Dinitrogen Activation within Frustrated Lewis Pairs Is Promoted by Adding External Electric Fields.

This study uses computational means to explore the feasibility of N2 cleavage by frustrated Lewis pair (FLPs) species. The employed FLP systems are phosphane/borane (1) and carbene/borane (2). Previous studies show that 1 and 2 react with H2 and CO2 but do not activate N2. The present study demonstrates that N2 is indeed inert, and its activation requires augmentation of the FLPs by an external tool. As we demonstrate here, FLP-mediated N2 activation can be achieved by an external electric field oriented along the reaction axis of the FLP. Additionally, the study demonstrates that FLP -N2 activation generates useful nitrogen compound, e.g., hydrazine (H2N-NH2). In summary, we conclude that FLP effectively activates N2 in tandem with oriented external electric fields (OEEFs), which play a crucial role. This FLP/OEEF combination may serve as a general activator of inert molecules.

Sulfonium Cation in the Service of π-Acid Catalysis.

While still rare, cationic ligands offer much promise as tunable electron-withdrawing ligands for π-acid catalysis. Recently, we introduced pincer-type sulfonium cations into the list of available strongly π-acidic ancillary ligands. However, the M-S bond in sulfonium complexes of these ligands was found highly labile, precluding their catalytic applications. Herein we demonstrate that this obstacle can be overcome by increasing the rigidity of the sulfonium pincer scaffold. X-ray analyses confirm that despite bearing a formal positive charge, the sulfur atom of this newly designed sulfonium ligand maintains its coordination to the Pt(II)-center, while DFT calculations indicate that by doing so it strongly enhances the electrophilic character of the metal. Kinetic studies carried out on three model cycloisomerization reactions prove that such a tris-cationic sulfonium-Pt(II) complex is highly reactive, compared to its thioether-based analogue. This proof-of-concept study presents the first example of employing sulfonium-based ligands in homogeneous catalysis.

Valence Bond Theory Allows a Generalized Description of Hydrogen Bonding.

This paper describes the nature of the hydrogen bond (HB), B:---H-A, using valence bond theory (VBT). Our analysis shows that the most important HB interactions are polarization and charge transfer, and their corresponding sum displays a pattern that is identical for a variety of energy decomposition analysis (EDA) methods. Furthermore, the sum terms obtained with the different EDA methods correlate linearly with the corresponding VB quantities. The VBT analysis demonstrates that the total covalent-ionic resonance energy (RECS) of the HB portion (B---H in B:---H-A) correlates linearly with the dissociation energy of the HB, ΔEdiss. In principle, therefore, RECS(HB) can be determined by experiment. The VBT wavefunction reveals that the contributions of ionic structures to the HB increase the positive charge on the hydrogen of the corresponding external/free O-H bonds in, for example, the water dimer compared with a free water molecule. This increases the electric field of the external O-H bonds of water clusters and contributes to bringing about catalysis of reactions by water droplets and in water-hydrophobic interfaces.

Dichotomy of Delocalization/Localization and Charge-Shift Bonding in Germanazene and its Heavier Group 14 Analogues: a Valence Bond Study.

We present here a valence bond analysis of structure and π-delocalization in Ge3 (NH)3 , which models germanazene that was prepared by Power et al. To get a broader perspective, we explore the entire E3 (NH)3 series (E=C, Si, Ge, Sn, Pb). Thus, while (4n+2)π systems of carbon rings are aromatic with cyclic π-delocalization, the E3 (NH)3 rings are dominated by a nonbonded structure, wherein π-lone pairs are localized on the N atoms. Nevertheless, these molecules enjoy large covalent-ionic resonance energies of 153.0, 86.6, 74.2, 61.2, and 58.9 kcal/mol, respectively, for E=C, Si, Ge, Sn, Pb. The covalent-ionic mixing in E3 (NH)3 creates π-systems, which are stabilized by charge-shift bonding. Thus, unlike in benzene, in Ge3 (NH)3 delocalization of π-electron pairs of the N atoms is primarily confined to the domains of their adjacent Ge atoms. These features carry over to the substituted germanazene, Ge3 (NAr)3 (Ar=Ph).

On the nature of the chemical bond in valence bond theory.

This Perspective outlines a panoramic description of the nature of the chemical bond according to valence bond theory. It describes single bonds and demonstrates the existence of a "forgotten family" of charge-shift bonds (CSBs) in which the entire/most of the bond energy arises from the resonance between the covalent and ionic structures of the bond. Many of the CSBs are homonuclear bonds. Hypervalent molecules (e.g., XeF2) are CSBs. This Perspective proceeds to describe multiple bonded molecules with an emphasis on C2 and 3O2. C2 has four electron pairs in its valence shell and, hence, 14 covalent structures and 1750 ionic structures. This Perspective outlines an effective methodology of peeling the electronic structure to the minimal and important number of structures: a dominant structure that displays a quadruple bond and two minor structures with π + σ bonds, which stabilize the quadruple bond by resonance. 3O2 is chosen because it is a diradical, which is persistent and life-sustaining. It is shown that the persistence of this diradical is due to the charge-shift bonding of the π-3-electron bonds. This section ends with a discussion of the roles of π vs σ in the geometric preferences of benzene, acetylene, ethene, and their Si-based analogs. Subsequently, this Perspective discusses bonding in clusters of univalent metal atoms, which possess only parallel spins (n+1Mn), and are nevertheless bonded due to the resonance interactions that stabilize the repulsive elementary structure (all spins are up). The bond energy reaches ∼40 kcal/mol for a pair of atoms (in n+1Cun; n ∼ 10-12). The final subsection discusses singlet excited states in ethene, ozone, and SO2. It demonstrates the capability of the breathing-orbital VB method to yield an accurate description of a variety of excited states using merely 10 or few VB structures. Furthermore, the method underscores covalent structures that play a key role in the correct description and bonding of these excited states.

The roles of charge transfer and polarization in non-covalent interactions: a perspective from ab initio valence bond methods.

Noncovalent interactions are ubiquitous and have been well recognized in chemistry, biology and material science. Yet, there are still recurring controversies over their natures, due to the wide range of noncovalent interaction terms. In this Essay, we employed the Valence Bond (VB) methods to address two types of interactions which recently have drawn intensive attention, i.e., the halogen bonding and the CH‧‧‧HC dihydrogen bonding. The VB methods have the advantage of interpreting molecular structures and properties in the term of electron-localized Lewis (resonance) states (structures), which thereby shed specific light on the alteration of the bonding patterns. Due to the electron localization nature of Lewis states, it is possible to define individually and measure both polarization and charge transfer effects which have different physical origins. We demonstrated that both the ab initio VB method and the block-localized wavefunction (BLW) method can provide consistent pictures for halogen bonding systems, where strong Lewis bases NH3, H2O and NMe3 partake as the halogen bond acceptors, and the halogen bond donors include dihalogen molecules and XNO2 (X = Cl, Br, I). Based on the structural, spectral, and energetic changes, we confirm the remarkable roles of charge transfer in these halogen bonding complexes. Although the weak C-H∙∙∙H-C interactions in alkane dimers and graphene sheets are thought to involve dispersion only, we show that this term embeds delicate yet important charge transfer, bond reorganization and polarization interactions.

Nature of the Trigger Linkage in Explosive Materials Is a Charge-Shift Bond.

Explosion begins by rupture of a specific bond, in the explosive, called a trigger linkage. We characterize this bond in nitro-containing explosives. Valence-bond (VB) investigations of X-NO2 linkages in alkyl nitrates, nitramines, and nitro esters establish the existence of Pauli repulsion that destabilizes the covalent structure of these bonds. The trigger linkages are mainly stabilized by covalent-ionic resonance and are therefore charge-shift bonds (CSBs). The source of Pauli repulsion in nitro explosives is unique. It is traced to the hyperconjugative interaction from the oxygen lone pairs of NO2 into the σ(X-N)* orbital, which thereby weakens the X-NO2 bond, and depletes its electron density as X becomes more electronegative. Weaker trigger bonds have higher CSB characters. In turn, weaker bonds increase the sensitivity of the explosive to impacts/shocks which lead to detonation. Application of the analysis to realistic explosives supports the CSB character of their X-NO2 bonds by independent criteria. Furthermore, other families of explosives also involve CSBs as trigger linkages (O-O, N-O, Cl-O, N-I, etc. bonds). In all of these, detonation is initiated selectively at the CSB of the molecule. A connection is made between the CSB bond-weakening and the surface-electrostatic potential diagnosis in the trigger bonds.

Valence Bond Theory-Its Birth, Struggles with Molecular Orbital Theory, Its Present State and Future Prospects.

This essay describes the successive births of valence bond (VB) theory during 1916-1931. The alternative molecular orbital (MO) theory was born in the late 1920s. The presence of two seemingly different descriptions of molecules by the two theories led to struggles between the main proponents, Linus Pauling and Robert Mulliken, and their supporters. Until the 1950s, VB theory was dominant, and then it was eclipsed by MO theory. The struggles will be discussed, as well as the new dawn of VB theory, and its future.

Electric-Field Mediated Chemistry: Uncovering and Exploiting the Potential of (Oriented) Electric Fields to Exert Chemical Catalysis and Reaction Control.

This Perspective discusses oriented external-electric-fields (OEEF), and other electric-field types, as "smart reagents", which enable in principle control over wide-ranging aspects of reactivity and structure. We discuss the potential of OEEFs to control nonredox reactions and impart rate-enhancement and selectivity. An OEEF along the "reaction axis", which is the direction whereby electronic reorganization converts reactants' to products' bonding, will accelerate reactions, control regioselectivity, induce spin-state selectivity, and elicit mechanistic crossovers. Simply flipping the direction of the OEEF will lead to inhibition. Orienting the OEEF off the reaction axis enables control over stereoselectivity, enantioselectivity, and product selectivity. For polar/polarizable reactants, the OEEF itself will act as tweezers, which orient the reactants and drive their reaction. OEEFs also affect bond-dissociation energies and dissociation modes (covalent vs ionic), as well as alteration of molecular geometries and supramolecular aggregation. The "key" to gaining access to this toolbox provided by OEEFs is microscopic control over the alignment between the molecule and the applied field. We discuss the elegant experimental methods which have been used to verify the theoretical predictions and describe various alternative EEF sources and prospects for upscaling OEEF catalysis in solvents. We also demonstrate the numerous ways in which the OEEF effects can be mimicked by use of (designed) local-electric fields (LEFs), i.e., by embedding charges or dipoles into molecules. LEFs and OEEFs are shown to be equivalent and to obey the same ground rules. Outcomes are exemplified for Diels-Alder cycloadditions, oxidative addition of bonds by transition-metal complexes, H-abstractions by oxo-metal species, ionic cleavage of halogen bonds, methane activation, etc.

Covalent vs Charge-Shift Nature of the Metal-Metal Bond in Transition Metal Complexes: A Unified Understanding.

We present here a general conceptualization of the nature of metal-metal (M-M) bonding in transition-metal (TM) complexes across the periods of TM elements, by use of ab initio valence-bond theory. The calculations reveal a dual-trend: For M-M bonds in groups 7 and 9, the 3d-series forms charge-shift bonds (CSB), while upon moving down to the 5d-series, the bonds become gradually covalent. In contrast, M-M bonds of metals having filled d-orbitals (groups 11 and 12) behave oppositely; initially the M-M bond is covalent, but upon moving down the Periodic Table, the CSB character increases. These trends originate in the radial-distribution-functions of the atomic orbitals, which determine the compactness of the valence-orbitals vis-à-vis the filled semicore orbitals. Key factors that gauge this compactness are the presence/absence of a radial-node in the valence-orbital and relativistic contraction/expansion of the valence/semicore orbitals. Whenever these orbital-types are spatially coincident, the covalent bond-pairing is weakened by Pauli-repulsion with the semicore electrons, and CSB takes over. Thus, for groups 3-10, which possess (n - 1)s2(n - 1)p6 semicores, this spatial-coincidence is maximal at the 3d-transition-metals which consequently form charge-shift M-M bonds. However, in groups 11 and 12, the relativistic effects maximize spatial-coincidence in the third series, wherein the 5d10 core approaches the valence 6s orbital, and the respective Pauli repulsion generates M-M bonds with CSB character. These considerations create a generalized paradigm for M-M bonding in the transition-elements periods, and Pauli repulsion emerges as the factor that unifies CSB over the periods of main-group and transition elements.

Charge-Shift Bonding: A New and Unique Form of Bonding.

Charge-shift bonds (CSBs) constitute a new class of bonds different than covalent/polar-covalent and ionic bonds. Bonding in CSBs does not arise from either the covalent or the ionic structures of the bond, but rather from the resonance interaction between the structures. This Essay describes the reasons why the CSB family was overlooked by valence-bond pioneers and then demonstrates that the unique status of CSBs is not theory-dependent. Thus, valence bond (VB), molecular orbital (MO), and energy decomposition analysis (EDA), as well as a variety of electron density theories all show the distinction of CSBs vis-à-vis covalent and ionic bonds. Furthermore, the covalent-ionic resonance energy can be quantified from experiment, and hence has the same essential status as resonance energies of organic molecules, e.g., benzene. The Essay ends by arguing that CSBs are a distinct family of bonding, with a potential to bring about a Renaissance in the mental map of the chemical bond, and to contribute to productive chemical diversity.

TITAN: A Code for Modeling and Generating Electric Fields-Features and Applications to Enzymatic Reactivity.

We present here a versatile computational code named "elecTric fIeld generaTion And maNipulation (TITAN)," capable of generating various types of external electric fields, as well as quantifying the local (or intrinsic) electric fields present in proteins and other biological systems according to Coulomb's Law. The generated electric fields can be coupled with quantum mechanics (QM), molecular mechanics (MM), QM/MM, and molecular dynamics calculations in most available software packages. The capabilities of the TITAN code are illustrated throughout the text with the help of examples. We end by presenting an application, in which the effects of the local electric field on the hydrogen transfer reaction in cytochrome P450 OleTJE enzyme and the modifications induced by the application of an oriented external electric field are examined. We find that the protein matrix in P450 OleTJE acts as a moderate catalyst and that orienting an external electric field along the Fe─O bond of compound I has the biggest impact on the reaction barrier. The induced catalysis/inhibition correlates with the calculated spin density on the O-atom. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Captodative Substitution Enhances the Diradical Character of Compounds, Reduces Aromaticity, and Controls Single-Molecule Conductivity Patterns: A Valence Bond Study.

The present contribution uses a valence bond (VB) perspective to consider the captodative substitution strategy, a method to enhance the diradical character of (potentially aromatic) compounds. We confirm the qualitative reasoning that has generally been used to rationalize the diradical-character-enhancing effect of captodative substitution: this type of substitution scheme disproportionally stabilizes specific Dewar/diradical(oid) VB structures, thus increasing their weight in the full ground-state wave function. Furthermore, we assess the effect of captodative substitution on the aromaticity of the considered compound. We observe a clear trade-off between diradical character and aromaticity for our model systems: as one of these properties increases, the other decreases. This finding is especially significant within the field of single-molecule electronics because it enables unification of the previously observed inverse proportionality between the aromaticity of a compound and the magnitude of conductance through that molecule, with the observed proportionality between diradical character and the magnitude of conductance associated with a compound. To some extent, both properties, i.e., aromaticity and diradical character, appear to be the flip-sides of the same coin.

Orbitals and the Interpretation of Photoelectron Spectroscopy and (e,2e) Ionization Experiments.

Electron momentum spectroscopy, scanning tunneling microscopy, and photoelectron spectroscopy provide unique information about electronic structure, but their interpretation has been controversial. This essay discusses a framework for interpretation. Although this interpretation is not new, we believe it is important to present this framework in light of recent publications. The key point is that these experiments provide information about how the electron distribution changes upon ionization, not how electrons behave in the pre-ionized state. Therefore, these experiments do not lead to a "selection of the correct orbitals" in chemistry and do not overturn the well-known conclusion that both delocalized molecular orbitals and localized molecular orbitals are useful for interpreting chemical structure and dynamics. The two types of orbitals can produce identical total molecular electron densities and therefore molecular properties. Different types of orbitals are useful for different purposes.

Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution Reactions: Mechanistic Landscape, Electrostatic and Electric-Field Control of Reaction Rates, and Mechanistic Crossovers.

This study investigates the rich mechanistic landscape of the iconic electrophilic aromatic substitution (EAS) reaction class, in the gas phase, in solvents, and under stimulation by oriented external electric fields. The study uses DFT calculations, complemented by a qualitative valence bond (VB) perspective. We construct a comprehensive and unifying framework that elucidates the many surprising mechanistic features, uncovered in recent years, of this class of reactions. For example, one of the puzzling issues which have attracted significant interest recently is the finding of a variety of concerted mechanisms that do not involve the formation of σ-complex intermediates, in apparent contradiction to the generally accepted textbook mechanism. Our VB modeling elucidates the existence of both the concerted and stepwise mechanisms and uncovers the root causes and necessary conditions for the appearance of these intermediates. Furthermore, our VB analysis offers insight into the potential applications of external electric fields as smart, green, and selective catalysts, which can control at will reaction rates, as well as mechanistic crossovers, for this class of reactions. Finally, we highlight how understanding of the electric fields effect on the EAS reaction could lead to the formulation of guiding principles for the design of improved heterogeneous catalysts. Overall, our analysis underscores the powerful synergy offered by combining molecular orbital and VB theory to tackle interesting and challenging mechanistic questions in chemistry.

Oriented External Electric Fields: Tweezers and Catalysts for Reactivity in Halogen-Bond Complexes.

This theoretical study establishes ways of controlling and enabling an uncommon chemical reaction, the displacement reaction, B:---(X-Y) → (B-X)+ + :Y-, which is nascent from a B:---(X-Y) halogen bond (XB) by nucleophilic attack of the base, B:, on the halogen, X. In most of the 14 cases examined, these reactions possess high barriers either in the gas phase (where the X-Y bond dissociates to radicals) or in solvents such as CH2Cl2 and CH3CN (which lead to endothermic processes). Thus, generally, the XB species are trapped in deep minima, and their reactions are not allowed without catalysis. However, when an oriented-external electric field (OEEF) is directed along the B---X---Y reaction axis, the field acts as electric tweezers that orient the XB along the field's axis, and intensely catalyze the process, by tens of kcal/mol, thus rendering the reaction allowed. Flipping the OEEF along the reaction axis inhibits the reaction and weakens the interaction of the XB. Furthermore, at a critical OEEF, each XB undergoes spontaneous and barrier-free reaction. As such, OEEF achieves quite tight control of the structure and reactivity of XB species. Valence bond modeling is used to elucidate the means whereby OEEFs exert their control.

Cross Conjugation in Polyenes and Related Hydrocarbons: What Can Be Learned from Valence Bond Theory about Single-Molecule Conductance?

This study examined the nature of the electronic structure of representative cross-conjugated polyenes from a valence bond (VB) perspective. Our VBSCF calculations on a prototypical dendralene model reveal a remarkable inhibition of the delocalization compared to linear polyenes. Especially along the C-C backbone, the delocalization is virtually quenched so that these compounds can essentially be considered as sets of isolated butadiene units. In direct contrast to the dendralene chains, quinodimethane compounds exhibit an enhancement in their delocalization compared to linear polyenes. We demonstrate that this quenching/enhancement of the delocalization is inherently connected to the relative weights of specific types of long-bond VB structures. From our ab initio treatment, many localization/delocalization-related concepts and phenomena, central to both organic chemistry and single-molecule electronics, emerge. Not only do we find direct insight into the relation between topology and the occurrence of quantum interference (QI), but we also find a phenomenological justification of the recently proposed diradical character-based rule for the estimation of the magnitude of molecular conductance. Generally, our results can be conceptualized using the "arrow-pushing" concept, originating from resonance theory.

Comment on "Decoding real space bonding descriptors in valence bond language" by A. Martín Pendás and E. Francisco, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2018, 20, 12368.

The authors of the above entitled paper suggest that molecular orbital (MO) and valence bond (VB) theories may generate conflicting insights into bonding. Therefore, they derive a real-space (RS) quantum chemical topology (QCT) approach (QCT-RS), and use it to extract insight into the H2 and LiH bonds, and contrast this insight with the one generated by VB calculations. The authors' conclusions strongly contradict the usual bonding paradigms that arise from classical VB theory. Our Comment critically examines these claims and shows that MO and VB theories do not differ in their interpretations of bonding when both are applied on equal footing. It is furthermore shown that the conclusions based on this QCT-RS approach originate from a redefinition of VB structures in a manner that departs from the commonly accepted ones. This disparity of definitions of VB structures creates confusion. Thus, (a) the claim that in QCT-RS all covalency emanates from the covalent-ionic resonance, is generally incorrect in classical VB theory; and (b) contrary to the description of LiH as fully ionic in the above entitled paper, classical VB theory shows that this bond is well described as a superposition of a major covalent structure (albeit polarized) and a less important ionic one. The s-p hybridization of Li in the covalent structure is the major contributor to the dipole moment of LiH.