RESUMEN
PURPOSE: A first of its kind experimental verification of dose-averaged linear energy transfer (LETd) optimized treatment plans for proton therapy has been carried out using a silicon-on-insulator microdosimeter at the Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH), Boston, USA. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Three clinical treatment plans of a typical ependymoma structure set were designed using the standard clinical approach, the proposed protocol approach, and a one-field approach. The plans were then reoptimized to reduce the LETd-weighted dose in the brain stem. All six plans were delivered in a solid water phantom and the experimental yDâ¾ measured. RESULTS: After LETd optimization, a reduction in yDâ¾ was found within the brain stem by an average of 12%, 19%, and 4% for the clinical, protocol, and one-field plans, respectively, while maintaining adequate coverage of the tumor structure. The experimental LETd-weighted doses were in agreement with the treatment planning system calculations and Monte Carlo simulations and reinforced the improvement of the optimization. CONCLUSIONS: This work demonstrates the first experimental verification of the clinical implementation of LETd optimization for patient treatment with proton therapy.
Asunto(s)
Neoplasias Encefálicas , Ependimoma , Transferencia Lineal de Energía , Método de Montecarlo , Fantasmas de Imagen , Terapia de Protones , Dosificación Radioterapéutica , Planificación de la Radioterapia Asistida por Computador , Planificación de la Radioterapia Asistida por Computador/métodos , Humanos , Terapia de Protones/métodos , Neoplasias Encefálicas/radioterapia , Neoplasias Encefálicas/diagnóstico por imagen , Ependimoma/radioterapia , Ependimoma/diagnóstico por imagen , Radiometría/métodos , Radiometría/instrumentación , Tronco Encefálico/diagnóstico por imagen , Silicio , Órganos en Riesgo/efectos de la radiaciónRESUMEN
The use of field-specific apertures, routine in scattered or uniform-scanned proton fields, are still a necessity in pencil-beam scanned (PBS) fields to sharpen the penumbral edge at low energies and in high fraction dose application beyond that achievable with small spot size. We describe a model implemented in our clinical pencil-beam algorithm that models the insertion of a shaped aperture, including shapes adapted per energy layer such as may be achieved with a multi-leaf collimator. The model decomposes the spot transport into discrete steps. The first step transport a uniform intensity field of high-resolution sub-pencil-beams at the layer energy through the medium. This transport only considers primary scattering in both the patient and an optional range-shifter. The second step models the aperture areas and edge penumbral transition as a modulation of the uniform intensity. The third step convolves individual steps over the uniform-transported field including the aperture-modified intensities. We also introduce an efficient model based on a Clarkson sector integration for nuclear scattered halo protons. This avoids the explicit modeling of long range halo protons to the detriment of computational efficiency in calculation and optimization. We demonstrate that the aperture effect is primarily due to in-patient and shifter scattering with a small contribution from the apparent beam source position. The model provides insight into the primary physics contributions to the penumbra and the nuclear halo. The model allowed us to fully deploy our PBS capacity at our two-gantry center without which PBS treatments would have been inferior compared to scattered fields with apertures. Finally, Monte Carlo calculations have (nearly) replaced phenomenological pencil-beam models for collimated fields. Phenomenological models do, however, allow exposition of underlying clinical phenomena and closer connection to representative clinical observables.
Asunto(s)
Terapia de Protones , Protones , Algoritmos , Humanos , Dosificación Radioterapéutica , Planificación de la Radioterapia Asistida por ComputadorRESUMEN
Setup and range uncertainties compromise radiotherapy plan robustness. We introduce a method to evaluate the clinical effect of these uncertainties on the population using tumor control probability (TCP) and normal tissue complication probability (NTCP) models. Eighteen oropharyngeal cancer patients treated with curative intent were retrospectively included. Both photon (VMAT) and proton (IMPT) plans were created using a planning target volume as planning objective. Plans were recalculated for uncertainty scenarios: two for range over/undershoot (IMPT) or CT-density scaling (VMAT), six for shifts. An average shift scenario ([Formula: see text]) was calculated to assess random errors. Dose differences between nominal and scenarios were translated to TCP (2 models) and NTCP (15 models). A weighted average (W_Avg) of the TCP\NTCP based on Gaussian distribution over the variance scenarios was calculated to assess the clinical effect of systematic errors on the population. TCP/NTCP uncertainties were larger in IMPT compared to VMAT. Although individual perturbations showed risks of plan deterioration, the [Formula: see text] scenario did not show a substantial decrease in any of the TCP endpoints suggesting evaluated plans in this cohort were robust for random errors. Evaluation of the W_Avg scenario to assess systematic errors showed in VMAT no substantial decrease in TCP endpoints and in IMPT a limited decrease. In IMPT, the W_Avg scenario had a mean TCP loss of 0%-2% depending on plan type and primary or nodal control. The W_Avg for NTCP endpoints was around 0%, except for mandible necrosis in IMPT (W_Avg: 3%). The estimated population impact of setup and range uncertainties on TCP/NTCP following VMAT or IMPT of oropharyngeal cancer patients was small for both treatment modalities. The use of TCP/NTCP models allows for clinical interpretation of the population effect and could be considered for incorporation in robust evaluation methods. Highlights: - TCP/NTCP models allow for a clinical evaluation of uncertainty scenarios. - For this cohort, in silico-PTV based IMPT plans and VMAT plans were robust for random setup errors. - Effect of systematic errors on the population was limited: mean TCP loss was 0%-2%.
Asunto(s)
Neoplasias Orofaríngeas/radioterapia , Terapia de Protones/efectos adversos , Planificación de la Radioterapia Asistida por Computador/métodos , Radioterapia de Intensidad Modulada/efectos adversos , Incertidumbre , Algoritmos , Humanos , Modelos Estadísticos , Distribución Normal , Órganos en Riesgo/efectos de la radiación , Probabilidad , Dosificación Radioterapéutica , Estudios RetrospectivosRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: In scanned proton beam therapy systematic deviations in spot size at iso-center can occur as a result of changes in the beam-line optics. There is currently no general guideline of the spot size accuracy required clinically. In this work we quantify treatment plan robustness to systematic spot size variations as a function of spot size and spot spacing, and we suggest guidelines for tolerance levels for spot size variations. METHODS: Through perturbation of spot size in treatment plans for 7 patients and a phantom, we evaluated the dose impact of systematic spot size variations of 5% up to 50%. We investigated the dependence on nominal spot size by studying scenarios with small, medium and large spot sizes for various inter-spot spacings. To come to tolerance levels, we used the Γ passing rate and dose-volume-histograms. RESULTS: Limits on spot size accuracy were extracted for 8 sites, 3 different spot sizes and 3 different inter-spot spacings. While the allowable spot size variation strongly depends on the spot size, the inter-spot spacing turned out to be only of limited influence. CONCLUSIONS: Plan robustness to spot size variations strongly depend on spot size, with small spot plans being much more robust than larger spots plans. Inter-spot spacing did not influence plan robustness. Combining our results with existing literature, we propose limits of ±25%, ±20% and ±10% of the spot width σ, for spots with σ of 2.5, 5.0 and 10â¯mm in proton therapy spot scanning facilities, respectively.
Asunto(s)
Terapia de Protones/métodos , Dosis de Radiación , Humanos , Fantasmas de Imagen , Dosificación Radioterapéutica , Planificación de la Radioterapia Asistida por ComputadorRESUMEN
PURPOSE: To characterize the modulation transfer function (MTF) of proton radiography using GEANT4 Monte Carlo simulations. METHODS: A phantom was specifically modeled using five main materials: bone (1.92 g/cm3 ), muscle (1.2 g/cm3 ), water (1.0 g/cm3 ), adipose tissue (0.9 g/cm3 ), and lung (0.3 g/cm3 ). The basic geometry of the phantom consists of cube-shaped inserts of biological materials placed in water. The thickness of the water, the size of the cube, the depth of the cube in the water, and the proton beam energy have all been varied and studied. The contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) between the two materials was evaluated at multiple points along a line-of-interest (LOI) in order to ultimately characterize the spatial resolution by the 10% point of the modulation-transfer-function (MTF10% or MTF 10). RESULTS: The MTF was generated for interfaces of water-lung, water-bone, water-muscle, water-adipose. This study indicates that proton radiography can distinguish one material from another with a resolution better than 1 mm for water-adipose and water-muscle or sub-millimeter in cases of water-bone and water-lung interfaces. CONCLUSIONS: The sub-millimeter resolution of proton radiography offers clinicians a potentially tool in specific tumor diagnostics (such as in lung cancer), patient-setup for daily proton therapy, and the reduction of absorbed dose delivered when compared to photon imaging.
RESUMEN
PURPOSE: Patient specific apertures are commonly employed in passive double scattering (DS) proton therapy (PT). This study was aimed at identifying the potential benefits of using such an aperture in pencil beam scanning (PBS). METHODS: An accurate Geant4 Monte Carlo model of the PBS PT treatment head at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) was developed based on an existing model of the passive double-scattering (DS) system. The Monte Carlo code specifies the treatment head at MGH with sub-millimeter accuracy and was configured based on the results of experimental measurements performed at MGH. This model was then used to compare out-of-field doses in simulated DS treatments and PBS treatments. The PBS treatments were simulated both with and without the patient-specific aperture used in the DS treatment. RESULTS: For the conditions explored, a typical prostate field, the lateral penumbra in PBS is wider than in DS, leading to higher absorbed doses and equivalent doses adjacent to the primary field edge. For lateral distances greater than 10cm from the field edge, the doses in PBS appear to be lower than those observed for DS. Including an aperture at nozzle exit reduces the penumbral width by preventing wide-angle scatter from reaching the patient. This can reduce the dose in PBS for lateral distances of less than 10cm from the field edge by over an order of magnitude and allow better dose conformity. CONCLUSIONS: Placing a patient-specific aperture at nozzle exit during PBS treatments can potentially reduce doses lateral to the primary radiation field by over an order of magnitude. This has the potential to further improve the normal tissue sparing capabilities of PBS. The magnitude of this effect depends on the beam spot size of the scanning system and is thus facility dependent.
RESUMEN
PURPOSE: To ensure the quality assurance of small field, dynamic radiotherapy, we present and validate a radiation tracking system based on long scintillating fibers that allows for the real-time measurement of the position and energetic fluence of a small incident radiation field. METHOD: We aligned 60 parallel scintillating fibers on a thin grooved acrylic slab with a 100-cm source-to-fibers distance. Both ends of each scintillating fiber were coupled to clear optical fibers to enable light collection by a single CCD camera using an f/0.95, 50 mm focal length lens. Using a small, static photon radiation field of 2×2 cm2 of a Varian Clinac iX, we changed the interaction position on the prototype using the linac treatment couch. The interaction position parallel and perpendicular to the scintillating fiber array were deduced using the optical attenuation of the scintillating fibers. The energetic fluence of the incident field was calculated from the fibers light fluxes, corrected for the position dependent optical attenuation and scintillation efficiency. RESULTS: Considering a treatment couch positioning error of ±0.5 mm, the system was able to measure the field position with a mean error of 0.1 mm perpendicular and 0.8 mm parallel to the scintillating fiber array. The maximum error measured using this setup was of 0.13 mm perpendicular and 3.2 mm parallel to the scintillating fiber array. The energetic fluence was determined with a mean error of 0.5% and a maximum error of 2.2%. CONCLUSIONS: This work demonstrates the capacity of a long scintillating fibers array to detect in real-time both the position and the energetic fluence of an incident small radiation field. Such methodology would allow for the real-time tracking of small field in both photon and particle radiation therapy.