Developing and validating a multi-criteria decision analytic tool to assess the value of cancer clinical trials: evaluating cancer clinical trial value.

BACKGROUND: Demonstrating safety and efficacy of new medical treatments requires clinical trials but clinical trials are costly and may not provide value proportionate to their costs. As most health systems have limited resources, it is therefore important to identify the trials with the highest value. Tools exist to assess elements of a clinical trial such as statistical validity but are not wholistic in their valuation of a clinical trial. This study aims to develop a measure of clinical trials value and provide an online tool for clinical trial prioritisation. METHODS: A search of the academic and grey literature and stakeholder consultation was undertaken to identify a set of criteria to aid clinical trial valuation using multi-criteria decision analysis. Swing weighting and ranking exercises were used to calculate appropriate weights of each of the included criteria and to estimate the partial-value function for each underlying metric. The set of criteria and their respective weights were applied to the results of six different clinical trials to calculate their value. RESULTS: Seven criteria were identified: 'unmet need', 'size of target population', 'eligible participants can access the trial', 'patient outcomes', 'total trial cost', 'academic impact' and 'use of trial results'. The survey had 80 complete sets of responses (51% response rate). A trial designed to address an 'Unmet Need' was most commonly ranked as the most important with a weight of 24.4%, followed by trials demonstrating improved 'Patient Outcomes' with a weight of 21.2%. The value calculated for each trial allowed for their clear delineation and thus a final value ranking for each of the six trials. CONCLUSION: We confirmed that the use of the decision tool for valuing clinical trials is feasible and that the results are face valid based on the evaluation of six trials. A proof-of-concept applying this tool to a larger set of trials with an external validation is currently underway.

[18F]-fluoroethyl-L-tyrosine (FET) in glioblastoma (FIG) TROG 18.06 study: protocol for a prospective, multicentre PET/CT trial.

INTRODUCTION: Glioblastoma is the most common aggressive primary central nervous system cancer in adults characterised by uniformly poor survival. Despite maximal safe resection and postoperative radiotherapy with concurrent and adjuvant temozolomide-based chemotherapy, tumours inevitably recur. Imaging with O-(2-[18F]-fluoroethyl)-L-tyrosine (FET) positron emission tomography (PET) has the potential to impact adjuvant radiotherapy (RT) planning, distinguish between treatment-induced pseudoprogression versus tumour progression as well as prognostication. METHODS AND ANALYSIS: The FET-PET in Glioblastoma (FIG) study is a prospective, multicentre, non-randomised, phase II study across 10 Australian sites and will enrol up to 210 adults aged ≥18 years with newly diagnosed glioblastoma. FET-PET will be performed at up to three time points: (1) following initial surgery and prior to commencement of chemoradiation (FET-PET1); (2) 4 weeks following concurrent chemoradiation (FET-PET2); and (3) within 14 days of suspected clinical and/or radiological progression on MRI (performed at the time of clinical suspicion of tumour recurrence) (FET-PET3). The co-primary outcomes are: (1) to investigate how FET-PET versus standard MRI impacts RT volume delineation and (2) to determine the accuracy and management impact of FET-PET in distinguishing pseudoprogression from true tumour progression. The secondary outcomes are: (1) to investigate the relationships between FET-PET parameters (including dynamic uptake, tumour to background ratio, metabolic tumour volume) and progression-free survival and overall survival; (2) to assess the change in blood and tissue biomarkers determined by serum assay when comparing FET-PET data acquired prior to chemoradiation with other prognostic markers, looking at the relationships of FET-PET versus MRI-determined site/s of progressive disease post chemotherapy treatment with MRI and FET-PET imaging; and (3) to estimate the health economic impact of incorporating FET-PET into glioblastoma management and in the assessment of post-treatment pseudoprogression or recurrence/true progression. Exploratory outcomes include the correlation of multimodal imaging, blood and tumour biomarker analyses with patterns of failure and survival. ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION: The study protocol V.2.0 dated 20 November 2020 has been approved by a lead Human Research Ethics Committee (Austin Health, Victoria). Other clinical sites will provide oversight through local governance processes, including obtaining informed consent from suitable participants. The study will be conducted in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki and Good Clinical Practice. Results of the FIG study (TROG 18.06) will be disseminated via relevant scientific and consumer forums and peer-reviewed publications. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: ANZCTR ACTRN12619001735145.

Palliative Care Clinical Trials: Building Capability and Capacity.

Clinical trials are a key component of expanding the evidence base in palliative care. A key strategic objective of the Victorian Comprehensive Cancer Centre (VCCC), a multisite cancer center alliance, was to increase palliative care clinical trial expertise. The palliative care services within the VCCC alliance presented substantial trial development opportunities with large number of patients and established relationships, but few trial-active centers. Objectives: To establish a multi-site "Building Capability in Palliative Care Clinical Trials" program as a service development, and to assess the strategies, activities, and the outcomes resulting from this program. Methods: A series of strategies and activities were developed linked to the key program objectives of increasing the number of clinical sites and skilled clinicians conducting clinical trials, increasing the number of trials available and patients participating, broadening research opportunities in palliative care, and establishing the program sustainability. Results: In the two years of implementation, the program resulted in the establishment and conduct of several Phase 4 postmarketing pharmacovigilance studies, nine Phase 2 and 3 trials across five palliative care services, and a Phase 1 clinical trial. During the program, 150 patients were recruited to clinical trials, and 258 prospective pharmacovigilance monitoring cases were recorded. Five investigator-initiated trials were developed by clinical trial fellows and achieved competitive (n = 3) or commercial (n = 2) funding. Clinicians reported that undertaking clinical trials had increased attention to the evidence base of care provision, and increased service research activity more broadly. Long-term sustainability remains a challenge, particularly in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Conclusions: Clinical trials in palliative care services are feasible, acceptable, and result in increased attention to the evidence base of care. The strategies detailing the framework, activities, and outcomes have been collated to facilitate implementation of clinical trials in other sites and with other trial-naive disciplinary groups.

Carboplatin dosing in the era of IDMS-creatinine; the Cockroft-Gault formula no longer provides a sufficiently accurate estimate of glomerular filtration rate for routine use in clinical care.

BACKGROUND: Glomerular filtration rate (GFR) measured by Chromium-51-EDTA excretion (51Cr-GFR) is considered the gold standard of renal function assessment, but serum creatinine in the Cockcroft-Gault (CG) formula is routinely used to estimate GFR for carboplatin dosing. Serum creatinine measured by isotope-dilution-mass-spectrometry (IDMS) can generate spuriously high GFR estimates when used in the CG formula. We hypothesized that GFR calculated using IDMS-creatinine in the CG formula (CG-GFR) exposes patients to inaccurate carboplatin dosing. METHODS: This is a multicenter retrospective study of patients who had a 51Cr-GFR assessment for malignant or non-malignant indications, with a matched CG-GFR. Carboplatin dose based on 51Cr-GFR at AUC5 was used as the reference. RESULTS: 550 patients were analyzed, median age 62 (19-90), 64% female. Indication for GFR evaluation: malignancy (85%), assessment for live kidney donation (12%), other (3%). Median ratio of CG-GFR: 51Cr-GFR 1.04 (0.43-3.38); <0.8 in 72 patients (13%), >1.2 in 180 patients (33%). Despite capping of CG-GFR at 125 mL/min, dosing according to AUC6 would have resulted in 18% of patients being underdosed and 23% overdosed by >100 mg compared to 51Cr-GFR. Subgroup analysis identified BMI (>35, MPE 39%), gender (female MPE 15%), GFR indication (malignancy MPE 11%) as risk factors for overestimate of CG-GFR, and BMI < 20 for underestimate (MPE -3.5%). CONCLUSIONS: The convention of considering AUC5 carboplatin based on 51Cr-GFR, and AUC6 carboplatin based on CG-GFR as equivalent is invalid and should be abandoned. When 51Cr-GFR is unavailable, capping CG-GFR at 125 mL/min is recommended.

Glioblastoma multiforme in the very elderly.

Glioblastoma is the most malignant and most common primary brain tumour and is treated with resection followed by post-operative radiotherapy and chemotherapy. However, a significant amount of patients are older than 80 years, and such an approach may not be appropriate. Data on patients aged 80 or older with glioblastoma from two hospitals was collected using the CNS Tumour Database on the Australian Comprehensive Cancer Outcomes and Research Database (ACCORD) system operated by BioGrid. Between 2008 and July 2011, 40 patients aged 80 years or older were diagnosed with glioblastoma. The median ECOG PS was 2 and the ASA score was 3. All 40 patients underwent surgery and 33% had a gross total resection. Only six patients (15%) had either post-operative radiotherapy or chemotherapy. The overall median survival was 4 months (range 0-18 months) and 28% of patients lived between 6 and 24 months. This is the largest reported cohort of very elderly patients with glioblastoma. Patients tolerated surgery but few went on to receive post-operative radiotherapy or chemotherapy. This patient population requires special attention and in particular would benefit from participation in suitable clinical trials to determine the best care regime.

Ependymoma in adults: Local experience with an uncommon tumour.

This study reviews our tertiary hospital experience in an adult population of ependymoma patients. Ependymomas are uncommon tumours of the central nervous system (CNS) and the literature provides little information to guide management and predict prognosis. The prospectively maintained Australian Comprehensive Cancer Outcomes and Research Database of CNS tumours was searched for patients diagnosed with ependymomas at the Royal Melbourne Hospital between January 2008 and December 2013. A total of 39 adult patients with ependymoma were identified, including 13 with spinal myxopapillary ependymoma. The mean age at diagnosis was 44 years. All patients underwent surgical resection, 67% of whom had a gross macroscopic resection. Postoperative adjuvant radiotherapy was administered to 11 patients (30%), two (5%) died from progressive disease and seven (18%) developed recurrent disease. Our findings are consistent with the existing literature for patient demographics and the approach to treatment, whilst our clinical outcomes appear more favourable. This study provides the basis for further and necessary research, including determination of the molecular characterisation of these tumours and the identification of prognostic and predictive biomarkers and treatment targets.

MGAT3 mRNA: a biomarker for prognosis and therapy of Alzheimer's disease by vitamin D and curcuminoids.

Practical biomarkers of Alzheimer's disease (AD) prognosis are lacking. Correspondingly, no drugs are known to decrease disease progression, although vitamin D3 has positive effects on cognition in vivo and 1α, 25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 (1,25 D3) on amyloid-ß 1-42 (Aß) phagocytosis in vitro. We have examined in a pilot study a new biomarker in peripheral blood mononuclear cells, the transcription of mRNA of ß-1,4-mannosyl-glycoprotein 4-ß-N-acetylglucosaminyltransferase (MGAT3), the essential gene for Aß phagocytosis. The transcription of MGAT3 stimulated by Aß distinguishes macrophages into Type 0 (very low MGAT3 transcription), Type I (low MGAT3 transcription up regulated by bisdemethoxycurcumin), and Type II (high MGAT3 transcription down regulated by bisdemethoxycurcumin). In this pilot study of 20 AD patients and 20 control subjects, 45% patients, but only 10% control subjects, were Type 0 (p-value = 0.009). Type 0 AD patients had worse 2-year prognosis regarding loss of independence than Type I and Type II patients (p-value = 0.013). Phagocytosis of Aß in Type I and II patients was shown to be dependent on 1,25 D3 using a specific inhibitor of the 1,25 D3-VDR activated nuclear receptor transcription factor. In a Type II patient, recovery from cognitive dysfunction related to surgical anesthesia was preceded by an improvement in phagocytosis of Aß. The results of this pilot study suggest that the MGAT3 Type biomarker may characterize subgroups of AD patients with different disease progression. In vitro results suggest that vitamin D3 supplementation might be beneficial in both Type I and II patients, whereas curcuminoids only in Type I. These results must be investigated in a large prospective study.

An exploration of patients' memories and experiences of hyperbaric oxygen therapy in a multiplace chamber.

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES: To examine patients' memories and experiences of hyperbaric oxygen therapy in a multiplace chamber of a hyperbaric medicine unit in Australia. BACKGROUND: There is minimal literature available documenting patients' feelings and memories of hyperbaric oxygen therapy, particularly in a multiplace chamber. DESIGN: Exploratory. METHODS: A convenience sample of seven non-emergency patients was interviewed separately at the conclusion of their multi-session therapy. A semi-structured approach elicited in-depth information regarding their experiences and memories of the hyperbaric oxygen therapy. Interviews were 30-45 minutes long and audiotaped for transcription and analysis. Field notes were also used to note non-verbal cues and other observations not evident from the audio material. Data collection ceased when data saturation was evident from the interviews. Interview transcripts were examined using a content analysis approach, with textual coding and thematic development. RESULTS: Issues derived from the data included: the uncertainty of the treatment; the noise and cold of the chamber; the discomfort of the mask or hood; and the boredom. Participant responses to the therapy related to previous noxious experiences and the individual's personality. CONCLUSIONS: This information was used to examine ways of reducing any negative feelings and experiences associated with hyperbaric oxygen therapy, thus improving the service provided to patients. RELEVANCE TO CLINICAL PRACTICE: Identification of these stressors and related issues may also enable subsequent development of a risk-stratification instrument to predict patients who do not complete treatment.

Phase I and pharmacokinetic evaluation of intravenous hyaluronic acid in combination with doxorubicin or 5-fluorouracil.

BACKGROUND: Pre-clinically, hyaluronan (HA) has been demonstrated to systemically target chemotherapeutic drugs to tumours while ameliorating treatment toxicities. This study is a preliminary clinical investigation to determine if HA could be safely used in combination with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) and doxorubicin (DOX). METHODS: Thirty patients with metastatic cancer were intravenously administered 500 mg/m2 HA in combination with escalating doses of DOX (30-60 mg/m2) or 5-FU (cumulative dose of 1,350-2,250 mg/m2 per cycle). The effect of pre-administration of 20 mg/m2 of folinic acid on HA/5-FU chemotherapy was also investigated. Patients were randomized to receive either HA/chemotherapy or chemotherapy alone in their first treatment cycle and vice versa for the second cycle. Patients received HA and chemotherapy in all subsequent cycles. RESULTS: Treatment was well tolerated, tumour responses were observed and the co-administration of HA did not alter the pharmacokinetics of clinically relevant doses of 5-FU or DOX. CONCLUSION: High doses of intravenous high-molecular-weight HA can be safely co-administered with clinical doses of chemotherapy without significantly altering the toxicity or pharmacokinetics of the drugs or HA.

Carcinoid associated encephalitis successfully treated with tryptophan.

This case report describes the rare phenomenon of encephalopathy associated with massive carcinoid tumor. Extensive investigation failed to reveal an obvious cause but a presumptive diagnosis of tryptophan deficiency was made and she was commenced on tryptophan dietary supplements. A rapid and complete response resulted. This case report discusses this unusual case and reviews the literature regarding carcinoid associated encephalopathy.

Antidiabetic actions of arachidonic acid and zinc in genetically diabetic Goto-Kakizaki rats.

In previous studies, we showed that feeding arachidonic acid (AA) supplemented with a fixed amount of zinc lowered blood glucose concentrations in the fed state and water intake in rats with streptozotocin-induced diabetes. The present study was designed to determine dose-dependent effects of AA supplemented with a fixed amount of zinc on fed blood glucose levels, water intake, and glucose tolerance in genetically type 2 diabetic Goto-Kakizaki (G-K) Wistar rats. In an acute study, 20 mg/kg AA plus 10 mg/kg zinc administered via gastric gavage significantly improved oral glucose tolerance in G-K rats when compared to rats given distilled water (DW) only. When rats were treated chronically (2 weeks) with increasing doses of AA in drinking water, fed blood glucose concentrations and water intake were maximally decreased with diets containing 20 or 30 mg/L AA plus 10 mg/L zinc. Three-hour average area-above-fasting glucose concentrations (TAFGC; index of oral glucose tolerance) in diabetic G-K rats treated with 10, 20, or 30 mg/L AA plus 10 mg/L zinc for 2 weeks were significantly decreased relative to DW-treated rats. The effect on TAFGC values was maintained for an additional 2 weeks after cessation of treatment. Plasma insulin levels significantly increased in rats treated with 20 mg/L AA only or 10 mg/L AA plus 10 mg/L zinc, but not in rats treated with 20 or 30 mg/L AA plus 10 mg/L zinc, which are the most effective doses for the improvement of clinical signs of diabetes in G-K rats. In in vitro assays, 0.2 mg/mL AA in the incubation media was optimal for glucose uptake in isolated soleus muscle slices. These results suggest that treatment of genetically diabetic G-K rats with AA plus zinc lowers blood glucose levels via improvement of insulin sensitivity.