Religious/spiritual coping resources and their relationship with adjustment in patients newly diagnosed with breast cancer in the UK.

BACKGROUND: Religious/spiritual resources may serve multiple functions in adjustment to cancer. However, there is very little evidence of the importance of religious/spiritual variables outside the USA. This paper reports the cross-sectional data of a longitudinal study examining the beneficial and harmful effects of religious/spiritual coping resources on adjustment in the first year after a breast cancer diagnosis. METHOD: One hundred and fifty-five patients newly diagnosed with breast cancer were assessed after surgery. Several aspects of religiousness/spirituality in relation to anxiety and depression were examined: religiosity/spirituality, strength of faith, belief in God, private and public practices, spiritual involvement, perceived spiritual support and positive and negative religious coping strategies. Non-religious coping, social support and optimism were also assessed. RESULTS: 'Feeling punished and abandoned by God' significantly explained 5% of the variance in increased levels of anxiety but was partially mediated by denial coping. It was also partially mediated by acceptance coping, lowering levels of anxiety. Feeling punished and abandoned by God was a significant independent predictor of depressed mood, explaining 4% of the variance. CONCLUSION: Using religious/spiritual resources in the coping process during the early stages of breast cancer may play an important role in the adjustment process in patients with breast cancer. Patients may benefit from having their spiritual needs addressed as experiencing some form of religious/spiritual struggle may serve as a barrier to illness adjustment. Implications for research and clinical practices are discussed.

Do religious/spiritual coping strategies affect illness adjustment in patients with cancer? A systematic review of the literature.

The present paper systematically reviews studies examining the potential beneficial or harmful effects of religious/spiritual coping with cancer. Using religion and spirituality as resources in coping may be specifically prevalent in patients with cancer considering the potentially life-threatening nature of the illness. Religious/spiritual coping may also serve multiple functions in long-term adjustment to cancer such as maintaining self-esteem, providing a sense of meaning and purpose, giving emotional comfort and providing a sense of hope. Seventeen papers met the inclusion criteria of which seven found some evidence for the beneficial effect of religious coping, but one of these also found religious coping to be detrimental in a sub-sample of their population. A further three studies found religious coping to be harmful and seven found non-significant results. However, many studies suffered from serious methodological problems, especially in the manner in which religious coping was conceptualised and measured. The studies also failed to control for possible influential variables such as stage of illness and perceived social support. Due to this, any firm conclusions about the possible beneficial or harmful effects of religious coping with cancer is lacking. These problems are discussed and suggestions for future studies are made.