Sequestration and Destruction of Rinderpest Virus-Containing Material 10 Years after Eradication.

In 2021, the world marked 10 years free from rinderpest. The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization and World Organisation for Animal Health have since made great strides in consolidating, sequencing, and destroying stocks of rinderpest virus-containing material, currently kept by only 14 known institutions. This progress must continue.

Protection of Cattle against Rinderpest by Vaccination with Wild-Type but Not Attenuated Strains of Peste des Petits Ruminants Virus.

UNLABELLED: Although rinderpest virus (RPV) has been eradicated in the wild, efforts are still continuing to restrict the extent to which live virus is distributed in facilities around the world and to prepare for any reappearance of the disease, whether through deliberate or accidental release. In an effort to find an alternative vaccine which could be used in place of the traditional live attenuated RPV strains, we have determined whether cattle can be protected from rinderpest by inoculation with vaccine strains of the related morbillivirus, peste des petits ruminants virus (PPRV). Cattle were vaccinated with wild-type PPRV or either of two established PPRV vaccine strains, Nigeria/75/1 or Sungri/96. All animals developed antibody and T cell immune responses to the inoculated PPRV. However, only the animals given wild-type PPRV were protected from RPV challenge. Animals given PPRV/Sungri/96 were only partially protected, and animals given PPRV/Nigeria/75/1 showed no protection against RPV challenge. While sera from animals vaccinated with the vaccine strain of RPV showed cross-neutralizing ability against PPRV, none of the sera from animals vaccinated with any strain of PPRV was able to neutralize RPV although sera from animals inoculated with wild-type PPRV were able to neutralize RPV-pseudotyped vesicular stomatitis virus. IMPORTANCE: Rinderpest virus has been eradicated, and it is only the second virus for which this is so. Significant efforts are still required to ensure preparedness for a possible escape of RPV from a laboratory or its deliberate release. Since RPV vaccine protects sheep and goats from PPRV, it is important to determine if the reverse is true as this would provide a non-RPV vaccine for dealing with suspected RPV outbreaks. This is probably the last in vivo study with live RPV that will be approved.

Rinderpest eradication: challenges for remaining disease free and implications for future eradication efforts.

In 2011, the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) declared global freedom from rinderpest, formally announcing that rinderpest virus infections had been eliminated from susceptible livestock populations. At the same time, it was recognised that rinderpest virus, and material containing rinderpest virus, remained stored in an unspecified number of facilities across the world. Although natural infections had been eliminated, there remained a risk that rinderpest could reoccur if such infectious material accidentally leaked or was intentionally released from one of these facilities into a susceptible animal population. To minimise this risk, the OIE and FAO, with the support of international partners, set in place a framework to: reduce the quantity of remaining rinderpest-virus-containing material; ensure that such material was only stored in high-security facilities; regulate any handling or manipulation of the virus; maintain vigilance amongst livestock keepers and Veterinary Services in the post-eradication era; and develop contingency plans to deal with any suspected or actual reoccurrence of rinderpest disease. In 2016, five years after the declaration of global freedom from rinderpest, official reports to the OIE show that virus and virus-containing material remain stored in 21 countries worldwide in 22 separate facilities, of which only five have been inspected and approved for holding rinderpest virus or vaccine. There is still much work to be done to further reduce the risk of a reoccurrence.

En 2011, l'Organisation mondiale de la santé animale (OIE) et l'Organisation des Nations Unies pour l'alimentation et l'agriculture (FAO) ont annoncé officiellement l'élimination de l'infection due au virus de la peste bovine dans les populations d'animaux d'élevage sensibles, déclarant ainsi la planète indemne de cette maladie. Parallèlement, les deux organisations faisaient état de l'existence d'un nombre indéterminé d'établissements dans le monde détenant des stocks du virus bovipestique ainsi que des produits contenant ce virus. Malgré l'élimination de l'infection chez ses hôtes naturels, un risque de réapparition de la peste bovine subsiste en cas de fuite accidentelle ou d'émission délibérée de ces produits infectieux dans les populations animales sensibles à partir de l'un de ces établissements. Afin de minimiser ce risque, l'OIE et la FAO soutenus par leurs partenaires internationaux ont mis en place un cadre visant plusieurs objectifs : réduire les quantités restantes de produits contenant le virus de la peste bovine dans le monde ; veiller à ce que ces produits ne soient stockés que dans des établissements de haute sécurité ; réglementer les conditions de détention et de manipulation du virus ; poursuivre la surveillance exercée par les éleveurs et les Services vétérinaires au cours de la phase post-éradication ; concevoir des plans d'urgence visant à faire face à toute réapparition suspectée ou confirmée de la peste bovine. En 2016, soit cinq ans après la déclaration de l'éradication mondiale de la peste bovine, il ressort des rapports officiels adressés à l'OIE que 21 pays détiennent encore des stocks du virus de la peste bovine ou des produits contenant ce virus, répartis en 22 établissements distincts dont seulement cinq ont fait l'objet d'une inspection et ont été dûment habilités à détenir des stocks de virus de la peste bovine ou de vaccins contre cette maladie. Il reste donc encore beaucoup à faire pour continuer à réduire le risque de réapparition de la peste bovine.

En 2011, la Organización Mundial de Sanidad Animal (OIE) y la Organización de las Naciones Unidas para la Alimentación y la Agricultura (FAO) anunciaron oficialmente que las infecciones causadas por el virus de la peste bovina habían sido eliminadas de las poblaciones sensibles de ganado, declarando así que el mundo quedaba libre de la enfermedad. Al mismo tiempo, significaron que un número no especificado de instalaciones dispersas por el mundo albergaban muestras del virus y otros productos que lo contenían. Aunque las infecciones naturales habían quedado eliminadas, subsistía el riesgo de reaparición de la peste bovina si en una de esas instalaciones se producía una fuga accidental o una liberación intencionada de material infeccioso y este entraba en contacto con una población animal sensible. Para reducir al mínimo tal riesgo, la OIE y la FAO, con apoyo de colaboradores internacionales, definieron un dispositivo encaminado a: reducir el volumen de material restante con contenido viral de la peste bovina; garantizar que ese material fuera conservado únicamente en instalaciones de alta seguridad; reglamentar toda manipulación del virus; mantener la vigilancia entre cuidadores de ganado y Servicios Veterinarios en el periodo posterior a la erradicación; y elaborar planes de emergencia para responder a toda reaparición, presunta o confirmada, de la peste bovina. En 2016, cinco años después de la declaración de ausencia mundial de peste bovina, los informes oficiales remitidos a la OIE daban fe de que había virus y productos que lo contenían en 22 instalaciones situadas en 21 países del mundo, de las que solo cinco habían sido inspeccionadas y homologadas para albergar virus de la peste bovina o vacunas contra la enfermedad. Queda pues mucho trabajo por delante para reducir en mayor medida el riesgo de reaparición.

Rinderpest experience.

Rinderpest, the most dreaded disease of cattle, originated as far back as the domestication of cattle, occurring in Asia more than 10,000 years ago. It has been the main preoccupation of Veterinary Service activities for many centuries and was the major motivation for establishing the first veterinary school in Lyon, France, in 1761. Gaining control of the disease was the impetus for the founding of many regional and international organisations (including the World Organisation for Animal Health). Outbreaks of rinderpest have led to food shortages and starvation, economic losses and poverty, social unrest, and disrupted transport networks in regions where agriculture was dependent on draught cattle. The rinderpest virus, causative agent of the disease, has also been used as a biological weapon in the past. Many regional rinderpest eradication campaigns have been implemented, including Joint Project 15; the Pan-African Rinderpest Campaign (PARC); the South Asia Rinderpest Eradication Campaign; the West Asia Rinderpest Eradication Campaign; and the Pan African Programme for the Control of Epizootics. All of these campaigns were supported by regional and international organisations, and the disease was finally eradicated in 2011. The benefit of PARC in terms of the value of avoided losses in cattle products due to the decrease in the disease's occurrence was estimated to be between 581,000 and 35,433,000 European currency units. Currently, the world is prepared to prevent the deliberate or accidental release of the remaining infectious rinderpest virus material which exists in research and diagnostic facilities across the world.

La peste bovine, la plus redoutable des maladies bovines, existe depuis l'époque reculée de la domestication des bovins, puisqu'elle est apparue en Asie il y a plus de dix mille ans. Au fil des siècles, cette maladie a été une préoccupation centrale des services en charge de la santé animale et a été le motif principal de la création de la première école vétérinaire, à Lyon (France) en 1761. L'ambition de maîtriser la peste bovine a participé de l'élan qui a vu naître nombre d'organisations régionales et internationales (dont l'Organisation mondiale de la santé animale). Les épidémies de peste bovine ont entraîné des pénuries alimentaires et des famines, des pertes économiques et une pauvreté accrue, une instabilité sociale et l'effondrement des réseaux de transport dans les régions où l'agriculture dépendait des bovidés de trait. Le virus responsable de la peste bovine a également été utilisé en tant qu'arme biologique dans le passé. De nombreuses campagnes d'éradication de la peste bovine ont été mises en œuvre à l'échelle régionale, parmi lesquelles le Projet conjoint 15, la Campagne panafricaine de lutte contre la peste bovine (PARC), la Campagne d'éradication de la peste bovine en Asie du Sud, la Campagne d'éradication de la peste bovine en Asie occidentale et le Programme panafricain de contrôle des épizooties. Ces campagnes ont toutes reçu le soutien d'organisations régionales et internationales et la maladie a finalement été éradiquée en 2011. Les bénéfices du programme PARC en termes de pertes de production évitées dans le secteur bovin grâce au déclin de l'incidence de la maladie ont été estimés entre 581 000 et 35 433 000 ECU (unité de compte européenne). Aujourd'hui, le monde est prêt à prévenir toute libération délibérée ou accidentelle des stocks restants de produits contenant le virus de la peste bovine détenus dans différents établissements de recherche et de diagnostic répartis dans le monde.

Los orígenes de la peste bovina, que es la más temida de las enfermedades del ganado vacuno, se remontan a la domesticación de los bovinos, que se dio en Asia hace más de 10 000 años. Durante muchos siglos ha sido una de las grandes preocupaciones que han guiado el trabajo de los Servicios Veterinarios, y fue uno de los principales factores que motivaron la fundación de la primera escuela de veterinaria en Lyon (Francia) en 1761. El objetivo de llegar a controlar la enfermedad fue el acicate que llevó a la creación de numerosas organizaciones de ámbito regional e internacional (entre ellas la Organización Mundial de Sanidad Animal). Los brotes de peste bovina han causado episodios de escasez de alimentos y hambruna, pérdidas económicas, pobreza y disturbios sociales, sin olvidar la desorganización de las redes de transporte en regiones donde la agricultura dependía del ganado de tiro. En el pasado el virus de la peste bovina, agente causal de la enfermedad, también ha sido utilizado como arma biológica. Numerosas campañas regionales de erradicación de la peste bovina han visto la luz, entre ellas el llamado Proyecto Conjunto 15, la Campaña panafricana contra la peste bovina (PARC), la Campaña de Erradicación de la Peste Bovina en Asia Meridional, la Campaña de Erradicación de la Peste Bovina en Asia Occidental y el Programa Panafricano de Control de Epizootias. Gracias a todas estas iniciativas, respaldadas por organizaciones regionales e internacionales, en 2011 la enfermedad quedó por fin erradicada. Según las estimaciones, basadas en el valor económico de las pérdidas de productos ganaderos evitadas gracias a la reducción de los casos de enfermedad, la PARC deparó entre 581 000 y 35 433 000 Ecus (unidades de cuenta europeas) de beneficios. En la actualidad el mundo está preparado para evitar toda liberación accidental o deliberada de las muestras infecciosas de virus de la peste bovina que aún se conservan en centros de investigación y diagnóstico de todo el planeta.

Livestock vaccination in India: an analysis of theory and practice among multiple stakeholders.

An effective and efficient disease prevention and control strategy is of paramount importance to improve the quality and quantity of livestock production in the Indian context. Although livestock vaccination is considered an emerging innovation of socioeconomic importance in the Indian dairy industry, the rate of adoption and diffusion of vaccination technology is very low at field level. In this context, the authors examined the efforts of the Government of India to protect livestock health and control disease, considered the lessons learnt from rinderpest eradication, looked at field practices and the reality on the ground, and studied the perceptions of multiple stakeholders with regards to the relevance, profitability and sustainability of vaccination. In this study, the authors consider policy implications for the Indian dairy industry using the responses of 360 dairy farmers, 80 research scientists and 40 extension workers in India. The study revealed that scientists and extension experts rated vaccination highly in terms of its relevance, profitability and sustainability, while the perception of farmers was less favourable. The study also observed that, even after implementation of various disease control programmes with heavy financial expenditure, there was a wide gap between farmers and scientists and between farmers and extension workers with regards to their perceptions of the relevance, profitability and sustainability of vaccination, while the gap was very narrow between scientists and extension workers. It can be concluded, therefore, that there is a need to generate innovations for disease control that are perceived as relevant, profitable and sustainable so as to encourage higher levels of diffusion and adoption at field level. This study recommends that farmers partner with researchers and extension workers to ensure effective generation and transfer of new dairying technologies, leading to higher production and productivity in the Indian dairy sector.

En Inde, l'amélioration qualitative et quantitative de la productivité des élevages passe nécessairement par la mise en place de stratégies efficaces et efficientes de prévention et de contrôle des maladies animales. Les producteurs de lait et de produits laitiers considèrent la vaccination du bétail comme une innovation importante au plan socio-économique mais le niveau d'adoption et de diffusion des technologies vaccinales demeure très faible sur le terrain. Ce constat a incité les auteurs à effectuer une étude visant à analyser les efforts déployés par le gouvernement indien pour protéger la santé du bétail et pour lutter contre les maladies, à déterminer le niveau de prise en compte des leçons de l'éradication de la peste bovine, et à décrire les pratiques et la situation concrète sur le terrain ainsi que la manière dont les diverses parties prenantes perçoivent la pertinence, la rentabilité économique et les effets dans le temps de la vaccination. Dans cette étude, les auteurs ont interrogé 360 éleveurs de vaches laitières, 80 chercheurs et 40 agents de vulgarisation en Inde afin de déterminer les effets des politiques zoosanitaires sur le secteur de l'élevage laitier indien. L'étude a montré que la pertinence, la rentabilité économique et les effets dans le temps de la vaccination étaient perçus très favorablement par les chercheurs et par les agents de vulgarisation, tandis que la perception des éleveurs était moins positive. L'étude a également permis de constater que l'écart manifeste entre la perception des éleveurs d'un côté et celle des chercheurs et des agents de vulgarisation de l'autre concernant la pertinence, la rentabilité et l'effet dans le temps de la vaccination subsistait même après la mise en oeuvre à grands frais de programmes de lutte contre les maladies animales, tandis que cet écart était minime entre les chercheurs et les agents de vulgarisation. Les auteurs concluent sur la nécessité de veiller à ce que les innovations mises en place en matière de lutte contre les maladies animales soient perçues comme pertinentes, rentables et durables, afin de promouvoir une meilleure appropriation et diffusion de ces méthodes sur le terrain. Les auteurs préconisent le recours à des partenariats entre les éleveurs, les chercheurs et les agents de vulgarisation afin d'assurer une conception et un transfert efficaces des technologies dans le secteur de la production de lait et d'améliorer ainsi la production et la productivité du secteur laitier indien.

En el contexto de la India, para mejorar la producción bovina tanto en calidad como en cantidad es de capital importancia disponer de una estrategia eficaz y eficiente de prevención y control de enfermedades. Aunque la vacunación del ganado está considerada una innovación incipiente de gran importancia socioeconómica para el sector lechero del país, sobre el terreno se dan índices muy bajos de adopción y difusión de las técnicas de vacunación. En tales circunstancias, los autores examinaron las iniciativas del Gobierno de la India para proteger la salud del ganado y combatir sus enfermedades, repasaron las enseñanzas extraídas de la erradicación de la peste bovina, observaron la praxis y las realidades sobre el terreno e indagaron en la percepción que tienen numerosos interlocutores del sector de la pertinencia, rentabilidad y sostenibilidad de las vacunaciones. A partir de las respuestas aportadas por 360 productores, 80 investigadores y 40 agentes de extensión del país, los autores estudian las repercusiones normativas para la industria lechera india. El proceso puso de manifiesto que los científicos y especialistas en extensión otorgan a la vacunación un lugar de privilegio por lo que respecta a su pertinencia, rentabilidad y sostenibilidad, mientras que a los productores les merece una opinión menos positiva. Los autores observaron igualmente que, aun tras la implantación de diversos programas de lucha zoosanitaria que supusieron cuantiosas inversiones económicas, existía un gran desfase entre los productores, por un lado, y los científicos y agentes de extensión, por el otro, en cuanto a la valoración que hacían de la pertinencia, rentabilidad y sostenibilidad de las vacunaciones, mientras que las opiniones de científicos y agentes de extensión apenas diferían. Cabe concluir, por lo tanto, que para inducir sobre el terreno mayores niveles de adopción y difusión es indispensable generar innovaciones de lucha zoosanitaria que sean percibidas como algo pertinente, rentable y sostenible. Los autores recomiendan que los productores trabajen en asociación con los investigadores y agentes de extensión para lograr así que se generen y transfieran eficazmente nuevas tecnologías de producción lechera, lo que a su vez redundará en un aumento de la producción y productividad del sector lechero indio.

Rinderpest: A Disease of the Past, and a Present Threat.

Rinderpest is a highly contagious viral disease that affects ungulates such as cattle, buffalo, yak, and various wildlife species, leading to significant morbidity and mortality. The global eradication of rinderpest was successfully accomplished in 2011 through extensive vaccination efforts. Today, safeguarding against the re-emergence of rinderpest in animal populations is paramount. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations and the World Organization for Animal Health are entrusted through a series of resolutions with the responsibility to prevent the re-emergence of rinderpest in animals.

Rinderpest virus sequestration and use in posteradication era.

After the 2011 declaration of rinderpest disease eradication, we surveyed 150 countries about rinderpest virus stocks. Forty-four laboratories in 35 countries held laboratory-attenuated strains, field strains, or diagnostic samples. Vaccine and reagent production and laboratory experiments continued. Rigorous standards are necessary to ensure that stocks are kept under safe conditions.

The long journey: a brief review of the eradication of rinderpest.

In 2011, the 79th General Session of the World Assembly of the World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) and the 37th Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAD) Conference adopted a resolution declaring the world free from rinderpest and recommending follow-up measures to preserve the benefits of this new and hard-won situation. Eradication is an achievable objective for any livestock disease, provided that the epidemiology is uncomplicated and the necessary tools, resources and policies are available. Eradication at a national level inevitably reflects national priorities, whereas global eradication requires a level of international initiative and leadership to integrate these tools into a global framework, aimed first at suppressing transmission across all infected areas and concluding with a demonstration thatthis has been achieved. With a simple transmission chain and the environmental fragility of the virus, rinderpest has always been open to control and even eradication within a zoosanitary approach. However, in the post-1945 drive for more productive agriculture, national and global vaccination programmes became increasingly relevant and important. As rinderpest frequently spread from one region to another through trade-related livestock movements, the key to global eradication was to ensure that such vaccination programmes were carried out in a synchronised manner across all regions where the disease was endemic - an objective to which the European Union, the United States Agency for International Development, the International Atomic Energy Agency, the African Union-Interafrican Bureau of Animal Resources, FA0 and OIE fully subscribed. This article provides a review of rinderpest eradication, from the seminal work carried out by Giovanni Lancisi in the early 18th Century to the global declaration in 2011.

Disease properties, geography, and mitigation strategies in a simulation spread of rinderpest across the United States.

For the past decade, the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations has been working toward eradicating rinderpest through vaccination and intense surveillance by 2012. Because of the potential severity of a rinderpest epidemic, it is prudent to prepare for an unexpected outbreak in animal populations. There is no immunity to the disease among the livestock or wildlife in the United States (US). If rinderpest were to emerge in the US, the loss in livestock could be devastating. We predict the potential spread of rinderpest using a two-stage model for the spread of a multi-host infectious disease among agricultural animals in the US. The model incorporates large-scale interactions among US counties and the small-scale dynamics of disease spread within a county. The model epidemic was seeded in 16 locations and there was a strong dependence of the overall epidemic size on the starting location. The epidemics were classified according to overall size into small epidemics of 100 to 300 animals (failed epidemics), epidemics infecting 3,000 to 30,000 animals (medium epidemics), and the large epidemics infecting around one million beef cattle. The size of the rinderpest epidemics were directly related to the origin of the disease and whether or not the disease moved into certain key counties in high-livestock-density areas of the US. The epidemic size also depended upon response time and effectiveness of movement controls.

Protection of cattle against rinderpest with vaccinia virus recombinants expressing the HA or F gene.

Rinderpest is a highly contagious ruminant viral disease manifested by a rapid course and greater than 90% mortality. Infectious vaccinia virus recombinants were constructed that express either the hemagglutinin or the fusion gene of rinderpest virus. All cattle vaccinated with either recombinant or with the combined recombinants produced neutralizing antibodies against rinderpest virus and were protected against the disease when challenged with more than 1000 times the lethal dose of the virus.

Rinderpest seroprevalence in wildlife in Kenya and Tanzania, 1982-1993.

Eight hundred and thirty five serum samples collected from eight wild artiodactyl species in Kenya and Tanzania between 1982 and 1993 were tested for virus-neutralising (VN) antibodies to rinderpest (RP) virus. Antibodies were found in 116 of 344 buffaloes (Syncerus caffer) but not in the other species including 349 wildebeest (Connochaetes taurinus). Most of the antibody positive buffaloes were from the Maasai Mara-Serengeti ecosystem (MM-SE) and would have had opportunity for exposure to the virus during the epidemic of rinderpest in buffalo confirmed there in 1982. Buffalo born after 1985 did not have antibody indicating that virus stopped circulating in this population at or around that time. This second demonstration that RP virus disappears from the MM-SE is further evidence that these species are not permanent reservoirs of this virus. Re-infection of wildlife is transient and they remain valuable sentinels for infection in nearby domestic livestock.

[Austrian Low Countries, Europe's animal health pioneer, 1769-1776]. / Les Pays-Bas autrichiens précurseurs Européens en police sanitaire 1769-1776.

Two previously unpublished manuscripts reveal how innovative the Austrian Low Countries were when they introduced an animal health policy to control rinderpest in 1769. The policy was novel in that it replaced the slaughter of individual sick animals with herd slaughter. Unfortunately, a number of neighbouring countries failed to emulate this sure-fire method of controlling rinderpest, among them France.