Pregnancy dedifferentiates memory CD8+ T cells into hypofunctional cells with exhaustion-enriched programs.

Alloreactive memory, unlike naïve, CD8+ T cells resist transplantation tolerance protocols and are a critical barrier to long-term graft acceptance in the clinic. We here show that semi-allogeneic pregnancy successfully reprogrammed memory fetus/graft-specific CD8+ T cells (TFGS) towards hypofunction. Female C57BL/6 mice harboring memory CD8+ T cells generated by the rejection of BALB/c skin grafts and then mated with BALB/c males achieved rates of pregnancy comparable to naive controls. Post-partum fetus/graft-specific CD8+ T cells (TFGS) from skin-sensitized dams upregulated expression of T cell exhaustion (TEX) markers (Tox, Eomes, PD-1, TIGIT, and Lag3). Transcriptional analysis corroborated an enrichment of canonical T exhaustion (TEX) genes in post-partum memory TFGS and additionally, revealed a downregulation of a subset of memory-associated transcripts. Strikingly, pregnancy induced extensive epigenetic modifications of exhaustion- and memory-associated genes in memory TFGS, whereas minimal epigenetic modifications were observed in naive TFGS cells. Finally, post-partum memory TFGS durably expressed the exhaustion-enriched phenotype, and their susceptibility to transplantation tolerance was significantly restored compared to memory TFGS. These findings advance the concept of pregnancy as an epigenetic modulator inducing hypofunction in memory CD8+ T cells that has relevance not only for pregnancy and transplantation tolerance, but also for tumor immunity and chronic infections.

Coordinated elimination of bacterial taxa optimally attenuates alloimmunity and prolongs allograft survival.

This study aimed to dissect the relationship between specific gut commensal bacterial subgroups, their functional metabolic pathways, and their impact on skin allograft outcome and alloimmunity. We previously showed that oral broad-spectrum antibiotic (Abx) pretreatment in mice delayed skin, heart, and lung allograft rejection and dampened alloimmune responses. Here, rationally designed Abx combinations targeting major bacterial groups were used to elucidate their individual contribution to modulating alloimmune responses. Abx cocktails targeting intestinal gram-negative, gram-positive, or anaerobic/gram-positive bacteria by oral gavage, all delayed skin allograft rejection, and reduced alloreactive T cell priming to different extents. Notably, the most pronounced extension of skin allograft survival and attenuation of alloimmunity were achieved when all gut bacterial groups were simultaneously targeted. These results suggest a model in which the strength of the alloimmune response is additively tuned up by gut microbial diversity. Shotgun metagenomic sequencing enabled strain-level resolution and identified a shared commensal, Parabacteroides distasonis, as the most enriched following all Abx treatments. Oral administration of P.distasonis to mice harboring a diverse microbiota significantly prolonged skin allograft survival, identifying a probiotic with therapeutic benefit in transplantation.

Multimodality Imaging of Infective Endocarditis.

Infective endocarditis (IE) is a complex multisystemic disease resulting from infection of the endocardium, the prosthetic valves, or an implantable cardiac electronic device. The clinical presentation of patients with IE varies, ranging from acute and rapidly progressive symptoms to a more chronic disease onset. Because of its severe morbidity and mortality rates, it is necessary for radiologists to maintain a high degree of suspicion in evaluation of patients for IE. Modified Duke criteria are used to classify cases as "definite IE," "possible IE," or "rejected IE." However, these criteria are limited in characterizing definite IE in clinical practice. The use of advanced imaging techniques such as cardiac CT and nuclear imaging has increased the accuracy of these criteria and has allowed possible IE to be reclassified as definite IE in up to 90% of cases. Cardiac CT may be the best choice when there is high clinical suspicion for IE that has not been confirmed with other imaging techniques, in cases of IE and perivalvular involvement, and for preoperative treatment planning or excluding concomitant coronary artery disease. Nuclear imaging may have a complementary role in prosthetic IE. The main imaging findings in IE are classified according to the site of involvement as valvular (eg, abnormal growths [ie, "vegetations"], leaflet perforations, or pseudoaneurysms), perivalvular (eg, pseudoaneurysms, abscesses, fistulas, or prosthetic dehiscence), or extracardiac embolic phenomena. The differential diagnosis of IE includes evaluation for thrombus, pannus, nonbacterial thrombotic endocarditis, Lambl excrescences, papillary fibroelastoma, and caseous necrosis of the mitral valve. The location of the lesion relative to the surface of the valve, the presence of a stalk, and calcification or enhancement at contrast-enhanced imaging may offer useful clues for their differentiation. ©RSNA, 2024 Test Your Knowledge questions for this article are available in the supplemental material.

Advancing mouse models for transplantation research.

Mouse models have been instrumental in understanding mechanisms of transplant rejection and tolerance, but cross-study reproducibility and translation of experimental findings into effective clinical therapies are issues of concern. The Mouse Models in Transplantation symposium gathered scientists and physician-scientists involved in basic and clinical research in transplantation to discuss the strengths and limitations of mouse transplant models and strategies to enhance their utility. Participants recognized that increased procedure standardization, including the use of prespecified, defined endpoints, and statistical power analyses, would benefit the field. They also discussed the generation of new models that incorporate environmental and genetic variables affecting clinical outcomes as potentially important. If implemented, these strategies are expected to improve the reproducibility of mouse studies and increase their translation to clinical trials and, ideally, new Food and Drug Administration-approved drugs.

Low-affinity CD8+ T cells provide interclonal help to high-affinity CD8+ T cells to augment alloimmunity.

Following solid organ transplantation, small precursor populations of polyclonal CD8+ T cells specific for any graft-expressed antigen preferentially expand their high-affinity clones. This phenomenon, termed "avidity maturation," results in a larger population of CD8+ T cells with increased sensitivity to alloantigen, posing a greater risk for graft rejection. Using a mouse model of minor-mismatched skin transplantation, coupled with the tracking of 2 skin graft-reactive CD8+ T cell receptor-transgenic tracer populations with high and low affinity for the same peptide-major histocompatibility complex, we explored the conventional paradigm that CD8+ T cell avidity maturation occurs through T cell receptor affinity-based competition for cognate antigen. Our data revealed "interclonal CD8-CD8 help," whereby lower/intermediate affinity clones help drive the preferential expansion of their higher affinity counterparts in an interleukin-2/CD25-dependent manner. Consequently, the CD8-helped high-affinity clones exhibit greater expansion and develop augmented effector functions in the presence of their low-affinity counterparts, correlating with more severe graft damage. Finally, interclonal CD8-CD8 help was suppressed by costimulation blockade treatment. Thus, high-affinity CD8+ T cells can leverage help from low-affinity CD8+ T cells of identical specificity to promote graft rejection. Suppressing provision of interclonal CD8-CD8 help may be important to improve transplant outcomes.

Sex, T Cells, and the Microbiome in Natural ABO Antibody Production in Mice.

BACKGROUND: "Natural" ABO antibodies (Abs) are produced without known exposure to A/B carbohydrate antigens, posing significant risks for hyperacute rejection during ABO-incompatible transplantation. We investigated anti-A "natural" ABO antibodies versus intentionally induced Abs with regard to the need for T-cell help, the impact of sex, and stimulation by the microbiome. METHODS: Anti-A was measured by hemagglutination assay of sera from untreated C57BL/6 wild-type (WT) or T cell-deficient mice of both sexes. Human ABO-A reagent blood cell membranes were injected intraperitoneally to induce anti-A Abs. The gut microbiome was eliminated by maintenance of mice in germ-free housing. RESULTS: Compared with WT mice, CD4 + T-cell knockout (KO), major histocompability complex-II KO, and αß/γδ T-cell receptor KO mice produced much higher levels of anti-A nAbs; females produced dramatically more anti-A nAbs than males, rising substantially with puberty. Sensitization with human ABO-A reagent blood cell membranes did not induce additional anti-A in KO mice, unlike WT. Sex-matched CD4 + T-cell transfer significantly suppressed anti-A nAbs in KO mice and rendered mice responsive to A-sensitization. Even under germ-free conditions, WT mice of several strains produced anti-A nAbs, with significantly higher anti-A nAbs levels in females than males. CONCLUSIONS: Anti-A nAbs were produced without T-cell help, without microbiome stimulation, in a sex- and age-dependent manner, suggestive of a role for sex hormones in regulating anti-A nAbs. Although CD4 + T cells were not required for anti-A nAbs, our findings indicate that T cells regulate anti-A nAb production. In contrast to anti-A nAbs, induced anti-A production was T-cell dependent without a sex bias.

Heterogeneity in allospecific T cell function in transplant-tolerant hosts determines susceptibility to rejection following infection.

Even when successfully induced, immunological tolerance to solid organs remains vulnerable to inflammatory insults, which can trigger rejection. In a mouse model of cardiac allograft tolerance in which infection with Listeria monocytogenes (Lm) precipitates rejection of previously accepted grafts, we showed that recipient CD4+ TCR75 cells reactive to a donor MHC class I-derived peptide become hypofunctional if the allograft is accepted for more than 3 weeks. Paradoxically, infection-induced transplant rejection was not associated with transcriptional or functional reinvigoration of TCR75 cells. We hypothesized that there is heterogeneity in the level of dysfunction of different allospecific T cells, depending on duration of their cognate antigen expression. Unlike CD4+ TCR75 cells, CD4+ TEa cells specific for a peptide derived from donor MHC class II, an alloantigen whose expression declines after transplantation but remains inducible in settings of inflammation, retained function in tolerant mice and expanded during Lm-induced rejection. Repeated injections of alloantigens drove hypofunction in TEa cells and rendered grafts resistant to Lm-dependent rejection. Our results uncover a functional heterogeneity in allospecific T cells of distinct specificities after tolerance induction and reveal a strategy to defunctionalize a greater repertoire of allospecific T cells, thereby mitigating a critical vulnerability of tolerance.

Methods to Study TLRs in Transplantation.

Toll-like receptors (TLRs) are key regulators of immune responses, including alloimmune responses. In this chapter, we present protocols to study whether and/or how TLRs can contribute to solid-organ transplant rejection. We describe methods to reduce heterogeneity in microbiome variations between animals before beginning experiments to limit confounding factors, protocols using TLR agonists to prevent anti-CD154/donor splenocyte transfer-mediated tolerance, and recipes to heat-kill microbes or use hosts genetically deficient in TLR-dependent pathways to distinguish between TLR-dependent and live bacteria-dependent effects.

Microbiota-dependent and -independent effects of obesity on transplant rejection and hyperglycemia.

Obesity is associated with dysbiosis and a state of chronic inflammation that contributes to the pathogenesis of metabolic diseases, including diabetes. We have previously shown that obese mice develop glucose intolerance, increased alloreactivity, and accelerated transplant rejection. In the present study, we investigated the influence of the microbiota on diet-induced obesity (DIO)-associated transplant rejection and hyperglycemia. Antibiotic treatment prolonged graft survival and reduced fasting glycemia in high-fat diet (HFD)-fed specific-pathogen-free (SPF) mice, supporting a role for the microbiota in promoting accelerated graft rejection and hyperglycemia induced by DIO. Further supporting a microbiota-dependent effect, fecal microbiota transfer from DIO SPF mice into germ-free mice also accelerated graft rejection when compared with lean mice-fecal microbiota transfer. Notably, HFD could be also detrimental to the graft independently from microbiota, obesity, and hyperglycemia. Thus, whereas HFD-associated hyperglycemia was exclusively microbiota-dependent, HFD affected transplant outcomes via both microbiota-dependent and -independent mechanisms. Importantly, hyperglycemia in DIO SPF mice could be reduced by the addition of the gut commensal Alistipes onderdonkii, which alleviated both HFD-induced inflammation and glucose intolerance. Thus, microbial dysbiosis can be manipulated via antibiotics or select probiotics to counter some of the pathogenic effects of obesity in transplantation.

Pregnancy programs epigenetic and transcriptional exhaustion in memory CD8+ T cells.

Alloreactive memory T cells, unlike naive T cells, fail to be restrained by transplantation tolerance protocols or regulatory T cells, and therefore represent a critical barrier to long-term graft acceptance. Using female mice sensitized by rejection of fully-mismatched paternal skin allografts, we show that subsequent semi-allogeneic pregnancy successfully reprograms memory fetus/graft-specific CD8+ T cells (TFGS) towards hypofunction in a manner that is mechanistically distinct from naive TFGS. Post-partum memory TFGS were durably hypofunctional, exhibiting enhanced susceptibility to transplantation tolerance induction. Furthermore, multi-omics studies revealed that pregnancy induced extensive phenotypic and transcriptional modifications in memory TFGS reminiscent of T cell exhaustion. Strikingly, at loci transcriptionally modified in both naive and memory TFGS during pregnancy, chromatin remodeling was observed exclusively in memory and not naive TFGS. These data reveal a novel link between T cell memory and hypofunction via exhaustion circuits and pregnancy-mediated epigenetic imprinting. This conceptual advance has immediate clinical relevance to pregnancy and transplantation tolerance.

Oral administration of the commensal Alistipes onderdonkii prolongs allograft survival.

Intestinal commensals can exert immunomodulatory effects on the host, with beneficial or detrimental consequences depending on underlying diseases. We have previously correlated longer survival of minor mismatched skin grafts in mice with the presence of an intestinal commensal bacterium, Alistipes onderdonkii. In this study, we investigated its sufficiency and mechanism of action. Oral administration of A onderdonkii strain DSM19147 but not DSM108265 was sufficient to prolong minor mismatched skin graft survival through inhibition of tumor necrosis factor production. Through metabolomic and metagenomic comparisons between DSM19147 and DSM108265, we identified candidate gene products associated with the anti-inflammatory effect of DSM19147. A onderdonkii DSM19147 can lower inflammation both at a steady state and after transplantation and may serve as an anti-inflammatory probiotic beneficial for transplant recipients.

Reduced Satb1 expression predisposes CD4+ T conventional cells to Treg suppression and promotes transplant survival.

Limiting CD4+ T cell responses is important to prevent solid organ transplant rejection. In a mouse model of costimulation blockade-dependent cardiac allograft tolerance, we previously reported that alloreactive CD4+ conventional T cells (Tconvs) develop dysfunction, losing proliferative capacity. In parallel, induction of transplantation tolerance is dependent on the presence of regulatory T cells (Tregs). Whether susceptibility of CD4+ Tconvs to Treg suppression is modulated during tolerance induction is unknown. We found that alloreactive Tconvs from transplant tolerant mice had augmented sensitivity to Treg suppression when compared with memory T cells from rejector mice and expressed a transcriptional profile distinct from these memory T cells, including down-regulated expression of the transcription factor Special AT-rich sequence-binding protein 1 (Satb1). Mechanistically, Satb1 deficiency in CD4+ T cells limited their expression of CD25 and IL-2, and addition of Tregs, which express higher levels of CD25 than Satb1-deficient Tconvs and successfully competed for IL-2, resulted in greater suppression of Satb1-deficient than wild-type Tconvs in vitro. In vivo, Satb1-deficient Tconvs were more susceptible to Treg suppression, resulting in significantly prolonged skin allograft survival. Overall, our study reveals that transplantation tolerance is associated with Tconvs' susceptibility to Treg suppression, via modulated expression of Tconv-intrinsic Satb1. Targeting Satb1 in the context of Treg-sparing immunosuppressive therapies might be exploited to improve transplant outcomes.

Host-versus-commensal immune responses participate in the rejection of colonized solid organ transplants.

Solid organ transplantation is the preferred treatment for end-stage organ failure. Although transplant recipients take life-long immunosuppressive drugs, a substantial percentage of them still reject their allografts. Strikingly, barrier organs colonized with microbiota have significantly shorter half-lives than non-barrier transplanted organs, even in immunosuppressed hosts. We previously demonstrated that skin allografts monocolonized with the common human commensal Staphylococcus epidermidis (S.epi) are rejected faster than germ-free (GF) allografts in mice because the presence of S.epi augments the effector alloimmune response locally in the graft. Here, we tested whether host immune responses against graft-resident commensal microbes, including S.epi, can damage colonized grafts independently from the alloresponse. Naive hosts mounted an anticommensal T cell response to colonized, but not GF, syngeneic skin grafts. Whereas naive antigraft commensal T cells modestly damaged colonized syngeneic skin grafts, hosts with prior anticommensal T cell memory mounted a post-transplant immune response against graft-resident commensals that significantly damaged colonized, syngeneic skin grafts. Importantly, allograft recipients harboring this host-versus-commensal immune response resisted immunosuppression. The dual effects of host-versus-commensal and host-versus-allograft responses may partially explain why colonized organs have poorer outcomes than sterile organs in the clinic.

Linked sensitization by memory CD4+ T cells prevents costimulation blockade-induced transplantation tolerance.

Dominant infectious tolerance explains how brief tolerance-inducing therapies result in lifelong tolerance to donor antigens and "linked" third-party antigens, while recipient sensitization and ensuing immunological memory prevent the successful induction of transplant tolerance. In this study, we juxtapose these 2 concepts to test whether mechanisms of dominant infectious tolerance can control a limited repertoire of memory T and B cells. We show that sensitization to a single donor antigen is sufficient to prevent stable transplant tolerance, rendering it unstable. Mechanistic studies revealed that recall antibody responses and memory CD8+ T cell expansion were initially controlled, but memory CD4+Foxp3- T cell (Tconv) responses were not. Remarkably, naive donor-specific Tconvs at tolerance induction also acquired a resistance to tolerance, proliferating and acquiring a phenotype similar to memory Tconvs. This phenomenon of "linked sensitization" underscores the challenges of reprogramming a primed immune response toward tolerance and identifies a potential therapeutic checkpoint for synergizing with costimulation blockade to achieve transplant tolerance in the clinic.

Oral alloantigen exposure promotes donor-specific tolerance in a mouse model of minor-mismatched skin transplantation.

Oral antigen exposure is a powerful, non-invasive route to induce immune tolerance to dietary antigens, and has been modestly successful at prolonging graft survival in rodent models of transplantation. To harness the mechanisms of oral tolerance for promoting long-term graft acceptance, we developed a mouse model where the antigen ovalbumin (OVA) was introduced orally prior to transplantation with skin grafts expressing OVA. Oral OVA treatment pre-transplantation promoted permanent graft acceptance and linked tolerance to skin grafts expressing OVA fused to the additional antigen 2W. Tolerance was donor-specific, as secondary donor-matched, but not third-party allografts were spontaneously accepted. Oral OVA treatment promoted an anergic phenotype in OVA-reactive CD4+ and CD8+ conventional T cells (Tconvs) and expanded OVA-reactive Tregs pre-transplantation. However, skin graft acceptance following oral OVA resisted partial depletion of Tregs and blockade of PD-L1. Mechanistically, we revealed a role for the proximal gut draining lymph nodes (gdLNs) in mediating this effect, as an intestinal infection that drains to the proximal gdLNs prevented tolerance induction. Our study extends previous work applying oral antigen exposure to transplantation and serves as proof of concept that the systemic immune mechanisms supporting oral tolerance are sufficient to promote long-term graft acceptance.

Toward an understanding of allogeneic conflict in pregnancy and transplantation.

Pregnancy is recognized as a spontaneously acquired state of immunological tolerance by the mother to her semi-allogeneic fetus, but it is a major cause of allosensitization in candidates for organ transplantation. This sensitization, assessed by the presence of anti-HLA IgG, contributes to sex disparity in access to transplantation and increases the risk for rejection and graft loss. Understanding this dual tolerance/sensitization conundrum may lead to new strategies for equalizing access to transplantation among sexes and improving transplant outcomes in parous women. Here, we review the clinical evidence that pregnancy results in humoral sensitization and query whether T cell responses are sensitized. Furthermore, we summarize preclinical evidence on the effects of pregnancy on fetus-specific CD4+ conventional, regulatory, and CD8+ T cells, and humoral responses. We end with a discussion on the impact of the divergent effects that pregnancy has upon alloantigen re-encounter in the context of solid organ transplantation, and how these insights point to a therapeutic roadmap for controlling pregnancy-dependent allosensitization.

Taurodeoxycholic acid and valine reverse obesity-associated augmented alloimmune responses and prolong allograft survival.

Obesity initiates a chronic inflammatory network linked to perioperative complications and increased acute rejection rates in organ transplantation. Bariatric surgery is the most effective treatment of obesity recommended for morbidly obese transplant recipients. Here, we delineated the effects of obesity and bariatric surgery on alloimmunity and transplant outcomes in diet-induced obese (DIO) mice. Allograft survival was significantly shorter in DIO-mice. When performing sleeve gastrectomies (SGx) prior to transplantation, we found attenuated T cell-derived alloimmune responses resulting in prolonged allograft survival. Administering taurodeoxycholic acid (TDCA) and valine, metabolites depleted in DIO-mice and restored through SGx, prolonged graft survival in DIO-mice comparable with SGx an dampened Th1 and Th17 alloimmune responses while Treg frequencies and CD4+ T cell-derived IL-10 production were augmented. Moreover, in recipient animals treated with TDCA/valine, levels of donor-specific antibodies had been reduced. Mechanistically, TDCA/valine restrained inflammatory M1-macrophage polarization through TGR5 that compromised cAMP signaling and inhibited macrophage-derived T cell activation. Consistently, administering a TGR5 agonist to DIO-mice prolonged allograft survival. Overall, we provide novel insights into obesity-induced inflammation and its impact on alloimmunity. Furthermore, we introduce TDCA/valine as a noninvasive alternative treatment for obese transplant patients.

Regulation of Alloantibody Responses.

The control of alloimmunity is essential to the success of organ transplantation. Upon alloantigen encounter, naïve alloreactive T cells not only differentiate into effector cells that can reject the graft, but also into T follicular helper (Tfh) cells that promote the differentiation of alloreactive B cells that produce donor-specific antibodies (DSA). B cells can exacerbate the rejection process through antibody effector functions and/or B cell antigen-presenting functions. These responses can be limited by immune suppressive mechanisms mediated by T regulatory (Treg) cells, T follicular regulatory (Tfr) cells, B regulatory (Breg) cells and a newly described tolerance-induced B (TIB) cell population that has the ability to suppress de novo B cells in an antigen-specific manner. Transplantation tolerance following costimulation blockade has revealed mechanisms of tolerance that control alloreactive T cells through intrinsic and extrinsic mechanisms, but also inhibit alloreactive B cells. Thus, the control of both arms of adaptive immunity might result in more robust tolerance, one that may withstand more severe inflammatory challenges. Here, we review new findings on the control of B cells and alloantibody production in the context of transplant rejection and tolerance.