Histological Comparison of Porcine Small Intestine Submucosa and Bovine Type-I Collagen Conduit for Nerve Repair in a Rat Model.

Purpose: After nerve injury, macrophages and Schwann cells remove axon and myelin debris. We hypothesized that nerves repaired with different conduit materials will result in varying levels of these cell populations, which impacts Wallerian degeneration and axonal regeneration. Methods: We performed a unilateral sciatic nerve transection in 18 rats. The nerves were repaired with small intestine submucosa (SIS, n = 9) or isolated type-I collagen (CLC, n = 9) conduits. Rats were monitored for 4 weeks. Histology samples were obtained from the proximal nerve, mid-implant, and distal nerve regions. Samples were stained for total macrophages, M2 macrophages, foamy phagocytes, Schwann cells, vascular components, axon components, and collagen density. Results: Distal nerve analyses showed higher populations of total macrophages and M2 macrophages in SIS-repaired nerves and higher density of foamy phagocytes in CLC-repaired nerves. Proximal nerve, mid-implant, and distal nerve analyses showed higher Schwann cell and vascular component densities in SIS-repaired nerves. Axon density was higher in the mid-implant region of SIS-repaired nerves. Collagen staining in the mid-implant was scant, but less collagen density was observed in SIS-repaired versus CLC-repaired nerves. Conclusions: In the distal nerve, the following were observed: (1) lower total macrophages in CLC-repaired nerves, suggesting lower overall inflammation versus SIS-repaired nerves; (2) higher M2 macrophages in SIS-repaired versus CLC-repaired nerves, a driving factor for higher total macrophages and indicative of an inflammation resolution response in SIS-repaired nerves; and (3) a lower foamy phagocyte density in SIS-repaired nerves, suggesting earlier resolution of Wallerian degeneration versus CLC-repaired nerves. In the proximal nerve, mid-implant, and distal nerve, higher Schwann cell and vascular component densities were noted in SIS-repaired nerves. In the mid-implant, a higher axon component density and a lower collagen density of the SIS-repaired nerves versus CLC-repaired nerves were noted. These results indicate more robust nerve regeneration with less collagen deposition. Clinical relevance: This in vivo study evaluated two common conduit materials that are used in peripheral nerve repair. Clinical outcomes of nerves repaired with conduits may be impacted by the response to different conduit materials. These nerve repair responses include Wallerian degeneration, nerve regeneration, and nerve scarring. This study evaluated Wallerian degeneration using total macrophages, M2 macrophages, and foamy phagocytes. Nerve regeneration was evaluated using Schwann cells and axons. Nerve scarring was evaluated using vascular and collagen density.

Characterization of Nerve Damage After an Injury to the Adjacent Soft Tissue: A Pilot Animal Study.

Traumatic injuries may result in the formation of soft tissue adhesions between peripheral nerves and surrounding soft tissue. These soft tissue adhesions lead to compression and ischemic stress within fascicles due to nonpliability of adhered scar tissue, and nerve tension due to loss of nerve gliding from scar tethering. These changes in the soft tissue bed surrounding the nerve may result in axon degeneration and neuroma-in-continuity. Preclinical models that simulate clinically relevant levels of scar in the nerve environment may be impactful to the development of surgical techniques and treatments to prevent adhesions. This study presents the results of a rodent model with an induced indirect nerve injury by (1) thermal insult to the soft tissue bed surrounding the nerve and (2) air-drying the surrounding soft tissue bed of the nerve. Our findings suggest that inducing an injury of the soft tissue bed results in increased intraneural scar and extraneural adhesions to the nerve compared to a sham procedure. Thermal induced injuries showed more macrophages and changes in nerve health compared to air-dried induced injuries. The changes in the nerves of the induced injury groups, specifically the thermal injury group, may be meaningful for evaluating treatments for nontransected nerve injuries.

A Comparative Study of Porcine Small Intestine Submucosa and Cross-Linked Bovine Type I Collagen as a Nerve Conduit.

Purpose: We compared 2 commercially available nerve conduits-the Axoguard Nerve Connector, made of porcine small intestine submucosa (SIS), and the NeuraGen Nerve Guide, made of cross-linked bovine type I collagen (Col)-using a rodent model at 4 weeks, specifically focusing on subchronic host responses to the implants. Methods: A unilateral 5-mm sciatic nerve defect was created in 18 male Lewis rats and was repaired with SIS or Col conduits. After 4 weeks, histological evaluations of morphology, collagen content, macrophage polarization, vascularization, axonal regeneration, and myelination were conducted. To achieve a blinded examination, an independent qualified pathologist evaluated the images that were stained with hematoxylin-eosin, α-smooth muscle actin, and Masson trichrome stains. Results: The results showed a dominant macrophage type 2 (M2) response in the SIS group and a dominant macrophage type 1 (M1) response in the Col group. The SIS group showed deeper implant vascularization and fibroblast ingrowth than the Col group. Collagen deposition was higher within the lumen of the Col group than the SIS group. All Col conduits were surrounded by a colocalized staining of Masson trichrome and α-smooth muscle actin, forming a capsule-like structure. Conclusion: Distinctive histological features were identified for each conduit at the cellular level. The SIS conduits had a significantly higher number of host macrophages expressing M2 surface marker CD163, and the Col conduits showed a predominance of host macrophages expressing the M1 surface marker CD80. Data suggest that promoting the M2 response for tissue engineering and regenerative medicine is associated with a remodeling response. In addition, an independent analysis revealed an encapsulation-like appearance around all Col conduits, which is similar to what is seen in breast implant capsules. Clinical relevance: The biomaterial choice for conduit material can play an important role in the host tissue response, with the potential to impact adverse events and patient outcomes.

Bench-to-Bedside Lessons Learned: Commercialization of an Acellular Nerve Graft.

Peripheral nerve injury can result in debilitating outcomes including loss of function and neuropathic pain. Although nerve repair research and therapeutic development are widely studied, translation of these ideas into clinical interventions has not occurred at the same rate. At the turn of this century, approaches to peripheral nerve repair have included microsurgical techniques, hollow conduits, and autologous nerve grafts. These methods provide satisfactory results; however, they possess numerous limitations that can prevent effective surgical treatment. Commercialization of Avance, a processed nerve allograft, sought to address limitations of earlier approaches by providing an off-the-shelf alternative to hollow conduits while maintaining many proregenerative properties of autologous grafts. Since its launch in 2007, Avance has changed the landscape of the nerve repair market and is used to treat tens of thousands of patients. Although Avance has become an important addition to surgeon and patient clinical options, the product's journey from bench to bedside took over 20 years with many research and commercialization challenges. This article reviews the events that have brought a processed nerve allograft from the laboratory bench to the patient bedside. Additionally, this review provides a perspective on lessons and considerations that can assist in translation of future medical products.

Application of a Porcine Small Intestine Submucosa Nerve Cap for Prevention of Neuromas and Associated Pain.

Painful neuroma formation is a common and debilitating sequela of traumatic or oncologic nerve amputations. Studies suggest that isolating transected nerve stumps within protective caps during amputation surgery or revision procedures may assist in preventing symptomatic nerve-end neuroma formation. This study evaluated the local effects of two porcine small intestine submucosa (pSIS) nerve caps of differing configurations on a terminal nerve end in an animal model. The tibial nerves of 57 Sprague Dawley rats were transected and transposed to the lateral hind leg. The nerves were treated with one of three SIS materials, including (i) a nerve cap with spiraling chambering, termed spiral nerve cap (SNC), (ii) a nerve cap with bifurcated chambers termed chambered nerve cap (CNC), or (iii) an open tube. The surgical control consisted of nerve stumps that were not treated. Overall tissue response, axonal swirling, optical density of axons, and behavioral pain response were quantified at 8 and 12 weeks postoperatively. There were no notable differences between the performance of the SNC and CNC groups. The pSIS nerve caps mitigated aberrant axonal regeneration and decreased neuroma formation and associated pain response. These findings suggest that nerve caps with internal chambers for axonal outgrowth may improve axonal alignment, therefore reducing the likelihood of symptomatic neuroma formation. Impact statement This study provides evidence for using nerve caps with internal structure on nerve stumps after amputation surgeries to reduce or prevent symptomatic neuromas. This study showed that porcine small intestine submucosa had a favorable remodeling profile and tissue response, illustrating that this device can be used to (i) minimize soft tissue attachments around the nerves that are capped, (ii) align axonal outgrowth to guide nerve regeneration away from aberrant neuroma formation, and (iii) act as a barrier between the nerve and external stimuli ultimately remodeling into a new soft tissue layer around the nerve stump thus decreasing symptomatic neuroma formation.

Immediate Enhancement of Nerve Function Using a Novel Axonal Fusion Device After Neurotmesis.

BACKGROUND: The management of peripheral nerve injuries remains a large challenge for plastic surgeons. With the inability to fuse axonal endings, results after microsurgical nerve repair have been inconsistent. Our current nerve repair strategies rely upon the slow and lengthy process of axonal regeneration (~1 mm/d). Polyethylene glycol (PEG) has been investigated as a potential axonal fusion agent; however, the percentage of axonal fusion has been inconsistent. The purpose of this study was to identify a PEG delivery device to standardize outcomes after attempted axonal fusion with PEG. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We used a rat sciatic nerve injury model in which we completely transected and repaired the left sciatic nerve to evaluate the efficacy of PEG fusion over a span of 12 weeks. In addition, we evaluated the effectiveness of a delivery device's ability to optimize results after PEG fusion. RESULTS: We found that PEG rapidly (within minutes) restores axonal continuity as assessed by electrophysiology, fluorescent retrograde tracer, and diffusion tensor imaging. Immunohistochemical analysis shows that motor axon counts are significantly increased at 1 week, 4 weeks, and 12 weeks postoperatively in PEG-treated animals. Furthermore, PEG restored behavioral functions up to 50% compared with animals that received the criterion standard epineurial repair (control animals). CONCLUSIONS: The ability of PEG to rapidly restore nerve function after neurotmesis could have vast implications on the clinical management of traumatic injuries to peripheral nerves.

Novel degradable co-polymers of polypyrrole support cell proliferation and enhance neurite out-growth with electrical stimulation.

Synthetic polymers such as polypyrrole (PPy) are gaining significance in neural studies because of their conductive properties. We evaluated two novel biodegradable block co-polymers of PPy with poly(epsilon-caprolactone) (PCL) and poly(ethyl cyanoacrylate) (PECA) for nerve regeneration applications. PPy-PCL and PPy-PECA co-polymers can be processed from solvent-based colloidal dispersions and have essentially the same or greater conductivity (32 S/cm for PPy-PCL, 19 S/cm for PPy-PECA) compared to the PPy homo-polymer (22 S/cm). The PPy portions of the co-polymers permit electrical stimulation whereas the PCL or PECA blocks enable degradation by hydrolysis. For in vitro tests, films were prepared on polycarbonate sheets by air brushing layers of dispersions and pressing the films. We characterized the films for hydrolytic degradation, electrical conductivity, cell proliferation and neurite extension. The co-polymers were sufficient to carry out electrical stimulation of cells without the requirement of a metallic conductor underneath the co-polymer film. In vitro electrical stimulation of PPy-PCL significantly increased the number of PC12 cells bearing neurites compared to unstimulated PPy-PCL. For in vivo experiments, the PPy co-polymers were coated onto the inner walls of nerve guidance channels (NGCs) made of the commercially available non-conducting biodegradable polymer poly(3-hydroxybutyrate-co-3-hydroxyvalerate) (PHB-HV). The NGCs were implanted in a 10 mm defect made in the sciatic nerve of rats, and harvested after 8 weeks. Histological staining showed axonal growth. The studies indicated that these new conducting degradable biomaterials have good biocompatibility and support proliferation and growth of PC12 cells in vitro (with and without electrical stimulation) and neurons in vivo (without electrical stimulation).

Effects of collagen 1, fibronectin, laminin and hyaluronic acid concentration in multi-component gels on neurite extension.

Recovery after peripheral nerve injury remains a significant challenge. Extracellular matrix proteins and hydrogels of extracellular matrix components have been shown to improve regeneration in peripheral nerve entubulation models, especially over long distances. The chemical properties, ligand identity and density, and mechanical properties of the hydrogel can affect neurite extension. However, the importance of combinatorial effects between different components in co-gels of several extracellular matrix components is unclear. In this study, we investigated neurite extension from explanted dorsal root ganglia cultured within co-gels made from laminin, fibronectin, collagen 1 and hyaluronic acid. Laminin had a strong, dose-dependent effect on both neurite length and outgrowth. Fibronectin was slightly, but generally not significantly, inhibitory to neurite extension. The concentration of collagen 1 and hyaluronic acid did not have significant effects on neurite extension. The combinatorial effects among the four components were additive rather than synergistic. A co-gel made with 1.5 mg/ml collagen 1 and 1.5 mg/ml laminin was optimum in this study, resulting in an average neurite length of 1532 +/- 91 microm versus 976 +/- 32 microm for controls, and an increase in overall volume outgrowth (reflecting neurite length and branching) of 85.9+/-9.3% over controls. This co-gel provides a mechanically stable scaffold with high ligand density and biochemical affinity. The results of this study support the use of co-gels of laminin and collagen 1 for promoting regeneration in peripheral nerve injuries and suggest that interactions among hydrogel components are not significant.

Optimized acellular nerve graft is immunologically tolerated and supports regeneration.

To replace the autologous graft as a clinical treatment of peripheral nerve injuries we developed an optimized acellular (OA) nerve graft that retains the extracellular structure of peripheral nerve tissue via an improved chemical decellularization treatment. The process removes cellular membranes from tissue, thus eliminating the antigens responsible for allograft rejection. In the present study, the immunogenicity and regenerative capacity of the OA grafts were tested. Histological examination of the levels of CD(8+) cells and macrophages that infiltrated the OA grafts suggested that the decellularization process averted cell-mediated rejection of the grafts. In a subsequent experiment, regeneration in OA grafts was compared with that in isografts (comparable to the clinical autograft) and two published acellular graft models. After 84 days, the axon density at the midpoints of OA grafts was statistically indistinguishable from that in isografts, 910% higher than in the thermally decellularized model described by Gulati (J. Neurosurg. 68, 117, 1988), and 401% higher than in the chemically decellularized model described by Sondell et al. (Brain Res. 795, 44, 1998). In summary, the results imply that OA grafts are immunologically tolerated and that the removal of cellular material and preservation of the matrix are beneficial for promoting regeneration through an acellular nerve graft.