ABSTRACT
Prediction is fundamental in music listening. Two types of expectations have been proposed: schematic expectations, which arise from knowledge of tonal regularities (e.g., harmony and key) acquired through long-term plasticity and learning, and dynamic expectations, which arise from short-term regularity representations (e.g., rhythmic patterns and melodic contours) extracted from ongoing musical contexts. Although both expectations are indispensable in music listening, how they interact with each other in music prediction remains unclear. The present study examined the relationship between schematic and dynamic expectations in music processing using event-related potentials (ERPs). At the ending note of the melodies, the schematic expectation was violated by presenting a note with music-syntactic irregular (i.e., outof- key note), while the dynamic expectation was violated by presenting a contour deviant based on online statistical learning of melodic patterns. Schematic and dynamic expectations were manipulated to predict the same note. ERPs were recorded for the music-syntactic irregularity and the contour deviant, which occurred independently or simultaneously. The results showed that the music-syntactic irregularity elicited an early right anterior negativity (ERAN), reflecting the prediction error in the schematic expectation, while the contour deviant elicited a mismatch negativity (MMN), reflecting the prediction error in the dynamic expectation. Both components occurred within a similar latency range. Moreover, the ERP amplitude was multiplicatively increased when the irregularity and deviance occurred simultaneously. These findings suggest that schematic and dynamic expectations function concurrently in an interactive manner when both expectations predict the same note.
Subject(s)
Music , Humans , Motivation , Evoked Potentials/physiology , Learning , Perception , Auditory Perception/physiology , Acoustic Stimulation/methods , Evoked Potentials, Auditory/physiology , Electroencephalography/methodsABSTRACT
In music and language domains, it has been suggested that patterned transitions of sounds can be acquired implicitly through statistical learning. Previous studies have investigated the statistical learning of auditory regularities by recording early neural responses to a sequence of tones presented at high or low transition probabilities. However, it remains unclear whether the statistical learning of musical chord transitions is reflected in endogenous, regularity-dependent components of the event-related potential (ERP). The present study aimed to record the mismatch negativity (MMN) elicited by chord transitions that deviated from newly learned transitional regularities. Chords were generated in a novel 18 equal temperament pitch class scale to avoid interference from the existing tonal representations of the 12 equal temperament pitch class system. Thirty-six adults without professional musical training listened to a sequence of randomly inverted chords in which certain chords were presented with high (standard) or low (deviant) transition probabilities. An irrelevant timbre change detection task was assigned to make them attend to the sequence during the ERP recording. After that, a familiarity test was administered in which the participants were asked to choose the more familiar chord sequence out of two successive sequences. The results showed that deviant transitions elicited the MMN, although the participants could not recognize the standard transition beyond the level of chance. These findings suggest that humans can statistically learn new transitional regularities of chords in a novel musical scale, even though they did not recognize them explicitly. This study provides further evidence that music-syntactic regularities can be acquired implicitly through statistical learning.
Subject(s)
Evoked Potentials, Auditory , Music , Adult , Humans , Evoked Potentials, Auditory/physiology , Acoustic Stimulation/methods , Electroencephalography , Auditory Perception/physiology , LearningABSTRACT
Humans can detect various anomalies in a sound sequence without attending to each dimension explicitly. Event-related potentials (ERPs) have been used to examine the processes of auditory deviance detection. Previous research has shown that music-syntactic anomalies elicit early right anterior negativity (ERAN), whereas more general acoustic irregularities elicit mismatch negativity (MMN). Although these ERP components occur in a similar latency range with a similar scalp topography, the relationship between the detection processes they reflect remains unclear. This study compared these components by manipulating music-syntactic (chord progression) and acoustic (intensity) irregularities orthogonally in two experiments. Non-musicians (Experiment 1: N = 39; Experiment 2: N = 24) were asked to listen to chord sequences, each consisting of 5 four-voice chords, as they watched a silent video clip. Standard, harmonic-deviant, intensity-deviant and double-deviant chords occurred at the final position in each sequence. Deviant stimuli were presented infrequently (p = .10) in Experiment 1 and equiprobably (p = .25) in Experiment 2. Regardless of deviance probability, both harmonic and intensity deviants elicited similar negativities, which were indistinguishable in terms of latency or scalp distribution. When the two deviant types occurred simultaneously, the negativity increased in an additive manner; that is, the amplitude of the double-deviant ERP was as large as the sum of the single-deviant ERPs. These findings suggest that the detection of music-syntactic and acoustic irregularities works independently, based on different regularity representations.
Subject(s)
Electroencephalography , Music , Humans , Acoustic Stimulation/methods , Electroencephalography/methods , Auditory Perception/physiology , Acoustics , Evoked Potentials, Auditory/physiologyABSTRACT
The perceptual processing of a sound is facilitated when the sound matches auditory imagery. Previous studies have shown that auditory imagery and actual sound activate the auditory cortex in a similar fashion. To investigate whether auditory imagery is a modality-specific representation or an amodal representation, the current study examined how watching silent music videos affected the auditory processing of sound excerpts. Twenty university students were asked to form musical imagery of Japanese popular songs while watching the official music videos. Event-related brain potentials were recorded in response to short sound excerpts from the on-screen video or from a different video. The results showed that the amplitude of the exogenous N1 component (90-110 ms) was smaller for imagery-matched than for unmatched sound excerpts. The electrical source of the difference was estimated in the auditory cortex. After the N1, the matched excerpts elicited a larger late positive potential (400-800 ms) than the unmatched excerpts. These findings suggest that auditory imagery involves modality-specific neural processing and that imagery-matched sounds are processed efficiently at an early stage, inducing additional cognitive processing at a later stage.