ABSTRACT
Background: In Kampo medicine, tongue examination is used to diagnose the pathological condition "Sho," but an objective evaluation method for its diagnostic ability has not been established. We constructed a tongue diagnosis electronic learning and evaluation system based on a standardized tongue image database. Purpose: This study aims to verify the practicality of this assessment system by evaluating the tongue diagnosis ability of Kampo specialists (KSs), medical professionals, and students. Methods: In the first study, we analyzed the answer data of 15 KSs in an 80-question tongue diagnosis test that assesses eight aspects of tongue findings and evaluated the (i) test score, (ii) test difficulty and discrimination index, (iii) diagnostic consistency, and (iv) diagnostic match rate between KSs. In the second study, we administered a 20-question common Kampo test and analyzed the answer data of 107 medical professionals and 56 students that assessed the tongue color discrimination ability and evaluated the (v) correct answer rate, (vi) test difficulty, and (vii) factors related to the correct answer rate. Result: In the first study, the average test score was 62.2 ± 10.7 points. Twenty-eight questions were difficult (correct answer rate, <50%), 34 were moderate (50%-85%), and 18 were easy (≥85%). Regarding intrarater reliability, the average diagnostic match rate of five KSs involved in database construction was 0.66 ± 0.08, and as for interrater reliability, the diagnostic match rate between the 15 KSs was 0.52 (95% confidence interval, 0.38-0.65) for Gwet's agreement coefficient 1, and the degree of the match rate was moderate. In the second study, the difficulty level of questions was moderate, with a correct rate of 81.3% for medical professionals and 82.1% for students. The discrimination index was good for medical professionals (0.35) and poor for students (0.06). Among medical professionals, the correct answer group of this question had a significantly higher total score on the Kampo common test than the incorrect answer group (85.3 ± 8.4 points vs. 75.8 ± 11.8 points, p < 0.01). Conclusion: This system can objectively evaluate tongue diagnosis ability and has high practicality. Utilizing this system can be expected to contribute to improving learners' tongue diagnosis ability and standardization of tongue diagnosis.
ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study was to develop an objective, content-valid, and reliable assessment method for Kampo medicine using an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) for the assessment of clinical competence in Kampo medicine. METHODS: We developed a blueprint followed by a list of 47 assessment items and three task scenarios related to clinical competence in Kampo medicine. An eight-member test committee checked the relevance of the assessment items on a Likert scale. We calculated a content validity index and content validity ratio, and used the Angoff method to set the passing threshold. We trained a total of nine simulated patients with three assigned to each scenario. We conducted an OSCE for 11 candidates with varying medical abilities, and conducted three stations per person, which were evaluated by one evaluator in one room by direct observation. We used video recordings to test the inter-rater reliability of the three raters. We used the test results to verify the reliability of the assessment chart. RESULTS: The inter-rater reliability (intraclass correlation coefficient [2,1]) was 0.973. The reliability of the assessment chart for each scenario (Cronbach's α) was 0.86, 0.89, and 0.85 for Scenarios 1, 2, and 3, respectively. The reliability of the assessment chart for the whole OSCE (Cronbach's α) was 0.90. CONCLUSIONS: We developed a content-valid new OSCE assessment method for Kampo medicine and obtained high inter-rater and test reliabilities. Our findings suggest that this is one of the most reliable evaluation methods for assessing clinical competence in Kampo medicine.
Subject(s)
Educational Measurement , Medicine, Kampo , Clinical Competence , Educational Measurement/methods , Humans , Physical Examination , Reproducibility of ResultsABSTRACT
Kampo medicine has been practiced as traditional medicine (TM) in Japan. Kampo medicine uses Kampo formulae that are composed of multiple crude drugs to make Kampo formulae. In Japan, Kampo formulae are commonly used instead of or combined with Western medicines. If drug therapy that follows the guidelines for neuropathic pain does not work or cannot be taken due to side effects, various Kampo formulae are considered as the next line of treatment. Since Kampo formulae are composed of two or more kinds of natural crude drugs, and their extracts contain many ingredients with pharmacological effects, one Kampo formula usually has multiple effects. Therefore, when selecting a formula, we consider symptoms other than pain. This review outlines the Kampo formulae that are frequently used for pain treatment and their crude drugs and the basic usage of each component. In recent years, Yokukansan (YKS) has become one of the most used Kampo formulae for pain treatment with an increasing body of baseline research available. We outline the known and possible mechanisms by which YKS exerts its pharmacologic benefits as an example of Kampo formulae's potency and holistic healing properties.
ABSTRACT
Stomatitis is occasionally multiple, recurrent, and refractory. Currently, mucositis induced by chemotherapy and radiation therapy in patients with cancer has become a significant clinical problem. Effective treatments have not been established and the treatment of numerous cases remains a challenge for physicians. Traditional Japanese herbal medicines termed Kampo formulae (i.e., Hangeshashinto, Orengedokuto, Inchinkoto, Orento, Byakkokaninjinto, Juzentaihoto, Hochuekkito, and Shosaikoto) are used for treating various types of stomatitis and mucositis. Its use has been based on the Kampo medical theories-empirical rules established over thousands of years. However, recently, clinical and basic research studies investigating these formulae have been conducted to obtain scientific evidence. Clinical studies investigating efficacies of Shosaikoto and Orento for the treatment of cryptogenic stomatitis and acute aphthous stomatitis and those investigating the effects of Hangeshashinto, Orengedokuto, and Juzentaihoto on chemotherapy- or radiotherapy-induced mucositis have been conducted. The Kampo formulae comprise several crude drugs, whose mechanisms of action are gradually being clarified. Most of these drugs that are used for the treatment of stomatitis possess anti-inflammatory, analgesic, and antioxidative properties. In this review, we introduce the clinical applications and summarize the available evidence on the Kampo formulae for the treatment of stomatitis and oral mucositis.
ABSTRACT
This article highlights several refractory oral diseases, such as stomatitis, burning mouth syndrome (BMS), glossalgia, atypical facial pain (AFP), oral cancer, dry mouth, and Sjögren's syndrome (SJS), in which use of Japanese herbal medicines, Kampo medicines (KM), on the basis of Kampo theory could exert the maximum effects on human body. (1) In acute stomatitis, heat because of agitated vital energy may affect the head, chest, and middle abdominal region. Stomatitis is also related to the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). There are many antioxidants in the crude extracts of KM. Thus, we can control environmental factors (cold, heat, dampness, dryness) and vital energy, blood, and fluid of the organ systemically using KM to treat stomatitis and eliminate local ROS accumulation. (2) BMS, glossalgia, and AFP are multifactorial syndromes involving the interaction of biological and psychological factors. Local temperature decrease and edema often occur in chronic pain. These are local circulatory disturbances that can be resolved by improving the flow of blood and fluid. Several KM, such as Tokishakuyakusan and Kamishoyosan (KSS), are effective for enhancing peripheral circulation. Those such as Saikokaryukotuboreito, Yokukansan, KSS, and Saibokutou can reduce stress and associated pain by altering glutamatergic and monoaminergic transmission in the brain. The clinical efficacy of KM for BMS and AFP may depend on the regulation of the mesolimbic dopaminergic and descending glutamatergic pain modulation systems. (3) Regarding oral cancer treatment, I introduce four possible applications of KM, inhibition of the proliferation of cancer cells, complementation of the main cancer therapy, reduction of side effect caused by the main anti-cancer therapy and improvement of quality of life such as the overall status and/or oral discomfort. This review explains in more details Hozai such as Hochuekkito (HET), Juzendaihoto, and Ninjinyoeito (NYT) that are frequently used to improve both immunosuppression and deficiencies of Ki, Ketsu, and Sui in oral cancer patients. (4) Heat- and cold-dryness stages exist in dry mouth and SJS. Byakkokaninjinto is useful for heat-dryness, while NYT, Bakumondoto, and HET have moisturizing effects in the cold-dryness stage. Thus, Kampo therapy is useful for many oral diseases that cannot be cured by western medicine.
ABSTRACT
Prostaglandin E(2) (PGE(2)) is essential for fracture healing. Systemic administration of EP4 ligands such as PGE(2) and other synthetic EP4 agonists appears to transduce anabolic signals by binding to receptor EP4. Therefore, the present study was designed to test whether administration of EP4 agonist accelerates the healing of drill-hole injury in the femoral diaphysis. After surgery, a total of 128 Wistar rats, at the age of 12 weeks, were assigned to basal control (n = 8), and three groups with respective doses of 0 (vehicle control), 10 (low-dose), and 30 (high-dose) microg/kg body weight of the agent were subcutaneously injected twice a day. Femoral specimens were obtained at 0, 5, 7, 14, 21, and 28 days. In EP4 agonist-treated groups, the total bone volume of the regenerating bone in the defect did not significantly differ, but the regenerated cortical bone volume measured by histomorphometry and cortical bone mineral content (Ct. BMC) by pQCT dose-dependently increased at 14 and 21 days compared to the control. In the high-dose group, the value of osteoclast surface significantly increased compared with that in the control at 14 days. Expression levels of osteocalcin and TRAP mRNAs in the injured tissue increased at 14 days. Expression levels of EP4, BMP-2, and RANKL mRNAs increased at 7 days in the high-dose group. The bone mineral values of the lumbar bone at 28 days, measured by DXA, did not differ in the three groups. These data indicated that systemic administration of EP4 agonist ONO-4819.CD accelerated cortical bone healing after drill-hole injury by upregulating the local turnover of the regenerating bone.