Diagnostics of RF coupling in H- ion sources as a tool for optimizing source design and operational parameters.

Radio frequency (RF) driven H- ion sources are operated at very high power levels of up 100 kW in order to achieve the desired performance. For the experimental setup, these are demanding conditions possibly limiting the source reliability. Therefore, assessing the optimization potential in terms of RF power losses and the RF power transfer efficiency η to the plasma has moved to the focus of both experimental and numerical modeling investigations at particle accelerator and neutral beam heating sources for fusion plasmas. It has been demonstrated that, e.g., at typical neutral beam injection ion source setups, about half of the RF power provided by the generator is lost in the RF coil and the Faraday shield due to Joule heating or via eddy currents. In a best practice approach, it is exemplarily demonstrated at the ITER RF prototype ion source how experimental evaluation accompanied by numerical modeling of the ion source can be used to improve η. Individual optimization measures regarding the Faraday shield, the RF coil, the discharge geometry, the RF driving frequency, and the application of ferrites are discussed, which could reduce the losses by a factor of two. The provided examples are intended as exemplary guidelines, which can be applied at other setups in order to achieve with low-risk effort an optimized ion source design in terms of reduced losses and hence increased reliability.

Emission spectroscopy of negative hydrogen ion sources: From VUV to IR.

The target parameters of negative ion sources regarding the current of extracted negative ions, the current of co-extracted electrons, the pulse duration, the duty cycle, and the availability of the system can be rather strict. Knowledge of plasma parameters such as the electron temperature and the electron density and also properties of molecules or photon fluxes can provide essential insights into the ion source physics needed for reaching the target parameters. Emission spectroscopy is a non-invasive tool enabling access to line-of-sight averaged values of plasma parameters. This paper gives an overview of the application of emission spectroscopy in the visible range, extended for long wavelengths to the near-IR and for short wavelengths to the vacuum ultraviolet (VUV)/UV range. The amount of information to be gained from measured emission spectra is directly correlated with the effort invested for calibrating the system. Examples are given, ranging from simple monitoring to the complex evaluation of molecular spectra and the determination of highly energetic photon fluxes in the VUV/UV range. Additional emphasis is laid on the population models needed for the interpretation of measured spectra.

Cavity ring-down spectroscopy system for the evaluation of negative hydrogen ion density at the ELISE test facility.

The large RF negative hydrogen (deuterium) ion source at the ELISE test facility (half of the ITER-NBI source size) has been equipped with a Cavity Ring-Down Spectroscopy (CRDS) system, in order to measure the negative hydrogen (deuterium) ion density in the region in front of the plasma grid (first grid of the extraction system). The challenge of this diagnostic for ELISE relies on the large size of the source and therefore on the plasma length across which the measurements are performed as well as the long pulses at RF power, which can affect the cavity mirror reliability. A dedicated experiment on the mirror reliability was performed, ensuring the feasibility of measurements for long pulses (several hundred seconds) at high RF power. Two horizontal lines of sight were dedicated to CRDS: the measured density was in the range between 4 × 1016 and 1 × 1017 m-3, with a slightly higher density for the bottom lines of sight, for both the isotope hydrogen and deuterium. Different temporal evolution was observed for the two isotopes, showing a higher instability for the deuterium case: this is in correlation with the extracted negative ion current density and inversely correlated with the coextracted electron current density. The CRDS system allowed performing the first measurements of negative ion density for a long pulse (1000 s) in a large source: the temporal behavior and the effect of the beam extraction will also be discussed.

Beamlet scraping and its influence on the beam divergence at the BATMAN Upgrade test facility.

For the ITER fusion experiment, two neutral beam injectors are required for plasma heating and current drive. Each injector supplies a power of about 17 MW, obtained from neutralization of 40 A (46 A), 1 MeV (0.87 MeV) negative deuterium (hydrogen) ions. The full beam is composed of 1280 beamlets, formed in 16 beamlet groups, and strict requirements apply to the beamlet core divergence (<7 mrad). The test facility BATMAN Upgrade uses an ITER-like grid with one beamlet group, which consists of 70 apertures. In a joint campaign performed by IPP and Consorzio RFX to better assess the beam optics, the divergence of a single beamlet was compared to a group of beamlets at BATMAN Upgrade. The single beamlet is measured with a carbon fiber composite tile calorimeter and by beam emission spectroscopy, whereas the divergence of the group of beamlets is measured by beam emission spectroscopy only. When increasing the RF power at low extraction voltages, the divergence of the beamlet and of the group of beamlets is continuously decreasing and no inflection point toward an overperveant beam is found. At the same time, scraping of the extracted ion beam at the second grid (extraction grid) takes place at higher RF power, supported by the absence of the normally seen linear behavior between the measured negative ion density in the plasma close to the extraction system and the measured extracted ion current. Beside its influence on the divergence, beamlet scraping needs to be considered for the determination of the correct perveance and contributes to the measured coextracted electron current.

Formation of large negative deuterium ion beams at ELISE.

Negative ion sources for neutral beam injection (NBI) in fusion experiments are based on the surface production of H- or D- on cesiated low work function surfaces. In the recent years, it was demonstrated at the large RF driven ion source of the ELISE (Extraction from a Large Ion Source Experiment) test facility that the requirements for the ITER NBI systems can be fulfilled by hydrogen. This is a big step toward the first operational period of ITER, planned for up to 2035. However, for the following operational period, neutral beam systems working in deuterium are needed. Operation of negative hydrogen ion sources in deuterium is significantly more demanding than in hydrogen: the amount of coextracted electrons is much higher and their increase during pulses is much more pronounced, limiting the achievable performance. This paper presents the results of investigations aimed to improve the insight into the physics related to this isotope effect. Due to the higher atomic mass of deuterium, cesium is removed much more effectively from reservoirs at the walls, resulting in a depletion of these reservoirs and a strongly increased cesium density in the plasma. Additionally, a correlation between the fluxes of charged particles toward the inner ion source surfaces and the coextracted electrons is identified.

Neutron measurements at the ELISE neutral beam test facility and implications for neutron based diagnostics at SPIDER.

Along the route to the development of a neutral beam injector for ITER, the Padua based Source for Production of Ion of Deuterium Extracted from Rf plasma (SPIDER) and megavolt ITER injector and concept advancement facilities will make use of neutron diagnostics to quantify the homogeneity of the neutral beam profile by measuring the map of the neutron emission from the beam dump with the close-contact neutron emission surface mapping (CNESM) system. Neutrons are here produced from beam-target reactions between the deuterium beam and the deuterons previously adsorbed in the calorimeter. In order to aid the interpretation of the diagnostic data, a dedicated experiment on neutron emission from beam-target reactions with beam parameters approaching those expected at SPIDER has been performed at the Extraction from a Large Ion Source Experiment (ELISE) neutral beam test facility. The time trace of neutron emission has been measured using a calibrated liquid scintillator detector at increasing power densities on the target. Compared to calculations based on the local mixing model, a systematic discrepancy was observed exceeding the statistical accuracy of the measurements and increasing as a linear function of the power density. The data are used to derive an empirical temperature dependent correction for applications to neutron measurements at SPIDER.

Deuterium results at the negative ion source test facility ELISE.

The ITER neutral beam system will be equipped with large radio frequency (RF) driven negative ion sources, with a cross section of 0.9 m × 1.9 m, which have to deliver extracted D- ion beams of 57 A at 1 MeV for 1 h. On the extraction from a large ion source experiment test facility, a source of half of this size is being operational since 2013. The goal of this experiment is to demonstrate a high operational reliability and to achieve the extracted current densities and beam properties required for ITER. Technical improvements of the source design and the RF system were necessary to provide reliable operation in steady state with an RF power of up to 300 kW. While in short pulses the required D- current density has almost been reached, the performance in long pulses is determined in particular in Deuterium by inhomogeneous and unstable currents of co-extracted electrons. By application of refined caesium evaporation and distribution procedures, and reduction and symmetrization of the electron currents, considerable progress has been made and up to 190 A/m2 D-, corresponding to 66% of the value required for ITER, have been extracted for 45 min.

Determination of discharge parameters via OES at the Linac4 H⁻ ion source.

Optical emission spectroscopy (OES) measurements of the atomic Balmer series and the molecular Fulcher transition have been carried out at the Linac4 ion source in order to determine plasma parameters. As the spectroscopic system was only relatively calibrated, the data evaluation only yielded rough estimates of the plasma parameters (T(e) ≈ 1.2 eV, n(e) ≈ 1 × 10(19) m(-3), and n(H/)n(H2) ≈ 0.5 at standard operational parameters). The analysis of the Fulcher transition revealed a non-thermal "hockey-stick" rotational population of the hydrogen molecules. At varying RF power, the measurements at the on-axis line of sight (LOS) showed a peak in the rotational temperatures between 25 and 40 kW of RF power, whereas a steady decrease with power was observed at a tilted LOS, indicating the presence of strong plasma parameter gradients.

Installation of spectrally selective imaging system in RF negative ion source.

A spectrally selective imaging system has been installed in the RF negative ion source in the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor-relevant negative ion beam test facility ELISE (Extraction from a Large Ion Source Experiment) to investigate distribution of hydrogen Balmer-α emission (Hα) close to the production surface of hydrogen negative ion. We selected a GigE vision camera coupled with an optical band-path filter, which can be controlled remotely using high speed network connection. A distribution of Hα emission near the bias plate has been clearly observed. The same time trend on Hα intensities measured by the imaging diagnostic and the optical emission spectroscopy is confirmed.

Linac4 H⁻ ion sources.

CERN's 160 MeV H(-) linear accelerator (Linac4) is a key constituent of the injector chain upgrade of the Large Hadron Collider that is being installed and commissioned. A cesiated surface ion source prototype is being tested and has delivered a beam intensity of 45 mA within an emittance of 0.3 π ⋅ mm ⋅ mrad. The optimum ratio of the co-extracted electron- to ion-current is below 1 and the best production efficiency, defined as the ratio of the beam current to the 2 MHz RF-power transmitted to the plasma, reached 1.1 mA/kW. The H(-) source prototype and the first tests of the new ion source optics, electron-dump, and front end developed to minimize the beam emittance are presented. A temperature regulated magnetron H(-) source developed by the Brookhaven National Laboratory was built at CERN. The first tests of the magnetron operated at 0.8 Hz repetition rate are described.

Towards 20 A negative hydrogen ion beams for up to 1 h: Achievements of the ELISE test facility (invited).

The large-scale RF-driven ion source of the test facility extraction from a large ion source experiment is aimed to deliver an accelerated ion current of 20 A D(-) (23 A H(-)) with an extracted electron-to-ion ratio below one for up to 1 h. Since the first plasma pulses for 20 s in volume operation in early 2013, followed by caesiation of the ion source, substantial progress has been achieved in extending the pulse length and the RF power. The record pulses in hydrogen are stable 400 s pulses with an extracted ion current of 18.3 A at 180 kW total RF power and 9.3 A at 80 kW stable for 1 h. For deuterium pulse, length and RF power are limited by the amount of co-extracted electrons.

Investigation of the boundary layer during the transition from volume to surface dominated H⁻ production at the BATMAN test facility.

BATMAN (Bavarian Test Machine for Negative ions) is a test facility equipped with a 18 scale H(-) source for the ITER heating neutral beam injection. Several diagnostics in the boundary layer close to the plasma grid (first grid of the accelerator system) followed the transition from volume to surface dominated H(-) production starting with a Cs-free, cleaned source and subsequent evaporation of caesium, while the source has been operated at ITER relevant pressure of 0.3 Pa: Langmuir probes are used to determine the plasma potential, optical emission spectroscopy is used to follow the caesiation process, and cavity ring-down spectroscopy allows for the measurement of the H(-) density. The influence on the plasma during the transition from an electron-ion plasma towards an ion-ion plasma, in which negative hydrogen ions become the dominant negatively charged particle species, is seen in a strong increase of the H(-) density combined with a reduction of the plasma potential. A clear correlation of the extracted current densities (j(H(-)), j(e)) exists with the Cs emission.

Concepts of magnetic filter fields in powerful negative ion sources for fusion.

The performance of large negative ion sources used in neutral beam injection systems is in long pulses mainly determined by the increase of the currents of co-extracted electrons. This is in particular a problem in deuterium and limits the ion currents which are for long pulses below the requirements for the ITER source. In the source of the ELISE test facility, the magnetic field in front of the first grid, which is essential to reduce the electron current, is generated by a current of several kA flowing through the plasma facing grid. Weakening of this field by the addition of permanent magnets placed close to the lateral walls has led to a reduction of the electron current by a factor three without loss of ion current when source was operated in volume production. If this effect can be validated for the cesiated source, it would be a large step towards achieving the ITER parameter in long pulses.

First hydrogen operation of NIO1: Characterization of the source plasma by means of an optical emission spectroscopy diagnostic.

NIO1 (Negative Ion Optimization 1) is a compact and flexible radio frequency H(-) ion source, developed by Consorzio RFX and INFN-LNL. The aim of the experimentation on NIO1 is the optimization of both the production of negative ions and their extraction and beam optics. In the initial phase of its commissioning, NIO1 was operated with nitrogen, but now the source is regularly operated also with hydrogen. To evaluate the source performances, an optical emission spectroscopy diagnostic was installed. The system includes a low resolution spectrometer in the spectral range of 300-850 nm and a high resolution (50 pm) one, to study, respectively, the atomic and the molecular emissions in the visible range. The spectroscopic data have been interpreted also by means of a collisional-radiative model developed at IPP Garching. Besides the diagnostic hardware and the data analysis methods, the paper presents the first plasma measurements across a transition to the full H mode, in a hydrogen discharge. The characteristic signatures of this transition in the plasma parameters are described, in particular, the sudden increase of the light emitted from the plasma above a certain power threshold.

Fundamental studies on the Cs dynamics under ion source conditions.

The performance of surface conversion based negative hydrogen ion sources is mainly determined by the caesium dynamics. Therefore, fundamental investigations in vacuum and plasma are performed at a flexible laboratory setup with ion source parameters. Studies on the influence of Cs on the plasma parameters of H2 and D2 plasmas showed that ne and Te in the bulk plasma are not affected by relevant amounts of Cs and no isotopic differences could be observed. The coating of the vessel surfaces with Cs, however, leads to a considerable gettering of hydrogen atoms from the plasma volume and to the decrease of ne close to a sample surface due to the formation of negative ions.

Modeling of neutrals in the Linac4 H(-) ion source plasma: hydrogen atom production density profile and Hα intensity by collisional radiative model.

To control the H(0) atom production profile in the H(-) ion sources is one of the important issues for the efficient and uniform surface H(-) production. The purpose of this study is to construct a collisional radiative (CR) model to calculate the effective production rate of H(0) atoms from H2 molecules in the model geometry of the radio-frequency (RF) H(-) ion source for Linac4 accelerator. In order to validate the CR model by comparison with the experimental results from the optical emission spectroscopy, it is also necessary for the model to calculate Balmer photon emission rate in the source. As a basic test of the model, the time evolutions of H(0) production and the Balmer Hα photon emission rate are calculated for given electron energy distribution functions in the Linac4 RF H(-) ion source. Reasonable test results are obtained and basis for the detailed comparisons with experimental results have been established.

3D numerical simulations of negative hydrogen ion extraction using realistic plasma parameters, geometry of the extraction aperture and full 3D magnetic field map.

Decreasing the co-extracted electron current while simultaneously keeping negative ion (NI) current sufficiently high is a crucial issue on the development plasma source system for ITER Neutral Beam Injector. To support finding the best extraction conditions the 3D Particle-in-Cell Monte Carlo Collision electrostatic code ONIX (Orsay Negative Ion eXtraction) has been developed. Close collaboration with experiments and other numerical models allows performing realistic simulations with relevant input parameters: plasma properties, geometry of the extraction aperture, full 3D magnetic field map, etc. For the first time ONIX has been benchmarked with commercial positive ions tracing code KOBRA3D. A very good agreement in terms of the meniscus position and depth has been found. Simulation of NI extraction with different e/NI ratio in bulk plasma shows high relevance of the direct negative ion extraction from the surface produced NI in order to obtain extracted NI current as in the experimental results from BATMAN testbed.

First results of the ITER-relevant negative ion beam test facility ELISE (invited).

An important step in the European R&D roadmap towards the neutral beam heating systems of ITER is the new test facility ELISE (Extraction from a Large Ion Source Experiment) for large-scale extraction from a half-size ITER RF source. The test facility was constructed in the last years at Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik Garching and is now operational. ELISE is gaining early experience of the performance and operation of large RF-driven negative hydrogen ion sources with plasma illumination of a source area of 1 × 0.9 m(2) and an extraction area of 0.1 m(2) using 640 apertures. First results in volume operation, i.e., without caesium seeding, are presented.

Ways to improve the efficiency and reliability of radio frequency driven negative ion sources for fusion.

Large RF driven negative hydrogen ion sources are being developed at IPP Garching for the future neutral beam injection system of ITER. The overall power efficiency of these sources is low, because for the RF power supply self-excited generators are utilized and the plasma is generated in small cylindrical sources ("drivers") and expands into the source main volume. At IPP experiments to reduce the primary power and the RF power required for the plasma production are performed in two ways: The oscillator generator of the prototype source has been replaced by a transistorized RF transmitter and two alternative driver concepts, a spiral coil, in which the field is concentrated by ferrites, which omits the losses by plasma expansion and a helicon source are being tested.