Benchmarking of BMDC assay and related QSAR study for identifying sensitizing chemicals.

The Bone-Marrow derived Dendritic Cell (BMDC) test is a promising assay for identifying sensitizing chemicals based on the 3Rs (Replace, Reduce, Refine) principle. This study expanded the BMDC benchmarking to various in vitro, in chemico, and in silico assays targeting different key events (KE) in the skin sensitization pathway, using common substances datasets. Additionally, a Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship (QSAR) model was developed to predict the BMDC test outcomes for sensitizing or non-sensitizing chemicals. The modeling workflow involved ISIDA (In Silico Design and Data Analysis) molecular fragment descriptors and the SVM (Support Vector Machine) machine-learning method. The BMDC model's performance was at least comparable to that of all ECVAM-validated models regardless of the KE considered. Compared with other tests targeting KE3, related to dendritic cell activation, BMDC assay was shown to have higher balanced accuracy and sensitivity concerning both the Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA) and human labels, providing additional evidence for its reliability. The consensus QSAR model exhibits promising results, correlating well with observed sensitization potential. Integrated into a publicly available web service, the BMDC-based QSAR model may serve as a cost-effective and rapid alternative to lab experiments, providing preliminary screening for sensitization potential, compound prioritization, optimization and risk assessment.

Identification of the allergenic sensitizing potential of bisphenol A substitutes used in the industry.

BACKGROUND: Bisphenol (BP-)A is a chemical used in Europe to produce polycarbonate plastics and epoxy resin or as colour developer in thermal paper. Due to its toxicity, BPA presence was restricted by European regulations. Therefore, substitute chemicals are replacing BPA. OBJECTIVE: To assess the allergenic sensitizing potential of 27 substitutes to BPA used in the industry. METHODS: The expression of two costimulatory molecules and six cytokines were analysed by flow cytometry in mouse bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDCs) exposed to the chemicals. RESULTS: All substances except one induced overexpression of at least one receptor and were thus identified as having allergenic sensitizing potential. Based on the BMDC model, they were classified as extreme (1 out of 27), strong (20 out of 27) and moderate (5 out of 27) sensitizers. BPA was classified as a moderate sensitizer and BPF was the only substitute classified as a non-sensitizer. The more potent substitutes induced more than 2-fold secretion of CCL3, CCL4 and/or CCL5 by dendritic cells. CONCLUSION: Most of the BPA substitutes tested in this study have an allergenic sensitizing potential; 24 of them being more potent than BPA itself. Only BPE, BPF and 2,4-BPS appeared to be weaker sensitizers than BPA.

The BMDC model, a performant cell-based test to assess the sensitizing potential and potency of chemicals including pre/pro-haptens.

BACKGROUND: Chemical-induced allergies at workplace represent a significant occupational health issue. These substances must be properly identified as sensitizers. In previous studies, an original model using mouse bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDC) was developed for this purpose. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate the predictive capacity of the BMDC model with a large panel of sensitizers (including pre- and pro-haptens) and non-sensitizers. METHODS: The readout from the BMDC model is based on expression levels of six phenotypic markers measured by flow cytometry. RESULTS: The results indicate that 29 of the 37 non-sensitizers, and 81 of the 86 sensitizers were correctly classified compared to the Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA). Statistical analysis revealed the BMDC model to have a sensitivity of 94%, a specificity of 78%, and an accuracy of 89%. The EC2 (Effective Concentration) values calculated with this model allow sensitizers to be categorized into four classes: extreme, strong, moderate and weak. CONCLUSIONS: These excellent predictive performances show that the BMDC model discriminates between sensitizers and non-sensitizers with outstanding precision equal to or better than existing validated alternative models. Moreover, this model allows to predict sensitization potency of chemicals. The BMDC test could therefore be proposed as an additional tool to assess the sensitizing potential and potency of chemicals.

A new cytometry-based method reveals an accumulation of Nrf2 in dendritic cells exposed to two respiratory sensitizers.

The mechanisms underlying chemical respiratory sensitization are incompletely understood. One of the major cell types involved in this pathology are dendritic cells. In this study, the mechanisms of the NRF2-Keap1 pathway were studied using a bone marrow-derived dendritic cell model exposed to two respiratory sensitizers: ammonium hexachloroplatinate (HCP) and ammonium tetrachloroplatinate (ATCP). Expression levels for two Nrf2-regulated genes, hmox1 and srxn1, were analyzed by real time-quantitative polymerase chain reaction. A flow cytometry-based method was also developed to measure intracellular Nrf2 accumulation in dendritic cells following exposure. Exposure to HCP and ATCP increased both hmox1 and srxn1 gene expression, and was associated with accumulation of Nrf2 protein in cells. Overall, these results show that the respiratory sensitizers, in addition to skin sensitizers, can also induced markers associated with NRF2-Keap1 pathway activation in dendritic cells. This study contributes to a better understanding of the adverse outcome of respiratory sensitization.

Activation of T cells by dendritic cells exposed to a reference sensitizer: Towards a promising model to assess the allergenic potential of chemicals.

BACKGROUND: Low molecular weight chemicals constitute one of the major causes of occupational allergies. European legislation on chemicals recommends limiting the use of in vivo models for assessing the sensitizing potential of chemicals, and encourages the development of integrated alternative methods. An in vitro mouse model of bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDCs) that showed good accuracy (75%) and sensitivity (69%) has previously been developed to assess the sensitizing potential of chemicals. OBJECTIVE: To assess the ability of BMDCs to activate T cells (TCs) in vitro. METHODS: BMDCs pre-exposed to the reference sensitizer ammonium hexachloroplatinate (AHCP) were co-cultured with different subpopulations of TCs. TC activation was assessed by surface marker expression, proliferation, and cytokine release. RESULTS: The results showed significant activation of TCs co-cultured with dendritic cells pre-exposed to AHCP as evaluated by CD124 expression, proliferation, and cytokine secretion. Moreover, the response of TCs appeared to be Th2-oriented. Naive TCs were shown to be involved in this response, and the removal of regulatory TCs did not improve the cell response. CONCLUSIONS: The BMDCs used in this previously developed model appear to have the ability to activate TCs, confirming that the BMDC model represents a reliable assay for assessing the sensitizing potential of chemicals.

In vitro detection of chemical allergens: an optimized assay using mouse bone marrow-derived dendritic cells.

BACKGROUND: Identification of the allergenic potency of chemicals is a key step in the safety assessment process. Predictive assays that require no or few animals are needed. OBJECTIVES: To develop an alternative in vitro mouse bone marrow-derived dendritic cell (BMDC) assay to determine the allergenic potential of chemicals. METHODS: BMDCs were exposed to well-known allergens and to non-allergenic chemicals. Surface marker expression and cytokine release of BMDCs were analysed after treatment. RESULTS: Eleven tested chemicals showed a significant stimulation index (SI) of >1.5 (accuracy, 75%; sensitivity, 69%). The four non-allergens all showed a SI of <1.5. Eight contact allergens tested showed a significant SI of >1.5 (accuracy, 92%; sensitivity, 89%), whereas only two respiratory allergens showed a significant SI of >1.5 (accuracy, 60%; sensitivity, 33%). CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that the BMDC assay could become a reliable test for assessment of the allergenic potential of chemicals. The next step should include the testing of further chemicals, with the aim of integrating this assay into the toolbox of in vitro methods for the evaluation of the allergenic potential of chemicals.