CDV was detected by IS-RT-PCR. Following conventional in situ hybridization, CDV-N was detectable in 10 of 15 pagetic bone samples. However, after five, and particularly 10, cycles of IS-RT-PCR, CDV-N was found in all 15 samples. There was no evidence of CDV in four samples from uninvolved sites from pagetic patients, or in any of the other control samples. In this study, using the novel technique of IS-RT-PCR, CDV was found to be present in 100% of pagetic samples examined. There was no evidence of the virus in any of the control samples, including samples of bone from uninvolved sites from patients with Paget's disease. These results provide additional proof that CDV is present within pagetic bone and further support the hypothesis that paramyxoviruses are involved in the etiopathology of Paget's disease.

Paget's disease and osteoclast biology.

Paget's disease is the most exaggerated example of bone remodeling in which abnormal osteoclastic bone resorption remains coupled to new bone formation. There are abnormalities in the stages of osteoclast development, and studies in Paget's disease have suggested a major role for IL-6 in human osteoclast activity. The pathophysiologic basis for these abnormalities is not clearly defined, except that the primary cellular abnormality resides in the osteoclast. Many important questions about the pathophysiology of Paget's disease still remain to be answered, including: (1) What is the identity of the virus in pagetic osteoclasts?; (2) Are Paget's patients in different geographical locales harboring a similar virus in their osteoclasts, or can different paramyxoviruses induce Paget's disease?; (3) How is the virus maintained and propagated for many years, so that it can be expressed in the osteoclast, a cell with a finite lifespan?; and (4) Since Paget's disease has a very high familial tendency, with up to 40% of patients having an affected relative, what is the genetic locus associated with Paget's disease, and does this genotype result in an increased propensity for hematopoietic cells such as the osteoclast to harbor paramyxoviruses? The application of the techniques of molecular and cell biology to Paget's disease should provide answers to some of these questions and give important insights into the normal bone remodeling process.

Multinucleated cells formed in vitro from Paget's bone marrow express viral antigens.

Paget's disease of bone is characterized by large numbers of osteoclasts that have viral-like nuclear and/or cytoplasmic inclusions. Pagetic osteoclasts express respiratory syncytial viral (RSV) and measles viral (MV) nucleocapsid antigens. The data suggest a possible viral etiology for Paget's disease. However, studies to characterize further the putative viral inclusions in Paget's osteoclasts have been severely hampered by the extreme difficulty in isolating large numbers of osteoclasts from pagetic bone. The recent demonstration that osteoclast-like multinucleated cells (MNC), that had certain characteristics of pagetic osteoclasts formed in marrow cultures from Paget's patients, may permit studies to describe this virus further. Therefore, we have cultured marrow samples from involved and uninvolved bones from Paget's patients and from normal subjects to determine if the MNC formed in these cultures express viral antigens. RSV and/or MV antigens were expressed in the mononuclear cells and/or the MNC formed in 12 of 12 marrow cultures from active lesions of patients with Paget's disease, with 40-50% of the cells expressing viral antigens. In contrast, less than 5% of cells isolated from cultures from normal subjects expressed RSV and/or MV. These results suggest that MNC formed in long-term marrow cultures from patients with Paget's disease frequently express paramyxoviral antigens and are very similar to pagetic osteoclasts. Thus, these marrow cultures may be useful for further characterizing the virus in Paget's disease.

Paget's disease of bone and unvaccinated dogs.

The etiology of Paget's disease is unknown, but several observations suggest a viral cause. Since canine distemper virus is among those proposed to be a causal agent, we investigated the hypothesis that dog ownership may increase the risk of Paget's disease of bone by means of a case control study. One hundred and fifty patients with Paget's disease and 185 controls were interviewed using a structured questionnaire administered by the same interviewer. Participants were asked about their socioeconomic background and their exposure to pets. The risk of Paget's disease was not significantly increased in individuals. However, ownership of a mongrel dog was associated with a significant increase in risk (OR = 1.6; 95% CI = 1.0-2.4) and the risk increased still further with the ownership of an unvaccinated dog (OR = 2.8; 95% CI = 1.8-4.5). Additionally, ownership of cats and birds excluding dog owners, increased the risk of Paget's disease (OR = 2.5; 95% CI = 1.0-5.0; OR = 2.3; 95% CI = 1.0-5.3, respectively). These data suggest that previous exposure to cats, birds, and dogs unvaccinated for canine distemper may increase the risk of an individual developing Paget's disease of bone.

Are paramyxoviruses involved in Paget's disease? A negative view.

We believe that the assembled data are consistent with the presence of mRNA species and/or proteins in pagetic bone that are recognized by some paramyxovirus antibodies and nucleic acid probes. The evidence presented so far is insufficient to substantiate claims for the "unequivocal" presence of paramyxovirus sequences in pagetic bone, because the molecular targets for these probes could be endogenous mRNA's and proteins rather than viruses. Positive reports of a viral presence in Paget's disease have so far been confined to two laboratories, both of which have consistently demonstrated evidence for the virus they have worked on most. We argue that independent replication of the aforementioned findings is necessary to conclude that pagetic bone can be considered a site of chronic paramyxovirus infection. For this to be convincing, we would expect to see colocalization of viral antigens, mRNA, and genomic RNA in cells that also show ultrastructural evidence of viral infection. If virus is indeed present, it should, in addition, be possible to clone and characterize extensive tracts of viral cDNA from samples of pagetic tissue. Although we acknowledge that the absence of evidence for viral mRNA in some RT-PCR studies does not constitute evidence of absence, the data implicating paramyxoviruses as causal agents is conflicting and insufficient to prove a cause-effect relationship. In view of this, we believe that the role of paramyxovirus infection as a cause Paget's disease remains uncertain.

Absence of measles virus and canine distemper virus transcripts in long-term bone marrow cultures from patients with Paget's disease of bone.

The presence of intranuclear inclusions in pagetic osteoclasts with similar characteristics to those seen in some slow viral diseases has lead to the hypothesis that Paget's disease is caused by a similar infection. Bone marrow aspirates from seven patients with hemipelvic Paget's disease were taken from both sides of the pelvis and cultured under identical conditions. RNA was extracted after approximately 2 weeks of culture and reverse transcriptase-linked polymerase chain reaction used to investigate the expression of measles and canine distemper virus RNA. We were unable to detect the presence of measles virus (MV) or canine distemper virus (CDV) transcripts in bone marrow cultures from either affected or unaffected sites in any of our patients. The results of this study do not support a role for MV or CDV in the pathogenesis of Paget's disease of bone.

Canine bone marrow cell cultures infected with canine distemper virus: an in vitro model of Paget's disease.

We have previously shown that the canine paramyxovirus, canine distemper virus (CDV), is a possible aetiologic agent in Paget's disease of bone and in the canine bone disorder, metaphyseal osteopathy. More recently, we have examined the effects of CDV on the formation of multinucleated, tartrate resistant acid phosphatase positive, calcitonin receptor positive, osteoclast-like cells in cultures of canine bone marrow mononuclear cells, and shown that both in vitro and in vivo infection with CDV produced a dose dependent increase in the number and size of osteoclast-like cells. We have now extended these results to show that CDV infection induces interleukin-6 and c-Fos mRNA in these cells, similar to our recent findings in pagetic bone cells. These results further support the hypothesis that CDV might be involved in the aetiopathogenesis of Paget's disease and metaphyseal osteopathy and suggest that canine marrow culture systems will prove useful as an in vitro model to examine the disease processes in more detail.