Effects of knee injection on skeletal muscle metabolism and contractile force in rats.

OBJECTIVE: We tested the hypothesis that intrusion of the knee joint capsule alters quadriceps muscle metabolism and function independently from the damage induced to knee cartilage. METHODS: Adult rats were separated into four groups: intraarticular injections of saline (SAL; n=9); intraarticular injections of papain, a model for osteoarthritis (PIA; n=7); sham injections (SHAM; n=8); and controls (CTL; n=5). 31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy (31P-MRS) was performed after 2 weeks. Spectra were obtained from the left quadriceps: two at baseline, eight during electrical stimulation with simultaneous measurement of contractile force, and 15 during recovery. 31P-MRS data were presented as the ratio of inorganic phosphate (Pi) to phosphocreatine (PCr), concentrations of PCr [PCr], intramuscular pH, and the rates and time constants of PCr breakdown during stimulation and PCr recovery. Intramuscular cytokine concentrations were measured within the quadriceps. Histologic slides of the knees were scored for severity of cartilage damage. RESULTS: The interventional groups produced values of Pi/PCr ratio, [PCr], contractile force and pH that were significantly different from CTL. These changes in muscle function were accompanied by higher concentrations of interleukin-1 observed with PIA and SAL. We did not observe any effect of cartilage damage on muscle function or metabolism. CONCLUSIONS: Knee joint intrusion alters quadriceps muscle metabolism with accelerated depletion of energy stores and fatigue during stimulation. This study demonstrates that needle intrusion into the knee joint results in muscle dysfunction, independently from the extent of cartilage damage.

Pitfalls in the measurement of metabolite concentrations using the one-pulse experiment in in Vivo NMR: commentary on "On neglecting chemical exchange effects when correcting in vivo (31)P MRS data for partial saturation".

In an article in a previous issue of the Journal of Magnetic Resonance, Ouwerkerk and Bottomley (J. Magn. Reson. 148, pp. 425--435, 2001) show that even in the presence of chemical exchange, the dependence of saturation factors on repetition time in the one-pulse experiment is approximately monoexponential. They conclude from this fact that the effect of chemical exchange on the use of saturation factors when correcting for partial saturation is negligible. We take issue with this conclusion and demonstrate that because saturation factors in the presence of chemical exchange are strongly dependent upon all of the chemical parameters of the system, that is, upon all T(1)'s and M(0)'s of resonances in the exchange network and upon the reaction rates themselves, it is problematic to apply saturation factor corrections in situations in which any of these parameters may change. The error criterion we establish reflects actual errors in quantitation, rather than departures from monoexponentiality.