Experimental evidence for the correlation between RNA structural fluctuations and the frequency of beneficial mutations.

ABSTRACT

RNA has been used as a model molecule to understand the adaptive evolution process owing to the simple relationship between the structure (i.e., phenotype) and sequence (i.e., genotype). RNA usually forms multiple substructures with similar thermodynamic stabilities, called structural fluctuations. Ancel and Fontana theoretically proposed that structural fluctuation is directly related to the ease of change in structures by mutations and thus works as a source of adaptive evolution; however, experimental verification is limited. Here, we analyzed 76 RNA genotypes that appeared in our previous in vitro evolution to examine whether (i) RNA fluctuation decreases as adaptive evolution proceeds and (ii) RNAs that have larger fluctuations tend to have higher frequencies of beneficial mutations. We first computationally estimated the structural fluctuations of all RNAs and observed that they tended to decrease as their fitness increased. We next measured the frequency of beneficial mutations for 10 RNA genotypes and observed that the total number of beneficial mutations was correlated with the size of the structural fluctuations. These results consistently support the idea that the structural fluctuation of RNA, at least those evaluated in our study, works as a source of adaptive evolution.