Radiation plus local hyperthermia versus radiation plus the combination of local and whole-body hyperthermia in canine sarcomas.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of increasing intratumoral temperatures by the combination of local hyperthermia (LH) and whole body hyperthermia (WBH) on the radiation response of canine sarcomas. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Dogs with spontaneous soft tissue sarcomas and no evidence of metastasis were randomized to be treated with radiation combined with either LH alone or LH + WBH. Dogs were accessioned for treatment at two institutions. The radiation dose was 56.25 Gy, given in 25 2.25 Gy daily fractions. Two hyperthermia treatments were given; one during the first and one during the last week of treatment. Dogs were evaluated after treatment for local recurrence, metastasis, and complications. RESULTS: Sixty-four dogs were treated between 1989 and 1993. The use of LH+WBH resulted in statistically significant increases in the low and middle regions of the temperature distributions. The largest increase was in the low temperatures with median CEM 43 T90 values of 4 vs. 49 min for LH vs. LH + WBH, respectively (p<0.001). There was no difference in duration of local tumor control between hyperthermia groups (p = 0.59). The time to metastasis was shorter for dogs receiving LH + WBH (p = 0.02); the hazard ratio for metastatic disease for dogs in the LH + WBH group was 2.4 (95% confidence interval, 1.2-5.4) with respect to dogs in the LH group. Complications were greater in larger tumors and in tumors treated with LH + WBH, CONCLUSION: The combination of LH + WBH with radiation therapy, as described herein, was not associated with an increase in local tumor control in comparison to use of LH with radiation therapy. The combination of LH + WBH also appeared to alter the biology of the metastatic process and was associated with more complications than LH. We identified no rationale for further study of LH + WBH in combination with radiation for treatment of solid tumors.

Hyperthermia treatment planning and temperature distribution reconstruction: a case study.

While a great deal of effort has been applied toward solving the technical problems associated with modelling clinical hyperthermia treatments, much of that effort has focused on only estimating the power deposition. Little effort has been applied toward using the modelled power depositions (either electromagnetic (EM) or ultrasonic) as inputs to estimate the hyperthermia induced three-dimensional temperature distributions. This paper presents a case report of a patient treated with hyperthermia at the Duke University Medical Center where numerical modelling of the EM power deposition was used to prospectively plan the treatment. Additionally, the modelled power was used as input to retrospectively reconstruct the transient three-dimensional temperature distribution. The modelled power deposition indicated the existence of an undesirable region of high power in the normal tissue. Based upon this result, amplitudes and phases for driving the hyperthermia applicator were determined that eliminated the region of high power and subsequent measurements confirmed this. The steady-state and transient three-dimensional temperature distributions were reconstructed for four out of the seven treatments. The reconstructed steady-state temperatures agreed with the measured temperatures; root-mean-square error ranged from 0.45 to 1.21 degrees C. The transient three-dimensional tumour temperature was estimated assuming that the perfusion was constant throughout the treatment. Using the computed three-dimensional transient temperature distribution, the hyperthermia thermal dose was computed. The equivalent minutes at 43 degrees C achieved by 50% (T50Eq43) of the tumour volume was computed from the measured data and the three-dimensional reconstructed distribution yielding T50Eq43 = 40.6 and 19.8 min respectively.

Eugene Robertson Special Lecture. Hyperthermia from the clinic to the laboratory: a hypothesis.

Recently reported thermal isoeffective dose-response relationships in human tumours confirm the existence of an effect of hyperthermia in combination with radiotherapy. The prognostically important thermal doses are based upon the lowest temperatures achieved within tumours, and these thermal doses are well below those used in most laboratory studies that have provided the rational for hyperthermia treatment. Direct thermal cytotoxicity and thermal radiosensitization are insignificant at these low thermal doses. Other explanations for the mechanism of hyperthermia effect appear warranted. We hypothesize that hyperthermia at low thermal doses causes reoxygenation and hence direct radiosensitization in vivo.

Clinical outcome after neoadjuvant thermoradiotherapy in high grade soft tissue sarcomas.

In the treatment of soft tissue sarcomas, hyperthermia has been demonstrated to enhance tumor necrosis from radiation therapy. The current study reports the clinical course of patients treated with this neoadjuvant therapy regimen. Forty-four patients with deep, undisturbed, nonmetastatic, high grade soft tissue sarcomas completed a neoadjuvant treatment protocol with combined hyperthermia and radiation therapy followed by wide surgical resection. Negative surgical margins were obtained in 40 patients. There was one local recurrence, thus yielding a local control rate of 97.5%. All other failures were either through regional lymphatic spread or pulmonary metastasis. As a group, the patients at 36 months had a 72% overall and a 58% disease-free survival. The most common pathologic diagnosis was malignant fibrous histiocytoma (MFH), which demonstrated a 36-month survival of 52% vs. 82% for others (P = 0.02). Tumor size was not prognostically significant for disease free or overall survival (P = 0.13). Those patients with surgical margins < 1 cm had a significantly lower disease-free survival and overall survival in a multivariate analysis (P = 0.02 and P = 0.006, respectively). Overall survival did not correlate with either the number of hyperthermia treatments received or the amount of tumor necrosis. Although this neoadjuvant protocol results in excellent local control rates, overall survival rates are comparable to adjuvant therapy employing radiation alone.

Therapy monitoring in human and canine soft tissue sarcomas using magnetic resonance imaging and spectroscopy.

PURPOSE: The goals of this study were to determine whether magnetic resonance parameters (a) can identify early during therapy those patients most likely to respond to hyperthermia and radiotherapy, (b) can provide prior to or early during therapy information about the temperature distributions which can be obtained in patients receiving hyperthermia, and (c) can provide an understanding of the effects of hyperthermia on tumor metabolic status. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Twenty-one human patients and 10 canine patients with soft tissue sarcomas treated with preoperative hyperthermia and radiation had a series of magnetic resonance imaging and phosphorous spectroscopy studies done. To address the goals for both the human and canine populations, changes in mean T2 relaxation times, pH, and various phosphometabolite ratios from the pretreatment (Study 1) to the post first hyperthermia study (Study 2) were correlated with treatment outcome; pretreatment magnetic resonance parameters and changes in magnetic resonance parameters (Study 2-Study 1) were compared with various cumulative thermal descriptors; and thermal descriptors of the first hyperthermia were compared with changes in magnetic resonance phosphometabolite ratios. RESULTS: A decrease in adenosine triphosphate/phosphomonoester from study 1 to study 2 is associated with a greater chance of > or = 95% necrosis in surgical resected tumors from human patients, but no significant relationships were observed between changes in tumor pH or phosphometabolite ratios and time to local failure in dogs. Pretreatment magnetic resonance parameters correlated with various thermal dose descriptors in canines but not in humans. Change in adenosine triphosphate/inorganic phosphate and phosphomonoester signal to noise ratio correlated with cumulative thermal descriptors in dogs and humans, respectively. In dogs only, increases in thermal dose resulted in decreases in high energy phosphometabolites. CONCLUSION: Changes in magnetic resonance parameters early during therapy may be predictive of treatment outcome. Pretreatment and changes in magnetic resonance parameters appear to predict how well a tumor will be heated during hyperthermia. Magnetic resonance spectroscopy also appears to be a useful tool to study the effects of various thermal doses on tumor metabolic status.

Intraperitoneal cisplatin and regional hyperthermia for ovarian carcinoma.

PURPOSE: To review the theoretical basis and results of a Phase I study of concurrent intraperitoneal cisplatin and hyperthermia in the treatment of ovarian carcinoma. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Previously treated patients with epithelial ovarian carcinoma received intraperitoneal instillation of cisplatin and 60 minutes of regional hyperthermia, with a goal temperature of 41.5 degrees C. Cisplatin dose started at 20 mg/m2 with escalation to the maximally tolerated dose. Six such cycles given every 3 weeks were planned. Pharmacokinetic studies with and without hyperthermia were performed. RESULTS: Fifteen patients receiving 17 courses of treatment were evaluable. The maximally tolerated dose of cisplatin was between 80 and 120 mg/m2. The dose limiting toxicity was nephrotoxicity in all but one course. The median intraperitoneal temperature was 40.7 degrees C; the majority of treatments in which the goal temperature was not reached had power limited by patient discomfort. No major toxicities attributable to hyperthermia were noted. Pharmacokinetic studies noted no significant differences between treatments with vs. without hyperthermia, with intraperitoneal to plasma area under the curve ratios being 30-35. Ten patients had a decline in their CA-125 count during treatment, although in only two patients did this response persist beyond their course of treatment. CONCLUSION: Intraperitoneal cisplatin and regional hyperthermia can be performed with reasonable toxicity. The maximally tolerated dose of 80-120 mg/m2 in pretreated patients (which is similar to those reported with cisplatin alone) and median intraperitoneal temperatures of 40.7 degrees C, however, are felt to be too low to be efficacious in a significant percentage of women with bulky recurrent disease. Further study using intravenous thiosulfate and controlled analgesia is being performed.

Manipulation of intra- and extracellular pH in spontaneous canine tumours by use of hyperglycaemia.

We evaluated the use of hyperglycaemia to reduce tumour pH in dog with spontaneous tumours. Dogs were randomized to two groups: control and glucose. Intravenous administration of 20% glucose was used to induce and maintain hyperglycaemia. Extra- and intracellular tumour pH were measured using interstitial pH microelectrodes and 31P-MRS, respectively. During the administration of glucose, the mean (+/- SEM) blood glucose concentration was 419.8 (+/- 32.8) and 121.1 (+/- 8.0) mg/dl for the glucose and control groups, respectively. The mean extracellular tumour pH before and following 90 min of hyperglycaemia was 7.15 (+/- 0.08) and 7.15 (+/- 0.09). During consecutive measurements, intracellular tumour pH did not change significantly for the control group or the group subjected to hyperglycaemic manipulation. In contradistinction to previous rodent studies, our results demonstrate that hyperglycaemia alone is not sufficient to manipulate either intra- (pHi) or extracellular (pHe) hydrogen ion concentration in spontaneous canine soft tissue tumours.

Cumulative minutes with T90 greater than Tempindex is predictive of response of superficial malignancies to hyperthermia and radiation.

PURPOSE: To better define thermal parameters related to tumor response in superficial malignancies treated with combined hyperthermia and radiation therapy. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Patients were randomized to receive one or two hyperthermia treatments per week with hyperthermia given during each week of irradiation. Hyperthermia was given for 60 min with treatments begun within 1 hr following irradiation. Power was increased to patient tolerance or normal tissue temperature of 43.0 degrees C. Irradiation was generally given 5 times per week with doses prescribed to normal tissue tolerance (generally 24-70 Gy at 1.8-2.5 Gy per fraction). Multipoint thermometry was used with temperatures obtained every 5 min. RESULTS: One hundred eleven individual treatment fields containing 1 or more tumor nodules were completely evaluable. The complete and overall response rates were 46% and 80%, respectively. Forty-one percent of all treatment fields (51% of responding lesions) remained controlled at 2 years. Multivariate analysis revealed that the cumulative minutes that the temperature achieved by 90% of the measured tumor sites (T90) was > or = 40.0 degrees C, tumor histology, tumor volume, and radiation dose were significantly associated with complete tumor response. The complete response rate was not significantly affected by the number of hyperthermia treatments given per week. The incidence of clinically significant complications was low. CONCLUSIONS: These results support the usefulness of the cumulative minute system in describing time-temperature relationships. The significance of thermal variables with regard to tumor response strongly supports the contention that hyperthermia can be a useful adjunct to irradiation for the local control of cancer.

Sensitivity of hyperthermia trial outcomes to temperature and time: implications for thermal goals of treatment.

PURPOSE: In previous work we have found that the cumulative minutes of treatment for which 90% of measured intratumoral temperatures (T90) exceeded 39.5 degrees C was highly associated with complete response of superficial tumors. Similarly, the cumulative time for which 50% of intratumoral temperatures (T50) exceeded 41.5 degrees C was highly associated with the presence of > 80% necrosis in soft tissue sarcomas resected after radiotherapy and hyperthermia. In the present work we have calculated the time for isoeffective treatments with T90 = 43 degrees C and T50 = 43 degrees C, respectively, using published thermal isoeffective dose formulae. The purpose of these calculations was to determine the sensitivity of treatment outcome to variations in thermal isoeffective dose. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The basis for the calculations were the thermal parameters and treatment outcomes in three patient populations: 44 patients with moderate or high grade soft tissue sarcoma treated preoperatively with hyperthermia and radiation; 105 patients with superficial tumors treated with hyperthermia and radiation, and 59 patients with deep tumors treated with hyperthermia and radiation. RESULTS: The thermal dose values calculated are strongly associated with outcome in multivariate logistic regression analysis. Simple dose-response equations result from the analysis, and we use these equations to assess the sensitivity of outcome upon variations in thermal dose. This information, in turn, allows us to estimate the number of patients required in Phase II and III trials of hyperthermia and radiation therapy. CONCLUSIONS: For regimens of 5 to 10 hyperthermia treatments, improvements in median T90 (superficial tumors) and T50 (deep tumors) parameters by 1.2-1.5 degrees C could result in response rates high enough (compared to radiotherapy alone) to justify Phase III trials. A similar improvement in response rates would require an increase in overall duration of treatment by a factor of 3 to 5. This would be difficult to achieve while also avoiding thermal tolerance induction. Achieving these temperature goals may be possible with improvements in hyperthermia technology. Alternatively, there may be ways to increase the sensitivity of cells to temperatures that can be achieved currently, such as pH reduction or chemosensitization.

Use of nitroprusside to increase tissue temperature during local hyperthermia in normal and tumor-bearing dogs.

The present study investigates the effects of nitroprusside, a potent vasodilating agent, on tissue temperature during local hyperthermia in five normal and five tumor-bearing dogs. Caudal thigh muscles were heated in normal dogs and muscle temperatures were recorded during hyperthermia. Tumor-bearing dogs received two hyperthermia treatments during a course of radiation therapy. Temperatures were recorded in tumor and surrounding normal tissues. Mean arterial pressure was decreased by approximately 40-45% during nitroprusside infusion and was associated with a compensatory increase in heart rate and increases in tissue temperature. In normal dogs, muscle temperatures increased an average of 1.7 degrees C with nitroprusside administration. When nitroprusside was administered at the beginning of local hyperthermia to induce step-down heating, approximately 48% of the measured positions in caudal thigh muscle achieved a temperature greater than or equal to 43 degrees C, sufficient to induce step-down heating, during the hyperthermia episode. In tumor-bearing dogs, there was a significant increase in tumor and normal tissue temperatures during nitroprusside administration. Estimated T90 and T50 descriptors increased by 0.9 degrees C and 1.6 degrees C, respectively, for tumor tissue and by 0.4 degrees C and 1.2 degrees C, respectively, for normal tissue. Despite the increase in normal tissue temperatures no toxicity was observed in these dogs. Nitroprusside may be a useful agent for manipulation of tumor temperatures during the entire hyperthermia treatment or for a short time period at the initiation of treatment to induce step-down heating.

Serious toxicity associated with annular microwave array induction of whole-body hyperthermia in normal dogs.

Using a regional annular microwave array it was possible to produce a systemic temperature of 42 degrees C in approximately 80 min with applied net power levels of approximately 150 W. Resulting temperature distributions were non-uniform. Sites within the array were above systemic temperature during heating but approximated systemic temperature during the plateau phase. Sites outside of the array were lower than systemic temperature during heating and plateau phases. Dogs allowed to recover from the procedure experienced severe toxicity consisting of lumbar muscle haemorrhage, pain and swelling, and pelvic limb paralysis. Histologically, there was severe myopathy and haemorrhage and oedema in neural tissue in the caudal lumbar spine. Acute necrosis of lymphoid tissue was observed in all dogs. Temperatures in muscle reached 43-46 degrees C and were higher than at other measured sites. Spinal canal temperatures were essentially equal to rectal temperature, approximating 42-43 degrees C during heating and plateau phases. These data suggest regionally induced whole-body hyperthermia may result in: (1) power deposition non-uniformity leading to muscle and spinal canal temperatures which exceed systemic temperature and which are sufficient to cause serious toxicity; (2) systemic temperature non-uniformity which is undesirable for systemic thermochemotherapy; and (3) possible immunological dysfunction associated with lymphoid necrosis. Extreme caution must be exercised in administering energy to localized regions of human patients with the intent of elevating systemic temperature.

Phase I/II study of external radio frequency phased array hyperthermia and external beam radiotherapy in the treatment of prostate cancer: technique and results of intraprostatic temperature measurements.

As part of an ongoing Phase I/II study at Duke University Medical Center investigating the toxicity and efficacy of external beam radiotherapy plus hyperthermia for deep-seated, locally advanced or recurrent solid tumors, 12 patients with prostate malignancies (adenocarcinoma--11, leiomyosarcoma--1) were treated with radiotherapy plus hyperthermia. Hyperthermia was given after radiotherapy using a Radio Frequency Phase/Amplitude Control Sigma 60 annular phased array device. All patients had simultaneous temperature measurements made in the rectal lumen and within the prostate during at least one hyperthermia session. Intraprostate thermometers were placed via a unique method described herein using both computerized tomography scan and a rigid sigmoidoscope for guidance. We were able to achieve the desired tumor temperature of > or = 42.5 degrees C in only 1/28 (3.5%) of hyperthermia treatments. Subjective symptoms of pain and/or pressure limited power deposition in 79% of hyperthermia treatments. Higher temperatures were achieved in the distal rectum than in the prostate in all treatments, although the differences were not statistically significant. This temperature differential could not be compensated by using phase and amplitude steering. Rectal temperatures adjacent to the prostate were predictive of prostate temperatures. We conclude that using this regional heating technique we were unable to demonstrate an ability to get an advantageous temperature differential between the prostate and normal tissue. This technique is not useful as an adjuvant to radiation therapy for prostate cancer. The usefulness of other regional heating techniques and devices should be explored.

Heating patterns generated by phase modulation of a hexagonal array of interstitial antennas.

In this paper, we investigate an array of six interstitial microwave antennas used for hyperthermia cancer treatment. The purpose is to generate both uniform and controlled nonuniform heating patterns in biological tissue by phase modulating the signals applied to each antenna. The array consists of six antennas positioned on the corners of a hexagon. The distance between two diagonal antennas is 4 cm. The distributions of absorbed power per unit mass within the array are computed, and then converted into temperature distributions through a thermal conduction simulation. The SAR and temperature patterns are presented in both the lateral plane (perpendicular to the antennas) and the axial plane (parallel with the antennas). By proper phase modulation of microwave signals applied to each antenna, a uniform heating pattern can be produced within the entire array volume. Also, a peripheral heating pattern may be generated around the array; again, by using the proper phase modulation. The modulation schemes for generating both types of heating patterns are discussed.

Clinical experience with a multi-element ultrasonic hyperthermia system: analysis of treatment temperatures.

A summary of tumour temperature data obtained from 31 patients who underwent 147 hyperthermia treatments with the Sonotherm 1000 ultrasonic system is presented. The treatment goal was to achieve a minimum of 42.0 degrees C in tumour for 60 min duration with normal tissues remaining below 43.0 degrees C. In 83% of treatments at least one measured tumour temperature reached or exceeded 42.0 degrees C at some time during the treatment. Nineteen per cent of these treatments had a time- and spatial-averaged temperature (measured in tumour) greater than or equal to 42.0 degrees C. A variety of anatomical sites were treated and these were grouped into four categories: groin/trunk, axilla, breast/chest wall and head/neck. Measured temperatures in tumours located in the groin and trunk sites were significantly higher (22% greater than or equal to 42 degrees C) than other locations. The head and neck treatment temperatures were significantly lower (8% of measured points greater than or equal to 42 degrees C.

Effects of hyperthermia and irradiation on the growth of mouse melanoma tumors following immunotherapy.

Recent investigations suggest that adjuvant hyperthermia enhances the response of human malignant melanoma to ionizing radiation. A study was undertaken to explore the effect of radiation and hyperthermia on the responsiveness of melanoma following active immunization with lethally irradiated B16 melanoma cells in C57 BL 6 mice. Two groups of mice were treated: group 1 received immunotherapy on days 2-5 following tumor inoculation, and group 2 received immunotherapy on days 15-18 following tumor inoculation. The mice in each group were subsequently randomized into one of three subgroups: 1) no further treatment; 2) radiation therapy alone (6 Gy in a single fraction); 3) radiation therapy and regional hyperthermia (43 degrees C x 1 hour). Tumor sizes were measured regularly, and between day 52 and 63 the animals were sacrificed and the lungs sectioned for counting of metastatic tumors. Results from this study show that the immunomodulated B16 murine melanoma is responsive to radiation therapy alone and that this responsiveness is enhanced by the addition of adjuvant regional hyperthermia. There did not appear to be any significant effect of radiation therapy or radiation therapy plus hyperthermia on the development of lung metastases in this tumor model system.

Soft-tissue sarcomas: MR imaging and MR spectroscopy for prognosis and therapy monitoring. Work in progress.

The authors studied the usefulness of hydrogen-1 T2 measurements and phosphorus-31 magnetic resonance (MR) spectroscopy as indicators of prognosis and monitors of response to therapy in a group of patients with soft-tissue sarcomas. All eight patients were treated with combined local hyperthermia and fractionated radiation therapy, followed by surgical resection of the tumor. Each patient underwent T2 measurements and five patients underwent MR spectroscopy (phase encoded in one dimension) before treatment, after the first hyperthermia treatment, at the end of the therapy course, and just before surgery. Catheter thermometry was performed at each hyperthermia treatment. The T2 and MR spectroscopic variables were compared with thermometric data and the histologic findings from the complete surgical specimen. Changes in T2 correlated with histologic grade of tumor and thermometric data. The pretherapy tumor pH correlated positively, and changes during therapy in pH, ratio of phosphocreatine to inorganic phosphate (Pi), ratio of nucleoside triphosphate to Pi, and the phosphomonoester signal-to-noise ratio correlated negatively, with the percentage of tumor necrosis on the surgical specimen. These preliminary data suggest MR imaging and MR spectroscopy may be useful in the evaluation of such patients before and during therapy.