Water and Cu+ Synergy in Selective CO2 Hydrogenation to Methanol over Cu-MgO-Al2O3 Catalysts.

The CO2 hydrogenation reaction to produce methanol holds great significance as it contributes to achieving a CO2-neutral economy. Previous research identified isolated Cu+ species doping the oxide surface of a Cu-MgO-Al2O3-mixed oxide derived from a hydrotalcite precursor as the active site in CO2 hydrogenation, stabilizing monodentate formate species as a crucial intermediate in methanol synthesis. In this work, we present a molecular-level understanding of how surface water and hydroxyl groups play a crucial role in facilitating spontaneous CO2 activation at Cu+ sites and the formation of monodentate formate species. Computational evidence has been experimentally validated by comparing the catalytic performance of the Cu-MgO-Al2O3 catalyst with hydroxyl groups against that of its hydrophobic counterpart, where hydroxyl groups are blocked using an esterification method. Our work highlights the synergistic effect between doped Cu+ ions and adjacent hydroxyl groups, both of which serve as key parameters in regulating methanol production via CO2 hydrogenation. By elucidating the specific roles of these components, we contribute to advancing our understanding of the underlying mechanisms and provide valuable insights for optimizing methanol synthesis processes.

Vibrational frequencies of CO bound to all three low-index cerium oxide surfaces: A consistent theoretical description of vacancy-induced changes using density functional theory.

The facet-dependent adsorption of CO on oxidized and reduced CeO2 single crystal surfaces is reviewed, with emphasis on the effect of CO coverage and the ability of state-of-the-art quantum-mechanical methods to provide reliable energies and an accurate description of the IR vibrational frequency of CO. Comparison with detailed, high-resolution experimental infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy data obtained for single crystal samples allows the assignment of the different CO vibrational bands observed on all three low-index ceria surfaces. Good agreement is achieved with the hybrid density functional theory approach with the HSE06 functional and with saturation coverage. It is shown that CO is very sensitive to the structure of cerium oxide surfaces and to the presence of oxygen vacancies. The combined theoretical-experimental approach offers new opportunities for a better characterization of ceria nanoparticles and for unraveling changes occurring during reactions involving CO at higher pressures.

Toward an Atomic-Level Understanding of Ceria-Based Catalysts: When Experiment and Theory Go Hand in Hand.

ConspectusBecause ceria (CeO2) is a key ingredient in the formulation of many catalysts, its catalytic roles have received a great amount of attention from experiment and theory. Its primary function is to enhance the oxidation activity of catalysts, which is largely governed by the low activation barrier for creating lattice O vacancies. Such an important characteristic of ceria has been exploited in CO oxidation, methane partial oxidation, volatile organic compound oxidation, and the water-gas shift (WGS) reaction and in the context of automotive applications. A great challenge of such heterogeneously catalyzed processes remains the unambiguous identification of active sites.In oxidation reactions, closing the catalytic cycle requires ceria reoxidation by gas-phase oxygen, which includes oxygen adsorption and activation. While the general mechanistic framework of such processes is accepted, only very recently has an atomic-level understanding of oxygen activation on ceria powders been achieved by combined experimental and theoretical studies using in situ multiwavelength Raman spectroscopy and DFT.Recent studies have revealed that the adsorption and activation of gas-phase oxygen on ceria is strongly facet-dependent and involves different superoxide/peroxide species, which can now be unambiguously assigned to ceria surface sites using the combined Raman and DFT approach. Our results demonstrate that, as a result of oxygen dissociation, vacant ceria lattice sites are healed, highlighting the close relationship of surface processes with lattice oxygen dynamics, which is also of technical relevance in the context of oxygen storage-release applications.A recent DFT interpretation of Raman spectra of polycrystalline ceria enables us to take account of all (sub)surface and bulk vibrational features observed in the experimental spectra and has revealed new findings of great relevance for a mechanistic understanding of ceria-based catalysts. These include the identification of surface oxygen (Ce-O) modes and the quantification of subsurface oxygen defects. Combining these theoretical insights with operando Raman experiments now allows the (sub)surface oxygen dynamics of ceria and noble metal/ceria catalysts to be monitored under the reaction conditions.Applying these findings to Au/ceria catalysts provides univocal evidence for ceria support participation in heterogeneous catalysis. For room-temperature CO oxidation, operando Raman monitoring the (sub)surface defect dynamics clearly demonstrates the dependence of catalytic activity on the ceria reduction state. Extending the combined experimental/DFT approach to operando IR spectroscopy allows the elucidation of the nature of the active gold as (pseudo)single Au+ sites and enables us to develop a detailed mechanistic picture of the catalytic cycle. Temperature-dependent studies highlight the importance of facet-dependent defect formation energies and adsorbate stabilities (e.g., carbonates). While the latter aspects are also evidenced to play a role in the WGS reaction, the facet-dependent catalytic performance shows a correlation with the extent of gold agglomeration. Our findings are fully consistent with a redox mechanism, thus adding a new perspective to the ongoing discussion of the WGS reaction.As outlined above for ceria-based catalysts, closely combining state-of-the-art in situ/operando spectroscopy and theory constitutes a powerful approach to rational catalyst design by providing essential mechanistic information based on an atomic-level understanding of reactions.

Erratum: Vibrational Frequencies of Cerium-Oxide-Bound CO: A Challenge for Conventional DFT Methods [Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 256101 (2020)].

This corrects the article DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.256101.

Insight into the mechanism of the water-gas shift reaction over Au/CeO2 catalysts using combined operando spectroscopies.

The mechanism of the low-temperature water-gas shift (LT-WGS) reaction over Au/CeO2 catalysts with different ceria terminations, i.e., (111), (110), and (100) facets, was investigated. Using combined operando Raman and UV-Vis spectroscopy as well as isotope exchange experiments, we are able to draw conclusions about the reducibility behaviour and the exchange of surface oxygen. Additional density functional theory (DFT) calculations facilitate the vibrational bands assignments and enhance the interpretation of the results on a molecular level. A facet-dependent role of gold is observed with respect to the oxygen dynamics, since for the CeO2(111) facet the presence of gold is required to exchange surface oxygen, whereas the CeO2(110) facet requires no gold, as rationalized by the low defect formation energy of this facet. This behaviour suggests that surface properties (termination, stepped surface) may have a strong effect on the reactivity. While the reduction of the support accompanies the reaction, its extent does not directly correlate with activity, highlighting the importance of other properties, such as the dissociative adsorption of water and/or CO2/H2 desorption. The results of our facet-dependent study are consistent with a redox mechanism, as underlined by H218O isotopic exchange experiments demonstrating the ready exchange of surface oxygen.

Ce=O Terminated CeO2.

Multiply bonded lanthanide oxo groups are rare in coordination compounds and have not previously been reported for a surface termination of a lanthanide oxide. Here we report the observation of a Ce=O terminated ceria surface in a CeO2 (111)-( 3 × 3 )R30° reconstruction of ≈3 nm thick ceria islands prepared on Pt(111). This is evidenced by scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM), low energy electron diffraction (LEED) and high-resolution electron energy loss spectroscopy (HREELS) measurements in conjunction with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. A Ce=O stretching frequency of 775 cm-1 is observed in HREELS, compared with 766 cm-1 calculated by DFT. The calculations also predict that the Ce=O bond is weak, with an oxygen vacancy formation energy of 0.85 eV. This could play an important role in the facile removal of lattice oxygen from CeO2 , accompanied by the reduction of CeIV to CeIII , which is a key attribute of ceria-based systems in connection with their unique catalytic properties.

Vibrational Frequencies of Cerium-Oxide-Bound CO: A Challenge for Conventional DFT Methods.

In ceria-based catalysis, the shape of the catalyst particle, which determines the exposed crystal facets, profoundly affects its reactivity. The vibrational frequency of adsorbed carbon monoxide (CO) can be used as a sensitive probe to identify the exposed surface facets, provided reference data on well-defined single crystal surfaces together with a definitive theoretical assignment exist. We investigate the adsorption of CO on the CeO_{2}(110) and (111) surfaces and show that the commonly applied DFT(PBE)+U method does not provide reliable CO vibrational frequencies by comparing with state-of-the-art infrared spectroscopy experiments for monocrystalline CeO_{2} surfaces. Good agreement requires the hybrid DFT approach with the HSE06 functional. The failure of conventional density-functional theory (DFT) is explained in terms of its inability to accurately describe the facet- and configuration-specific donation and backdonation effects that control the changes in the C─O bond length upon CO adsorption and the CO force constant. Our findings thus provide a theoretical basis for the detailed interpretation of experiments and open up the path to characterize more complex scenarios, including oxygen vacancies and metal adatoms.

Oxygen-Vacancy Dynamics and Entanglement with Polaron Hopping at the Reduced CeO_{2}(111) Surface.

The migration of oxygen vacancies (V_{O}) in ceria-based systems is crucial to their functionality in applications. Yet, although the V_{O}'s structure and the distribution of the Ce^{3+} polarons at the CeO_{2}(111) surface has received extensive attention, the dynamic behaviors of V_{O}'s and polarons are not fully understood. By combining density functional theory calculations and ab initio molecular dynamics simulations, we show that the movements of V_{O}'s and polarons exhibit very distinct entanglement characteristics within a temperature range of 300-900 K, and that the positions of the Ce^{3+} polarons play a key role in the V_{O} migration. Long-distance vacancy migration occurs at moderate temperatures when the "suitable" Ce^{3+} distribution remains long enough to promote oxygen migration. This study provides microscopic insight into the interplay between the electronic and ionic charge transport in ceria that will be beneficial for the rational design of conductive ceria-based materials.

Direct Conversion of Methane to Methanol on Ni-Ceria Surfaces: Metal-Support Interactions and Water-Enabled Catalytic Conversion by Site Blocking.

The transformation of methane into methanol or higher alcohols at moderate temperature and pressure conditions is of great environmental interest and remains a challenge despite many efforts. Extended surfaces of metallic nickel are inactive for a direct CH4 → CH3OH conversion. This experimental and computational study provides clear evidence that low Ni loadings on a CeO2(111) support can perform a direct catalytic cycle for the generation of methanol at low temperature using oxygen and water as reactants, with a higher selectivity than ever reported for ceria-based catalysts. On the basis of ambient pressure X-ray photoemission spectroscopy and density functional theory calculations, we demonstrate that water plays a crucial role in blocking catalyst sites where methyl species could fully decompose, an essential factor for diminishing the production of CO and CO2, and in generating sites on which methoxy species and ultimately methanol can form. In addition to water-site blocking, one needs the effects of metal-support interactions to bind and activate methane and water. These findings should be considered when designing metal/oxide catalysts for converting methane to value-added chemicals and fuels.

In†Situ Investigation of Methane Dry Reforming on Metal/Ceria(111) Surfaces: Metal-Support Interactions and C-H Bond Activation at Low Temperature.

Studies with a series of metal/ceria(111) (metal=Co, Ni, Cu; ceria=CeO2 ) surfaces indicate that metal-oxide interactions can play a very important role for the activation of methane and its reforming with CO2 at relatively low temperatures (600-700 K). Among the systems examined, Co/CeO2 (111) exhibits the best performance and Cu/CeO2 (111) has negligible activity. Experiments using ambient pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy indicate that methane dissociates on Co/CeO2 (111) at temperatures as low as 300 K-generating CHx and COx species on the catalyst surface. The results of density functional calculations show a reduction in the methane activation barrier from 1.07 eV on Co(0001) to 0.87 eV on Co2+ /CeO2 (111), and to only 0.05 eV on Co0 /CeO2-x (111). At 700 K, under methane dry reforming conditions, CO2 dissociates on the oxide surface and a catalytic cycle is established without coke deposition. A significant part of the CHx formed on the Co0 /CeO2-x (111) catalyst recombines to yield ethane or ethylene.

Diffusion Barriers Block Defect Occupation on Reduced CeO_{2}(111).

Surface defects are believed to govern the adsorption behavior of reducible oxides. We challenge this perception on the basis of a combined scanning-tunneling-microscopy and density-functional-theory study, addressing the Au adsorption on reduced CeO_{2-x}(111). Despite a clear thermodynamic preference for oxygen vacancies, individual Au atoms were found to bind mostly to regular surface sites. Even at an elevated temperature, aggregation at step edges and not decoration of defects turned out to be the main consequence of adatom diffusion. Our findings are explained with the polaronic nature of the Au-ceria system, which imprints a strong diabatic character onto the diffusive motion of adatoms. Diabatic barriers are generally higher than those in the adiabatic regime, especially if the hopping step couples to an electron transfer into the ad-gold. As the population of O vacancies always requires a charge exchange, defect decoration by Au atoms becomes kinetically hindered. Our study demonstrates that polaronic effects determine not only electron transport in reducible oxides but also the adsorption characteristics and therewith the surface chemistry.

Dry Reforming of Methane on a Highly-Active Ni-CeO2 Catalyst: Effects of Metal-Support Interactions on C-H Bond Breaking.

Ni-CeO2 is a highly efficient, stable and non-expensive catalyst for methane dry reforming at relative low temperatures (700 K). The active phase of the catalyst consists of small nanoparticles of nickel dispersed on partially reduced ceria. Experiments of ambient pressure XPS indicate that methane dissociates on Ni/CeO2 at temperatures as low as 300 K, generating CHx and COx species on the surface of the catalyst. Strong metal-support interactions activate Ni for the dissociation of methane. The results of density-functional calculations show a drop in the effective barrier for methane activation from 0.9 eV on Ni(111) to only 0.15 eV on Ni/CeO2-x (111). At 700 K, under methane dry reforming conditions, no signals for adsorbed CHx or C species are detected in the C 1s XPS region. The reforming of methane proceeds in a clean and efficient way.

In situ and theoretical studies for the dissociation of water on an active Ni/CeO2 catalyst: importance of strong metal-support interactions for the cleavage of O-H bonds.

Water dissociation is crucial in many catalytic reactions on oxide-supported transition-metal catalysts. Supported by experimental and density-functional theory results, the effect of the support on OH bond cleavage activity is elucidated for nickel/ceria systems. Ambient-pressure O 1s photoemission spectra at low Ni loadings on CeO2 (111) reveal a substantially larger amount of OH groups as compared to the bare support. Computed activation energy barriers for water dissociation show an enhanced reactivity of Ni adatoms on CeO2 (111) compared with pyramidal Ni4 particles with one Ni atom not in contact with the support, and extended Ni(111) surfaces. At the origin of this support effect is the ability of ceria to stabilize oxidized Ni(2+) species by accommodating electrons in localized f-states. The fast dissociation of water on Ni/CeO2 has a dramatic effect on the activity and stability of this system as a catalyst for the water-gas shift and ethanol steam reforming reactions.

Hydrogen activation, diffusion, and clustering on CeO2(111): a DFT+U study.

We present a comprehensive density functional theory+U study of the mechanisms underlying the dissociation of molecular hydrogen, and diffusion and clustering of the resulting atomic species on the CeO2(111) surface. Contrary to a widely held view based solely on a previous theoretical prediction, our results show conclusively that H2 dissociation is an activated process with a large energy barrier ~1.0 eV that is not significantly affected by coverage or the presence of surface oxygen vacancies. The reaction proceeds through a local energy minimum--where the molecule is located close to one of the surface oxygen atoms and the H-H bond has been substantially weaken by the interaction with the substrate--, and a transition state where one H atom is attached to a surface O atom and the other H atom sits on-top of a Ce(4+) ion. In addition, we have explored how several factors, including H coverage, the location of Ce(3+) ions as well as the U value, may affect the chemisorption energy and the relative stability of isolated OH groups versus pair and trimer structures. The trimer stability at low H coverages and the larger upward relaxation of the surface O atoms within the OH groups are consistent with the assignment of the frequent experimental observation by non-contact atomic force and scanning tunneling microscopies of bright protrusions on three neighboring surface O atoms to a triple OH group. The diffusion path of isolated H atoms on the surface goes through the adsorption on-top of an oxygen in the third atomic layer with a large energy barrier of ~1.8 eV. Overall, the large energy barriers for both, molecular dissociation and atomic diffusion, are consistent with the high activity and selectivity found recently in the partial hydrogenation of acetylene catalyzed by ceria at high H2/C2H2 ratios.

Evidence for subsurface ordering of oxygen vacancies on the reduced CeO2(111) surface using density-functional and statistical calculations.

Oxygen vacancies on ceria (CeO(2)) surfaces play a crucial role in catalytic applications, yet whether vacancies are at surface or subsurface sites on reduced CeO(2)(111), and whether vacancies agglomerate or repel each other, is still under discussion, with few and inconsistent experimental results. By combining density-functional theory (DFT) in the DFT+U (U is an effective onsite Coulomb interaction parameter) approach and statistical thermodynamics, we show that the energetically most stable near-surface oxygen vacancy structures for a broad range of vacancy concentrations, Θ (1/16 ≤ Θ ≤ 1 monolayer) have all vacancies at subsurface oxygen sites and predict that the thermodynamically stable phase for a wide range of reducing conditions is a (2 × 2) ordered subsurface vacancy structure (Θ = 1/4). Vacancy-induced lattice relaxations effects are crucial for the interpretation of the repulsive interactions, which are at the basis of the vacancy spacing in the (2 × 2) structure. The findings provide theoretical data to support the interpretation of the most recent experiments, bringing us closer to solving the debate.

Tuning Selectivity in the Direct Conversion of Methane to Methanol: Bimetallic Synergistic Effects on the Cleavage of C-H and O-H Bonds over NiCu/CeO2 Catalysts.

The efficient activation of methane and the simultaneous water dissociation are crucial in many catalytic reactions on oxide-supported transition metal catalysts. On very low-loaded Ni/CeO2 surfaces, methane easily fully decomposes, CH4 → C + 4H, and water dissociates, H2O→ OH + H. However, in important reactions such as the direct oxidation of methane to methanol (MTM), where complex interplay exists between reactants (CH4, O2), it is desirable to avoid the complete dehydrogenation of methane to carbon. Remarkably, the barrier for the activation of C-H bonds in CHx (x = 1-3) species on Ni/CeO2 surfaces can be manipulated by adding Cu, forming bimetallic NiCu clusters, whereas the ease for cleavage of O-H bonds in water is not affected by ensemble effects, as obtained from density functional theory-based calculations. CH4 activation occurs only on Ni sites, and H2O activation occurs on both Ni and Cu sites. The MTM reaction pathway for the example of the Ni3Cu1/CeO2 model catalyst predicts a higher selectivity and a lower activation barrier for methanol production, compared with that for Ni4/CeO2. These findings point toward a possible strategy to design active and stable catalysts which can be employed for methane activation and conversions.

Shape-Controlled Pathways in the Hydrogen Production from Ethanol Steam Reforming over Ceria Nanoparticles.

The ethanol surface reaction over CeO2 nanooctahedra (NO) and nanocubes (NC), which mainly expose (111) and (100) surfaces, respectively, was studied by means of infrared spectroscopy (TPSR-IR), mass spectrometry (TPSR-MS), and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. TPSR-MS results show that the production of H2 is 2.4 times higher on CeO2-NC than on CeO2-NO, which is rationalized starting from the different types of adsorbed ethoxy species controlled by the shape of the ceria particles. Over the CeO2(111) surface, monodentate type I and II ethoxy species with the alkyl chain perpendicular or parallel to the surface, respectively, were identified. Meanwhile, on the CeO2(100) surface, bidentate and monodentate type III ethoxy species on the checkerboard O-terminated surface and on a pyramid of the reconstructed (100) surface, respectively, are found. The more labile surface ethoxy species on each ceria nanoshape, which are the monodentate type I or III ethoxy on CeO2-NO and CeO2-NC, respectively, react on the surface to give acetate species that decompose to CO2 and CH4, while H2 is formed via the recombination of hydroxyl species. In addition, the more stable monodentate type II and bidentate ethoxy species on CeO2-NO and CeO2-NC, respectively, give an ethylenedioxy intermediate, the binding of which is facet-dependent. On the (111) facet, the less strongly bound ethylenedioxy desorbs as ethylene, whereas on the (100) facet, the more strongly bound intermediate also produces CO2 and H2 via formate species. Thus, on the (100) facet, an additional pathway toward H2 formation is found. ESR activity measurements show an enhanced H2 production on the nanocubes.

Highly Active and Stable Ni/La-Doped Ceria Material for Catalytic CO2 Reduction by Reverse Water-Gas Shift Reaction.

The design of an active, effective, and economically viable catalyst for CO2 conversion into value-added products is crucial in the fight against global warming and energy demand. We have developed very efficient catalysts for reverse water-gas shift (rWGS) reaction. Specific conditions of the synthesis by combustion allow the obtention of macroporous materials based on nanosized Ni particles supported on a mixed oxide of high purity and crystallinity. Here, we show that Ni/La-doped CeO2 catalysts─with the "right" Ni and La proportions─have an unprecedented catalytic performance per unit mass of catalyst for the rWGS reaction as the first step toward CO2 valorization. Correlations between physicochemical properties and catalytic activity, obtained using a combination of different techniques such as X-ray and neutron powder diffraction, Raman spectroscopy, in situ near ambient pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, electron microscopy, and catalytic testing, point out to optimum values for the Ni loading and the La proportion. Density functional theory calculations of elementary steps of the reaction on model Ni/ceria catalysts aid toward the microscopic understanding of the nature of the active sites. This finding offers a fundamental basis for developing economical catalysts that can be effectively used for CO2 reduction with hydrogen. A catalyst based on Ni0.07/(Ce0.9La0.1Ox)0.93 shows a CO production of 58 × 10-5 molCO·gcat-1·s-1 (700 °C, H2/CO2 = 2; selectivity to CO > 99.5), being stable for 100 h under continuous reaction.

Electron localization in defective ceria films: a study with scanning-tunneling microscopy and density-functional theory.

Scanning-tunneling microscopy and density-functional theory have been employed to identify the spatial correlation between an oxygen vacancy and the associated Ce(3+) ion pair in a defective CeO(2)(111) film. The two Ce(3+) ions can occupy different cationic shells around the vacancy. The resulting variation in the chemical environment leads to a splitting of the filled Ce(3+) f levels, which is detected with STM spectroscopy. The position of the Ce(3+) ion pair is reflected in characteristic defect patterns observed in empty-state STM images, which arise from the bright appearance of Ce(4+) ions next to the defect while the Ce(3+) remain dark. Both findings demonstrate that at least one excess electron localizes in a Ce ion that is not adjacent to the O vacancy.

Facet-dependent stability of near-surface oxygen vacancies and excess charge localization at CeO2surfaces.

To study the dependence of the relative stability of surface (VA) and subsurface (VB) oxygen vacancies with the crystal facet of CeO2, the reduced (100), (110) and (111) surfaces, with two different concentrations of vacancies, were investigated by means of density functional theory (DFT + U) calculations. The results show that the trend in the near-surface vacancy formation energies for comparable vacancy spacings, i.e. (110) < (100) < (111), does not follow the one in the surface stability of the facets, i.e. (111) < (110) < (100). The results also reveal that the preference of vacancies for surface or subsurface sites, as well as the preferred location of the associated Ce3+polarons, are facet- and concentration-dependent. At the higher vacancy concentration, theVAis more stable than theVBat the (110) facet whereas at the (111), it is the other way around, and at the (100) facet, both theVAand theVBhave similar stability. The stability of theVAvacancies, compared to that of theVB, is accentuated as the concentration decreases. Nearest neighbor polarons to the vacant sites are only observed for the less densely packed (110) and (100) facets. These findings are rationalized in terms of the packing density of the facets, the lattice relaxation effects induced by vacancy formation and the localization of the excess charge, as well as the repulsive Ce3+-Ce3+interactions.