Immunoglobulin G inhibitor of thyroid-stimulating antibody is a cause of delay in the onset of neonatal Graves' disease.

Studies were carried out with the serum IgG from a mother and her two children who developed neonatal Graves' disease several weeks after birth. The maternal IgG: (a) stimulated the human thyroid in vitro, but maximal stimulation was found only with dilution of the IgG; (b) was very potent in the long-acting thyroid stimulator (LATS)-protector assay, but only when an inhibitor of the system was diluted out; (c) inhibited a standard preparation of LATS in the mouse bioassay; (d) was biphasic in the thyrotropin-binding inhibition (TBI) assay, i.e., enhanced binding at low concentrations of IgG and inhibited binding at high levels. Enhancement in the TBI assay was found only with particulate preparations of human thyroid membranes as receptor and not when that material was solubilized, nor with guinea pig fat cell membranes as receptor. Serial blood samples from the second child were obtained at birth and until 3 mo of age. In the thyroid slice (cyclic AMP) assay system there was a negative dose-response relationship in testing IgG until age 45 d when it became positive, coinciding with the clinical recognition that hyperthyroidism had developed. The data are compatible with a concept that this mother's IgG contained thyroid-stimulating antibody (TSAb) and another moiety that inhibited TSAb through an action on the thyroid cell membrane, thus delaying the onset of hyperthyroidism in the neonate until the inhibiting IgG was metabolically cleared to an ineffective concentration.

LATS-protector activity in thyrotoxicosis measured by thyroidal intracellular colloid droplet formation.

A modified assay method of LATS and LATS protector (LATSP) was devised employing murine thyroidal intracellular colloid droplet formation. This method is 4- to 8-fold more sensitive to stimulators than is the regular McKenzie bioassay. For the assay of LATSP, IgG to be tested was incubated with human thyroid homogenate, then LATS-IgG was added and it was further incubated. The potency of LATS in the mixture was assayed. The adequacy of the present method for the assay of LATSP was supported by the facts that the LATSP activity was roughly related to the dose of IgG tested and that the inactivation of LATSP was observed when the IgG was pretreated with human thyroid particulate fraction and then assayed. With this method, 7 out of 32 patients with thyrotoxicosis showed LATS and 18 showed LATSP. Changes in LATSP were followed up in 7 cases out of the 18. LATSP activity decreased and then disappeared in 6 out of the 7 cases, when they had been euthyroid for a certain period of time. At 12-20 months after the treatment either by thionamide medication or by subtotal thyroidectomy. LATSP and 131I-thyroid uptake were measured in these 6 patients. In all of the 6, LATSP was negative regardless of thyroid suppressibility.

Thyroid-stimulating autoantibodies usually contain only lambda-light chains: evidence for the "forbidden clone" theory.

Burnet's "forbidden clone" theory would predict that in patients with Graves' disease the pathogenic thyroid-stimulating autoantibody (TSab)-secreting clones arise by somatic mutation. Because each lymphocyte and its progeny are permanently committed to producing antibodies of a single light chain type, a clone arising by somatic mutation occurring in a single cell would be expected to produce autoantibodies of exclusively kappa or exclusively lambda type in an individual patient. Using affinity chromatographic techniques and monoclonal antibodies, we investigated the light chain type of TSab in 11 patients with Graves' disease. In all patients tested, TSab activity was confined to a single light chain type, confirming the recent work of Zakarija who used affinity chromatography with polyclonal antisera, but contrasting with earlier studies which used immuno-precipitation methods. Furthermore, the light chain type was lambda in 10 of the 11 patients. These observations provide support for the forbidden clone theory. In addition, the marked preponderance of patients producing TSab of the lambda-light chain type indicates that TSab are more likely to arise from the lambda repertoire of clones than from the kappa repertoire and suggests that immunoglobulin light chain V genes may be genetic determinants for susceptibility to Graves' disease.

Detection and properties of TSH-binding inhibitor immunoglobulins in patients with Graves' disease and Hashimoto's thyroiditis.

TSH-binding inhibitor immunoglobulins (TBII) have been detected in patients with Graves' disease and Hashimoto's thyroiditis by using the radioreceptor assay of TSH. In untreated Graves' patients, TBII levels correlated well with thyroidal 99mTc uptake at 30 min and the grade of epithelial hyperplasia of thyroid follicles. There were many Graves' patients whose sera contained high TBII levels but no detectable bioassayable thyroid-stimulating activity (LATS), and in these patients, close correlation was observed between serum levels of TBII and bioassayable LATS-protector activity. TBII were detectable in 2 (10%) of 20 patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, both of whom were clinically hypothyroid. The serum or IgG fraction from one of them, however, did not contain any significant LATS, LATS-protector, or human thyroid adenylate cyclase-stimulating activity and caused inhibition of adenylate cyclase stimulation by TSH. In that patient, TBII may be acting to block TSH binding to TSH receptors, thus causing TSH unresponsiveness and hypothyroidism.

A new in vitro assay for human thyroid stimulator using cultured thyroid cells: effect of sodium chloride on adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate increase.

A new sensitive in vitro assay for human thyroid stimulator (HTS) was developed using human thyroid adenoma cells in monolayer culture. After being cultured for 2 days, the cells were incubated in 0.3 ml Hank's solution without 0.8% NaCl (medium 1) and with thyroid stimulator (bovine TSH or 3 mg patient serum immunoglobulin G) at 37 C for 2 h. The cAMP generated in the cells and the medium during the incubation was measured by RIA. The assay was sensitive enough to elicit a 1.7- to 7.9-fold increase in cAMP at a TSH concentration of 10 microU/ml. HTS was detected in 33 (82.5%) of the 40 patients with untreated graves' disease using this assay system. In Hank's solution (medium 2), however, HTS was detected in only 5 (23.8%) of the 21 patients with untreated GRaves' disease. cAMP increment upon stimulation by either TSH or HTS in medium 1 was larger than that in medium 2, and the difference in the response to HTS using the two media was much greater than that in the response to TSH. Therefore, all HTS-immunoglobulin G studies showed higher activity using medium 1 than using medium 2 when expressed as bovine TSH equivalent. Analysis by the Lineweaver-Burk plot of dose-response curves of the effect of TSH and HTS stimulation on cAMP increment showed an increase in the Km upon the addition of NaCl to the medium. A similar inhibitory effect of NaCl (150 mM) was also observed in the assay system of human thyroid adenylate cyclase stimulator using crude plasma membrane fractions. In summary: 1) an assay for HTS measuring cAMP production in cultured thyroid adenoma cells was developed and the assay using low NaCL medium was found to be the most sensitive, and 2) the inhibitory effect of NaCl on the response to HTS was much greater than that on the response to TSH. These data suggest different behaviors of these two stimulators at their receptor sites.

A water-soluble fragment of the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor which binds both thyroid-stimulating hormone and thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor antibodies.

Previous studies have shown that freezing and thawing of human thyroid homogenates releases a water-soluble substance which reversibly binds to TSH-receptor antibodies. This substance has been designated long-acting thyroid stimulator absorbing activity (LAA). We now describe a new method for measuring LAA based on the TSH-receptor assay and application of the technique to the study of LAA. Our results indicate that LAA is a heat-labile glycoprotein which co-elutes with haemoglobin on gel filtration. Furthermore, LAA is retarded by columns of Sepharose-TSH but not by Sepharose coupled to human chorionic gonadotrophin, normal immunoglobulin G or bovine serum albumin, suggesting that LAA contains a binding site for TSH as well as for TSH-receptor antibodies. It would seem therefore that LAA is a water-soluble fragment of the TSH receptor possibly resulting from proteolytic cleavage of the receptor at a site close to the cell surface.

Activation of thyroid adenyl cyclase by antisera to thyroid plasma membrane preparations: effects of IgG and non-IgG antiserum components.

We have previously shown that IgG isolated from rabbit antibovine thyroid plasma membrane (anti-BTPM) antibodies exhibits properties similar to long acting thyroid stimulator (LATS) and HTS-lg in that it activates thyroid adenyl cyclase. In order to test whether another immunoglobulin class, eg, IgM, of anti-BTPM antiserum can also stimulate the bovine thyroid adenyl cyclase system, protein molecules of the antiserum were separated into different molecular sizes by gel filtration chromatography on Sephadex G-200. It was observed that the low molecular weight fraction, consisting predominantly of albumin, was inactive in stimulating adenyl cyclase of the thyroid gland. In contrast, both IgM-enriched and IgG-enriched fractions of the immune serum were fully active. Furthermore, the thyroid-stimulating activity of the IgM-enriched fraction can only be inhibited by anti-IgM and that of the IgG-enriched fraction by anti-IgG. Our data suggest that IgM, in addition to IgG, may also have LATS or LATS-like activities in terms of activating adenyl cyclase of the thyroid gland.

Treatment of hyperthyroidism in pregnancy with propylthiouracil and methimazole.

Twenty-one women were studied who had received propylthiouracil or methimazole during 26 pregnancies. Four of the infants had a goiter at birth, and 3 of these had neonatal thyrotoxicosis. In 2 children neonatal thyrotoxicosis was not evident at birth because of maternal antithyroid therapy. Five children had congenital defects. Two mothers were responsible for 4 of the children with abnormalities, and both mothers had been treated with thiourea drugs for long periods, ranging from 7 to 11 years. The majority of children who are exposed to these drugs in utero appear to have no subsequent ill effects. However, prolonged therapy with these agents may be undesirable.