Several common methods of making vesicles (except an emulsion method) capture intended lipid ratios.

Researchers choose different methods of making giant unilamellar vesicles in order to satisfy different constraints of their experimental designs. A challenge of using a variety of methods is that each may produce vesicles of different lipid compositions, even if all vesicles are made from a common stock mixture. Here, we use mass spectrometry to investigate ratios of lipids in vesicles made by five common methods: electroformation on indium tin oxide slides, electroformation on platinum wires, gentle hydration, emulsion transfer, and extrusion. We made vesicles from either 5-component or binary mixtures of lipids chosen to span a wide range of physical properties: di(18:1)PC, di(16:0)PC, di(18:1)PG, di(12:0)PE, and cholesterol. For a mixture of all five of these lipids, ITO electroformation, Pt electroformation, gentle hydration, and extrusion methods result in only minor shifts (≤ 5 mol%) in lipid ratios of vesicles relative to a common stock solution. In contrast, emulsion transfer results in ∼80% less cholesterol than expected from the stock solution, which is counterbalanced by a surprising overabundance of saturated PC-lipid relative to all other phospholipids. Experiments using binary mixtures of some of the lipids largely support results from the 5-component mixture. Exact values of lipid ratios variations likely depend on the details of each method, so a broader conclusion is that experiments that increment lipid ratios in small steps will be highly sensitive to the method of lipid formation and to sample-to-sample variations, which are low (roughly ±2 mol% in the 5-component mixture and either scale proportionally with increasing mole fraction or remain low). Experiments that increment lipid ratios in larger steps or that seek to explain general trends or new phenomena will be less sensitive to the method used. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Small changes to the amounts and types of lipids in membranes can drastically affect the membrane's behavior. Unfortunately, it is unknown whether (or to what extent) different methods of making vesicles alter the ratios of lipids in membranes, even when identical stock solutions are used. This presents challenges for researchers when comparing data with colleagues who use different methods. Here, we measure ratios of lipid types in vesicle membranes produced by five methods. We assess each method's reproducibility and compare resulting vesicle compositions across methods. In doing so, we provide a quantitative basis that the scientific community can use to estimate whether differences between their results can be simply attributed to differences between methods or to sample-to-sample variations.

Sterol-lipids enable large-scale, liquid-liquid phase separation in bilayer membranes of only 2 components.

Despite longstanding excitement and progress toward understanding liquid-liquid phase separation in natural and artificial membranes, fundamental questions have persisted about which molecules are required for this phenomenon. Except in extraordinary circumstances, the smallest number of components that has produced large-scale, liquid-liquid phase separation in bilayers has stubbornly remained at three: a sterol, a phospholipid with ordered chains, and a phospholipid with disordered chains. This requirement of three components is puzzling because only two components are required for liquid-liquid phase separation in lipid monolayers, which resemble half of a bilayer. Inspired by reports that sterols interact closely with lipids with ordered chains, we tested whether phase separation would occur in bilayers in which a sterol and lipid were replaced by a single, joined sterol-lipid. By evaluating a panel of sterol-lipids, some of which are found in bacteria, we discovered a minimal bilayer of only two components (PChemsPC and diPhyPC) that robustly demixes into micron-scale, liquid phases. It suggests a new role for sterol-lipids in nature, and it reveals a membrane in which tie-lines (and, therefore, the lipid composition of each phase) are straightforward to determine and will be consistent across multiple laboratories. Significance Statement: A wide diversity of bilayer membranes, from those with hundreds of lipids (e.g., vacuoles of living yeast cells) to those with very few (e.g., artificial vesicles) phase separate into micron-scale liquid domains. The number of components required for liquid-liquid phase separation has been perplexing: only two should be necessary, but more are required except in extraordinary circumstances. What minimal set of molecular characteristics leads to liquid-liquid phase separation in bilayer membranes? This question inspired us to search for single, joined "sterol-lipid" molecules to replace both a sterol and a phospholipid in membranes undergoing liquid-liquid phase separation. By producing phase-separating membranes with only two components, we mitigate experimental challenges in determining tie-lines and in maintaining constant chemical potentials of lipids.

Coupling liquid phases in 3D condensates and 2D membranes: Successes, challenges, and tools.

This review describes the major experimental challenges researchers meet when attempting to couple phase separation between membranes and condensates. Although it is well known that phase separation in a 2D membrane could affect molecules capable of forming a 3D condensate (and vice versa), few researchers have quantified the effects to date. The scarcity of these measurements is not due to a lack of intense interest or effort in the field. Rather, it reflects significant experimental challenges in manipulating coupled membranes and condensates to yield quantitative values. These challenges transcend many molecular details, which means they impact a wide range of systems. This review highlights recent exciting successes in the field, and it lays out a comprehensive list of tools that address potential pitfalls for researchers who are considering coupling membranes with condensates.

Remodeling of yeast vacuole membrane lipidomes from the log (one phase) to stationary stage (two phases).

Upon nutrient limitation, budding yeast of Saccharomyces cerevisiae shift from fast growth (the log stage) to quiescence (the stationary stage). This shift is accompanied by liquid-liquid phase separation in the membrane of the vacuole, an endosomal organelle. Recent work indicates that the resulting micrometer-scale domains in vacuole membranes enable yeast to survive periods of stress. An outstanding question is which molecular changes might cause this membrane phase separation. Here, we conduct lipidomics of vacuole membranes in both the log and stationary stages. Isolation of pure vacuole membranes is challenging in the stationary stage, when lipid droplets are in close contact with vacuoles. Immuno-isolation has previously been shown to successfully purify log-stage vacuole membranes with high organelle specificity, but it was not previously possible to immuno-isolate stationary-stage vacuole membranes. Here, we develop Mam3 as a bait protein for vacuole immuno-isolation, and demonstrate low contamination by non-vacuolar membranes. We find that stationary-stage vacuole membranes contain surprisingly high fractions of phosphatidylcholine lipids (∼40%), roughly twice as much as log-stage membranes. Moreover, in the stationary stage, these lipids have higher melting temperatures, due to longer and more saturated acyl chains. Another surprise is that no significant change in sterol content is observed. These lipidomic changes, which are largely reflected on the whole-cell level, fit within the predominant view that phase separation in membranes requires at least three types of molecules to be present: lipids with high melting temperatures, lipids with low melting temperatures, and sterols.

Plausible Sources of Membrane-Forming Fatty Acids on the Early Earth: A Review of the Literature and an Estimation of Amounts.

The first cells were plausibly bounded by membranes assembled from fatty acids with at least 8 carbons. Although the presence of fatty acids on the early Earth is widely assumed within the astrobiology community, there is no consensus regarding their origin and abundance. In this Review, we highlight three possible sources of fatty acids: (1) delivery by carbonaceous meteorites, (2) synthesis on metals delivered by impactors, and (3) electrochemical synthesis by spark discharges. We also discuss fatty acid synthesis by UV or particle irradiation, gas-phase ion-molecule reactions, and aqueous redox reactions. We compare estimates for the total mass of fatty acids supplied to Earth by each source during the Hadean eon after an extremely massive asteroid impact that would have reset Earth's fatty acid inventory. We find that synthesis on iron-rich surfaces derived from the massive impactor in contact with an impact-generated reducing atmosphere could have contributed ∼102 times more total mass of fatty acids than subsequent delivery by either carbonaceous meteorites or electrochemical synthesis. Additionally, we estimate that a single carbonaceous meteorite would not deliver a high enough concentration of fatty acids (∼15 mM for decanoic acid) into an existing body of water on the Earth's surface to spontaneously form membranes unless the fatty acids were further concentrated by another mechanism, such as subsequent evaporation of the water. Our estimates rely heavily on various assumptions, leading to significant uncertainties; nevertheless, these estimates provide rough order-of-magnitude comparisons of various sources of fatty acids on the early Earth. We also suggest specific experiments to improve future estimates. Our calculations support the view that fatty acids would have been available on the early Earth. Further investigation is needed to assess the mechanisms by which fatty acids could have been concentrated sufficiently to assemble into membranes during the origin of life.

Growth of Prebiotically Plausible Fatty Acid Vesicles Proceeds in the Presence of Prebiotic Amino Acids, Dipeptides, Sugars, and Nucleic Acid Components.

Fatty acid vesicles may have played a role in the origin of life as a major structural component of protocells, with the potential for encapsulation of genetic materials. Vesicles that grew and divided more rapidly than other vesicles could have had a selective advantage. Fatty acid vesicles grow by incorporating additional fatty acids from micelles, and certain prebiotic molecules (e.g., sugars, nucleobases, and amino acids) can bind to fatty acid vesicles and stabilize them. Here, we investigated whether the presence of a variety of biomolecules affects the overall growth of vesicles composed of decanoic acid, a prebiotically plausible fatty acid, upon micelle addition. We tested 31 molecules, including 15 dipeptides, 7 amino acids, 6 nucleobases or nucleosides, and 3 sugars. We find that the initial radius and final radius of vesicles are largely unaffected by the presence of the additional compounds. However, three dipeptides enhanced the initial rates of growth compared to control vesicles with no small molecules added; another three dipeptides decreased the initial rates of growth. We conclude that vesicles can indeed grow in the presence of a wide range of molecules likely to have been involved in the origin of life. These results imply that vesicles would have been able to grow in complex and heterogeneous chemical environments. We find that the molecules that enhance the initial growth rate tend to have hydrophobic groups (e.g., leucine), which may interact with the lipid membrane to affect growth rate; furthermore, the molecules that cause the largest decrease in initial growth rate are dipeptides containing a serine residue, which contains a hydroxyl group that could potentially hydrogen-bond with the fatty acid carboxylate groups.

Prebiotic Vesicles Retain Solutes and Grow by Micelle Addition after Brief Cooling below the Membrane Melting Temperature.

Replication of RNA genomes within membrane vesicles may have been a critical step in the development of protocells on the early Earth. Cold temperatures near 0 °C improve the stability of RNA and allow efficient copying, while some climate models suggest a cold early Earth, so the first protocells may have arisen in cold-temperature environments. However, at cold temperatures, saturated fatty acids, which would have been available on the early Earth, form gel-phase membranes that are rigid and restrict mobility within the bilayer. Two primary roles of protocell membranes are to encapsulate solutes and to grow by incorporating additional fatty acids from the environment. We test here whether fatty acid membranes in the gel phase accomplish these roles. We find that gel-phase membranes of 10-carbon amphiphiles near 0 °C encapsulate aqueous dye molecules as efficiently as fluid-phase membranes do, but the contents are released if the aqueous solution is frozen at -20 °C. Gel-phase membranes do not grow measurably by micelle addition, but growth resumes when membranes are warmed above the gel-liquid transition temperature. We find that longer, 12-carbon amphiphiles do not retain encapsulated contents near 0 °C. Together, our results suggest that protocells could have developed within environments that experience temporary cooling below the membrane melting temperature, and that membranes composed of relatively short-chain fatty acids would encapsulate solutes more efficiently as temperatures approached 0 °C.

Ripples at edges of blooming lilies and torn plastic sheets.

Ripples arise at edges of petals of blooming Lilium casablanca flowers and at edges of torn plastic sheets. In both systems, ripples are a consequence of excess length along the edge of a sheet. Through the use of time-lapse videos of blooming lilies and published images of torn plastic sheets, we find that ripples in both systems are well described by the scaling relationship a∝w(L-w), where a is amplitude, w is wavelength, and L is arc length. A phenomenological relationship previously reported for self-similar ripple patterns, namely ⟨a⟩∝⟨w⟩, can be recovered by assuming that buckling stress is constant. Excess length along petal edges can also influence their overall Gaussian curvature, such that petals invert from a cup shape to a saddle shape upon blooming. Previous simulations of these shape changes have assumed that petal thickness decreases at least quadratically. Here, we evaluate tomograms of several varieties of lily buds and find that this assumption is valid along the short axis of the buds, but not the long axis. A challenge of employing traditional tomography methods to measure petal thickness is that the sample is destroyed; a single bud cannot be followed through the entire blooming process. To address this challenge, we provide proof of principle that the nondestructive, label-free method of x-ray tomography produces high-contrast three-dimensional scans on time scales short enough to follow lily blooming.

Yeast cells actively tune their membranes to phase separate at temperatures that scale with growth temperatures.

Membranes of vacuoles, the lysosomal organelles of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (budding yeast), undergo extraordinary changes during the cell's normal growth cycle. The cycle begins with a stage of rapid cell growth. Then, as glucose becomes scarce, growth slows, and vacuole membranes phase separate into micrometer-scale domains of two liquid phases. Recent studies suggest that these domains promote yeast survival by organizing membrane proteins that play key roles in a central signaling pathway conserved among eukaryotes (TORC1). An outstanding question in the field has been whether cells regulate phase transitions in response to new physical conditions and how this occurs. Here, we measure transition temperatures and find that after an increase of roughly 15 °C, vacuole membranes appear uniform, independent of growth temperature. Moreover, populations of cells grown at a single temperature regulate this transition to occur over a surprisingly narrow temperature range. Remarkably, the transition temperature scales linearly with the growth temperature, demonstrating that the cells physiologically adapt to maintain proximity to the transition. Next, we ask how yeast adjust their membranes to achieve phase separation. We isolate vacuoles from yeast during the rapid stage of growth, when their membranes do not natively exhibit domains. Ergosterol is the major sterol in yeast. We find that domains appear when ergosterol is depleted, contradicting the prevalent assumption that increases in sterol concentration generally cause membrane phase separation in vivo, but in agreement with previous studies using artificial and cell-derived membranes.

Prebiotic Protocell Membranes Retain Encapsulated Contents during Flocculation, and Phospholipids Preserve Encapsulation during Dehydration.

The first cell membranes were likely composed of single-chain amphiphiles such as fatty acids. An open question is whether fatty acid membranes could have functioned within evaporative lakes on the early Earth, which have been hypothesized to concentrate prebiotic reactants. Evaporation also concentrates monovalent salts, which in turn cause fatty acid membrane vesicles to flocculate; significant loss of encapsulated contents during flocculation would have impeded early cell evolution. Here, we tested whether fatty acid vesicles retain encapsulated contents after flocculation and after drying. We found that vesicles composed of 2:1 decanoic acid:decanol encapsulate calcein dye throughout a process of flocculation in saturated salt solution and subsequent disaggregation of vesicles by dilution of the salt. However, 30 minutes of complete dehydration disrupted encapsulation by fatty acid vesicles. In contrast, phospholipid vesicles maintained encapsulation. Our results reveal a selective pressure for protocells to incorporate phospholipids: while fatty acid membranes can retain encapsulated contents during periods of dilute and saturating salt, phospholipids are necessary for encapsulation during dry periods. Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that evaporative lakes were productive sites for prebiotic chemistry and the origin of cells.

Prebiotic Membranes and Micelles Do Not Inhibit Peptide Formation During Dehydration.

Cycles of dehydration and rehydration could have enabled formation of peptides and RNA in otherwise unfavorable conditions on the early Earth. Development of the first protocells would have hinged upon colocalization of these biopolymers with fatty acid membranes. Using atomic force microscopy, we find that a prebiotic fatty acid (decanoic acid) forms stacks of membranes after dehydration. Using LC-MS-MS (liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry) with isotope internal standards, we measure the rate of formation of serine dipeptides. We find that dipeptides form during dehydration at moderate temperatures (55 °C) at least as fast in the presence of decanoic acid membranes as in the absence of membranes. Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that protocells could have formed within evaporating environments on the early Earth.

Endocytic proteins with prion-like domains form viscoelastic condensates that enable membrane remodeling.

Membrane invagination and vesicle formation are key steps in endocytosis and cellular trafficking. Here, we show that endocytic coat proteins with prion-like domains (PLDs) form hemispherical puncta in the budding yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae These puncta have the hallmarks of biomolecular condensates and organize proteins at the membrane for actin-dependent endocytosis. They also enable membrane remodeling to drive actin-independent endocytosis. The puncta, which we refer to as endocytic condensates, form and dissolve reversibly in response to changes in temperature and solution conditions. We find that endocytic condensates are organized around dynamic protein-protein interaction networks, which involve interactions among PLDs with high glutamine contents. The endocytic coat protein Sla1 is at the hub of the protein-protein interaction network. Using active rheology, we inferred the material properties of endocytic condensates. These experiments show that endocytic condensates are akin to viscoelastic materials. We use these characterizations to estimate the interfacial tension between endocytic condensates and their surroundings. We then adapt the physics of contact mechanics, specifically modifications of Hertz theory, to develop a quantitative framework for describing how interfacial tensions among condensates, the membrane, and the cytosol can deform the plasma membrane to enable actin-independent endocytosis.

Binding of Dipeptides to Fatty Acid Membranes Explains Their Colocalization in Protocells but Does Not Select for Them Relative to Unjoined Amino Acids.

Dipeptides, which consist of two amino acids joined by a peptide bond, have been shown to have catalytic functions. This observation leads to fundamental questions relevant to the origin of life. How could peptides have become colocalized with the first protocells? Which structural features would have determined the association of amino acids and peptides with membranes? Could the association of dipeptides with protocell membranes have driven molecular evolution, favoring dipeptides over individual amino acids? Using pulsed-field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance, we find that several prebiotic amino acids and dipeptides bind to prebiotic membranes. For amino acids, the side chains and carboxylate contribute to the interaction. For dipeptides, the extent of binding is generally less than that of the constituent amino acids, implying that other mechanisms would be necessary to drive molecular evolution. Nevertheless, our results are consistent with a scheme in which the building blocks of the biological polymers colocalized with protocells prior to the emergence of RNA and proteins.

Direct imaging of liquid domains in membranes by cryo-electron tomography.

Images of micrometer-scale domains in lipid bilayers have provided the gold standard of model-free evidence to understand the domains' shapes, sizes, and distributions. Corresponding techniques to directly and quantitatively assess smaller (nanoscale and submicron) liquid domains have been limited. Researchers commonly seek to correlate activities of membrane proteins with attributes of the domains in which they reside; doing so hinges on identification and characterization of membrane domains. Although some features of membrane domains can be probed by indirect methods, these methods are often constrained by the limitation that data must be analyzed in the context of models that require multiple assumptions or parameters. Here, we address this challenge by developing and testing two methods of identifying submicron domains in biomimetic membranes. Both methods leverage cryo-electron tomograms of ternary membranes under vitrified, hydrated conditions. The first method is optimized for probe-free applications: Domains are directly distinguished from the surrounding membrane by their thickness. This technique quantitatively and accurately measures area fractions of domains, in excellent agreement with known phase diagrams. The second method is optimized for applications in which a single label is deployed for imaging membranes by both high-resolution cryo-electron tomography and diffraction-limited optical microscopy. For this method, we test a panel of probes, find that a trimeric mCherry label performs best, and specify criteria for developing future high-performance, dual-use probes. These developments have led to direct and quantitative imaging of submicron membrane domains in vitrified, hydrated vesicles.

A Step toward Molecular Evolution of RNA: Ribose Binds to Prebiotic Fatty Acid Membranes, and Nucleosides Bind Better than Individual Bases Do.

A major challenge in understanding how biological cells arose on the early Earth is explaining how RNA and membranes originally colocalized. We propose that the building blocks of RNA (nucleobases and ribose) bound to self-assembled prebiotic membranes. We have previously demonstrated that the bases bind to membranes composed of a prebiotic fatty acid, but evidence for the binding of sugars has remained a technical challenge. Here, we used pulsed-field gradient NMR spectroscopy to demonstrate that ribose and other sugars bind to membranes of decanoic acid. Moreover, the binding of some bases is strongly enhanced when they are linked to ribose to form a nucleoside or - with the addition of phosphate - a nucleotide. This enhanced binding could have played a role in the molecular evolution leading to the production of RNA.

Prebiotic amino acids bind to and stabilize prebiotic fatty acid membranes.

The membranes of the first protocells on the early Earth were likely self-assembled from fatty acids. A major challenge in understanding how protocells could have arisen and withstood changes in their environment is that fatty acid membranes are unstable in solutions containing high concentrations of salt (such as would have been prevalent in early oceans) or divalent cations (which would have been required for RNA catalysis). To test whether the inclusion of amino acids addresses this problem, we coupled direct techniques of cryoelectron microscopy and fluorescence microscopy with techniques of NMR spectroscopy, centrifuge filtration assays, and turbidity measurements. We find that a set of unmodified, prebiotic amino acids binds to prebiotic fatty acid membranes and that a subset stabilizes membranes in the presence of salt and Mg2+ Furthermore, we find that final concentrations of the amino acids need not be high to cause these effects; membrane stabilization persists after dilution as would have occurred during the rehydration of dried or partially dried pools. In addition to providing a means to stabilize protocell membranes, our results address the challenge of explaining how proteins could have become colocalized with membranes. Amino acids are the building blocks of proteins, and our results are consistent with a positive feedback loop in which amino acids bound to self-assembled fatty acid membranes, resulting in membrane stabilization and leading to more binding in turn. High local concentrations of molecular building blocks at the surface of fatty acid membranes may have aided the eventual formation of proteins.

Correction to: Effect of endometrial mechanical stimulation in an unselected population undergoing in vitro fertilization: futility analysis of a double-blind randomized controlled trial.

The original version of this article unfortunately contained mistakes. The complete list of corrections is given below.

Effect of endometrial mechanical stimulation in an unselected population undergoing in vitro fertilization: futility analysis of a double-blind randomized controlled trial.

PURPOSE: Implantation failure is a major limiting factor of successful in vitro fertilization (IVF). The objective of this study was to determine if endometrial mechanical stimulation (EMS) by endometrial biopsy in the luteal phase of the cycle prior to embryo transfer (ET) improves clinical outcomes in an unselected subfertile population. METHODS: Double-blind, randomized controlled trial of EMS versus sham biopsy and odds of clinical pregnancy after IVF and embryo transfer. Secondary outcomes included spontaneous miscarriage and live birth. RESULTS: One hundred women enrolled and were randomized from 2013 to 2017. Enrollment was terminated after futility analysis showed no difference in clinical pregnancy between EMS versus control, 47.2% vs 61.7% (OR 0.55, 95% CI 0.25-1.23, p = 0.15). There were no significant differences between women who underwent EMS and those who did not in terms of positive pregnancy test 54.7% vs 63.8% (OR 0.69, 95% CI 0.31-1.53, p = 0.36), miscarriage 7.5% vs 2.1% (OR 3.76 95% CI 0.41-34.85, p = 0.22), or live birth 43.4% vs 61.7% (OR 0.48 95% CI 0.21-1.06, p = 0.07). CONCLUSIONS: EMS in the luteal phase of the cycle preceding embryo transfer does not improve clinical outcomes in an unselected subfertile population and may result in a lower live birth rate. We caution the routine use of EMS in an unselected population.

Tuning Length Scales of Small Domains in Cell-Derived Membranes and Synthetic Model Membranes.

Micron-scale, coexisting liquid-ordered (Lo) and liquid-disordered (Ld) phases are straightforward to observe in giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) composed of ternary lipid mixtures. Experimentally, uniform membranes undergo demixing when temperature is decreased: domains subsequently nucleate, diffuse, collide, and coalesce until only one domain of each phase remains. The sizes of these two domains are limited only by the size of the system. Under different conditions, vesicles exhibit smaller-scale domains of fixed sizes, leading to the question of what sets the length scale. In membranes with excess area, small domains are expected when coarsening is hindered or when a microemulsion or modulated phase arises. Here, we test predictions of how the size, morphology, and fluorescence levels of small domains vary with the membrane's temperature, tension, and composition. Using GUVs and cell-derived giant plasma membrane vesicles, we find that 1) the characteristic size of domains decreases when temperature is increased or membrane tension is decreased, 2) stripes are favored over circular domains for lipid compositions with low energy per unit interface, 3) fluorescence levels are consistent with domain registration across both monolayer leaflets of the bilayer, and 4) small domains form in GUVs composed of lipids both with and without ester-linked lipids. Our experimental results are consistent with several elements of current theories for microemulsions and modulated phases and inconsistent with others, suggesting a motivation to modify or enhance current theories.