Image Quality in Oncologic Chest Computerized Tomography With Iterative Reconstruction: A Phantom Study.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to validate iterative reconstruction technique in oncologic chest computed tomography (CT). METHODS: An anthropomorphic thorax phantom with 4 simulated tumors was scanned on a 64-slice CT scanner with 2 different iterative reconstruction techniques: one model based (MBIR) and one hybrid (ASiR). Dose levels of 14.9, 11.1, 6.7, and 0.6 mGy were used, and all images were reconstructed with filtered back projection (FBP) and both iterative reconstruction algorithms. Hounsfield units (HU) and absolute noise were measured in the tumors, lung, heart, diaphragm, and muscle. Contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRs) and signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) were calculated. RESULTS: Model-based iterative reconstruction (MBIR) increased CNRs of the tumors (21.1-192.2) and SNRs in the lung (-49.0-165.6) and heart (3.1-8.5) at all dose levels compared with FBP (CNR, 1.1-23.0; SNR, -7.5-31.6 and 0.2-1.1) and with adaptive statistical iterative reconstruction (CNR, 1.2-33.2; SNR, -7.3-37.7 and 0.2-1.5). At the lowest dose level (0.6 mGy), MBIR reduced the cupping artifact (HU range: 17.0 HU compared with 31.4-32.2). An HU shift in the negative direction was seen with MBIR. CONCLUSIONS: Quantitative image quality parameters in oncologic chest CT are improved with MBIR compared with FBP and simpler iterative reconstruction algorithms. Artifacts at low doses are reduced. A shift in HU values was shown; thus, absolute HU values should be used with care.

Water calibration for CT scanners with tube voltage modulation.

X-ray CT measures the attenuation of polychromatic x-rays through an object of interest. The CT data acquired are the negative logarithm of the relative x-ray intensity after absorption. These data must undergo water precorrection to linearize the measured data and convert them into line integrals through the patient that can be reconstructed to yield the final CT image. The function to linearize the measured projection data depends on the tube voltage U. In most circumstances, CT scans are carried out with a constant tube voltage. For those cases there are dozens of different techniques to carry out water precorrection. In our case the tube voltage is rather modulated as a function of the object. We propose an empirical cupping correction (ECCU) algorithm to correct for CT cupping artifacts that are induced by nonlinearities in the projection data. The method is rawdata based, empirical and requires neither knowledge of the x-ray spectrum nor of the attenuation coefficients. It aims at linearizing the attenuation data using a precorrection function of polynomial form in the polychromatic attenuation data q and in the tube voltage U. The coefficients of the polynomial are determined once using a calibration scan of a homogeneous phantom. The coefficients are computed in the image domain by fitting a series of basis images to a template image. The template image is obtained directly from the uncorrected phantom image and no assumptions on the phantom size or of its positioning are made. Rawdata are precorrected by passing them through the once-determined polynomial. Numerical examples are shown to demonstrate the quality of the precorrection. ECCU is achieved to remove the cupping artifacts and to obtain well-calibrated CT values. A combination of ECCU with analytical techniques yielding a hybrid cupping correction method is possible and allows for channel-dependent correction functions.

A fast and pragmatic approach for scatter correction in flat-detector CT using elliptic modeling and iterative optimization.

Scattered radiation is a major source of artifacts in flat detector computed tomography (FDCT) due to the increased irradiated volumes. We propose a fast projection-based algorithm for correction of scatter artifacts. The presented algorithm combines a convolution method to determine the spatial distribution of the scatter intensity distribution with an object-size-dependent scaling of the scatter intensity distributions using a priori information generated by Monte Carlo simulations. A projection-based (PBSE) and an image-based (IBSE) strategy for size estimation of the scanned object are presented. Both strategies provide good correction and comparable results; the faster PBSE strategy is recommended. Even with such a fast and simple algorithm that in the PBSE variant does not rely on reconstructed volumes or scatter measurements, it is possible to provide a reasonable scatter correction even for truncated scans. For both simulations and measurements, scatter artifacts were significantly reduced and the algorithm showed stable behavior in the z-direction. For simulated voxelized head, hip and thorax phantoms, a figure of merit Q of 0.82, 0.76 and 0.77 was reached, respectively (Q = 0 for uncorrected, Q = 1 for ideal). For a water phantom with 15 cm diameter, for example, a cupping reduction from 10.8% down to 2.1% was achieved. The performance of the correction method has limitations in the case of measurements using non-ideal detectors, intensity calibration, etc. An iterative approach to overcome most of these limitations was proposed. This approach is based on root finding of a cupping metric and may be useful for other scatter correction methods as well. By this optimization, cupping of the measured water phantom was further reduced down to 0.9%. The algorithm was evaluated on a commercial system including truncated and non-homogeneous clinically relevant objects.

Image quality and radiation dose on digital chest imaging: comparison of amorphous silicon and amorphous selenium flat-panel systems.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to compare the image quality and radiation dose in chest imaging using an amorphous silicon flat-panel detector system and an amorphous selenium flat-panel detector system. In addition, the low-contrast performance of both systems with standard and low radiation doses was compared. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In two groups of 100 patients each, digital chest radiographs were acquired with either an amorphous silicon or an amorphous selenium flat-panel system. The effective dose of the examination was measured using thermoluminescent dosimeters placed in an anthropomorphic Rando phantom. The image quality of the digital chest radiographs was assessed by five experienced radiologists using the European Guidelines on Quality Criteria for Diagnostic Radiographic Images. In addition, a contrast-detail phantom study was set up to assess the low-contrast performance of both systems at different radiation dose levels. Differences between the two groups were tested for significance using the two-tailed Mann-Whitney test. RESULTS: The amorphous silicon flat-panel system allowed an important and significant reduction in effective dose in comparison with the amorphous selenium flat-panel system (p < 0.0001) for both the posteroanterior and lateral views. In addition, clinical image quality analysis showed that the dose reduction was not detrimental to image quality. Compared with the amorphous selenium flat-panel detector system, the amorphous silicon flat-panel detector system performed significantly better in the low-contrast phantom study, with phantom entrance dose values of up to 135 muGy. CONCLUSION: Chest radiographs can be acquired with a significantly lower patient radiation dose using an amorphous silicon flat-panel system than using an amorphous selenium flat-panel system, thereby producing images that are equal or even superior in quality to those of the amorphous selenium flat-panel detector system.

Digital chest radiography system with amorphous selenium flat-panel detectors: Qualitative and dosimetric comparison with a dedicated film-screen system.

PURPOSE: To compare the quality and radiation dose of a conventional film-screen system and a digital system with amorphous selenium detectors in the study of the chest, by verifying overall performance and exposure levels for the main chest structures in patients of different sizes. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An analogic system (Chest-Changer, Dupont, Day-light model 1000) and a digital system (Directray Rad 1000C, Hologic) were tested on a total of 1000 patients randomly assigned to one of two groups of 500 subjects. The patients were further subdivided according to BMI (Body Mass Index). Image quality was determined by two chest radiologists who evaluated eight anatomical structures. The entrance surface dose (skin-dose), calculated based on the exposure parameters, was taken as the patient dose. RESULTS: Mean dose delivered was very similar for both techniques in the PA view (0.28 mGy), but it was greater in the LL projections obtained with the digital system (1.20 mGy versus 0.83 mGy). The highest overall scores were assigned to 43% and 23.2% analogic radiograms and 64% and 70.2% digital radiograms, for the PA and LL projections respectively. The scores assigned to the various anatomical structures confirmed the better performance of the digital system in almost all of the regions considered. CONCLUSIONS: The mean quality of radiograms is definitely higher with the digital system, in particular in the LL projections, where the higher patient doses are counterbalanced by fewer repeated scans. The greater level of exposure in the digital system appears nonetheless tolerable on account of the greater informativeness and therefore diagnostic gain and also considering the possibilities for improving the system.

[The amorphous selenium based flat-panel detector. Clinical experiences]. / Der Flachbilddetektor auf der Basis von amorphem Selen. Klinische Erfahrungen.

The possibility of acquiring digital radiographic images has been marked with a rapid development. The main advantages of such images are, above all, the electronic dispersal of images, the economical archiving and the computer supported post processing. The recently introduced large-area flat panel detectors offer, contrary to storage-phosphor-based computed radiography, a direct read-out modality. It must be emphasized that differences between direct and indirect detector technology exist,which we will discuss here. The working and advantages of the amorphous selenium based direct-conversion detectors will be examined in detail. Clinical cases will be presented based on a three-year experience with over 200,000 exposures with a detector chest unit.

Detection of pulmonary edema in pigs: storage phosphor versus amorphous selenium-based flat-panel-detector radiography.

PURPOSE: To compare diagnostic accuracy of soft-copy selenium-based digital radiographic images and soft-copy computed radiographic images obtained for detection of pulmonary edema in pigs. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Oleic acid was injected intraatrially into three pigs (weight, 20-25 kg) at doses of 0.04, 0.05, and 0.06 mL/kg to induce pulmonary edema. Thirty-seven sets of computed radiographic, digital radiographic, and thin-section computed tomographic (CT) scans were obtained every 20-30 minutes in three pigs over 4-6 hours. Images were masked for identity, randomly sorted, and displayed on a monitor. Four radiologists rated each image for presence of parenchymal opacities by using a dichotomous scoring system in two sessions. Presence of pulmonary edema was determined with thin-section CT and a severity scale. Intra- and interobserver variations were determined with the kappa statistic and the Z test and with the Cochran Q test and the McNemar test, respectively. True-positive, true-negative, false-positive, and false-negative rates were determined. McNemar test was used to determine statistical significance of differences in detection between computed and digital radiographic images. RESULTS: There was no significant intra- or interobserver variation, except for one pair of observers during the first interpretative session with computed radiographic images (P =.016, McNemar test). Overall sensitivity (92.1%) and diagnostic accuracy (90.2%) of digital radiography were significantly higher than those of computed radiography (79.6% and 83.4%, respectively) (P <.001 for sensitivity, P =.01 for diagnostic accuracy, McNemar test). In detection of minimal and mild pulmonary edema, sensitivity of digital radiography (84%) was significantly higher than that of computed radiography (58%) (P <.001). CONCLUSION: Soft-copy digital radiographic images are superior to soft-copy computed radiographic images obtained for detection of mild pulmonary edema in pigs.

[Digital radiography: from storage phosphor plates to direct detector systems]. / Digitale Radiographie: Von der Speicherfolie zum Direktdetektor.

All three currently commercially available systems for digital radiography of the chest such as the selenium drum, storage phosphor plates and the flat panel direct detector systems provide an excellent image quality that is at least equivalent or superior to that of conventional film. Reasons for that are the continuously improved detective or dose efficiency of the detector systems and an improved image processing. The new direct detector systems have the largest potential for dose reduction while storage phosphor and selenium radiographs are usually obtained with a dose comparable to that of a 400 speed system. Improved image processing algorithms allow for the production of digital images that are adapted to the conventional image characteristics within the lung regions combined with an increased transparency of the high absorption areas such as the retrocardial and retrodiaphragmatic regions.

Effect of dose levels on the diagnostic performance of a selenium-based digital chest system.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effect of dose reduction on diagnostic performance by using a digital chest imaging system in which amorphous selenium serves as the x-ray detector. METHODS: Two hundred forty-seven patients were examined with the selenium system. Three sets of images were made in each patient: one set with a standard x-ray dose, one set with 55% of the standard dose, and one set with 35% of the standard dose. All 741 images were read by two radiologists. The diagnostic value of each set of images for detection of pulmonary, mediastinal, and pleural pathology was analyzed with receiver operating characteristic (ROC) methodology by using computed tomography as the reference standard. The authors also assessed the effect of sex, height, and weight of the patients on the diagnostic performance of the readers. RESULTS: The areas under the ROC curves for the detection of various abnormalities at 100%, 55%, and 35% of the standard dose for observer 1, respectively, were pulmonary opacities 0.82, 0.83, 0.84; interstitial disease 0.71, 0.70, 0.72; mediastinal disease 0.81, 0.80, 0.77; and pleural abnormalities 0.71, 0.72, 0.72. There were no statistically significant differences between the two observers. CONCLUSIONS: No statistically significant difference was found between the radiologists' performance in detecting abnormalities with standard x-ray dose images and the performance with images made with 55% and 35% of the standard dose. Sex, height, and weight had no influence on diagnostic performance.

Digital selenium radiography: anti-scatter grid for chest radiography in a clinical study.

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the diagnostic performance of an additional stationary anti-scatter grid in digital selenium radiography (DSR) compared with images acquired with only an air gap. Chest radiographs were obtained with DSR in 100 patients with and without an anti-scatter grid. Four observers scored 12 anatomical landmarks, catheters and wire cerclages for their visualization in both subsets of images. Statistical analysis was performed using a paired t-test. Anatomical landmarks, catheters and wire cerclages were statistically better visualized in regions of high attenuation when the images were performed with an anti-scatter grid. No statistically significant difference was noted for peripheral regions, nor for sex and weight of the patient between the two modalities. Therefore, an anti-scatter grid is not recommended for chest radiography as it increases the radiation exposure of patients without having a significant impact on visualization for all regions of the chest.

Digital chest radiography with a selenium-based flat-panel detector versus a storage phosphor system: comparison of soft-copy images.

OBJECTIVE: We compared the soft-copy images produced by a digital chest radiography system that uses a flat-panel X-ray detector based on amorphous selenium with images produced by a storage phosphor radiography system for the visualization of anatomic regions of the chest. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two chest radiologists and two residents analyzed 46 pairs of posteroanterior chest radiographs on high-resolution video monitors (2560 x 2048 x 8 bits). In each pair, one radiograph was obtained with a storage phosphor radiography system, and the other radiograph was obtained with a selenium-based flat-panel detector radiography system. Each pair of radiographs was obtained at the same exposure settings. The interpreter rated the visibility and radiographic quality of 11 different anatomic regions. Each pair of images was ranked on a five-point scale (1 = prefer image A, 3 = no preference, 5 = prefer image B) for preference of technique. Statistical significance of preference was determined using the Wilcoxon's signed rank test. RESULTS: The interpreters had a statistically significant preference for the selenium-based radiography system in six (unobscured lung, hilum, rib, minor fissure, heart border, and overall appearance) of 11 anatomic regions (p<0.001) and for the storage phosphor system in two regions (proximal airway and thoracic spine) (p<0.05). Chest radiologists strongly preferred selenium-based images in eight regions, and they did not prefer storage phosphor images in any region. CONCLUSION: The soft-copy images produced by the selenium-based radiography system were perceived as equal or superior to those produced by the storage phosphor system in most but not all anatomic regions.

Comparison between a screen-film system and a selenium radiography system. An ROC study using simulated thoracic lesions.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the diagnostic image quality of the hard copies of a commercially available selenium detector-based computed radiography system compared to that of a conventional screen-film system. METHODS: Ten radiographs of an anthropomorphic chest phantom with simulated nodular and linear-reticular lesions were produced using either system. Each radiograph was subdivided into 15 fields containing zero lesions, one nodular lesion, one linear-reticular lesion, or both lesions. The total of 150 fields for each modality was reviewed by six radiologists, and receiver operating analysis was performed. RESULTS: The conventional screen-film system performed significantly better for nodular lesions, whereas no statistically significant difference was found between the detection rates of both systems for linear-reticular lesions. CONCLUSIONS: The better detection of nodules with the dedicated selenium detector can be explained by the higher dynamic range of the system. Detection of linear-reticular lesions was slightly but not significantly better with the screen-film system, but the detection rate of the selenium detector might be further improved with a different image processing technique.

[Digital selenium radiography: a comparison of the picture quality of thoracic images in normal and reduced image formats based on the structural anatomical details]. / Digitale Selenradiographie: Vergleich der Bildqualität von Thoraxaufnahmen in normalem und verkleinertem Bildformat anhand anatomischer Detailstrukturen.

PURPOSE: Is there a loss of information when using selenium radiographic images displayed with reduced image format compared to full format? METHOD: Digital selenium radiographic chest images in two planes were obtained in 35 patients for medical reasons. The digital data sets of each patient were separately displayed in full format on two different films and were printed in reduced format on one film. The format was reduced to 61% of the full format using an acquisition matrix of 2166 x 2488 pixels, an image display matrix of 4000 x 5000 pixels and a film format of 43 x 49 cm. All images were anonymously evaluated by four independent readers using a questionnaire concerning anatomic structures. RESULTS: Format reduction did not result in a loss of information in diagnostically relevant anatomic details. CONCLUSIONS: Displaying digital selenium radiographic data sets of thoracic view in two planes on one film presumably does not lead to a loss of diagnostic information. This procedure may help to reduce film costs.

Chest radiographic image quality: comparison of asymmetric screen-film, digital storage phosphor, and digital selenium drum systems--preliminary study.

Conventional screen-film radiography does not display all regions of the thorax satisfactorily. Three chest radiographic techniques display both the lung and the mediastinum with good contrast. These techniques are asymmetric screen-film (ASF), digital storage phosphor (DSP), and digital selenium drum (DSD) imaging. ASF systems use two asymmetric screen-film combinations to produce a wide-latitude image of the thorax with good contrast in the lungs. In DSP systems, image data are acquired digitally with a wide dynamic range by using the optical output of a photostimulable phosphor plate; in DSD systems, the wide-range digital image data are acquired by using the electronic charge generated on a drum coated with a thin layer of amorphous selenium. The appearance of a DSP or DSD radiograph is then determined by user-selected image processing operations: tone scaling, spatial frequency processing, and dynamic range compensation. Digital chest radiographs processed with strong regional equalization provide both excellent contrast in the lungs and effective display of the mediastinum and chest wall. At visual comparison, the high lung contrast and good mediastinal, retrocardiac, and subdiaphragmatic detail provided by the DSD method distinguish it from the other two methods.

X-ray imaging with amorphous selenium: theoretical feasibility of the liquid crystal light valve for radiography.

A novel radiographic imaging system based on a liquid crystal light valve is described. A liquid crystal light valve is a photon addressed spatial light modulator that consists of a high resolution, solid-state electrostatic detector (photoconductor) and an electro-optic light modulator (liquid crystal cell) physically coupled in a sandwich structure. We propose a light valve with a thick, x-ray sensitive photoconductive layer and call the system under study the x-ray light valve (XLV). The image formation in the XLV is based on x-ray exposure controlled modulation of light from an external source; the XLV is essentially an x-ray image intensifier that allows the image brightness to be adjusted independently from the x-ray exposure. Thus the XLV may be coupled to an optical imager, such as a charge coupled device (CCD), for image digitization without a secondary quantum sink. A model of the XLV operation is developed to investigate its sensitivity, speed, noise, and resolution. The imaging properties of the XLV are found to be time dependent, which leads to an unusual transmission versus exposure characteristic. The feasibility of clinical use of the XLV based on amorphous selenium (a-Se) photoconductor and a twisted nematic liquid crystal cell is analyzed, and the device is shown to be adaptable to a variety of radiographic imaging tasks.

[Can digital selenium-based radiography in thoracic diagnosis replace the analog x-ray imaging technic?]. / Kann die digitale Selenradiographie in der Thoraxdiagnostik die analoge Röntgenaufnahmetechnik ersetzen?

PURPOSE: To find out the diagnostic value of digital selenium radiography, we compared the image quality of chest x-ray images from 50 patients who had been examined via conventional chest x-ray and digital selenium radiography of the chest. METHOD: 50 patients with a malignant melanoma underwent chest x-ray within 3 months in conventional technique and with digital selenium radiography (Thoravision: Philips Medical Systems, Hamburg, Germany). In this period none of the patients showed a difference in respect of clinical status or radiological diagnosis. Simultaneous examinations on the same day were not performed to avoid unnecessary exposure to x-rays. The digital and conventional images were compared by 4 radiologists with regard to image quality by the detection of defined anatomic structures. RESULTS: Image quality of digital selenium radiography was considered superior to that of conventional chest x-rays in the mediastinum, the retrocardiac and retrodiaphragmatic areas, the superior and inferior lobes of the lung especially near the parietal pleura, and the chest wall. CONCLUSIONS: Compared to analogous techniques there is no loss of image information when employing digital selenium radiography in chest x-rays. On the contrary, new assessment criteria may be gained. We conclude that digital selenium radiography offers diagnostic advantages in chest x-ray examination.

Digital chest imaging using a selenium detector. The impact of hard copy size on observer performance: a computed tomography-controlled study.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors compare radiologist detection performance under clinical conditions for assessment of the effect of size reduction on the diagnostic performance of digital chest images obtained with a selenium detector. METHODS: Sixty-five patients were examined with the digital system. The images were acquired without an antiscatter grid. Sixty-five posteroanterior life-size images (35 x 43 cm) and sixty-five posteroanterior minified images (56% of life size) were analyzed by three observers for detection of pulmonary, mediastinal, and pleural pathology, using computed tomography as the reference standard. The diagnostic value of life-size and minified images for the detection of these chest abnormalities was analyzed with receiver operating characteristic (ROC) methods. RESULTS: For the detection of the various abnormalities by all radiologists, the areas under the ROC curves with life-size images versus minified images, respectively, were as follows: pulmonary opacities, 0.78 versus 0.78; interstitial disease, 0.74 versus 0.75; mediastinal disease, 0.70 versus 0.72; and pleural abnormalities 0.72 versus 0.67. CONCLUSIONS: There was no statistically significant difference between the radiologists' performance in detecting pulmonary, mediastinal, and pleural pathology with life-size versus that with minified (56% of life size) digital selenium chest radiography.

Memory artifact related to selenium-based digital radiography systems.

Digital images acquired on radiography systems with amorphous selenium detectors are susceptible to "memory artifacts" from prior x-ray exposures. In routine clinical use and in a laboratory experiment, artifacts appeared in chest radiographs until the selenium recovered from initial exposure. Memory artifacts were eliminated when 3 minutes or more elapsed between acquisition of a lateral chest radiograph and acquisition of the next radiograph.

[Digital chest x-rays with a selenium detector: a prospective comparison with a conventional film-screen combination]. / Digitale Röntgenthoraxaufnahmen mit einem Selendetektor: prospektiver Vergleich mit einer konventionellen Film-Folien-Kombination.

PURPOSE: To compare a new digital chest radiography system that uses amorphous selenium as the x-ray detector, with conventional radiography for the detection of pathological alterations of the chest. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Two observers analysed pairs of posteroanterior and lateral chest radiographs of 95 patients. One pair of radiographs was obtained with the digital selenium chest radiography system, and the other with conventional film-screen technique. 9 criteria were rated using a 4 point scale. Technical parameters were standardised. Radiation dose was measured in both techniques and compared. RESULTS: A total of 855 criteria were rated. 740 findings were diagnosed in accordance on both techniques (740/855 = 87%). 115 criteria (115/855 = 13%) showed deviations. The mean radiation dose for the selenium detector was 0.02 cGy and for the conventional system 0.11 cGy. CONCLUSION: The exposure of radiation is lower using a selenium x-ray detector compared to conventional film-screen technique in chest radiography. The digital selenium system performs well in a clinical setting, providing visualisation of pathological findings as good as a standard screen-film system.

Stimulable phosphor plates in chest radiology.

The stimulable phosphor plate technique has revolutionised radiology with portable equipment. The image quality permits diagnosis under difficult control conditions (ICUs). In order to achieve a signal-to-noise ratio, and therefore a contrast resolution similar to the commonly used film/screen systems, a higher radiation dose is needed. However, overall, with this technique a radiation dose reduction may be achieved as a result of the elimination of the need for retakes. The available stimulable phosphor plate systems, with adequate image processing are reliable, and at least as good as conventional film/screen systems for diagnosis in chest radiography. There are, however, other aspects that make the stimulable phosphor plate technique particularly appealing. Firstly, its reproducibility, which particularly in chest radiography allows images to be obtained with the same grey scale and darkness. Secondly, as this technique permits digital archiving and visualisation of images on screen, images can be rapidly distributed over a network making them available when and where they are needed.