K-wire Pull-Out Force After Multiple Redirection Attempts.

PURPOSE: To evaluate if redirecting a Kirschner wire (K-wire) through the same proximal hole will weaken the pull-out force and to test if multiple redirections will result in a continued stepwise decrease in pull-out force. METHODS: An Instron was used to test the pull-out force of K-wires using the peak initial failure load as a measure of failure of K-wire fixation. K-wires 0.062 inches in diameter were inserted with an angled drill guide into a bicortical bone substrate. Trials were divided into 7 groups with the first group having the K-wires placed through both cortices and then tested without redirection. In groups 2-6, the K-wire was placed bicortically and then withdrawn and redirected through the same proximal hole with 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 redirections. A control group in which the K-wire was only unicortical was also tested. RESULTS: Compared with the control group of no redirects, any number of redirections weakened the pull-out force. There was no difference between redirected groups and the unicortical group. When comparing between redirections, there were no significant differences in pull-out force. Regression analysis showed that, after the first redirection, there was no stepwise change in pull-out force with additional redirection. CONCLUSIONS: There was a significant decrease in pull-out force with any redirections, but there was no stepwise decrease in failure force after multiple redirections. The failure force of any redirection was similar to a unicortically placed wire. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Any K-wire redirection attempts in hand bone fixation can result in a considerably weakened construct.

Predicting Pedicle Screw Pullout and Fatigue Performance: Comparing Lateral Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry, Anterior to Posterior Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry, and Computed Tomography Hounsfield Units.

BACKGROUND: As the prevalence and associated health care costs of osteoporosis continue to rise in our aging population, there is a growing need to continue to identify methods to predict spine construct integrity accurately and cost-effectively. Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) in both anterior to posterior (AP) and lateral planes, as well as computed tomography (CT) Hounsfield units (HU), have all been investigated as potential preoperative predictive tools. The purpose of this study is to determine which of the 3 bone density analysis modalities has the highest potential for predicting pedicle screw biomechanics. METHODS: Lumbar spine specimens (L2, L3, and L4) from 6 fresh frozen cadavers were used for testing. AP-DEXA, lateral-DEXA, and CT images were obtained. Biomechanical testing of pedicle screws in each vertebrae was then performed including pullout strength and fatigue testing. Statistical analysis was performed. RESULTS: Pullout strength was best predicted by CT HU, followed by AP-DEXA, then lateral-DEXA (R 2 = 0.78, 0.70, and 0.40, respectively). Fatigue testing showed a significant correlation of relative rotation between HU value and AP-DEXA bone mineral density (R 2 = 0.54 and R 2 = 0.72, respectively), and there was a significant correlation between relative translation and HU value (R 2 = 0.43). There was a poor correlation between relative rotation and lateral-DEXA (R 2 = 0.13) as well as a poor correlation between relative translation and both AP- and lateral-DEXA (R 2 = 0.35 and R 2 = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: CT is the only modality with a statistically significant correlation to all biomechanical parameters measured (pullout strength, relative angular rotation, and relative translation). AP-DEXA also predicts the biomechanical measures of screw pullout and relative angular rotation and is superior to lateral-DEXA. CT may provide an incremental benefit in assessing fatigue strength, but this should be weighed against the disadvantages of cost and radiation. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: The results of this study can help to inform clinicians on different bone density analyses and their implications on pedicle screw failure.

Novel microcomposite implant for the controlled delivery of antibiotics in the treatment of osteomyelitis following total joint replacement.

The objective of this study was to develop a novel microcomposite implant to be used in the treatment of osteomyelitis following total joint arthroplasty, with the dual purpose of releasing high local concentrations of antibiotic to eradicate the infection while providing adequate mechanical strength to maintain the dynamic or static spacer. Vancomycin-loaded microcomposite implants were fabricated by incorporating drug-loaded microparticles comprised of mesoporous silica into commonly employed polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) bone cement, to yield a final drug loading of 10% w/w. In vitro release kinetics at 37°C were monitored by reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography, and compared to the release kinetics of current therapy implants consisting of drug alone incorporated at 10% w/w directly into PMMA bone cement. Results demonstrated a sevenfold improvement in the elution profile of microcomposite systems over current therapy implants. In vivo delivery of vancomycin to bone from microcomposite implants (70% of payload) was significantly higher than that from current therapy implants (approx. 22% of payload) and maintained significantly higher bone concentrations for up to 2 weeks duration. The elastic modulus showed no statistical difference between microcomposite implants and current standard therapy implants before drug elution, and maintenance of acceptable strength of microcomposite implants postdrug elution. These results demonstrate that we have developed a novel microcomposite spacer that will release continuously high antibiotic concentrations over a prolonged period of time, offering the possibility to eliminate infection and avoid the emergence of new resistant bacterial strains, while maintaining the requisite mechanical properties for proper space maintenance and joint fixation.

External fixator-augmented flexible intramedullary nailing of an unstable pediatric femoral shaft fracture model: a biomechanical study.

The objective of this study was to test the compressive strength and torsional stiffness provided by the addition of a two-pin external fixator to an unstable pediatric femoral shaft fracture model after being instrumented with flexible intramedullary nailing (FIMN), and to compare this to bridge plating and FIMN alone. A length-unstable oblique diaphyseal fracture was created in 15 pediatric sized small femur models. Fracture stabilization was achieved by three constructs: standard retrograde FIMN with two 3.5-mm titanium (Ti) nails (Group 1), FIMN augmented with a two-pin external fixator (Group 2), and a 4.5-mm bridge plate (Group 3). Groups I and II were tested in 10 cycles of axial rotation to 10° in both directions at 0.1 Hz under 36 kg of compression. Torsional stiffness was calculated. Compressive strength was calculated by applying an axial load of 5 mm/min until failure was encountered. Failure was defined as the force required to achieve 10° varus at the fracture site or shortening of 2 cm. Group II demonstrated a greater compressive strength compared to Group I (1067.32 N vs 453.49 N, P < 0.001). No significant difference in torsional stiffness was found between Groups I and II (0.45 vs 0.38 Nm/deg, P = 0.18). Group III showed superior compressive strength and rotational stiffness compared to Groups I and II. In an unstable pediatric femoral shaft fracture model, augmenting FIMN with a two-pin external fixator increased the compressive strength by 147%, but did not increase torsional stiffness. Bridge plating with a 4.5-mm plate provided superior compressive strength and torsional stiffness.

Sacral Endplate Penetrating Screw for Lumbosacral Fixation: A Cadaveric Biomechanical Study.

BACKGROUND: Cortical bone trajectory is a relatively new alternative for instrumentation of the lumbar spine. When performing lumbosacral instrumentation, a novel S1 endplate penetrating screw (EPS) has been recently shown to have higher insertional torque than the traditional trajectory screw, but the biomechanical properties of this new trajectory are yet to be verified with the cadaveric studies. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate 2 screw trajectories in sacra using cyclic loading and pullout tests, and to determine whether bone quality had different effects on the 2 trajectories. METHODS: Nine cadaveric sacra were used, 5 of which had normal bone mineral density (BMD) and 4 were osteoporotic. Each side of the sacra was randomly assigned to either EPS trajectory or S1-alar screw (S1AS) trajectory. Each screw then underwent cyclic loading followed by pullout force measurement. A mixed-design 2 way ANOVA test was used to detect differences between the groups. RESULTS: The EPS group had less relative rotation at the bone-screw interface during cyclic loading than the S1AS group (P = .016) regardless of bone quality. The pullout force following the cyclic loading was significantly higher in the EPS group (2349 ± 838 N) than the S1AS group (917 ± 909 N) in normal bone (P < .0001). The difference was more pronounced in osteoporotic bone with the EPS (1075 ± 216 N) compared to the S1AS (365 ± 422 N; P < .0001). CONCLUSION: The S1 EPS trajectory is significantly more stable against loosening and has a higher pullout force compared to the S1AS trajectory. The difference between the 2 trajectories is more pronounced in osteoporotic bone.

Screw design alters the effects of stress relaxation on pullout.

Stress relaxation during pullout of a pedicle screw decreases the peak load and stiffness of the bone-screw interface. However, it is unknown whether this can be generalized to all types of screw designs. This study aimed to show whether screw design altered the effects of stress relaxation on the mechanical performance of the pedicle screw during pullout. Twelve calf vertebrae were obtained: six vertebrae were instrumented with 7.5x40 mm conical pedicle screws and the other six with 5.0x40 mm cylindrical pedicle screws. The screws with two different designs were pulled out using either a standard pullout or a stress relaxation pullout protocol. Both bone-screw interfaces had lower stiffness in the stress relaxation pullout model than in the standard pullout model, but it was significant in only the cylindrical design group (P<0.05). However, the stress relaxation and standard pullout models did not yield any difference in peak loads in either screw type. Although stress relaxation at the bone-screw interface can alter the mechanical performance of the screw, this may be eliminated by modifying the screw design. A better understanding of viscoelastic properties of the bone-screw interface may help improve implant design and thus, clinical outcomes.

Temperature Rise in Kirschner Wires Inserted Using Two Drilling Methods: Forward and Oscillation.

BACKGROUND: Kirschner wires (K-wires) are commonly used in orthopedic surgery. However, the loosening of the pins can lead to delayed or improper healing or infection. Wire loosening can occur by thermal necrosis that occurs due to heat produced during wire insertion. Although the parameters that affect temperature rise in cortical bone during wire insertion and drilling have been studied, the effect of drilling mode (oscillation versus forward) is unknown. The purpose of this study was to compare the temperature changes occurring in cortical bone during wire insertions by oscillating and forward drills. Our hypothesis is that oscillation drilling would produce less heat compared with forward drilling in K-wire insertion with 2 commonly used wire diameters. METHODS: We drilled K-wires in a pig metacarpal model and measured the temperature rise between forward and oscillation drilling modes using diamond-tipped 0.062- and 0.045-inch-diameter K-wires. There were 20 holes drilled for each group (n = 20). RESULTS: The average temperature rise using the 0.062-inch K-wire under forward and oscillation insertion was 14.0 ± 5.5°C and 8.8 ± 2.6°C, respectively. For the 0.045-inch K-wire, under forward and oscillation insertion, the average temperature rise was 11.4 ± 2.6°C and 7.1 ± 1.9°C, respectively. The effects of the drilling mode and wire diameter on temperature rise were significant ( P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, the oscillation of K-wires during insertion causes a lower temperature rise when compared with forward drilling.

Pedicle screws with modular head vs. preassembled head used in cortical bone trajectory: Can pars and pedicle fractures be prevented in osteoporotic bone?

Pars and pedicle fractures as a result of CBT (cortical bone trajectory) during pedicle screw placement have been reported. The primary aim of the study is to compare the fracture rate between screws with modular heads to screws with standard pre-assembled tulip heads. The secondary aim of the study is to determine the potential variables that can be identified prior to instrumentation in order to predict risk of fractures. Twenty-four fresh frozen lumbar vertebrae were obtained from five different cadavers. Anatomical landmark measurements were obtained. Right and left pedicles of each vertebra were randomly instrumented with the preassembled head screws (n=24) and modular head screws (n=24) under video recording. X-ray images were obtained for measuring relative angle deviations between tapped and final screw trajectories. Finally, pullout tests were performed. Seventeen out of twenty-four (70.8%) of the spinous processes had to be excised in order to obtain proper trajectories. Six fractures occurred with pre-assembled head screws versus one in the modular head screws (p=0.04). Distances from the midline to the medial wall of the pedicle were marginally significant as a predictor for fracture (p=0.08). The pullout loads between both types of screws were not statistically different (p=0.38). Age was better correlated with pullout load than absolute bone density value (p<0.001). In conclusion, modular head screws had a significantly lower fracture rate than pre-assembled head screws for cortical bone trajectory in osteoporotic bone. There was no clear anatomic variable that could be measured pre-operatively to predict potential fracture risk in CBT.

C1 Lateral Mass Displacement and Transverse Atlantal Ligament Failure in Jefferson's Fracture: A Biomechanical Study of the "Rule of Spence".

BACKGROUND: Jefferson's fracture, first described in 1927, represents a bursting fracture of the C1 ring with lateral displacement of the lateral masses. It has been determined that if the total lateral mass displacement (LMD) exceeds 6.9 mm, there is high likelihood of transverse atlantal ligament (TAL) rupture, and if LMD is less than 5.7 mm TAL injury is unlikely. Several recent radiographic studies have questioned the accuracy and validity of the "rule of Spence" and it lacks biomechanical support. OBJECTIVE: To determine the amount of LMD necessary for TAL failure using modern biomechanical techniques. METHODS: Using a universal material testing machine, cadaveric TALs were stretched laterally until failure. A high-resolution, high-speed camera was utilized to measure the displacement of the lateral masses upon TAL failure. RESULTS: Eleven cadaveric specimens were tested (n = 11). The average LMD upon TAL failure was 3.2 mm (±1.2 mm). The average force required to cause failure of the TAL was 242 N (±82 N). From our data analysis, if LMD exceeds 3.8 mm, there is high probability of TAL failure. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that although the rule of Spence is a conceptually valid measure of TAL integrity, TAL failure occurs at a significantly lower value than previously reported (P < .001). Based on our literature review and findings, LMD is not a reliable independent indicator for TAL failure and should be used as an adjunctive tool to magnetic resonance imaging rather an absolute rule.

Cortex of the pedicle of the vertebral arch. Part I: Deformation characteristics during screw insertion.

OBJECT: Elastic deformation has been proposed as a mechanism by which vertebral pedicles can maintain pullout strength when conical screws are backed out from full insertion. The response to the insertion technique may influence both the extent of deformation and the risk of acute fracture during screw placement. The aim of this study was to determine the deformation characteristics of the lumbar pedicle cortex during screw placement. METHODS: Lumbar pedicles with linear strain gauges attached at the lateral and medial cortices were instrumented using 7.5-mm pedicle screws with or without preconditioning by insertion and removal of 6.5-mm screws. The strains and elastic recoveries of the medial and lateral cortices were determined. RESULTS: Mean medial wall strains tended to be lower than mean lateral wall strains when the 6.5-mm and 7.5-mm screw data were pooled (p = 0.07). After the screws had been removed, 71 to 79% of the deformation at the lateral cortex and 70 to 96% of the deformation at the medial cortex recovered. When inserted first, the 7.5-mm screw caused more plastic deformation at the cortex than it did when inserted after the 6.5-mm screw. Occasional idiosyncratic strain patterns were observed. No gross fracture was observed during screw placement. CONCLUSIONS: Screw insertion generated plastic deformation at the pedicle cortex even though the screw did not directly contact the cortex. The lateral and medial cortices responded differently to screw insertion. The technique of screw insertion affected the deformation behavior of the lumbar pedicles. With myriad options for screw selection and placement available, further study is needed before optimal placement parameters can be verified.

Cortex of the pedicle of the vertebral arch. Part II: Microstructure.

OBJECT: Although the gross anatomy of the pedicle in the human spine has been investigated in great detail, knowledge of the microanatomy of trabecular and cortical structures of the pedicle is limited. An understanding of the mechanical properties and structure of the pedicle bone is essential for improving the quality of pedicle screw placement. To enhance this understanding, the authors examined human cadaveric lumbar vertebrae. METHODS: In this study, the authors obtained seven human cadaveric lumbar vertebrae. The lateral and medial cortices of these pedicle specimens were sectioned and embedded in polymethylmethacrylate. Cross-sectional slices of cortex were obtained from each specimen and imaged with the aid of a high-resolution light microscope. Assessments of osteonal orientation, determinations of relative dimensions, and histomorphometric studies were performed. RESULTS: The cortex of the pedicle in each human lumbar vertebra had an osteonal structure with haversian canals laid down mainly in the anteroposterior (longitudinal) direction. The organization of osteons across the transverse cross-section was not homogeneous. The layer of lamellar bone that typically envelops cortical bone structures (such as in long bones) was not observed, and the lateral cortex was significantly thinner than the medial cortex (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The cortical bone surrounding the pedicle differed from bone in other anatomical regions such as the anterior vertebral body and femur. The osteonal orientation and lack of a lamellar sheath may account for the unique deformation characteristics of the pedicle cortex seen during pedicle screw placement.

Effects of angle and laminectomy on triangulated pedicle screws.

We aimed to demonstrate the effect of angle and laminectomy on paired pedicle screws to determine whether a 90 degrees screw angle is optimal as has been previously suggested. According to the angle between right and left screws, 28 calf vertebrae were divided into three groups and instrumented as follows: Group I: 60 degrees screw angle; Group II: 90 degrees angle; Group III: 60 degrees angle with laminectomy. The screws were connected using rods and cross-fixators and tested to peak pullout force. Triangulated pedicle screws provided 76.5% more pullout strength than single screws. Most of the specimens failed through loss of convergence angle (toggling of screws on the rods) and subsequent uni- or bilateral screw pullout. Mean+/-SD peak loads were: Group I: 2071+/-622 N; Group II: 1753+/-497 N; Group III: 2186+/-587 N. The differences were not significant (p>0.05). 90 degrees triangulation was not associated with a superior pullout performance versus conventional 60 degrees triangulation, suggesting that achieving additional triangulation angle is not necessary to obtain increased pullout strength. Laminectomy did not alter the effect of triangulation on fixation strength.

Load sharing within a human thoracic vertebral body: an in vitro biomechanical study.

OBJECTIVE: The vertebral body is the major load bearing part of the vertebra and consists of a central trabecular core surrounded by a thin cortical shell. The aim of this in vitro biomechanical study is to determine the debated issue of load sharing in a vertebral body. METHODS: A series of non-destructive compressive testing on excised human thoracic vertebral bodies were performed. The testing process consisted of a stepwise removal of the vertebrae's trabecular centrum and measurement of surface strains. RESULTS: Load sharing of cortical shell of osteopenic vertebrae (48.1+/-7.6) was significantly higher than that of normal vertebrae (44.3+/-10.6). Load sharing of middle thoracic vertebrae (49.4+/-10.0) was significantly higher than that of lower thoracic vertebrae (42.4+/-8.5). According to general linear model analysis, test speed and load were not found to be effectual on load sharing with the exception that osteopenic vertebrae showed lower cortical load sharing under higher loads. CONCLUSIONS: The cortical shell takes nearly 45% of physiological loads acting upon an isolated thoracic vertebra. Load sharing between cortical shell and trabecular centrum is significantly affected by spinal level and bone mineral density. The load borne by trabecular bone increases towards the lower spinal levels, and decreases by osteoporosis.

Heat Generation During Bone Drilling: A Comparison Between Industrial and Orthopaedic Drill Bits.

OBJECTIVES: Cortical bone drilling for preparation of screw placement is common in multiple surgical fields. The heat generated while drilling may reach thresholds high enough to cause osteonecrosis. This can compromise implant stability. Orthopaedic drill bits are several orders more expensive than their similarly sized, publicly available industrial counterparts. We hypothesize that an industrial bit will generate less heat during drilling, and the bits will not generate more heat after multiple cortical passes. METHODS: We compared 4 4.0 mm orthopaedic and 1 3.97 mm industrial drill bits. Three types of each bit were drilled into porcine femoral cortices 20 times. The temperature of the bone was measured with thermocouple transducers. The heat generated during the first 5 drill cycles for each bit was compared to the last 5 cycles. These data were analyzed with analysis of covariance. RESULTS: The industrial drill bit generated the smallest mean increase in temperature (2.8 ± 0.29°C) P < 0.0001. No significant difference was identified comparing the first 5 cortices drilled to the last 5 cortices drilled for each bit. The P-values are as follows: Bosch (P = 0.73), Emerge (P = 0.09), Smith & Nephew (P = 0.08), Stryker (P = 0.086), and Synthes (P = 0.16). The industrial bit generated less heat during drilling than its orthopaedic counterparts. The bits maintained their performance after 20 drill cycles. CONCLUSIONS: Consideration should be given by manufacturers to design differences that may contribute to a more efficient cutting bit. Further investigation into the reuse of these drill bits may be warranted, as our data suggest their efficiency is maintained after multiple uses.

A biomechanical comparison of the two- and four-hole side-plate dynamic hip screw in an osteoporotic composite femur model.

OBJECTIVES: The objectives of this study were (1) to compare the axial and torsional stiffness of a dynamic hip screw with a two- and four-hole side-plate in a synthetic model of a healed and stable intertrochanteric femur fracture and (2) to evaluate the load to failure, as well as propensity to peri-implant fracture. METHODS: Fourth-generation synthetic composite femur models, simulating osteoporotic bone, were implanted with 135° dynamic hip screws (DHS) with either a two- or four-hole side-plate with or without a stable intertrochanteric fracture. Specimens were cyclically loaded up to a nondestructive load to determine the axial and torsional stiffness. Constructs were then loaded to failure in axial compression emulating physiologic forces. Failure load and location of the peri-implant fractures were recorded. RESULTS: Axial and torsional stiffness did not differ significantly between the two- and four-hole constructs in either model. Likewise, there was no significant difference in the load to failure. In the intact femurs, failure occurred either at the end of the plate at the distal screw or through the lag screw hole. CONCLUSION: The results of this study demonstrate that DHS constructs with a two- or four-hole side-plate are biomechanically comparable with regard to axial and torsional stiffness and load to failure in an osteoporotic composite femur model. In a healed intertrochanteric fracture model, a two-hole construct did not appear to be more prone to peri-implant fracture. To date, a biomechanical comparison of these two implants with regard to torsional forces has not been reported.

Degradation of Bioresorbable Mg-4Zn-1Sr Intramedullary Pins and Associated Biological Responses in Vitro and in Vivo.

This article reports the degradation and biological properties of as-drawn Mg-4Zn-1Sr (designated as ZSr41) and pure Mg (P-Mg) wires as bioresorbable intramedullary pins for bone repair. Specifically, their cytocompatibility with bone marrow derived mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) and degradation in vitro, and their biological effects on peri-implant tissues and in vivo degradation in rat tibiae were studied. The as-drawn ZSr41 pins showed a significantly faster degradation than P-Mg in vitro and in vivo. The in vivo average daily degradation rates of both ZSr41 and P-Mg intramedullary pins were significantly greater than their respective in vitro degradation rates, likely because the intramedullary site of implantation is highly vascularized for removal of degradation products. Importantly, the concentrations of Mg2+, Zn2+, and Sr2+ ions in the BMSC culture in vitro and their concentrations in rat blood in vivo were all lower than their respective therapeutic dosages, i.e., in a safe range. Despite of rapid degradation with a complete resorption time of 8 weeks in vivo, the ZSr41 intramedullary pins showed a significant net bone growth because of stimulatory effects of the metallic ions released. However, proportionally released OH- ions and hydrogen gas caused adverse effects on bone marrow cells and resulted in cavities in surrounding bone. Thus, properly engineering the degradation properties of Mg-based implants is critical for harvesting the bioactivities of beneficial metallic ions, while controlling adverse reactions associated with the release of OH- ions and hydrogen gas. It is necessary to further optimize the alloy processing conditions and/or modify the surfaces, for example, applying coatings onto the surface, to reduce the degradation rate of ZSr41 wires for skeletal implant applications.

Axial cyclic behavior of the bone-screw interface.

Screw fixation strength is investigated by using a pullout test. Despite many screw pullout studies, the effects of loading rate on the pullout behavior of pedicle screws are not known. The objective of this study was to assess the effects of loading rate on the pullout stiffness and strength of pedicle screws. Sixty pedicle screws were inserted in foam blocks and pulled out at four different rates: 0.1, 1, 5 and 50 mm/min. Twenty of these 60 screws were cycled non-destructively at four different rates sequentially, i.e., 0.1, 1, 5 and 50 mm/min prior to pullout. Ten additional pedicle screws were inserted in five calf lumbar vertebrae, cycled as in foam group, and pulled out at a rate of either 0.1 or 50 mm/min. The results showed that the stiffness was higher at all rates compared to 0.1 mm/min in foam model but in bone model only 1 and 5 mm/min groups were higher compared to 0.1 mm/min. The pullout strength in 50 mm/min group was higher than that in 0.1 mm/min group in both foam and bone model. The results suggested that loading rate influenced the mechanics of the bone-screw interface. Therefore, a fair comparison between the pullout studies can be achieved under same loading rate conditions. Moreover, the cycling of the pedicle screws in axial direction within a pre-yield region showed an unusual hysteresis curve. Further studies are needed for a better understanding of the mechanics of the screw-bone interface.

Does Barbed Suture Repair Negate the Benefit of Peripheral Repair in Porcine Flexor Tendon?

Background: Advances in suture material and geometry have fueled interest in barbed suture tenorrhaphy. Theoretically, barbed suture allows better load distribution, smoother gliding under pulleys, and improved tendon blood flow. Minimal data exist on whether barbed tendon repair may benefit from supplementation by a peripheral stitch. The purpose of this study is to determine whether peripheral suture repair increases gap resistance in both conventional and barbed core repairs, increases maximum tensile strength, and fails before or after the core repair. Methods: Porcine flexor tendons were harvested and assigned randomly into 4 groups of 10 of varying suture constructs (3-0 PDS™ or 3-0 V-Loc 180™ core with or without peripheral 5-0 Vicryl™ repair). Core repairs were performed using a modified 4-strand cruciate repair. A servohydrolic tester was used for biomechanical testing of linear 2-mm gap resistance and maximum tensile strength. Results: Peripheral repair improved 2-mm gap resistance in all repairs, regardless of core suture type, conventional (173% increase) or barbed (204% increase). No change in the maximum tensile strength was found in either core suture type with peripheral repair. Peripheral repairs always failed before core repairs, at a significantly higher load of 74.2 ± 20.4 N in barbed versus 57.8 ± 12.2 N (P = .04) in conventional core repairs. Conclusions: The addition of peripheral repair improved gap resistance but not ultimate tensile strength in both conventional and barbed flexor tendon repairs in linear testing. The 4-strand cruciate flexor tendon repairs using barbed suture may require peripheral repair to withstand physiologic loads, as core repair alone using barbed suture was insufficient.

Comparison of Barbed Sutures in Porcine Flexor Tenorrhaphy.

Background: Barbed suture use has become more popular as technology and materials have advanced. Minimal data exist regarding performance of the 2 commercially available products, V-LocTM and StratafixTM in tendon repairs. The purpose of this study was to compare gap resistance and ultimate tensile strength of both suture materials and nonbarbed suture in a porcine ex vivo model. Methods: Porcine flexor tendons were harvested and divided into 3 groups of 10 of varying suture material (3-0 PDS™, 3-0 V- V-Loc 180™, or 3-0 Stratafix™). A modified 4-strand cruciate technique was used to repair each tendon. Knotless repair was performed using barbed suture, whereas a buried 6-throw square knot was done using conventional suture. A servohydrolic tester was used for biomechanical testing of linear 2-mm gap resistance and maximum tensile strength. Results: No difference was found in 2-mm gap resistance among the 3 groups. No difference was found in ultimate tensile strength between V-Loc™ (76.0 ± 9.4 N) and Stratafix™ (68.1 ± 8.4 N) repairs, but the ultimate strength of the PDS™ control group (83.4 ± 10.0 N) was significantly higher than that of Stratafix™. Conclusions: Barbed (knotless) and nonbarbed suture repairs demonstrate equivalent 2-mm gap resistance. Stratafix™ repairs show slightly inferior performance to nonbarbed repairs in ultimate tensile strength, although this occurred at gap distances far beyond the 2-mm threshold for normal tendon gliding. Both barbed and nonbarbed 4-strand cruciate flexor tendon repairs may require peripheral repair to withstand physiologic loads.

Fatigue Performance of Cortical Bone Trajectory Screw Compared With Standard Trajectory Pedicle Screw.

STUDY DESIGN: Cadaveric biomechanical study. OBJECTIVE: To determine fatigue behavior of cortical bone trajectory (CBT) pedicle screws. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Cortical bone trajectory screws have been becoming popular in spine surgery; however, the long-term fatigue behavior of the new CBT screws remains understudied and limitations not well defined. METHODS: Twelve vertebrae from six cadaveric lumbar spines were obtained. After bone mineral density (BMD) measurements, each vertebral body was instrumented with screws from each group, that is, CBT (4.5 × 25 mm) or standard pedicle screw (6.5 × 55 mm). A load (± 4 Nm sagittal bending) was applied under displacement control at 1 Hz. Each construct was loaded for 100 cycles or until 6° of loosening was observed. After fatigue testing, the screws were pulled out axially at 5 mm/min. RESULTS: The standard pedicle screw showed better resistance against 100 cycle loading compared with the CBT screws (P < 0.001, 6.9° ± 4.8° vs. 15.2° ± 5.5°, respectively). The standard pedicle screw testing usually required more than 100 cycles of loading to achieve the critical loosening (3592 ± 4564 cycles), whereas the CBT screw never exceeded 100 cycles (84 ± 24 cycles) (P = 0.002). Increased BMD was significantly associated with a higher number of cycles and less loosening. The standard pedicle screw group had a higher postfatigue pullout load than the CBT screw group (P = 0.001, 776 ± 370 N and 302 ± 232 N, respectively). CONCLUSION: The standard pedicle screw had a better fatigue performance compared with the CBT screw in vertebra with compromised bone quality. The proper insertion of the CBT screw might be prevented by the laminar anatomy depending on the screw head design. The CBT screw damaged the bone along its shaft by rotating around a fulcrum, located at either the pars, pedicle isthmus, or the junction of the pedicle and superior endplate, contingent upon the strength of the bone.