Problems encountered by parents of infants with clubfoot treated by the Ponseti method in Madagascar: A study to inform better practice.

OBJECTIVE: Ponseti treatment for clubfoot is effective and inexpensive, improving children's social participation. Two rehabilitation centres in Madagascar piloted Ponseti treatment; however, at one centre 46% of infants failed to complete treatment. The aim of this study was to determine the causes of defaulting in order to facilitate subsequent improvements nationwide when treatment is rolled out to all centres. METHODS: Questionnaire-based interviews. PATIENTS: Twenty mothers of infants younger than 1 year were interviewed after 3 months of treatment in relation to difficulties they experienced with continuing treatment. RESULTS: Fifteen families of these had financial problems: 7 incurred debt, 2 sold possessions, 4 parents stopped work an 2 did not give any further details. All mothers experienced distress; 9 hid their child's foot, and 8 were accused of wrong-doing during pregnancy. Three families travelled more than 500 km to the treatment centre and journeys were costly and difficult. Ponseti splints were acceptable, but aftercare of the splints proved problematic. CONCLUSION: Repeated travel to the clinic resulted in financial and social burden on the families, which reduced their ability to engage in treatment. The findings of this study are similar to work from other countries, but publications on rehabilitation from Madagascar are few. Improved support for parents, information, splinting with better materials and provision of treatment more locally are needed. Financial support for parents is key to enhancing children's life chances.

[Clubfoot associated with tibial and fibular hemimelia]. / Der Klumpfuß bei tibialer und fibularer Hemimelie.

AIM: Clubfoot is rarely associated with tibial or fibular hemimelia. Treatment is complex and in most of the cases extensive surgery is required. At present experience with Ponseti casting is limited. We describe casting and surgical treatment of 10 clubfeet associated with tibial and fibular hemimelia. MATERIAL AND METHOD: Between 1.1.2004 and 31.12.2009 398 clubfeet were treated with casting in our institution. In the same period 10 clubfeet were associated with fibular or tibial hemimelia. Treatment started in 9 clubfeet with Ponseti manipulation and casting. We used the classification of Weber for tibial hemimelia and the Kalamchi-Achterman classification and Paley classification for fibular hemimelia. Data of all patients were prospectively documented and the result of the foot deformity was evaluated before a first lengthening procedure. Documentation included patient data, associated foot pathologies, surgical procedures, functional results. Functional results were evaluated before the first lengthening procedure started. RESULTS: Three patients had tibial hemimelia, two Weber type 1, one Weber type 2, one Weber type 3. five patients had fibular hemimelia, Paley type IV or Kalamchi-Achterman Type IA. One child had bilateral fibular hemimelia. The prospective leg length discrepancy ranged from 3.2 cm to 14 cm. Four feet had initially a successful treatment with casting. In a type 2 according to Weber we performed an ankle reconstruction procedure to correct tibiofibular diastases. Four feet underwent PMR. We had four relapses. Two equinus relapses were treated with a posterior release. Two severe relapses were finally corrected with resection of the coalition and midfoot osteotomies. In a Weber type 3 case a complex reconstruction was performed using an Ilisarov and a TSF frame. Functional results showed in a mean follow-up of 42.2 months (24-72 months) a dorsiflexion between 5 and 20° (Ø 7.7°) and a plantarflexion between 10 and 40° (Ø 26.1°). CONCLUSION: Treatment of clubfoot associated with tibial or fibular hemimelia with the Ponseti technique is limited because of complex hindfoot deformities including tarsal coalitions. Nevertheless treatment after birth starts with casting. Only mild cases of hemimelia without coalition can be corrected with the Ponseti technique. In a case of tibiofibular diastasis successful casting is possible, but extensive surgery is often necessary. In more severe cases we do not recommend casting. In these cases surgical treatment, including posteromedial release, osteotomies for the hindfoot, resection of coalitions or complex osteotomies with Ilisarov or TSF frame is the treatment of choice.

[Mid-term results of idiopathic clubfeet treated with the Ponseti method]. / Mittelfristige Ergebnisse der Behandlung des idiopathischen Klumpfußes mit der Ponseti-Methode.

AIM: The Ponseti method is accepted worldwide for the treatment of congenital clubfoot. We report about our experience in a 7-year period. The purpose of the study was to evaluate the history of well treated feet between primary correction and the age of 5-6 years with relapse rate and functional results. MATERIAL AND METHOD: Between 1.1.2004 and 31.12.2005 we treated 71 patients with 102 idiopathic clubfeet with the Ponseti method. All patients were prospectively evaluated. We used the Pirani score. The patients' results were documented when the children started to walk and before primary school. The results were compared and statistically evaluated. We used the McKay score and measured the talocalcaneal angle on lateral and a. p. radiographs. RESULTS: 89 % clubfeet were successful treated with the Ponseti method. At walking age plantar flexion was between 30° und 50° (∅ 42°) and dorsiflexion between 5° and 30° (∅ 25°). Before primary school plantar flexion was between 30° and 50° (∅ 37,8°) and dorsiflexion between 0° and 25° (∅ 13,9°). Using the McKay score we had 91 % excellent or good results. 31 % cases had surgical treatment of a relapse. In the relapse group 82 % had an excellent or good result according to the McKay score. CONCLUSION: The Ponseti method is a very effective technique to treat idiopathic clubfeet. In the first 5 to 6 years of age there is a significant loss of range of motion. The relapse rate is comparable to those of other clubfoot treatment concepts. The relapse treatment of the Ponseti technique, with recasting, tibialis anterior tendon transfer and Achilles tendon lengthening leads to good functional results.

Nonoperative clubfoot treatment using the French physical therapy method.

Ninety-eight patients (142 clubfeet) treated nonoperatively by the French physical therapy method were reviewed to determine the effectiveness of this technique. All were 3 months old or less when treatment began and were rated for initial clubfoot severity using the Dimeglio scale (moderate, severe, very severe). Follow-up averaged 35 months (range 20-62 months). Forty-two percent of the feet needed no surgery to achieve a plantigrade position, 9% needed heelcord tenotomies, 29% needed posterior releases, and 20% needed comprehensive posteromedial releases. The Dimeglio scale was prognostic for outcomes, with moderate feet having the best results and very severe feet having the worst results. The French physical therapy method significantly reduced the need for operative intervention at the authors' institution.