Towards Coleoptera-specific high-throughput screening systems for compounds with ecdysone activity: development of EcR reporter assays using weevil (Anthonomus grandis)-derived cell lines and in silico analysis of ligand binding to A. grandis EcR ligand-binding pocket.

Molting in insects is regulated by ecdysteroids and juvenile hormones. Several synthetic non-steroidal ecdysone agonists are on the market as insecticides. These ecdysone agonists are dibenzoylhydrazine (DBH) analogue compounds that manifest their toxicity via interaction with the ecdysone receptor (EcR). Of the four commercial available ecdysone agonists, three (tebufenozide, methoxyfenozide and chromafenozide) are highly lepidopteran specific, one (halofenozide) is used to control coleopteran and lepidopteran insects in turf and ornamentals. However, compared to the very high binding affinity of these DBH analogues to lepidopteran EcRs, halofenozide has a low binding affinity for coleopteran EcRs. For the discovery of ecdysone agonists that target non-lepidopteran insect groups, efficient screening systems that are based on the activation of the EcR are needed. We report here the development and evaluation of two coleopteran-specific reporter-based screening systems to discover and evaluate ecdysone agonists. The screening systems are based on the cell lines BRL-AG-3A and BRL-AG-3C that are derived from the weevil Anthonomus grandis, which can be efficiently transduced with an EcR reporter cassette for evaluation of induction of reporter activity by ecdysone agonists. We also cloned the almost full length coding sequence of EcR expressed in the cell line BRL-AG-3C and used it to make an initial in silico 3D-model of its ligand-binding pocket docked with ponasterone A and tebufenozide.

High-throughput screening of ecdysone agonists using a reporter gene assay followed by 3-D QSAR analysis of the molting hormonal activity.

In this study, 172 diacylhydrazine analogs were examined for their ability to activate an ecdysone (molting hormone)-dependent reporter gene in a silkworm (Bombyx mori) cell-based high-throughput screening assay. The measured EC(50) values (concentration required to cause an effect in 50% of the cells) were used to construct a 3-D QSAR model that describes the ecdysone agonist activities of the diacylhydrazine analogs. Of these compounds, 14 exhibited no activity and were excluded from the 3-D QSAR analysis. The resulting equation described approximately 74% of the activity for 158 compounds. The final equation consisted of 42% electrostatic and 58% steric effects (r(2) = 0.74 and q(2) = 0.45). Comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) was used to visualize the steric and electrostatic potential fields that were favorable and unfavorable for biological activity. Of particular interest was the observation that the hydrophobic parameter (logP) was not necessary for describing the observed activities, although previous studies have cited the importance of hydrophobic parameters in both classical and 3-D QSAR analyses of these compounds. Modeling studies of the B. mori ecdysone receptor supported the observed physicochemical parameters required for activity reported by the CoMFA models. Comparison of the present analysis with those performed using other lepidopteran assay systems evidenced a high degree of correlation (r(2) = 0.81 for a Sf-9 cell-based assay and r(2) = 0.89 for a Chilo suppressalis integument-based assay), indicating that it is valid to compare the results generated with the B. mori cell-based system to those generated with previous lepidopteran assays. This novel assay system is amendable to a high-throughput screening format and should greatly increase our ability to discover novel agonists of molting hormone (ecdysone) activity.

A cell-based high-throughput screening system for detecting ecdysteroid agonists and antagonists in plant extracts and libraries of synthetic compounds.

Screening systems for ecdysteroid mimetic or antiecdysteroid substances in plant extracts or libraries of synthetic compounds are commonly based on the observation of morphological and/or growth responses in insect cell lines. Because these responses are slow and require careful monitoring, existing screening systems are considered limited regarding their applicability to analysis in high-throughput (HT) formats. Here we describe the generation of transformed silkmoth (Bombyx mori) cell lines that respond to the addition of ecdysone-like substances through the expression of the green fluorescent protein (GFP) and the appearance of green fluorescence. Because tests consist of three simple steps, i.e., 1) distribution of transformed cells in microtiter plates; 2) addition of compounds/extracts at different concentrations; and 3) quantification of fluorescence intensity by a fluorescence plate reader, they can be performed quickly and be easily adapted to a HT format. The generated reporter cell lines are used for the screening of extracts from available plant collections for the presence of compounds with ecdysone mimetic or antagonistic activities as well as for monitoring subsequent activity during enrichment and purification steps. The same cell lines are also used here for the determination of structure-activity relationships among available synthetic dibenzoylhydrazine derivatives. Finally, for the identified agonists, we show that their activity as determined by the cell-based screening assays parallels their bioactivity in growth inhibition and toxicity assays carried out on live insects.