Games as Tools to Address Conservation Conflicts.

Conservation conflicts represent complex multilayered problems that are challenging to study. We explore the utility of theoretical, experimental, and constructivist approaches to games to help to understand and manage these challenges. We show how these approaches can help to develop theory, understand patterns in conflict, and highlight potentially effective management solutions. The choice of approach should be guided by the research question and by whether the focus is on testing hypotheses, predicting behaviour, or engaging stakeholders. Games provide an exciting opportunity to help to unravel the complexity in conflicts, while researchers need an awareness of the limitations and ethical constraints involved. Given the opportunities, this field will benefit from greater investment and development.

Translational pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic modeling of QTc effects in dog and human.

INTRODUCTION: Preclinical assessment of the heart rate corrected QT interval (QTc) is an important component of the cardiovascular safety evaluation in drug discovery. Here we aimed to quantify the translational relationship between QTc prolongation and shortening in the conscious telemetered dog and humans by a retrospective pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic (PKPD) analysis. METHODS: QTc effects of 2 proprietary compounds and 2 reference drugs (moxifloxacin and dofetilide) were quantified in conscious dogs and healthy volunteers via a linear and Emax pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic models. The translational relationship was quantified by correlating the QTc response from dog and human at matching free drug concentrations. RESULTS: A consistent translational relationship was found at low delta-QTc intervals indicating that a QTc change of 2.5-8 ms in dog would correspond to a 10 ms change in human. DISCUSSION: The translational relationship developed here can be used to predict the QTc liability in human using preclinical dog data. It could therefore help protect the health of human volunteers, for example by appropriate clinical study design and dose selection, as well as improve future decision-making and help reduce compound attrition due to changes in QT interval.

Value of non-clinical cardiac repolarization assays in supporting the discovery and development of safer medicines.

Non-clinical QT-related assays aligned to the pharmaceutical drug discovery and development phases are used in several ways. During the early discovery phases, assays are used for hazard identification and wherever possible for hazard elimination. The data generated enable us to: (i) establish structure-activity relationships and thereby; (ii) influence the medicinal chemistry design and provide tools for effective decision making; and provide structure-activity data for in silico predictive databases; (iii) solve problems earlier; (iv) provide reassurance for compound or project to progress; and (v) refine strategies as scientific and technical knowledge grows. For compounds progressing into pre-clinical development, the 'core battery' QT-related data enable an integrated risk assessment to: (i) fulfil regulatory requirements; (ii) assess the safety and risk-benefit for compound progression to man; (iii) contribute to defining the starting dose during the phase I clinical trials; (iv) influence the design of the phase I clinical trials; (v) identify clinically relevant safety biomarkers; and (vi) contribute to the patient risk management plan. Once a compound progresses into clinical development, QT-related data can be applied in the context of risk management and risk mitigation. The data from 'follow-up' studies can be used to: (i) support regulatory approval; (ii) investigate discrepancies that may have emerged within and/or between non-clinical and clinical data; (iii) understand the mechanism of an undesirable pharmacodynamic effect; (iv) provide reassurance for progression into multiple dosing in humans and/or large-scale clinical trials; and (v) assess drug-drug interactions. Based on emerging data, the integrated risk assessment is then reviewed in this article, and the benefit-risk for compound progression was re-assessed. Project examples are provided to illustrate the impact of non-clinical data to support compound progression throughout the drug discovery and development phases, and regulatory approval.

Dog left ventricular midmyocardial myocytes for assessment of drug-induced delayed repolarization: short-term variability and proarrhythmic potential.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Evaluation of the potential for delayed ventricular repolarization and proarrhythmia by new drugs is essential. We investigated if dog left ventricular midmyocardial myocytes (LVMMs) that can be used as a preclinical model to assess drug effects on action potential duration (APD) and whether in these cells, short-term variability (STV) or triangulation could predict proarrhythmic potential. EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH: Beagle LVMMs and Purkinje fibres (PFs) were used to record APs. Effects of six reference drugs were assessed on APD at 50% (APD(50)) and 90% (APD(90)) of repolarization, STV(APD), triangulation (ratio APD(90)/APD(50)) and incidence of early afterdepolarizations (EADs) at 1 and 0.5 Hz. KEY RESULTS: LVMMs provided stable recordings of AP, which were not affected by four sequential additions of dimethyl sulphoxide. Effects of dofetilide, d-sotalol, cisapride, pinacidil and diltiazem, but not of terfenadine, on APD in LVMMs were found to be comparable with those recorded in PFs. LVMMs, but not PFs, exhibited a proarrhythmic response to I(Kr) blockers. Incidence of EADs was not related to differences in AP prolongation or triangulation, but corresponded to beat-to-beat variability of repolarization, here quantified as STV of APD. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: LVMMs provide a suitable preclinical model to assess the effects of new drugs on APD and also yield additional information about putative indicators of proarrhythmia that add value to an integrated QT/TdP risk assessment. Our findings support the concept that increased STV(APD) may predict drug-induced proarrhythmia.

A framework to assess the translation of safety pharmacology data to humans.

This article outlines a strategy for collecting accurate data for the determination of the sensitivity, specificity and predictive value of safety pharmacology models. This entails performing a retrospective analysis on commonly used safety pharmacology endpoints and an objective assessment of new non-clinical models. Such assessments require a systematic quantitative analysis of safety pharmacology parameters as well as clinical Phase I adverse events. Once the sensitivity, specificity and predictive capacity of models have been determined, they can be aligned within specific phases of the drug discovery and development pipeline for maximal impact, or removed from the screening cascade altogether. Furthermore, data will contribute to evidence-based decision-making based on the knowledge of the model sensitivity and specificity. This strategy should therefore contribute to the reduction of candidate drug attrition and a more appropriate use of animals. More data are needed to increase the power of analysis and enable more accurate comparisons of models e.g. pharmacokinetic/phamacodynamic (PK/PD) relationships as well as non-clinical and clinical outcomes for determining concordance. This task requires the collaboration and agreement of pharmaceutical companies to share data anonymously on proprietary and candidate drugs.

Early clinical development: evaluation of drug-induced torsades de pointes risk.

Drug-induced arrhythmias or QT interval prolongation is one of the two most common reasons for drugs to be denied regulatory approval or to have warnings imposed on their clinical labelling. The assessment of torsades de pointes (TdP) risk during clinical development of a new pharmaceutical compound has been an issue of debate since the original description of drug-induced proarrhythmia. TdP risk assessment is complicated by the very low incidence (e.g., <1/100,000 patient years of exposure) of clinical events for non-antiarrhythmic agents and thus the improbable likelihood of observing even one event during clinical development. Thus surrogate methods of determining risk are necessary. A clinical approach to the issue of TdP risk assessment during drug development has been developed and implemented internationally. These efforts have markedly reduced the likelihood that drugs with unknown TdP risks will be commercialized, have resulted in fostering extensive productive pre-clinical and clinical research, and subsequent improved understanding of drug-induced proarrhythmia. Current research efforts are directed to increasing the efficiency of clinical QT assessment and the impact of pre-clinical assessment on clinical development. This article describes the clinical evaluation of TdP risk during drug development and how pre-clinical assessment can impact the early clinical development TdP risk assessment.

Nonclinical proarrhythmia models: predicting Torsades de Pointes.

Prolongation of the QT interval and the cardiac action potential have been linked to a potentially fatal but rare tachyarrhythmia known as Torsades de Pointes (TdP). Nonclinical assays, such as those investigating the effect on I(Kr) (the hERG channel current), prolongation of the action potential duration (APD) and the QT interval, in vivo, have been developed to predict the risk of QT interval prolongation and TdP in man. However, there seems to be a dissociation between the risk of QT interval prolongation and the torsadogenic risk. There is an increasing mass of evidence showing that an increase in the QT interval does not necessarily lead to TdP. Thus, it appears that while standard assays are very good, although perhaps not infallible, at predicting the risk of QT interval prolongation in man they do not predict the proarrhythmic risk. Recently there has been a plethora of publications suggesting that there are electrophysiological markers associated with drug-induced TdP other than hERG channel activity, APD and the QT interval, and these markers may be better predictors of TdP. In this review, three in vitro and, briefly, three in vivo models or methods are discussed. These proarrhythmia models use electrophysiological markers such as transmural dispersion of repolarization, action potential triangulation, instability, reverse use-dependence, and the incidence of early after-depolarizations to predict the risk of TdP. Most of the models presented have been published widely. The particular variable or set of variables used by each model to predict the torsadogenic propensity of a drug has been reported to correlate with clinical outcome. While each variable/model has been shown to discriminate between antiarrhythmic and nonarrhythmic drugs, these reports should be interpreted cautiously since none has been independently (externally) assessed. Each model is discussed along with its particular merits and shortcomings; none, as yet, having shown a predictive value that makes it clearly superior to the others. Proarrhythmia models, in particular in vitro models, challenge current perceptions of appropriate surrogates for TdP in man and question existing nonclinical strategies for assessing proarrhythmic risk. The rapid emergence of such models, compounded by the lack of a clear understanding of the key proarrhythmic mechanisms has resulted in a regulatory reluctance to embrace such models. The wider acceptance of proarrhythmia models is likely to occur when there is a clear understanding and agreement on the key proarrhythmia mechanisms. Regardless of regulatory acceptance, with further validation these models may still enhance pharmaceutical company decision-making to provide a rational basis for drug progression, particularly in areas of unmet medical need.

Comparative pharmacology of guinea pig cardiac myocyte and cloned hERG (I(Kr)) channel.

INTRODUCTION: This study used whole-cell, patch clamp techniques on isolated guinea pig ventricular myocytes and HEK293 cells expressing cloned human ether-a-go-go-related gene (hERG) to examine the action of drugs causing QT interval prolongation and torsades de pointes (TdP) in man. Similarities and important differences in drug actions on cardiac myocytes and cloned hERG I(Kr) channels were established. Qualitative actions of the drugs on cardiac myocytes corresponded with results obtained from Purkinje fibers and measurement of QT interval prolongation in animal and human telemetry studies. METHODS AND RESULTS: Adult guinea pig ventricular myocytes were isolated by enzymatic digestion. Cells were continuously perfused with Tyrode's solution at 33-35 degrees C. Recordings were made using the whole-cell, patch clamp technique. Action potentials (APs) were elicited under current clamp. Voltage clamp was used to study the effect of drugs on I(Kr) (rapidly activating delayed rectifier potassium current), I(Na) (sodium current), and I(Ca) (L-type calcium current). Dofetilide increased the myocyte action potential duration (APD) in a concentration-dependent manner, with a pIC50 of 7.3. Dofetilide 1 microM elicited early afterdepolarizations (EADs) but had little affect on I(Ca) or I(Na). E-4031 increased APD in a concentration-dependent manner, with a pIC50 of 7.2. In contrast, 10 microM loratadine, desloratadine, and cetirizine had little effect on APD or I(Kr). Interestingly, cisapride displayed a biphasic effect on myocyte APD and inhibited I(Ca) at 1 microM. Even at this high concentration, cisapride did not elicit EADs. A number of AstraZeneca compounds were tested on cardiac myocytes, revealing a mixture of drug actions that were not observed in hERG currents in HEK293 cells. One compound, particularly AR-C0X, was a potent blocker of myocyte AP (pIC50 of 8.4). AR-C0X also elicited EADs in cardiac myocytes. The potencies of the same set of drugs on the cloned hERG channel also were assessed. The pIC50 values for dofetilide, E-4031, terfenadine, loratadine, desloratadine, and cetirizine were 6.8, 7.1, 7.3, 5.1, 5.2, and <4, respectively. Elevation of temperature from 22 to 35 degrees C significantly enhanced the current kinetics and amplitudes of hERG currents and resulted in approximately fivefold increase in E-4031 potency. CONCLUSION: Our study demonstrates the advantages of cardiac myocytes over heterologously expressed hERG channels in predicting QT interval prolongation and TdP in man. The potencies of some drugs in cardiac myocytes were similar to hERG, but only myocytes were able to detect important changes in APD characteristics and display EADs predictive of arrhythmia development. We observed similar qualitative drug profiles in cardiac myocytes, dog Purkinje fibers, and animal and human telemetry studies. Therefore, isolated native cardiac myocytes are a better predictor of drug-induced QT prolongation and TdP than heterologously expressed hERG channels. Isolated cardiac myocytes, when used with high-throughput patch clamp instruments, may have an important role in screening potential cardiotoxic compounds in the early phase of drug discovery. This would significantly reduce the attrition rate of drugs entering preclinical and/or clinical development. The current kinetics and amplitudes of the cloned hERG channel were profoundly affected by temperature, significantly altering the potency of one drug (E-4031). This finding cautions against routine drug testing at room temperature compared to physiologic temperature when using the cloned hERG channel.

The application of in vitro methods to safety pharmacology.

The ICH S7A guideline defines safety pharmacology (SP) studies as those that investigate 'the potential undesirable pharmacodynamic effects of a substance on physiological functions in relation to exposure in the therapeutic range and above', and permits both in vivo and in vitro techniques, as appropriate. The implementation of these ICH guidelines by the pharmaceutical industry--whilst providing a welcome and long overdue clarity into the scientific rationale, timing and regulatory requirements for SP studies--has also generated new challenges, both logistical and scientific, which have a major impact on drug development. These factors have motivated us to consider the introduction of in vitro techniques at an early stage of SP evaluation. Amongst these factors are: the expanded range of study types and physiological parameters to be assessed, the increased 'front-loading' of SP at earlier stages of the drug discovery process; the greater number of new chemical entities (NCEs) to be tested, together with limited compound supply; the condensed time frames for drug development, the higher and quicker throughput of in vitro vs. in vivo tests; the increasing predictability of in vitro tests and application of the '3Rs' rule of animal welfare (reduction, replacement and refinement). Also, there is the failure of traditional in vivo safety evaluation to predict certain clinical side-effects. The use of molecular (e.g. fluorescence and cloned ion channel), cellular (e.g. patch clamp and isolated cardiac cells) and tissue-based (e.g. microelectrodes and Purkinje fibres) methods offers a wide portfolio of novel techniques for SP evaluation of NCEs at a pre-in vivo stage. Thus, innovative in vitro techniques will contribute significantly to the early SP evaluation of NCEs.