Phosphogypsum impacts on soil chemical properties and vegetation tissue following reclamation.

Phosphogypsum (PG) is a by-product of phosphorus fertilizer that is typically stacked near production sites. Phosphogypsum contains trace elements and naturally occurring radioactive materials which may be hazardous to the surrounding environment. Phosphogypsum stack reclamation typically involves placing a soil cap and seeding grass to create a barrier for reducing environmental impacts; using woody species is uncommon. This study used three soil treatments with grass and woody species to determine whether mixing PG with soil affects soil chemical properties, and metal and radionuclide concentrations in tissue. None of the elements in soil was above Canadian guidelines for industrial land use. Aluminum, beryllium, chromium, copper, iron, magnesium, manganese, nickel, and vanadium were significantly higher in both study and reference sites than in pure PG; cadmium, calcium, fluoride, and strontium were significantly higher in pure PG. There was a poor correlation between soil and plant concentrations for most elements indicating trace elements were not in a bioavailable form. Trace elemental concentrations in plant tissue generally differed significantly with vegetation type but not within similar species. Trace elements and isotopes in PG were not high enough to affect plant growth. Among the isotopes, 222Ra emissions differed significantly with vegetation covers; activity of 226Ra in pure PG was above Canadian guidelines, but lower in vegetation tissue. This study suggests 15 cm soil mixed with PG can be used for PG stack revegetation when fast-growing Salix and Populus species are used in reclamation.

Application timing optimization of lignite-derived humic substances for three agricultural plant species and soil fertility.

Coal is mined for energy generation around the world, producing large amounts of waste and extensive disturbances to the environment. Post-mining lands with sandy soils to be reclaimed for agricultural uses are very challenging. The use of humic substances such as soil amendments has been discussed, although little information is available regarding application timing in the field. We conducted a field experiment over two consecutive growing seasons on a former coal mine in China, to investigate soil and vegetation response to a lignite-derived humic product called "nano humus" and to determine optimal application timing. Three economically valuable agricultural species, alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.), barley (Hordeum vulgare L.), and sea buckthorn (Hippophae rhamnoides L.), were used for this study. The benefits of the humic product on soil properties and plant growth under field conditions were expressed after 2 yr of application. A single application at the beginning of each growing season provided better results than splitting into two applications, with no impact of duration (months) between applications. A single application significantly increased soil available phosphorus by 63% and potassium by 96% relative to the control; it significantly enhanced total biomass of alfalfa by 749%, barley by 250%, and sea buckthorn by 147%. Our findings provided important practical implications for using a humic material as a soil amendment in coal mine reclamation, with potential applications in other agricultural and reclamation scenarios.

Effect of soil capping depth on phosphogypsum stack revegetation.

Phosphogypsum is a by-product of the phosphorus fertilizer production process and is typically stacked at the production sites. These stacks can potentially pose environmental hazards, which can be substantially reduced through reclamation by capping with soil and revegetation upon decommissioning. We conducted a study on a phosphogypsum stack using five soil capping depths (8, 15, 30, 46, 91 cm), an uncapped treatment, and five vegetation treatments (monocultures of four grass species Agrostis stolonifera L., Festuca ovina L., Deschampsia caespitosa (L.) Beauv., Agropyron trachycaulum (Link) Malte ex H.F. Lewis and one mix of the four species with Trifolium hybridum L.) to assess plant growth, health, rooting characteristics, and trace element uptake. Cobalt and nickel concentrations in plant tissue from plots with ≥ 15 cm soil capping were within ranges found at reference sites, whereas fluorine was three times elevated. Vegetation cover was significantly greater on capped than uncapped plots, being greatest for Agropyron trachycaulum (26%) and Festuca ovina (26%). Capping depths ≥ 15 cm had greater cover, biomass, and healthy plants than the 8 cm cover. Soil water content was similar in the 15-46 cm capping depth, with the lowest in the 91-cm caps. Fluorine, cobalt, and nickel were elevated in select plant tissue samples on the research plots relative to references, and cap depth affected tissue fluorine and cobalt concentrations but not nickel. Concentrations of these trace elements were lower than maximum tolerable levels for animal consumption. From this 5-year study, Agropyron trachycaulum and Festuca ovina and a soil cover depth of ≥ 15 cm are recommended for reclamation of phosphogypsum stacks.

Response of three native grass species on dry tailings reclamation substrate amended with petroleum coke.

Surface mining around the world has produced large quantities of waste materials with ecological impacts. Oil sands mining in Canada generates large volumes of petroleum coke and tailings every year, which are stockpiled in the mining areas and must be reclaimed through capping or used in reclamation substrates. A greenhouse study was conducted to determine whether substrates of various mixes of dry tailings (DT), tailings sand (TS), and peat mineral mix (PMM) with coke amendment would support emergence and growth of three grass species commonly used in land reclamation. After 16 wk in the greenhouse, plant performance varied with substrate and amendment. Treatment with DT/TS/PMM (50:25:25) with 40% coke had greatest cover, biomass, and density and the best plant health. Plant growth was inhibited in treatments with DT (100%) and coke (100%) due to high concentrations of hydrocarbons, undesirable exchangeable ions, and salinity that restricted soil water retention (gravimetric water content, hydraulic conductivity) relative to treatments with PMM. Agrostis scabra Willd. and Festuca saximontana. showed poor growth or did not survive on DT and DT/TS with coke. Elymus trachycaulus (Link) Gould ex Shinners performed better in all DT mixes and performed the best in DT/TS/PMM with 40% coke. Results from this study indicate that mixing with PMM could improve the reclamation potential of DT and coke.

Phosphogypsum capping depth affects revegetation and hydrology in Western Canada.

Phosphogypsum (PG), a byproduct of phosphate fertilizer manufacturing, is commonly stacked and capped with soil at decommissioning. Shallow (0, 8, 15, and 30 cm) and thick (46 and 91 cm) sandy loam caps on a PG stack near Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta, Canada, were studied in relation to vegetation establishment and hydrologic properties. Plant response was evaluated over two growing seasons for redtop ( L.), slender wheatgrass ( (Link) Malte ex H.F. Lewis), tufted hairgrass ( (L.) P. Beauv.), and sheep fescue ( L.) and for a mix of these grasses with alsike clover ( L.). Water content below the soil-PG interface was monitored with time-domain reflectometry probes, and leachate water quantity and quality at a depth of 30 cm was measured using lysimeters. Vegetation responded positively to all cap depths relative to bare PG, with few significant differences among cap depths. Slender wheatgrass performed best, and tufted hairgrass performed poorly. Soil caps <1 m required by regulation were sufficient for early revegetation. Soil water fluctuated more in shallow than in thick caps, and water content was generally between field capacity and wilting point regardless of cap depth. Water quality was not affected by cap depths ≤30 cm. Leachate volumes at 30 cm from distinct rainfall events were independent of precipitation amount and cap depth. The study period had lower precipitation than normal, yet soil caps were hospitable for plant growth in the first 2 yr of establishment.

Assessment of a reclamation cover system for phosphogypsum stacks in Central Alberta, Canada.

Phosphogypsum (PG), a byproduct of the phosphate fertilizer industry, was produced and stockpiled at the Agrium Fort Saskatchewan facility from 1965 to 1991. Upon decommissioning, the outer slopes of the PG stacks were reclaimed by applying 15 cm of topsoil and planting a non-native seed mix. Physical, chemical, and hydrologic evaluations of the cover system confirmed that plants were successfully growing in various soil capping depths and were often rooting more than 200 mm into the PG. Percolation past the substrate into PG during a typical storm event was low (< 10 mm), and runoff from the stacks was negligible. Runoff quality met most guidelines, but some parameters, including fluoride, were up to 18 times higher than provincial or federal guidelines for soil and water quality. However, the cover system, when applied appropriately, does meet basic reclamation objectives. The exceedances are found in areas where the cover system has been compromised by erosion or mixing or in areas where the cover system has not been fully applied, such as roads or the inner basin. In areas where the cover system has been applied successfully, basic reclamation requirements are met.